Noire Etoile
I have a question.
What is your opinion on whether a person says 'I am male/female.' vs. 'I want to be male/female.'
I've heard quite a few people say when someone says 'I want' it's because they have self-esteem issues or have some type of trauma.
Personally, I always say to myself 'I want to be male' only because I'm reminded everyday that I'm technically female. It's like I want to say 'I am' but I can't.
So what's your view on this? And have you heard of people being turned away from transitioning just because they said 'I want'?
Well, saying "I want to be male" means the same as "I want to have a p***s and flat chest," considering that it refers solely to physical sex. With something like "I want to be a man," with a social context, I would assume that they are not yet socially presenting that way, yet they want to start and want to be recognized as that gender. If I say "I'm a guy," then I would be referring to my mental state only, because I am not presenting as a guy offline. However, I would say that I want to be a guy, in social terms. So, there's three parts to it - social, mental, physical - and I would apply the statement to the part that best matched it.
I don't tell myself "I want to be male," but rather "I am Roy, not
her" and "One day I will be comfortable in my body" and such. Not so much "I want" as "I will be" or "My identity is".
...yeah, I don't know if you can make any sense of that, but there's my opinion and thoughts.
becky21k
Wow, I didn't even know there was such a thing as a 'dysphoria attack' .. and I've had them. I learned something
Yep. They're so much fun to have in the middle of the school day.
Fur_Cobain
I wish i knew what to say. I'm a newbie here, and I recently came out to my mother about becoming physically female.
She didn't take it well, but she hasn't disowned me and she's very accepting. My father on the other hand... he doesn't know, and lord knows how I'll break it to him.
Very similar situation I have here, 'cept FtM and my mom thinks it's a phase.
Quote:
Should I just go on HRT without his knowledge and then one day be like "hey dad, look, boobs!"??
My plan: Come back home from a year at college and say "Hey dad, you were right! Eating veggies and getting a job DID make a man of me!" (He jokes about that a lot, but has no clue.)
Quote:
Contrary to what he says, he's not accepting and he thinks people that alter their gender are "wrong in the head".
Eh, my dad made a homophobic comment when my mom said to him that I was questioning my sexuality. If you decide you really want to come out to him, then I would suggest informing him about the psychology surrounding it, with a book, educational video, etc. You could even try stuff like saying "I have a friend who's trans, and s/he mentioned this book/movie/etc. to me about the subject, and it's really interesting/enlightening. Want to read it/watch it with me?"