Ignacio Egnatius
i kinda find it hard to understand your english but correct me if it seem fit.
you said, before God there is an order. where did you get this idea?
before god created logic everything was a whim
even the creation of logic is a whim.
can you elaborate this?
ok so logic makes things more important than others, obviously the dollar is worth more then the penny, in normal circumstances taking into account society and what not
a computer is more advance then the type writer, we can reason this, bring into what goes into it, time lines, and more stuff
now nicki minaj is better then kesha. well we dont know what better is now do we. taste in music in no more rational then any other taste, i can like any band and you can like any band but there is no logical reason in which one is better, you can measure sales, popularity and what not, but that still isn't BETTER
if you want to get down to the bone, it is almost like scientific vs non scientific, but it goes deeper then that, it doesn't need to be empirical though it just needs to be able to line up premises like i did.
now imagine a world without logic, you cant assume anything, talking about it is almost self defeating becuase we are using logic to think of something that would have no logic. but you could not be right nor wrong in the world. god's inventions could of created god, no problem. this world without logic is reducing everything to things like, music taste. but somehow this god created logic, why? well you cant ask that, there is no logical answer, how can you explain why logic was created without saying why it would be logically needed
the thing is god would not need to create logic at all. it would have to somehow exist before him. unless of course he just created it and the only thing that makes god better then me is he has the power to create it, if i dont want to be logical i can say something like " you should kill everyone you see" well now there is no way a world can exist like that, but it could if logic wasnt there, i just cant make it happen, but god could. god would just have the power to do things that i cant, i am no more right, how could i be you cant give me logical reasons. i just dont have the power to make my vision real