Edward Cullen? Jacob Black?...huh?...Neither?[READ1.POST] | Page 1 | Stephenie Meyer Guild | Guild Forums

SIT THE F DOWN

Offline

Posted: Mon Aug 20, 2007 6:54 am

OK

EDWARDCULLEN,EDWARDCULLEN,EDWARDCULLEN

I love Edward...He's a totally wicked vampire and he claims to love Bella with all of his lost immortal soul...

But

I think BellaxEdward is an overrated relationship

I think their more addicted to each other then they are in love

And JACOB!

Jacob has to be the most rash, hot tempered, sarcastic and cunning lil werewolf yet

And he really loves Bella ... so he claims, and as foolish as he looked in Eclipse...

It really makes you wonder who Bella should choose...

Yes, she's in love with [addict to] Edward, but who would be better for her?

Both are dangerous...

Edward is vampire - ['nuff said.]

Because of them being together her life has been hanging on a short thread for the longest time...

[[*ahem* James,Laurent,Victoria Volturi,Jasper Cullen...himself]]

However he has protected her every time ... [sometimes], and It seems that Bella is hell bent on picking him... *spoiler in white* even with her new found love for Jacob.
And as you read in New Moon...She's catatonic without him

In the future?
Well the only future that seems possible for them is for Bella to give up her mortal life...[Eclipse]

Convenient?
I think not

Jacob is a werewolf - [...]

Jacob has kept her far safer then Edward ever has.
Yes, It is claimed that just being around Jacob when he's emotional is very dangerous.
But he has never hurt Bella, it seems he has control over his emotions like Edward had control over his thirst. [They are even...]

But In the future?
If Bella is to choose him, their relationship would always hang in the balance because he could be imprinted

Convenient?
Not really... but its less harsh then giving up, not only your life, but everything else like she would have to with Edward

In short...

Reality: ... Jacob is better for her, despite how miserable and "empty" she would be without Edward. Even with Jacob "healing her" [New Moon]... She'll be depressed when ever Jacob's back is turned

Who should she choose?

In my opinion ... Neither

But both Edward and Jacob have their strengths, their weaknesses and their major, MAJOR flaws
She'll be miserable either way. But it's because Jacob and Edward are so evenly matched that she can choose one of the other in the end
It's a WIN-WIN/LOSE-LOSE Situation we have here

At the end of Eclipse ... Bella's decision has been made. Jacob has also made a huge decision. And because of that Bella will have to all choose over again

Will the drama ever end?

Breaking Dawn is going to have everyone screaming in their reading pillows

No matter Bella chooses.

I can't fully support either of the two. Meyer has made them too evenly matched [damn, she's good]

Would you be able to choose??

Posted: Mon Aug 20, 2007 7:24 am

I have to agree with you on almost everything. As rash as it may seem, I really like BellaxEdward pairing. And as inconvienant, stupid, and mary-sue/gary-stue that it is, I'm a sucker for romance. I wouldn't mind BellaxJacob, but Jacob is just so rash and cocky and...rawr....He made me mad in Eclipse. But I agree, she should choose neither. But she says that she really loves Edward and Jacob, both. But she can't live without Edward, therefore Jacob is nothing? I don't think that's fair. I'm torn between the two. I really like Edward, but Jacob was such a good friend to her.... I don't really know, I'm just rambling here. Don't mind me, I just like bouncing ideas off posts.

Soul of Solitude

Offline

xalwaysxwinterx

Offline

Posted: Mon Aug 20, 2007 9:28 am

wow, two people actually chose NEITHER... haha

Posted: Mon Aug 20, 2007 9:31 am

I honestly don't think Edward or Bella could survive without the other. They already tried that and we saw where that got them. Yes, Jacob was a good friend to her, and yes, Bella loves him, but Bella could never love him the way she loves Edward.

Edward and Bella are soul mates, there for, I think Bella will pick Edward.

[Coffee]and[Cigarettes]

Offline

`Narutard!

Offline

Posted: Mon Aug 20, 2007 11:41 am

I <3 Jasper.

'Nuff said.
:]]

But.. I don't know who Bella will choose.
I'm sorta 50/50 on that category.
But, one of my bestfriends says she'll choose Edward.
:3

Posted: Tue Aug 21, 2007 12:01 am

Okay, I see your point, I REALLY DO. And I am not going to go all crazy fan girl because, frankly, it's NOT a for sure thing, the Bella and Edward. It is a thing I heart but it is iffy at times.

But the thing I do know is this. Even in real life, sometimes true love just isn't "convenient." And that's okay. redface

Kipluck

5,850 Points

0
0
0

Offline

somnium yum

5,600 Points

300
200
200

Offline

Posted: Tue Aug 21, 2007 4:07 pm

Right now i'm gonna say Edward... but thats probably because i haven't read eclipse yet (and yes, it's killing me).
Maybe i'll change my mind after reading eclipse...maybe not.

Posted: Tue Aug 21, 2007 5:30 pm

I think she is just going to stick with Edward. Why make things more complicated. She had already made her choice at the end of Eclipse.

[dancing]

Offline

Riri_Benihime

Offline

Posted: Tue Aug 21, 2007 6:21 pm

i think that she should chose edward. If she can't live without him....then it screams death. and if she goes to Jacob again, (after the choice) he'll seem like a rebound....and thats no good. Plus, he'll see she wants to kill herslef for chosing wrong (probably) and Jacob will feel like his own poo....(hehe...doggy poo! rofl ) And with Edward, she will feel like doggy poo, but she'll get over it once she gets changed. ....... ninja

Posted: Wed Aug 22, 2007 8:50 am

I TOTALLY get your point with that. =D But, frankly, I would choose Jacob, because he can do one thing for her that edward never could, and I think we all know what that is *cough*family*cough*kids*cough*nothavingtoleaveherfamilybehindandnevertalktothemagain*cough*. I think Jacob is actually better for her than Edward, and his being more human than edward, actually makes them un-even. I am in love with Jacob, and If i were bella I would choose him. I think that their (edwardxbella) is waay more of an addiction that real REAL love, and that deep down inside, bella loved jacob more than edward. I can picture it now. On BellaXedwards wedding day, when its time for bella to say "I do" Out of the corner of her eye, she sees Jacob, peering at her through the trees, and In that moment, she understands that he is better for her that edward could ever be, and she adds a T to the end of, I Do. *Sigh* I would totally gush over that. =) Anyways, i think you know my opinion on the whole relationship thing xD

heart Jacob

skl02134

Offline

RainyRose329

Offline

Posted: Thu Aug 23, 2007 3:26 pm

Wait... Didn't Jacob already imprint with Bella? Cause it said

"The worst part is what would have been." "What might have been." I sighed. "No." Jacob shook his head. "I'm exactly right for you, Bella. It would ahve been effortless for us - comfortable, easy as breathing. I was the natural path your life would have taken..." He stared into space for a moment, and I waited. :If the world was the way it was supposed to be, if there were no monsters and no magic..."

doesn't that mean that he imprinted bella?

Posted: Sat Sep 08, 2007 2:15 pm

RainyRose329

Wait... Didn't Jacob already imprint with Bella? Cause it said

"The worst part is what would have been." "What might have been." I sighed. "No." Jacob shook his head. "I'm exactly right for you, Bella. It would ahve been effortless for us - comfortable, easy as breathing. I was the natural path your life would have taken..." He stared into space for a moment, and I waited. :If the world was the way it was supposed to be, if there were no monsters and no magic..."

doesn't that mean that he imprinted bella?

No hun it doesnt.

If he imprinted "FANS" believe Jacob would have never let Bella go with Edward in the first place.

Jacob never says straight up he didnt imprint though.
And Bella is the one that said Jacob is her other soul mate.

He COULD have. But fans (mainly the edward supporters)
are denying it.

No one knows really weather they say they do or not.

But in that particular paragraph- no he didnt say that.

Strings of Destiny

Offline

Magical Fangirl Girl

Generous Gawker

7,450 Points

200
250
300

Offline

Posted: Sat Sep 08, 2007 7:50 pm

Strings Of Destiny

RainyRose329

Wait... Didn't Jacob already imprint with Bella? Cause it said

"The worst part is what would have been." "What might have been." I sighed. "No." Jacob shook his head. "I'm exactly right for you, Bella. It would ahve been effortless for us - comfortable, easy as breathing. I was the natural path your life would have taken..." He stared into space for a moment, and I waited. :If the world was the way it was supposed to be, if there were no monsters and no magic..."

doesn't that mean that he imprinted bella?

No hun it doesnt.

If he imprinted "FANS" believe Jacob would have never let Bella go with Edward in the first place.

Jacob never says straight up he didnt imprint though.
And Bella is the one that said Jacob is her other soul mate.

He COULD have. But fans (mainly the edward supporters)
are denying it.

No one knows really weather they say they do or not.

But in that particular paragraph- no he didnt say that.

No, Stephenie Meyer HERSELF has said that Jacob DID NOT imprint on Bella. So it is not just the Edward/Bella supporters.

And with your logic. "FANS" believe that Jacob imprinted on her, because they are so desparate to see Bella with Jake. >.<;; I hate it when people look down on others just because of who they support... DON'T DO IT!

Now back on topic. I am in love with the canon pairing. From the beginning it has been obvious who Bella will choose. It is and always will be Edward. Don't believe me? Wait for the rest of the books. Debating about it is just over thinking things.

This a rather predictable series actually. Don't jump at me for that, okay? It is the truth. Regardless of that, I love the plot and characters (all of them) to pieces.

Posted: Sun Sep 09, 2007 11:13 am

Ok I'm just gonna say this Edward is the love of her life. If he wasn't why would she let her life stay in constant danger? The only part about this I don't like is..well Bella has to give up her family and any future of her own family. in that respect Jacob is better. I don't know I personally would chose Edward but really Jacob seems like the better choice. Though what Autruna said was right we know what's going to happen. The story is almost like every other Vampire book or movie out there. (Don't kill me for that 'cause you know it's true. Human falls for a vampire. ) Bella will be changed and will be with Edward.

Alli_Slytherin_Princess

6,150 Points

100
200
200

Offline

suicidal_sal

Timid Lunatic

Offline

Posted: Sun Sep 09, 2007 7:03 pm

It has to has to has to be Edward! He's obviously more noble that Jacob, who is the biggest jerk! Besides, who wouldn't want to be with Edward and be a part of the Cullen family? Why would anyone want to be with Mike Newton? He's a poser! and a complete and total SQUARE! 3nodding hahaha, but I digress, it has to Edward, because he's perfect! heart but if she doesn't want him *two timing slut* I'll galdly take him biggrin

Welcome to Gaia! ::

Gaia Guilds

The Stephenie Meyer Guild™

Quick Reply

More Information