Lewis Carroll's Alice vs McGee's Alice vs Tim Burton Alice

What your perfect Alice in Wonderland?

Lewis Carroll's Alice	34.0%	[ 181 ]
McGee's Alice	30.5%	[ 162 ]
Tim Burton Alice	30.3%	[ 161 ]
none :-	5.3%	[ 28 ]
Total Votes:			[ 532 ]

[Otaku Ani]

Kaleidoscopic Cosplay

Let's face it.

Original books are way better than any movie adaptation they will ever make.

Really.

I hate that people watch the movies or play the games and think they know everything about Alice in Wonderland.

]:

Though in terms of adaption I will make room for American McGee's Alice.

I felt that the game was most true to the original story's darker elements and while it didn't entirely "stick to the books" it (the first game anyway) was a pretty damn good series based on the novels.

So yeah, basically my opinion is everything besides the books suck, except for American McGee's Alice. Possibly the old cartoon Disney movie. But other than that...no.

I agree. Books are much more intriguing. They leave alot more to your own personal imagination.

[Oreh Blazed]

book and original movie

[Cynder_Nightwish]

I have loved Alice in Wonderland for ages and have seen almost every version.

McGee's Alice is a great spin on the story. The design of the characters are wonderful. smile

[dragongirl035]

biggrin i like them all but i loved tim burton i love his verson of the cat

[Mei McKorrmik]

I love the McGee games.

[norakun91]

I liked them all equally. They each had Alice at different ages and different takes on her and wonderland and I enjoyed all of them.

[Lady-Alesana]

Okay, Anything that spews forth from the genius that is Tim Burton is undoubtedly twisted 3nodding 3nodding 3nodding blaugh blaugh blaugh rofl rofl rofl 4laugh 4laugh 4laugh 4laugh heart heart heart heart heart heart heart heart amazing. Nuff said.

[Requiem ex Inferni]

McGee's Alice, then Carroll's Alice. I can't really say anything about Burton's Alice, because Johnny Depp in Wonderland put so much focus on the Mad Hatter (a very minor character in the book, albeit a memorable one) that Alice practically became a supporting character.

[FlammableIce]

I absolutely adore American McGee's Alice. I think the games handle the characters very well plus the dark twist to the original works great.

[Taking Tea In Dreamland]

The original and Mcgee's Alice are great in their own ways, really. The character designs of the latter were very unique and the soundtrack was a treat, but the original just has that tinge of childish innocence to it that can't be beaten. Truthfully, I've never been a fan of Burton's version.

[Venima_Celestia]

I agree with original is better BUT each Alice has their own strengths & weaknesses. Boils down to generation and/or how the viewer likes their heroin....some people don't like an Alice that appears helpless & a "victim" but just as some don't agree with making her a sword carrying fearless warrior. Time changes everything but classics last forever.

[Triratna]

Obviously, Each of Us has different interpretation over Alice Pleasance Liddell.
She Lost in her own 7 years old Psychological archetype, Eating too much Drug and Drink too much wine.
Unlike other fairytale - Alice liddell are real person.
You can even make pilgrimage on her grave on St. Michael & All Angels Church in Lyndhurst.

Overtime, I prefer Shinedown Version over anything else.

[Gawjuzgabby]

GentryDuchess

All the Alice's are cool but I like McGee's Alice the best. Wonderland is a dark world and I want a little violence in a dark world. Tim Burton's Alice had beautiful pictures but it wasn't...I suppose, crazy enough? Though the original Alice in Wonderland will always hold a special place in my heart.

I totally agree! I liked the whole insanity theme, not to mention how wicked his characters all looked!! I heard McGee's might make another game!

[iamiwhoami]

Anyone aware of Marilyn Manson's Phantasmagoria: The Visions of Lewis Carroll? Here ya go.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=706QjHaJYxY

Sorry you have to log in to confirm your age.