Welcome to Gaia! ::

Debate/Discuss Religion

Back to Guilds

A guild devoted to discussing and debating different aspects of various world religions 

Tags: religion, faith, tolerance, discuss, debate 

Reply Debate/Discuss Atheism
Are you good without God? Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3 ... 5 6 7 8 9 [>] [»|]

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Your opinion on this?
It's ridiculous.
42%
 42%  [ 17 ]
They have a right to get their message out.
37%
 37%  [ 15 ]
I don't care.
20%
 20%  [ 8 ]
Total Votes : 40


Chieftain Twilight

Loyal Rogue

14,550 Points
  • Full closet 200
  • Tested Practitioner 250
  • Elocutionist 200
PostPosted: Thu Apr 22, 2010 12:39 am


xxEternallyBluexx
Chieftain Twilight
xxEternallyBluexx
Captain_Shinzo


Now, depending on the god I could understand but to the christian god, it seems like puppets played for an audience of few.

That's how it starts, kinda...we're supposed to be His servants at first. Later on though, we get to be His children, His friends...We're called kings and saints in the Bible! Plus, the other half of it is the Bible says you only get to choose between two masters, and if you serve yourself, then you're really serving the devil. So you basically get to choose between an amazing Dad who spoils you with grace and heavenly riches later on, or the illusion of being in charge of yourself, and worse then bubkis in the afterlife....


now that is quite a misunderstanding dear. sad you never STOP being his slaves. you are supposed to be happy and willing slaves, sacrifices to his will as it were. and you are at no point NOT his children and friends unless you are opposed to him. you are always all three at once.
How'd I make that mistake? XD I guess I meant it more like your relationsip with Him is what you need it to be...sometimes He's more like your friend, sometimes your father, but your right, I put that wrong. Oops. xp


heh. an ideal that i am trying to spread around the world is that Friendship is the ultimate expression of love. smile that you cannot be a good parent, or lover, or Master, or Slave, or pet, or cild or anything loving without first being a good friend.
PostPosted: Thu Apr 22, 2010 12:41 am


Chieftain Twilight
xxEternallyBluexx
Chieftain Twilight
xxEternallyBluexx
Chieftain Twilight


now, @ EB: i agree with Shinzo on the "make your own worthe" thing. let me explain it. we have a drive to live by codes of good and evil, and to have a purpose by which to live. that purpose doesn't exist objectively, so we have to decide for ourselves why we live. that can be a scary thought for some people, i know, i have suffered years of suicidal depression because of the realization that i didn't have any purpose or reason. but i found a cause that makes me feel glad, and i feel that that is my purpose. we each have our own purpose, because we choose what that purpose is. we find it however we do, some by religion, others by causes, and still others simply choose one.
I get the whole finding a purpose thing, but I don't think someone can make one in oneself without deluding themselves. I mean, how can you make a purpose in yourself when you know you won't last forever?


confused by simply acknowledging the fact that you arn't meant to last forever. your purpose is for your life. it is supposed to be what makes you feel complete and accomplished while you live. it's no delusion. i know that i have no objective purpose, and i am ok with that. in fact, i have a certain relief because of it. smile i'm not bound by anything other than self-governance! biggrin it's an incredible feeling, knowing (or at least believing) that i can shape my own future. ^_^

I don't know how to deal with that. I've never had to come to terms with being temporal, because I've heard when we die we got to Heaven (so long as we're Saved), my whole life. I can kinda see we're you're coming from ^^, but from the beliefs that have been ingrained into me since a young age, it'd be a great loss to give up the knowledge eternity awaits me, and I don't have to worry about how temporary life is.


i'm not saying there is no eternal afterlife. xd there is one. but in there, just like on this earth, your purpose is up to you. our life purpose is when we are alive. i know it makes no difference to you christians, what with your "heaven" and all that... personally... i think of heaven and hell as states of mind. i'm more inclined to think of the afterlife a plane of existence where all souls go to. i don't think that happiness/joy and pain/sadness can be eternal things. if it were, i'd just pray for oblivion or Nirvana. ._. i couldn't handle that kind of stagnancy.

you shouldn't turn your head away from the fact that life is temporary. you will enjoy life more and better when you apreciate how fleeting it is. smile plus, it's such a peaceful reminder that all things, good and bad, eventually fade away.

I do wonder about how God will work it out so eternal happiness won't become a bore, but I think it won't be that difficult. Boredom is a negative emotion, and excitement, thrill and anticipation are mostly positive one, so I think it'll be difficult for things to get stagnant.

I usually turn to the fact when life's hard, but when thing's are blissful I think about how that's a glimpse of eternity. Thinking of myself or anyone else as temporary is kinda a foreign concept to me though...

xxEverBluexx

6,300 Points
  • Citizen 200
  • Conversationalist 100
  • Tycoon 200

Chieftain Twilight

Loyal Rogue

14,550 Points
  • Full closet 200
  • Tested Practitioner 250
  • Elocutionist 200
PostPosted: Thu Apr 22, 2010 12:45 am


xxEternallyBluexx
Chieftain Twilight
xxEternallyBluexx
Chieftain Twilight
xxEternallyBluexx
Chieftain Twilight


now, @ EB: i agree with Shinzo on the "make your own worthe" thing. let me explain it. we have a drive to live by codes of good and evil, and to have a purpose by which to live. that purpose doesn't exist objectively, so we have to decide for ourselves why we live. that can be a scary thought for some people, i know, i have suffered years of suicidal depression because of the realization that i didn't have any purpose or reason. but i found a cause that makes me feel glad, and i feel that that is my purpose. we each have our own purpose, because we choose what that purpose is. we find it however we do, some by religion, others by causes, and still others simply choose one.
I get the whole finding a purpose thing, but I don't think someone can make one in oneself without deluding themselves. I mean, how can you make a purpose in yourself when you know you won't last forever?


confused by simply acknowledging the fact that you arn't meant to last forever. your purpose is for your life. it is supposed to be what makes you feel complete and accomplished while you live. it's no delusion. i know that i have no objective purpose, and i am ok with that. in fact, i have a certain relief because of it. smile i'm not bound by anything other than self-governance! biggrin it's an incredible feeling, knowing (or at least believing) that i can shape my own future. ^_^

I don't know how to deal with that. I've never had to come to terms with being temporal, because I've heard when we die we got to Heaven (so long as we're Saved), my whole life. I can kinda see we're you're coming from ^^, but from the beliefs that have been ingrained into me since a young age, it'd be a great loss to give up the knowledge eternity awaits me, and I don't have to worry about how temporary life is.


i'm not saying there is no eternal afterlife. xd there is one. but in there, just like on this earth, your purpose is up to you. our life purpose is when we are alive. i know it makes no difference to you christians, what with your "heaven" and all that... personally... i think of heaven and hell as states of mind. i'm more inclined to think of the afterlife a plane of existence where all souls go to. i don't think that happiness/joy and pain/sadness can be eternal things. if it were, i'd just pray for oblivion or Nirvana. ._. i couldn't handle that kind of stagnancy.

you shouldn't turn your head away from the fact that life is temporary. you will enjoy life more and better when you apreciate how fleeting it is. smile plus, it's such a peaceful reminder that all things, good and bad, eventually fade away.

I do wonder about how God will work it out so eternal happiness won't become a bore, but I think it won't be that difficult. Boredom is a negative emotion, and excitement, thrill and anticipation are mostly positive one, so I think it'll be difficult for things to get stagnant.

I usually turn to the fact when life's hard, but when thing's are blissful I think about how that's a glimpse of eternity. Thinking of myself or anyone else as temporary is kinda a foreign concept to me though...

mehhh... you enjoy yer favoured thought, and i'll enjoy min. ^_^ in the words of all the best people, Peace and Namaste.
PostPosted: Thu Apr 22, 2010 12:46 am


Chieftain Twilight
xxEternallyBluexx
Chieftain Twilight
xxEternallyBluexx
Captain_Shinzo


Now, depending on the god I could understand but to the christian god, it seems like puppets played for an audience of few.

That's how it starts, kinda...we're supposed to be His servants at first. Later on though, we get to be His children, His friends...We're called kings and saints in the Bible! Plus, the other half of it is the Bible says you only get to choose between two masters, and if you serve yourself, then you're really serving the devil. So you basically get to choose between an amazing Dad who spoils you with grace and heavenly riches later on, or the illusion of being in charge of yourself, and worse then bubkis in the afterlife....


now that is quite a misunderstanding dear. sad you never STOP being his slaves. you are supposed to be happy and willing slaves, sacrifices to his will as it were. and you are at no point NOT his children and friends unless you are opposed to him. you are always all three at once.
How'd I make that mistake? XD I guess I meant it more like your relationsip with Him is what you need it to be...sometimes He's more like your friend, sometimes your father, but your right, I put that wrong. Oops. xp


heh. an ideal that i am trying to spread around the world is that Friendship is the ultimate expression of love. smile that you cannot be a good parent, or lover, or Master, or Slave, or pet, or cild or anything loving without first being a good friend.

I don't know that that's always what someone needs at first though; like an abused girl might need a loving Father, and an arrogant man might need a Master...I think He wants us to become friends with Him, but there's a time and season to it like everything else.

And I think I gotta get off soon; it's about 3:45 where I am. xp

xxEverBluexx

6,300 Points
  • Citizen 200
  • Conversationalist 100
  • Tycoon 200

xxEverBluexx

6,300 Points
  • Citizen 200
  • Conversationalist 100
  • Tycoon 200
PostPosted: Thu Apr 22, 2010 12:49 am


Chieftain Twilight
xxEternallyBluexx
Chieftain Twilight
xxEternallyBluexx
Chieftain Twilight


confused by simply acknowledging the fact that you arn't meant to last forever. your purpose is for your life. it is supposed to be what makes you feel complete and accomplished while you live. it's no delusion. i know that i have no objective purpose, and i am ok with that. in fact, i have a certain relief because of it. smile i'm not bound by anything other than self-governance! biggrin it's an incredible feeling, knowing (or at least believing) that i can shape my own future. ^_^

I don't know how to deal with that. I've never had to come to terms with being temporal, because I've heard when we die we got to Heaven (so long as we're Saved), my whole life. I can kinda see we're you're coming from ^^, but from the beliefs that have been ingrained into me since a young age, it'd be a great loss to give up the knowledge eternity awaits me, and I don't have to worry about how temporary life is.


i'm not saying there is no eternal afterlife. xd there is one. but in there, just like on this earth, your purpose is up to you. our life purpose is when we are alive. i know it makes no difference to you christians, what with your "heaven" and all that... personally... i think of heaven and hell as states of mind. i'm more inclined to think of the afterlife a plane of existence where all souls go to. i don't think that happiness/joy and pain/sadness can be eternal things. if it were, i'd just pray for oblivion or Nirvana. ._. i couldn't handle that kind of stagnancy.

you shouldn't turn your head away from the fact that life is temporary. you will enjoy life more and better when you apreciate how fleeting it is. smile plus, it's such a peaceful reminder that all things, good and bad, eventually fade away.

I do wonder about how God will work it out so eternal happiness won't become a bore, but I think it won't be that difficult. Boredom is a negative emotion, and excitement, thrill and anticipation are mostly positive one, so I think it'll be difficult for things to get stagnant.

I usually turn to the fact when life's hard, but when thing's are blissful I think about how that's a glimpse of eternity. Thinking of myself or anyone else as temporary is kinda a foreign concept to me though...

mehhh... you enjoy yer favoured thought, and i'll enjoy min. ^_^ in the words of all the best people, Peace and Namaste.
^_^ Sounds good. Good night, because I don't think I'll be doing anymore posting.
PostPosted: Thu Apr 22, 2010 12:59 am


xxEternallyBluexx
Chieftain Twilight
xxEternallyBluexx
Chieftain Twilight
xxEternallyBluexx
Captain_Shinzo


Now, depending on the god I could understand but to the christian god, it seems like puppets played for an audience of few.

That's how it starts, kinda...we're supposed to be His servants at first. Later on though, we get to be His children, His friends...We're called kings and saints in the Bible! Plus, the other half of it is the Bible says you only get to choose between two masters, and if you serve yourself, then you're really serving the devil. So you basically get to choose between an amazing Dad who spoils you with grace and heavenly riches later on, or the illusion of being in charge of yourself, and worse then bubkis in the afterlife....


now that is quite a misunderstanding dear. sad you never STOP being his slaves. you are supposed to be happy and willing slaves, sacrifices to his will as it were. and you are at no point NOT his children and friends unless you are opposed to him. you are always all three at once.
How'd I make that mistake? XD I guess I meant it more like your relationsip with Him is what you need it to be...sometimes He's more like your friend, sometimes your father, but your right, I put that wrong. Oops. xp


heh. an ideal that i am trying to spread around the world is that Friendship is the ultimate expression of love. smile that you cannot be a good parent, or lover, or Master, or Slave, or pet, or cild or anything loving without first being a good friend.

I don't know that that's always what someone needs at first though; like an abused girl might need a loving Father, and an arrogant man might need a Master...I think He wants us to become friends with Him, but there's a time and season to it like everything else.

And I think I gotta get off soon; it's about 3:45 where I am. xp


well see, you are misinterpreting what i mean. my definition of friend is someone who is always there for you, who loves you and is loyal to you, and who is ready to do whatever is best for your wellbeing.

under that definition, a father being their for his daughter, and teaching her how to remain happy and strong-willed even in the face of an awful betrayal by some jerk, is an exact example of what i mean by being the best dad you can be by being the best friend you can be. get it? smile by being such a good and loving father he is being a good friend, the ultimate expression of love. and that friendship is in turn what makes him such a good father.

Chieftain Twilight

Loyal Rogue

14,550 Points
  • Full closet 200
  • Tested Practitioner 250
  • Elocutionist 200

She and Him

6,850 Points
  • Tycoon 200
  • Citizen 200
  • Flatterer 200
PostPosted: Thu Apr 22, 2010 6:58 pm



I wonder what Jesus would do if he had the money..

Billboard | Feed the hungry

Hmm.. billboard.. feed the hungry..

What a difficult decision.

Edit: I think if churches put their money to better use, they'd find a lot more people go to church. It's not as if the billboard will bring anyone to them.
PostPosted: Thu Apr 22, 2010 8:50 pm


xxEternallyBluexx
Captain_Shinzo


Now, depending on the god I could understand but to the christian god, it seems like puppets played for an audience of few.

That's how it starts, kinda...we're supposed to be His servants at first. Later on though, we get to be His children, His friends...We're called kings and saints in the Bible! Plus, the other half of it is the Bible says you only get to choose between two masters, and if you serve yourself, then you're really serving the devil. So you basically get to choose between an amazing Dad who spoils you with grace and heavenly riches later on, or the illusion of being in charge of yourself, and worse then bubkis in the afterlife....

As Epicurus proves, that seems pretty false.

Captain_Shinzo

6,250 Points
  • Member 100
  • Gaian 50
  • Dressed Up 200

xxEverBluexx

6,300 Points
  • Citizen 200
  • Conversationalist 100
  • Tycoon 200
PostPosted: Thu Apr 22, 2010 8:50 pm


Chieftain Twilight
xxEternallyBluexx
Chieftain Twilight
xxEternallyBluexx
Chieftain Twilight


now that is quite a misunderstanding dear. sad you never STOP being his slaves. you are supposed to be happy and willing slaves, sacrifices to his will as it were. and you are at no point NOT his children and friends unless you are opposed to him. you are always all three at once.
How'd I make that mistake? XD I guess I meant it more like your relationsip with Him is what you need it to be...sometimes He's more like your friend, sometimes your father, but your right, I put that wrong. Oops. xp


heh. an ideal that i am trying to spread around the world is that Friendship is the ultimate expression of love. smile that you cannot be a good parent, or lover, or Master, or Slave, or pet, or cild or anything loving without first being a good friend.

I don't know that that's always what someone needs at first though; like an abused girl might need a loving Father, and an arrogant man might need a Master...I think He wants us to become friends with Him, but there's a time and season to it like everything else.

And I think I gotta get off soon; it's about 3:45 where I am. xp


well see, you are misinterpreting what i mean. my definition of friend is someone who is always there for you, who loves you and is loyal to you, and who is ready to do whatever is best for your wellbeing.

under that definition, a father being their for his daughter, and teaching her how to remain happy and strong-willed even in the face of an awful betrayal by some jerk, is an exact example of what i mean by being the best dad you can be by being the best friend you can be. get it? smile by being such a good and loving father he is being a good friend, the ultimate expression of love. and that friendship is in turn what makes him such a good father.

I see. Your using friend in a more general way then I normally do, but what you're saying makes sense. ^^
PostPosted: Thu Apr 22, 2010 8:53 pm


Captain_Shinzo
xxEternallyBluexx
Captain_Shinzo


Now, depending on the god I could understand but to the christian god, it seems like puppets played for an audience of few.

That's how it starts, kinda...we're supposed to be His servants at first. Later on though, we get to be His children, His friends...We're called kings and saints in the Bible! Plus, the other half of it is the Bible says you only get to choose between two masters, and if you serve yourself, then you're really serving the devil. So you basically get to choose between an amazing Dad who spoils you with grace and heavenly riches later on, or the illusion of being in charge of yourself, and worse then bubkis in the afterlife....

As Epicurus proves, that seems pretty false.
You'll have to explain further...

xxEverBluexx

6,300 Points
  • Citizen 200
  • Conversationalist 100
  • Tycoon 200

xxEverBluexx

6,300 Points
  • Citizen 200
  • Conversationalist 100
  • Tycoon 200
PostPosted: Thu Apr 22, 2010 8:55 pm


She and Him

I wonder what Jesus would do if he had the money..

Billboard | Feed the hungry

Hmm.. billboard.. feed the hungry..

What a difficult decision.

Edit: I think if churches put their money to better use, they'd find a lot more people go to church. It's not as if the billboard will bring anyone to them.
Good point...
PostPosted: Thu Apr 22, 2010 9:05 pm


xxEternallyBluexx
Chieftain Twilight
xxEternallyBluexx
Chieftain Twilight
xxEternallyBluexx
Chieftain Twilight


now that is quite a misunderstanding dear. sad you never STOP being his slaves. you are supposed to be happy and willing slaves, sacrifices to his will as it were. and you are at no point NOT his children and friends unless you are opposed to him. you are always all three at once.
How'd I make that mistake? XD I guess I meant it more like your relationsip with Him is what you need it to be...sometimes He's more like your friend, sometimes your father, but your right, I put that wrong. Oops. xp


heh. an ideal that i am trying to spread around the world is that Friendship is the ultimate expression of love. smile that you cannot be a good parent, or lover, or Master, or Slave, or pet, or cild or anything loving without first being a good friend.

I don't know that that's always what someone needs at first though; like an abused girl might need a loving Father, and an arrogant man might need a Master...I think He wants us to become friends with Him, but there's a time and season to it like everything else.

And I think I gotta get off soon; it's about 3:45 where I am. xp


well see, you are misinterpreting what i mean. my definition of friend is someone who is always there for you, who loves you and is loyal to you, and who is ready to do whatever is best for your wellbeing.

under that definition, a father being their for his daughter, and teaching her how to remain happy and strong-willed even in the face of an awful betrayal by some jerk, is an exact example of what i mean by being the best dad you can be by being the best friend you can be. get it? smile by being such a good and loving father he is being a good friend, the ultimate expression of love. and that friendship is in turn what makes him such a good father.

I see. Your using friend in a more general way then I normally do, but what you're saying makes sense. ^^


aye, in a way i am. smile my point is, i see Friendship as, as i keep saying, the Ultimate Expression of Love.

Chieftain Twilight

Loyal Rogue

14,550 Points
  • Full closet 200
  • Tested Practitioner 250
  • Elocutionist 200

Captain_Shinzo

6,250 Points
  • Member 100
  • Gaian 50
  • Dressed Up 200
PostPosted: Thu Apr 22, 2010 9:10 pm


xxEternallyBluexx
Captain_Shinzo
xxEternallyBluexx
Captain_Shinzo


Now, depending on the god I could understand but to the christian god, it seems like puppets played for an audience of few.

That's how it starts, kinda...we're supposed to be His servants at first. Later on though, we get to be His children, His friends...We're called kings and saints in the Bible! Plus, the other half of it is the Bible says you only get to choose between two masters, and if you serve yourself, then you're really serving the devil. So you basically get to choose between an amazing Dad who spoils you with grace and heavenly riches later on, or the illusion of being in charge of yourself, and worse then bubkis in the afterlife....

As Epicurus proves, that seems pretty false.
You'll have to explain further...

Is God willing to prevent evil, but not able?
Then he is not omnipotent.
Is he able, but not willing?
Then he is malevolent.
Is he both able and willing?
Then whence cometh evil?
Is he neither able nor willing?
Then why call him God?

Epicurus posed this question a few questions. It poses the existence of evil and has stumped almost all Christians and most religious folk.
PostPosted: Thu Apr 22, 2010 9:12 pm


Captain_Shinzo
xxEternallyBluexx
Captain_Shinzo
xxEternallyBluexx
Captain_Shinzo


Now, depending on the god I could understand but to the christian god, it seems like puppets played for an audience of few.

That's how it starts, kinda...we're supposed to be His servants at first. Later on though, we get to be His children, His friends...We're called kings and saints in the Bible! Plus, the other half of it is the Bible says you only get to choose between two masters, and if you serve yourself, then you're really serving the devil. So you basically get to choose between an amazing Dad who spoils you with grace and heavenly riches later on, or the illusion of being in charge of yourself, and worse then bubkis in the afterlife....

As Epicurus proves, that seems pretty false.
You'll have to explain further...

Is God willing to prevent evil, but not able?
Then he is not omnipotent.
Is he able, but not willing?
Then he is malevolent.
Is he both able and willing?
Then whence cometh evil?
Is he neither able nor willing?
Then why call him God?

Epicurus posed this question a few questions. It poses the existence of evil and has stumped almost all Christians and most religious folk.


glad i heard this. good way to put my belief that he either does not live, or is malevolant.

Chieftain Twilight

Loyal Rogue

14,550 Points
  • Full closet 200
  • Tested Practitioner 250
  • Elocutionist 200

xxEverBluexx

6,300 Points
  • Citizen 200
  • Conversationalist 100
  • Tycoon 200
PostPosted: Thu Apr 22, 2010 9:58 pm


Captain_Shinzo
xxEternallyBluexx
Captain_Shinzo
xxEternallyBluexx
Captain_Shinzo


Now, depending on the god I could understand but to the christian god, it seems like puppets played for an audience of few.

That's how it starts, kinda...we're supposed to be His servants at first. Later on though, we get to be His children, His friends...We're called kings and saints in the Bible! Plus, the other half of it is the Bible says you only get to choose between two masters, and if you serve yourself, then you're really serving the devil. So you basically get to choose between an amazing Dad who spoils you with grace and heavenly riches later on, or the illusion of being in charge of yourself, and worse then bubkis in the afterlife....

As Epicurus proves, that seems pretty false.
You'll have to explain further...

Is God willing to prevent evil, but not able?
Then he is not omnipotent.
Is he able, but not willing?
Then he is malevolent.
Is he both able and willing?
Then whence cometh evil?
Is he neither able nor willing?
Then why call him God?

Epicurus posed this question a few questions. It poses the existence of evil and has stumped almost all Christians and most religious folk.

Ah, that. Okay, it's that He is able, but He doesn't because love demands there is a choice. Evil comes from seperating from God, and doing what is against His will, and He needed to offer us the option of being able to do wrong because He didn't want us enslaved to His will, but wanted us to love Him of our own accord. He intended us to have a high place (I think there's even a verse that says He set us only a little below Him, but I might have that wrong). Considering that high place, I'm guessing we had to go through something more intense then the rest of creation.
rolleyes And no, it hasn't stumped 'almost all Christians'. I bet that most haven't even seen that, and if I'm not completely stumped by that, and I'm not all that brillant, then there's probably Christians smarter then me who could come up with an argument that blows that out of the water. Plus if it had everyone so stumped, the church wouldn't exist.
Reply
Debate/Discuss Atheism

Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3 ... 5 6 7 8 9 [>] [»|]
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum