Welcome to Gaia! ::

Greek Mythology Guild

Back to Guilds

A guild for lovers of Greek Mythology in all its rich variety. 

Tags: Greek, Greece, Classical, Mythology, Myth 

Reply Greek Mythology Guild
Who's Better, Zeus, Poseidon, or Hades? Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3 ... 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 [>] [»|]

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Who's better?
Zeus
22%
 22%  [ 24 ]
Poseidon
27%
 27%  [ 29 ]
Hades
49%
 49%  [ 52 ]
Total Votes : 105



Mirastella


Bunny Enthusiast

PostPosted: Sat Mar 13, 2010 12:11 pm


Herry Rockabore
kingofjokers7
~ContessaLeandra~
Barn Lord
Luna Lumine
I notice no-one picked Zeus on the poll. Probably because he's a hypocrite and a whore. But y'know, it's probably pretty tough to rule the world. So many people with problems you have to solve.

And Poseidon is the diety representing water, which humans are pretty much made up of and cannot survive without.

Regardless, I vote Hades. He's one of very few honest Greek dieties.

Hades is not honest.



My point would be that he KIDNAPPED and married his niece, and Persephone is not happy to be there at all. And contrary to popular belief, he did actually cheat on his wife with some nymphs, I believe. So I agree.
But did he lie about kidnapping Persephone? I'm pretty sure he made a deal with Demeter so at least one god is happy all the time. And about the cheating, you don't hate Zues for it, you don't hate Aphrodite for it, and when you live as long as the gods, you get bored very easily.

The point is that people sometimes pretty much call Hades a sweet, innocent, little angel saint when he was clearly not perfect and did naughty stuff just like Zeus.

While he didn't lie about stealing Persephone, he didn't let Demeter know that he kidnapped her. He probably wouldn't have ever let Demeter know if Zeus hadn't convinced him to reason with Demeter since she refused to usher in vegetation. And even then he didn't exactly play fair he tricked Persephone into staying with him by getting her to eat the seeds. Not exactly my definition of honest, but it does make for a captivating story.

And also often the cheating is the one thing that makes people dislike Zeus and Aphrodite, which kind of annoys me. If you ask me their promiscuity is due to 2 things 1. They both have unhappy marriages and 2. They clearly have the highest sex drives of the deities. While that really is not an excuse for cheating, they couldn't get a divorce because Hera had the Queen title and Aphrodite was stuck with Hephaestus since it was arranged that way. Besides I am sort of willing to excuse the behavior because if not for how they acted we wouldn't be able to function without Eros, Persephone, Artemis, Apollo, Hermes, etc.

I dunno about how Aphrodite felt about her lovers besides Ares and Adonis, but I think Zeus actually showed he cared about the women he seduced since he tried to protect them from Hera and he did the right thing when Semele was struck dead due to the oath she forced him to make that made him reveal his god form to her, leaving him to put Dionysus in his thigh. I think that that shows me he isn't ALL bad. He isn't all good either but he's not heartless like some people paint him as.


About Hades: Right on. I'm not sure if this is accurate but it was Zeus who accepted Hades' permission to take Persephone away since he IS her father - convincing Demeter is scary. So it was through trickery that he got what he wanted. I can understand that he's usually a strict but fair god with tedious tasks - so it's possible that he couldn't stand losing her although he can be greedy at times (No offense, Hades).

About Zeus & Aphrodite: Even if I don't like the idea of cheating, I sorta do felt sorry for them. At least, Zeus can put a stop to conflicts or something like that while Aphrodite can be sympathetic (Pygmalion) and... makes things interesting, I guess. ^^;
PostPosted: Sat Mar 13, 2010 12:28 pm


Consider the way the Greek universe works. Lust and love are governed by Eros, the winged god of desire. Zeus' many illicit affairs could be chalked up to his nephew being mischievous and picking on his uncle.

Akherontis
Captain



Mirastella


Bunny Enthusiast

PostPosted: Sat Mar 13, 2010 12:43 pm


That makes sense. I thought only mortals are part of his tricks. :u
PostPosted: Sat Mar 13, 2010 12:47 pm


Mira Rosey
That makes sense. I thought only mortals are part of his tricks. :u


Seneca, Phaedra: "This winged god rules ruthlessly throughout the earth and inflames Zeus himself, wounded with unquenched fires. Ares, the warrior god, has felt those flames; that god has felt them who fashions the three-forked thunderbolts, yea, he who tends the hot furnaces ever raging ‘neath Aetna’s peaks is inflamed by so mall a fire as this. Nay, Phoebus, himself, who guides with sure aim his arrows from the bowstring, a boy of more sure aim pierces with his flying shaft, and flits about, baneful alike to heaven and to earth."

Nonnus, Dionysiaca: "Enchanted by Semele, Zeus received the sweet maddening spark in a heart which new it well. Allfather was worsted by a child: little Eros with his feeble shot set afire this Archer of Thunderbolts. Not the deluge of the flood, not the fiery lightning could help its possessor: that huge heavenly flame itself was vanquished by the small fire of unwarlike Paphia; little Eros faced the shaggy skin, his magical girdle faced the aegis; the heavy-booming din of the thunderclap was the slave of his lovebreeding quiver. The god was shaken by the heartbewitching sting of desire for Semele, in amazement: for love is near neightbour to admiration."

Akherontis
Captain



Mirastella


Bunny Enthusiast

PostPosted: Sat Mar 13, 2010 1:15 pm


Akherontis
Mira Rosey
That makes sense. I thought only mortals are part of his tricks. :u


Seneca, Phaedra: "This winged god rules ruthlessly throughout the earth and inflames Zeus himself, wounded with unquenched fires. Ares, the warrior god, has felt those flames; that god has felt them who fashions the three-forked thunderbolts, yea, he who tends the hot furnaces ever raging ‘neath Aetna’s peaks is inflamed by so mall a fire as this. Nay, Phoebus, himself, who guides with sure aim his arrows from the bowstring, a boy of more sure aim pierces with his flying shaft, and flits about, baneful alike to heaven and to earth."

Nonnus, Dionysiaca: "Enchanted by Semele, Zeus received the sweet maddening spark in a heart which new it well. Allfather was worsted by a child: little Eros with his feeble shot set afire this Archer of Thunderbolts. Not the deluge of the flood, not the fiery lightning could help its possessor: that huge heavenly flame itself was vanquished by the small fire of unwarlike Paphia; little Eros faced the shaggy skin, his magical girdle faced the aegis; the heavy-booming din of the thunderclap was the slave of his lovebreeding quiver. The god was shaken by the heartbewitching sting of desire for Semele, in amazement: for love is near neightbour to admiration."


Cool. Thank you for the info on Eros. smile

Edit: Oh crap! I almost forgot - It's hard to choose since I became aware of their roles. But personally I picked Hades because he had to deal with the dead 24/7 with an assembled teams of workers. My second choice - Poseidon because of the wonders of the sea and he's feared with tsunamis and earthquakes.
PostPosted: Sat Mar 13, 2010 1:40 pm


BOOYAH!!!!! I'm winning the poll! I'm winning I'm winning I'm winning I'm winning I'm winning I'm winning I'm winning!!!!!!!!!

...I got a little excited there.

HadesPluto


Akherontis
Captain

PostPosted: Sat Mar 13, 2010 1:43 pm


HadesPluto
BOOYAH!!!!! I'm winning the poll! I'm winning I'm winning I'm winning I'm winning I'm winning I'm winning I'm winning!!!!!!!!!

...I got a little excited there.


You'd think being the wealthiest of gods with the largest kingdom would do wonders for you self-confidence, but apparently not.
PostPosted: Sat Mar 13, 2010 1:50 pm


Akherontis
HadesPluto
BOOYAH!!!!! I'm winning the poll! I'm winning I'm winning I'm winning I'm winning I'm winning I'm winning I'm winning!!!!!!!!!

...I got a little excited there.


You'd think being the wealthiest of gods with the largest kingdom would do wonders for you self-confidence, but apparently not.


He's just not used to the idea of being popular yet. Just give him some time. confused

Ares or Mars

9,350 Points
  • Brandisher 100
  • Survivor 150
  • Risky Lifestyle 100


Mirastella


Bunny Enthusiast

PostPosted: Sat Mar 13, 2010 1:51 pm


Lol. Better calm down before anyone else notices. xD;
Btw, when will does this poll end?
PostPosted: Sat Mar 13, 2010 1:52 pm


Mira Rosey

Cool. Thank you for the info on Eros. smile

Edit: Oh crap! I almost forgot - It's hard to choose since I became aware of their roles. But personally I picked Hades because he had to deal with the dead 24/7 with an assembled teams of workers. My second choice - Poseidon because of the wonders of the sea and he's feared with tsunamis and earthquakes.


Funnily enough, Poseidon wasn't even responsible for most of the sea's wonders and dangers. That was the territory of other sea gods. Thaumas was the god of sea wonders, and his daughters were the rainbow goddesses Iris and Arke, as well as the harpies, Aello and Okypete. Phorkys and Keto were the god and goddess of sea dangers, and their children were the monsters of the sea; Skylla, Thoosa, Ekhidna, the Gorgons and the Graiai. There was also Nereus, the old man of the sea whose twenty daughters were the Nereides (Mermaids), and Proteus, the shapeshifting god of herding seals.

Akherontis
Captain


HadesPluto

PostPosted: Sat Mar 13, 2010 1:55 pm


Ares or Mars
Akherontis
HadesPluto
BOOYAH!!!!! I'm winning the poll! I'm winning I'm winning I'm winning I'm winning I'm winning I'm winning I'm winning!!!!!!!!!

...I got a little excited there.


You'd think being the wealthiest of gods with the largest kingdom would do wonders for you self-confidence, but apparently not.


He's just not used to the idea of being popular yet. Just give him some time. confused


I agree with Ares. 4laugh
PostPosted: Sat Mar 13, 2010 1:56 pm


Akherontis
Mira Rosey

Cool. Thank you for the info on Eros. smile

Edit: Oh crap! I almost forgot - It's hard to choose since I became aware of their roles. But personally I picked Hades because he had to deal with the dead 24/7 with an assembled teams of workers. My second choice - Poseidon because of the wonders of the sea and he's feared with tsunamis and earthquakes.


Funnily enough, Poseidon wasn't even responsible for most of the sea's wonders and dangers. That was the territory of other sea gods. Thaumas was the god of sea wonders, and his daughters were the rainbow goddesses Iris and Arke, as well as the harpies, Aello and Okypete. Phorkys and Keto were the god and goddess of sea dangers, and their children were the monsters of the sea; Skylla, Thoosa, Ekhidna, the Gorgons and the Graiai. There was also Nereus, the old man of the sea whose twenty daughters were the Nereides (Mermaids), and Proteus, the shapeshifting god of herding seals.


Oh! Oops. Sorry about that. >.<; I really need to read more. Haha.


Mirastella


Bunny Enthusiast


Goddess of The Century

PostPosted: Sun Mar 14, 2010 12:31 pm


Ares or Mars
Goddess of The Century
joshleal
I think Hades won because he's the only one with an account here.


rofl


HE SPEAKS THE TRUTH! eek

User Image - Blocked by "Display Image" Settings. Click to show.


Someone needs to make a Poseidon and Zeus to even up the playing field.
wink
PostPosted: Sun Mar 14, 2010 12:38 pm


Goddess of The Century
Ares or Mars
Goddess of The Century
joshleal
I think Hades won because he's the only one with an account here.


rofl


HE SPEAKS THE TRUTH! eek

User Image - Blocked by "Display Image" Settings. Click to show.


Someone needs to make a Poseidon and Zeus to even up the playing field.
wink


No, I think it's alright with Hades winning, there's about no chance of the other two catching up.

joshleal

3,350 Points
  • Dressed Up 200
  • Treasure Hunter 100
  • Full closet 200


Mirastella


Bunny Enthusiast

PostPosted: Mon Mar 15, 2010 12:14 pm


joshleal
Goddess of The Century
Ares or Mars
Goddess of The Century
joshleal
I think Hades won because he's the only one with an account here.


rofl


HE SPEAKS THE TRUTH! eek

User Image - Blocked by "Display Image" Settings. Click to show.


Someone needs to make a Poseidon and Zeus to even up the playing field.
wink


No, I think it's alright with Hades winning, there's about no chance of the other two catching up.


*Points at the poll*

Zeus - 24%
Poseidon - 20%

Looks like they are starting to catch. This time, Zeus' surprisingly in second now and sadly Poseidon's last.
Reply
Greek Mythology Guild

Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3 ... 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 [>] [»|]
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum