Temptress Alora
(?)Community Member
- Report Post
- Posted: Sun, 01 Apr 2007 01:38:19 +0000
Quote:
2) Under art, I somewhat don't agree with consistency, maybe eliminate or place less weighting on it. This is because many 'first chapters' of emerging artists is focused on establishing and stablising his style; to me there is nothing unusual about inconsistencies in the first chapter. This gives a more even playing ground for emerging artists against experienced artists.
For this contest, I think that consistency is important. If the characters look different on every page, to the point that you can never tell who is who, or if the art differs from page to page, I definitely think that there should be a point reduction for that.
I can understand if the art varies from chapter to chapter, considering that the artist is certain to improve over time. However, I don't think that the art should be varying too much in just twenty pages.
Also, I think that the site layout should hold some importance. I understand that not everyone is an HTML/CSS/Graphic master, but if the site looks like crap, that could be a big turnoff for some people. And, if the site is near impossible to navigate, that would also turn many potential readers away.