Welcome to Gaia! ::

The Gaian Gay-Straight Alliance

Back to Guilds

Our goal is to spread awareness of, lessen unwarranted hatred of, and create a safe haven for the LGBTQ community and their allies. 

Tags: Gay Straight Alliance, LGBT, homosexual, straight, transgender 

Reply The Gaian Gay-Straight Alliance
to those of you who consider suicide, why? Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3 ... 4 5 6 7 [>] [»|]

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Dusty-Boy

Dangerous Autobiographer

2,450 Points
  • Risky Lifestyle 100
  • Brandisher 100
  • Signature Look 250
PostPosted: Sun Oct 23, 2011 4:50 pm


Lady Kayura
OP, you clearly do not understand depression as a disease, nor have you expeirienced it. It isn't a matter of saying "I'll be happy now". If it was, don't you think people would be doing that?

That's called prejudgment, I'll simply tell you i've found myself holding a loaded gun to my skull, It took me a lot of time to stop thinking I was "Too worthless to even kill myself"

eventually I realized that I loved life, but fixated on the terrible things.... granted that's none of your business whether or not i've experienced depression.... But i digress that it is far from a disease. It's more like a high, something you get fixated on. It's hard to tell yourself your worth something when you've spent years allowing yourself to think you're worthless.



Quote:
Of course they would do that. I'm going to agree with Matasoga that the OP seems to be blaming depression on the person. And as someone that's seen others deal with depression and dealt with it myself, I find that pretty ******** insulting. Thanks, OP for trivializing what I've gone through. And blaming me for it.

If you've dealt with it yourself, then doesn't that reinforce my statement? This wasn't trivializing, it was simply me stating something because this guild has a large group of people who bring up suicide and self-hatred.

I cured myself, because noone can change your mind but you. it is you who thinks a certain way and only you can truly alter that perception... regardless of means, just find the end in an acceptance and happiness state.
Quote:

As for getting a job and degree and career, you're too young to understand but that isn't exactly an easy thing. Buy a house? Try buying a house on minimum wage. Try working FULL TIME and going to school FULL time and try to make enough to survive on. And going to school if you can even get the loans means you'll be paying them back for years. Decades. Yay for debt up to your eyeballs. Good luck getting a house after having to pay thousands of dollars for school. You make it sound so easy OP. You have no idea. Guess what. For some people, things will not get better. Life will continue to suck and they're stuck. But again, I don't expect you to understand that.
again, you and I aren't so different...... but here I am, In my apartment, in my debt, with my job that pays 8.45 an hour.... with an ROTC uniform in my closet and three history books on my table, I also have last semester's books because I wanted to keep them as trophies, and because I enjoy looking back on the interesting parts of the fields of Philosophy, Psychology and History... the math book is kinda in shambles though >.> ******** math...

Quote:

So I repeat, thanks for trivializing what I've gone through in my life, OP. Thanks for blaming me.



It's not blame, blame is saying you caused the problem. but you must own up to the fact that you're allowing yourself to continue these feelings. it's something I had to do and it's not comfortable.

I've had night terrors from my toddler years up until I was 19, I used to feel tears in my eyes when i was alone... every time. I've felt like someone who couldn't be anything because I let things get to me... know what I did about it?

I stopped, I thought really hard about it. Feelings are something that can't be controlled, only redirected... that's what I thought, I wasn't completely wrong but I wasn't exactly right either.

Here's why, If a man steals your wallet you will feel anger.
If you find out that he is a man who was so afraid to do anything else, because he has no other option but to steal for the life of his child, your view will be different..

you're looking at things in a primarily negative way whilst you're depressed. you think of the inherent evils or repercussions of things that bring harm into your perception of reality..
you may not see the boy checking you out when he looks at you, you might just see someone staring at you and ostracizing you.
Paranoia, Night terrors, Lonliness, extreme sorrow, doubt, ignorance.. these were the symptoms of my depression. Now I know what I am and what I can be. I know that the world is what I make of it, I know that anyone who says otherwise is just looking for a bad life. even if they don't think they are.

I'm not laying blame, I'm explaining that whilst under the influence of depression there is no real constant variable except the person who is depressed, I am explaining that it is a condition but not a disease. a disease is a problem, a bad thing, a condition is simply the state of things.

you can try to bastardize me and to negate what I have seen in my life. but honestly I think i got through to you, because you were defensive. that anger can be a mechanism. when people said I had a problem i got mad, I got defensive. I learned to do something that psychology classifies as projecting.

tell me, what are you doing? are you really thinking that I've trivialized it, or are you putting more depth into something that's just heavy.
PostPosted: Sun Oct 23, 2011 4:53 pm


I've considered suicide quite a few times in my life, for several different reasons. I know I won't do it, though. I'm too afraid to. I know that leaving my family behind would be terrible. I promised my best friend I wouldn't do it because she promised me.

But, depression isn't easily dealt with. It isn't. Your argument is pretty one-sided.

gas powered stick


Dusty-Boy

Dangerous Autobiographer

2,450 Points
  • Risky Lifestyle 100
  • Brandisher 100
  • Signature Look 250
PostPosted: Sun Oct 23, 2011 4:59 pm


Monochrome Monster
I've considered suicide quite a few times in my life, for several different reasons. I know I won't do it, though. I'm too afraid to. I know that leaving my family behind would be terrible. I promised my best friend I wouldn't do it because she promised me.

But, depression isn't easily dealt with. It isn't. Your argument is pretty one-sided.



I can't really speak from anything but experience, so It's one sided in that sense...... but honestly this is what I see to be truth, it's ashamed that others can't bring to themselves their own self-fulfilment.

there's an expression someone once told me at a party when I was younger. I loved it so.


The world is coated in a heaping pile of rot and s**t, some can view it for the filth it is, and some can view the fact that life springs from this soil, and that it brings about great things.


soil on the ground is just rotted life and fecal matter... but it's where gardens grow and animals live.

that's two polar different ways to look at it, the only way I can explain it really.
PostPosted: Sun Oct 23, 2011 5:47 pm


My paranoia won't leave me alone, my mother is under the impression that I'm a servant of Satan because of my religion, my mom's family lives for the sole purpose of arguing, my best friend was bullied for two years by her former best friend and I couldn't do anything, my dad's family hates anything that breathes, I'm insanely poor because my step father left my mother, my sister has tried to kill me several times and my mother doesn't care, my anti-socialism and bad English make it so I can barely choke out a damn sentence, my family raised me to be perfect and as I don't exceed their expectations they yell at me for all of their ******** problems and finally I lost most of my friends due to my obsessive-compulsive episodes. Good enough?

Sarah_L_Awesome

5,350 Points
  • Person of Interest 200
  • Hygienic 200
  • First step to fame 200

CheizLord

6,650 Points
  • Invisibility 100
  • Forum Regular 100
  • Citizen 200
PostPosted: Sun Oct 23, 2011 6:36 pm


Quote:

I'm not laying blame, I'm explaining that whilst under the influence of depression there is no real constant variable except the person who is depressed, I am explaining that it is a condition but not a disease. a disease is a problem, a bad thing, a condition is simply the state of things.

Depression isn't just a state of mind. It can be caused by life changes or through mental illness, and as I said earlier mental illnesses aren't something that can be fixed with a positive outlook on life, they are chemical imbalances in the brain that can only be changed through medication. and it could take years to find the medication that works well for each individual. Stop ignoring these facts.

While your depression might be caused by life changes or are situational not everyone else's depression is caused by this. Using solely your own life experience is a very ignorant approach to something as vastly complex as depression. Not everyone grieves for the same reasons or in the same way as you. Don't assume that something that works for you is going to work for everybody else.

You seriously need more outside perspective if you expect to hold even a grain of salt worth of perspective than what you are now.
PostPosted: Sun Oct 23, 2011 9:42 pm


CheizLord

Depression isn't just a state of mind. It can be caused by life changes or through mental illness, and as I said earlier mental illnesses aren't something that can be fixed with a positive outlook on life, they are chemical imbalances in the brain that can only be changed through medication.


This is actually incorrect.
Yes, mental illness can be caused by a chemical imballance in the brain, but the brain is a wonderous thing that can be taught to self-regulate it's chemistry. And possitivism (as well as the development of some other coping mechanisms) is exactly the way that's acchieved.

In fact, most good psychologists will tell you that medication is rarely a long-term answer. The purpose of it is to help control the symptoms to help you function and live up to the responsibilities required of you in day-to-day life, but it is not a solution. In fact, it can often become a hindrance due to dependancy and the fact that the ease with which you can mask symptoms makes a person less willing to put in the hard yards, weed themselves off the medication and learn to manage their illness properly.

Meeatu

5,250 Points
  • Forum Sophomore 300
  • Forum Regular 100
  • First step to fame 200

Esiris

Newbie Sophomore

10,300 Points
  • Member 100
  • Gender Swap 100
  • Popular Thread 100
PostPosted: Sun Oct 23, 2011 10:56 pm


Dusty-Boy


It's not blame, blame is saying you caused the problem. but you must own up to the fact that you're allowing yourself to continue these feelings. it's something I had to do and it's not comfortable....

I'm not laying blame, I'm explaining that whilst under the influence of depression there is no real constant variable except the person who is depressed, I am explaining that it is a condition but not a disease. a disease is a problem, a bad thing, a condition is simply the state of things.


You don't seem to understand the difference between the feeling of sadness and clinical depression.
There is a huge difference between feeling sad and low and clinical depression. I can change my sadness, depression isn't a matter of will.
PostPosted: Sun Oct 23, 2011 11:16 pm


Dusty-Boy

I'm not laying blame, I'm explaining that whilst under the influence of depression there is no real constant variable except the person who is depressed, I am explaining that it is a condition but not a disease. a disease is a problem, a bad thing, a condition is simply the state of things.

Hello, my partner was reading this and suggested I weigh in on things. I am diagnosed Bipolar II; I mainly swing low into depression. I am on two SSRIs that compliment each other. They keep my head above water.

Here is a snapshot of me before I starting swinging low. I was a 4.0 honor student in high school, I was first chair flute, and 2nd alto sax in jazz band. I liked to read and write. I was attending the local community college working on my AA while still in high school.

Then I swung really low for the first time. I felt like a slug, everything was slower. I read slower, I talked slower, my brain moved slower. Everything was darker. Literally, darker. I slept all day. I skipped school to sleep. I would sleep in my car and miss college classes. I was hemorrhaging my own life force and will power. I dropped out of band, i nearly flunked my senior year of high school, and almost dropped out of college. I went from a 4.0 to a 2.0 in about a year. I stopped reading. I stopped writing. I stopped showering. I stopped living. I would lose weeks of memory to the darkness. I don't remember going to home coming my senior year, I have the pictures, sure, but I don't remember it. Hell, I don't remember walking to get my high school diploma.

Sadness you are right you can snap out of it if you chose to. Like all emotions, sadness is transitory. It lasts for brief moments. I was sad when I heard about the earthquake and tsunami in Japan. It hurt my heart to think of the destruction there. Clinical depression is NOT sadness. Depression is not transitory. It stays, and stays and stays, no matter how many god damn happy thoughts you think. It is a dark cloud hovering only you. It is a medical condition. Without my meds, I go back to being a slug, no matter how hard I fight. I lose to the slug. With my meds, I am back at 16 credits of class, and a part time job. I shower every other day or so, depending on my hair. I am reading for fun again. Writing for fun again. I am currently working on finding an orchestra to play with.

As a psych major currently working on my BA, I cannot stress how wrong you are. It is a disease. There are marked differences in behavior and brain chemistry. I won't deny the over prescription of drugs (paired with overdiagnoses of depression) to those who are sad who need a pick me up, but I cannot ignore those of us who need those drugs to function like a normal human being. I am one of them. I am tethered to my drugs, or I risk being a slug.

Blackrose_Knight

Devoted Pirate


Lady Kayura

Fluffy Bunny

23,150 Points
  • Beta Gaian 0
  • Bunny Spotter 50
  • Conventioneer 300
PostPosted: Mon Oct 24, 2011 4:49 am


Dusty-Boy

That's called prejudgment, I'll simply tell you i've found myself holding a loaded gun to my skull, It took me a lot of time to stop thinking I was "Too worthless to even kill myself"

eventually I realized that I loved life, but fixated on the terrible things.... granted that's none of your business whether or not i've experienced depression.... But i digress that it is far from a disease. It's more like a high, something you get fixated on. It's hard to tell yourself your worth something when you've spent years allowing yourself to think you're worthless.


It isn't my business but guess what, you decided to share. Not like I asked.

It is a disease. Professionals in the medical field agree. What kind of research have you done to prove it isn't? None? What kind of medical professional are you? You aren't. Are you a doctor? No. So what makes you an expert in the field? Nothing. You don't think it's a disease? That's fine. Think what you want. I'd suggest though that you keep that thought to yourself because not only are you going to look foolish when you say that, you're going to piss people off. Saying depression isn't a disease is like saying gravity doesn't exist. Saying so is extremely ignorant.


Dusty-Boy

I cured myself, because noone can change your mind but you. it is you who thinks a certain way and only you can truly alter that perception... regardless of means, just find the end in an acceptance and happiness state.


If you cured yourself then guess what, bud, you didn't have depression. Hate to burst your little bubble there. You were feeling sad. You don't have any clue what real depression is because it sounds like you've not really experienced it. I personally don't care for how you're judging those that have felt it and the associated thoughts they (and I) have had.


Dusty-Boy
again, you and I aren't so different...... but here I am, In my apartment, in my debt, with my job that pays 8.45 an hour.... with an ROTC uniform in my closet and three history books on my table, I also have last semester's books because I wanted to keep them as trophies, and because I enjoy looking back on the interesting parts of the fields of Philosophy, Psychology and History... the math book is kinda in shambles though >.> ******** math...


Oh but we are. You see, I was referring to a friend that tends to be hopeless most of the time. I on the other hand am finished with school without student loans thanks to the hard work of my parents. But it seems ironic that you can't see how hard it is to advance in life since you're stuck. Though I don't get why you're rambling about subjects in school. Trying to change the topic from what you've said? That's what it seems like to me.

Oh, and another thing that makes us different is I am a health care professional. So when I say that depression isn't a state of mind but a disease, I have a degree and university to back me up. What do you have backing you up? Your own little opinions and no degree to back you up? Right. I win. Depression being a disease is based in fact, not opinion. The sooner you realize that, the better it'll be if you continue to post in this thread.


Dusty-Boy

It's not blame, blame is saying you caused the problem. but you must own up to the fact that you're allowing yourself to continue these feelings. it's something I had to do and it's not comfortable.


See, you're blaming me for not moving past my problems. It isn't like I'm thinking, hey, I'm going to be sad and s**t because horrible things happened to me. I suffer from a form of post traumatic stress disorder. It isn't as if I can say I'm going to be all happy and sunshine and flowers and that's the end of it. You are trivializing mental illness which is in turn putting blame on those that suffer from some sickness. And frankly that's ******** rude.


Dusty-Boy
I've had night terrors from my toddler years up until I was 19, I used to feel tears in my eyes when i was alone... every time. I've felt like someone who couldn't be anything because I let things get to me... know what I did about it?

I stopped, I thought really hard about it. Feelings are something that can't be controlled, only redirected... that's what I thought, I wasn't completely wrong but I wasn't exactly right either.


Oh boy. Night terrors. Man it must suck to be you. Try being abused as a child then raped as a young adult and see what that does to you, kid. It isn't something I can tell myself that hey, I'm just going to be done with it.


Dusty-Boy
Here's why, If a man steals your wallet you will feel anger.
If you find out that he is a man who was so afraid to do anything else, because he has no other option but to steal for the life of his child, your view will be different..


Actually, it won't be different. If that's the case the d**k that's stealing my wallet can get some government assistance. What if he steals my wallet with the last of my money that I need to feed MY child? Eh? Why should I give a damn about his life if he doesn't give a damn about mine? and again, nice try at changing the subject.


Dusty-Boy
you're looking at things in a primarily negative way whilst you're depressed. you think of the inherent evils or repercussions of things that bring harm into your perception of reality..
you may not see the boy checking you out when he looks at you, you might just see someone staring at you and ostracizing you.
Paranoia, Night terrors, Lonliness, extreme sorrow, doubt, ignorance.. these were the symptoms of my depression. Now I know what I am and what I can be. I know that the world is what I make of it, I know that anyone who says otherwise is just looking for a bad life. even if they don't think they are.


As I've said before, I don't think you're actually suffering from depression.


Dusty-Boy
I'm not laying blame, I'm explaining that whilst under the influence of depression there is no real constant variable except the person who is depressed, I am explaining that it is a condition but not a disease. a disease is a problem, a bad thing, a condition is simply the state of things.


No? Not blaming me? You are telling me that I can be happy and move on from my past quite easily. And the fact that I've not moved on means something is wrong with me. Isn't that what you're saying? That perhaps I'm not trying hard enough or I'm lazy? But hey, to you depression isn't a real disease.


Dusty-Boy
you can try to bastardize me and to negate what I have seen in my life. but honestly I think i got through to you, because you were defensive. that anger can be a mechanism. when people said I had a problem i got mad, I got defensive. I learned to do something that psychology classifies as projecting.

tell me, what are you doing? are you really thinking that I've trivialized it, or are you putting more depth into something that's just heavy.


Got through to me? I'm angry because you've hit on a pet peeve of mine, ignorance. To claim depression isn't a disease is just one of the dumbest things I've heard in a long time (and that's AFTER reading about Cain saying being gay is a choice and Bachmann saying Iraq should pay the USA back after the USA invaded them). So congrats.

I'm not mad at you. I just hope that younger people that know less than you don't actually read what you have to say. They may need help and you're telling them they're not sick. When someone is sick, it needs to be taken care of before it gets worse.

Yes, I really do feel like you've trivialized my experiences and sufferings because I am not like you. Problem is you don't seem to realize that I and others have been through experiences that make your little night terrors look like a walk in the park.

You're just another kid that's taken a psych 101 class and thinks they're an expert. That kind of thinking only reinforces how ignorant you really are. Claim to be an expert on depression after you've become a doctor. Doing so now is making you look foolish. Especially since you're spouting off incorrect information.

Lastly, I think you owe an apology to everyone that you've insulted and trivialized.
PostPosted: Mon Oct 24, 2011 5:02 am


Meeatu
CheizLord

Depression isn't just a state of mind. It can be caused by life changes or through mental illness, and as I said earlier mental illnesses aren't something that can be fixed with a positive outlook on life, they are chemical imbalances in the brain that can only be changed through medication.


This is actually incorrect.
Yes, mental illness can be caused by a chemical imballance in the brain, but the brain is a wonderous thing that can be taught to self-regulate it's chemistry. And possitivism (as well as the development of some other coping mechanisms) is exactly the way that's acchieved.

In fact, most good psychologists will tell you that medication is rarely a long-term answer. The purpose of it is to help control the symptoms to help you function and live up to the responsibilities required of you in day-to-day life, but it is not a solution. In fact, it can often become a hindrance due to dependancy and the fact that the ease with which you can mask symptoms makes a person less willing to put in the hard yards, weed themselves off the medication and learn to manage their illness properly.

First of all, moods are regulated by neurotransmitters in the brain, having a mental disorder like bipolar disorder is having a chemical imbalance. the medication and the medication only can stabilize and regulate the extremely low or high levels of dopamine, serotonin, etc.

That might make a good fiction story for people who believe in superpowers that think they can manipulate the inner workings of their brain, but its just flat out nonsense. Yes you can maintain your emotions to an extent through a clear mindset and maybe even through some meditation, but there's no way in hell a human being can regulate the neurotransmitters in their head. A chemical imbalance can only be stabalized by another chemical, aka medication.

If what you say were true then bipolar disorder and other mental illnesses would not exist because everyone could just will them away, and bipolar disorder is an honest to god genetically passed down illness, no less real then schizophrenia and multiple personality disorder.

I've been through this my entire life and not once have I heard such a ridiculous thing. MOST psychologists will tell you that mental illnesses involving chemical imbalances cannot be cured by sheer will power. They will urge you to take your medication religiously, and help you through the difficutiles of learning how to handle the disorder, because you're going to have it for the rest of your life. Yes the medicine can't do everything, but without it, especially with disorders like schizophrenia and schizo effective disorder, once people with these disorders come off of their medication they symptoms automatically return. and why? because the medication is the only thing suppressing them.

CheizLord

6,650 Points
  • Invisibility 100
  • Forum Regular 100
  • Citizen 200

BSPBleach

Proxy Gaian

8,000 Points
  • Citizen 200
  • Forum Junior 100
  • Money Never Sleeps 200
PostPosted: Mon Oct 24, 2011 5:39 am


i considered suicide once. but that was ages ago. when i was still in denial about who i was, back when i gave a crap what my parenmts wanted, back when i gave a crap what people thought and said......so when i was like 9. lol nearly half my life ago.

i still do now, but it's more of a 'what if' thing. i've grown up since then, and figured out who matters and what matters. and decided that suicide is more of a punishment to the people left alive and an act of cowardice and surrender by whoever died. so i'll just use my adapted on and off switches to form to whatever is needed and trudge through life. hopefully finding a way to get better credit since there's morons in maryland who called collections twice on a 14 yr old =_=
PostPosted: Mon Oct 24, 2011 5:44 am


CheizLord
Meeatu
CheizLord

Depression isn't just a state of mind. It can be caused by life changes or through mental illness, and as I said earlier mental illnesses aren't something that can be fixed with a positive outlook on life, they are chemical imbalances in the brain that can only be changed through medication.


This is actually incorrect.
Yes, mental illness can be caused by a chemical imballance in the brain, but the brain is a wonderous thing that can be taught to self-regulate it's chemistry. And possitivism (as well as the development of some other coping mechanisms) is exactly the way that's acchieved.

In fact, most good psychologists will tell you that medication is rarely a long-term answer. The purpose of it is to help control the symptoms to help you function and live up to the responsibilities required of you in day-to-day life, but it is not a solution. In fact, it can often become a hindrance due to dependancy and the fact that the ease with which you can mask symptoms makes a person less willing to put in the hard yards, weed themselves off the medication and learn to manage their illness properly.

First of all, moods are regulated by neurotransmitters in the brain, having a mental disorder like bipolar disorder is having a chemical imbalance. the medication and the medication only can stabilize and regulate the extremely low or high levels of dopamine, serotonin, etc.

That might make a good fiction story for people who believe in superpowers that think they can manipulate the inner workings of their brain, but its just flat out nonsense. Yes you can maintain your emotions to an extent through a clear mindset and maybe even through some meditation, but there's no way in hell a human being can regulate the neurotransmitters in their head. A chemical imbalance can only be stabalized by another chemical, aka medication.

If what you say were true then bipolar disorder and other mental illnesses would not exist because everyone could just will them away, and bipolar disorder is an honest to god genetically passed down illness, no less real then schizophrenia and multiple personality disorder.

I've been through this my entire life and not once have I heard such a ridiculous thing. MOST psychologists will tell you that mental illnesses involving chemical imbalances cannot be cured by sheer will power. They will urge you to take your medication religiously, and help you through the difficutiles of learning how to handle the disorder, because you're going to have it for the rest of your life. Yes the medicine can't do everything, but without it, especially with disorders like schizophrenia and schizo effective disorder, once people with these disorders come off of their medication they symptoms automatically return. and why? because the medication is the only thing suppressing them.
i'm sorry, i agree you're wrong. you can change anything you want about yourself (short of sex change i believe) with will power. i've seen people change eye colour, hair colour, cure amnemia, cause and cure depression with just will power. depression is nothing but a lump of issues, unknown or known. yes sometimes depression is a side effect of an illness, but most people don't even have depression purely because of the illness until they're told it's a side effect.

and every kind of doctor will tell you that everything under the sun require's constand medication to control, not to cure. why? because they all want the damned money. simple.

BSPBleach

Proxy Gaian

8,000 Points
  • Citizen 200
  • Forum Junior 100
  • Money Never Sleeps 200

CheizLord

6,650 Points
  • Invisibility 100
  • Forum Regular 100
  • Citizen 200
PostPosted: Mon Oct 24, 2011 6:56 am


BSPBleach
CheizLord
Meeatu
CheizLord

Depression isn't just a state of mind. It can be caused by life changes or through mental illness, and as I said earlier mental illnesses aren't something that can be fixed with a positive outlook on life, they are chemical imbalances in the brain that can only be changed through medication.


This is actually incorrect.
Yes, mental illness can be caused by a chemical imballance in the brain, but the brain is a wonderous thing that can be taught to self-regulate it's chemistry. And possitivism (as well as the development of some other coping mechanisms) is exactly the way that's acchieved.

In fact, most good psychologists will tell you that medication is rarely a long-term answer. The purpose of it is to help control the symptoms to help you function and live up to the responsibilities required of you in day-to-day life, but it is not a solution. In fact, it can often become a hindrance due to dependancy and the fact that the ease with which you can mask symptoms makes a person less willing to put in the hard yards, weed themselves off the medication and learn to manage their illness properly.

First of all, moods are regulated by neurotransmitters in the brain, having a mental disorder like bipolar disorder is having a chemical imbalance. the medication and the medication only can stabilize and regulate the extremely low or high levels of dopamine, serotonin, etc.

That might make a good fiction story for people who believe in superpowers that think they can manipulate the inner workings of their brain, but its just flat out nonsense. Yes you can maintain your emotions to an extent through a clear mindset and maybe even through some meditation, but there's no way in hell a human being can regulate the neurotransmitters in their head. A chemical imbalance can only be stabalized by another chemical, aka medication.

If what you say were true then bipolar disorder and other mental illnesses would not exist because everyone could just will them away, and bipolar disorder is an honest to god genetically passed down illness, no less real then schizophrenia and multiple personality disorder.

I've been through this my entire life and not once have I heard such a ridiculous thing. MOST psychologists will tell you that mental illnesses involving chemical imbalances cannot be cured by sheer will power. They will urge you to take your medication religiously, and help you through the difficutiles of learning how to handle the disorder, because you're going to have it for the rest of your life. Yes the medicine can't do everything, but without it, especially with disorders like schizophrenia and schizo effective disorder, once people with these disorders come off of their medication they symptoms automatically return. and why? because the medication is the only thing suppressing them.

i'm sorry, i agree you're wrong. you can change anything you want about yourself (short of sex change i believe) with will power. i've seen people change eye colour, hair colour, cure amnemia, cause and cure depression with just will power. depression is nothing but a lump of issues, unknown or known. yes sometimes depression is a side effect of an illness, but most people don't even have depression purely because of the illness until they're told it's a side effect.

and every kind of doctor will tell you that everything under the sun require's constand medication to control, not to cure. why? because they all want the damned money. simple.

1. Changing your hair or eye color using "just willpower" is literally impossible.You can't change genetic structure with your mind. hair and eye color is genetically passed down and to alter your DNA with your mind is nothing short of make believe.

2. What you're explaining is similar to the placebo effective, and although true in some cases, Is not true for everyone. There is extensive proof (including myself) that children at young ages before ever setting foot into a psychiatrists office show signs of their disorder, including manias and depressions. Again, bipolar disorder is genetically passed down and something embedded in your genetic line, and cannot be altered by sheer willpower.

3. No matter where you go in america people are getting drained of their money, but in this case it doesn't discredit the work that the medication is doing. someone with schizophrenia needs that medication because no amount of sheer willpower is going to stabilize their genetics. As I said before, when they're not on medication their symptoms will return, no matter how hard they try to force the voices away. Medication can't cure everything because we haven't made those kinds of advancements in science yet. simply put. We're still exploring the issues with chemical imbalanced disorders, and it's going to take some time before we come up with anything that advanced.

Honestly? I believe that you think its possible because you were manipulated into believing so and because It's exiting and interesting to think that people have those kinds of mental capabilities it makes you all the more inclined to believe it, but its not real. Yes you probably saw someone change their hair color, but probably because the winter or the summer came and their hair naturally changed over time, and they probably said they were changing it with willpower. And their eyes probably changed because of the reflection of the clothes they're wearing or because the color happened to shift slightly while you were watching them. There are realistic and legitimate reasons for what you witnessed or heard, but in that list, mental brain power isn't one of them.

Don't believe everything you hear.I bet you're young aren't you?
PostPosted: Mon Oct 24, 2011 7:07 am


Esiris
Dusty-Boy


It's not blame, blame is saying you caused the problem. but you must own up to the fact that you're allowing yourself to continue these feelings. it's something I had to do and it's not comfortable....

I'm not laying blame, I'm explaining that whilst under the influence of depression there is no real constant variable except the person who is depressed, I am explaining that it is a condition but not a disease. a disease is a problem, a bad thing, a condition is simply the state of things.


You don't seem to understand the difference between the feeling of sadness and clinical depression.
There is a huge difference between feeling sad and low and clinical depression. I can change my sadness, depression isn't a matter of will.

Thank you, by the way. I'm not the only one saying this.

CheizLord

6,650 Points
  • Invisibility 100
  • Forum Regular 100
  • Citizen 200

Dusty-Boy

Dangerous Autobiographer

2,450 Points
  • Risky Lifestyle 100
  • Brandisher 100
  • Signature Look 250
PostPosted: Mon Oct 24, 2011 9:33 am


CheizLord
Esiris
Dusty-Boy


It's not blame, blame is saying you caused the problem. but you must own up to the fact that you're allowing yourself to continue these feelings. it's something I had to do and it's not comfortable....

I'm not laying blame, I'm explaining that whilst under the influence of depression there is no real constant variable except the person who is depressed, I am explaining that it is a condition but not a disease. a disease is a problem, a bad thing, a condition is simply the state of things.


You don't seem to understand the difference between the feeling of sadness and clinical depression.
There is a huge difference between feeling sad and low and clinical depression. I can change my sadness, depression isn't a matter of will.

Thank you, by the way. I'm not the only one saying this.



To both of you, trust me, it lasted 18 years, it never wained and i thought it was a constant in my life,

I had depression, My fifth psychologist actually told me that it wouldn't be diagnosed simply because he saw in me that I was stubborn enough to overcome it and that I could actually do it on my own... he also said I should be medicated for a period of time but I declined as my family is against medication.

First off I was told i needed medication, but I declined.

Second off I used many things to help rewire myself, techniques that have since been "Discredited"


as to all you others, I'll respond tomorrow night in a lengthy post, I only have about ten minutes between class, getting home, and getting ready for work which goes until 11

so i'll talk to you all tomorrow night, simply because I do have a lot to say
Reply
The Gaian Gay-Straight Alliance

Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3 ... 4 5 6 7 [>] [»|]
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum