Welcome to Gaia! ::

The Island of Dr. Moreau Quester Central

Back to Guilds

 

 

Reply The Island of Dr. Moreau Questor Central
Official Character Critique Depot - TEMP CLOSED Goto Page: [] [<<] [<] 1 2 3 ... 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 [>] [»|]

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Island of Moreau
Captain

PostPosted: Sun Aug 27, 2006 2:45 pm


PykeDarkewoulfe
Official Critique Request
Gaia Username: PykeDarkewoulfe
Character Name: Jordan Essex
Serum Animal(s): Samoyed
Quest Thread: ]http://www.gaiaonline.com/guilds/viewtopic.php?t=3878359


The first thing that kind of strikes a chord with me is his appearance. He's described as being incredibly handsome and nearly perfect, including "ice blue eyes" and a great body. While genetics plays a big part, if he didn't work out regularly since high school he might still have a nice frame, but he would lose a big chunk of his muscle definition. Metabolism might keep him from being fat, but he wouldn't be extremely toned or anything. Anyway, tangent. He just raised a few too bishie flags for me. Nothing that would be required to change, but a flaw or two wouldn't hurt.

His back story seems a bit contrived if you ask me as well. Especially the father who was so adamant about not letting his son follow his dream but to just be a mindless jock because that's what he was. It's overdone and seems fairly unrealistic. Just because he saw one animal get killed when he was six he forbid him from ever owner another pet ever again? And then he ships him off to football and when his son actually commits to it, he never once said he was proud or acted happy in the least?

Also, where was his mother during all this? What did she think about it?

Also - I'm a bit unclear why he would want so badly to work for Feral Labs when he already had a job working with animals at Busche Garderns. Feral Labs is medicine research and while they work closely with animals - its usually animal testing. Something someone who so desperately wanted to "help" animals would probably not be chomping at the bit to do.

I would also like a bit more information on Bruno Moretti. Was he even an employee, or just posing as one? And if she was an employee, why did he specifically need Jordon's help?

I see no -major flaws- with the character as is, but I would like it a bit ironed out a bit before its sealed.
PostPosted: Sun Aug 27, 2006 2:52 pm


Tzell
Official Critique Request
Gaia Username: Tzell
Character Name: Adam Keller
Serum Animal(s): Arctic Fox
Quest Thread: ]http://www.gaiaonline.com/guilds/viewtopic.php?t=3955889


My only real beef with this character is ... how the heck did he managed to pose as a superior in Feral Labs? Did he get the job with fake documents? Or just "pretend"? Feral Lab has pretty state of the art security, it would be hard to pretend to work there for a matter for several weeks without anyone, uh, noticing.

Iron out a few of those details, otherwise everything sounds fine to me.

Island of Moreau
Captain


Island of Moreau
Captain

PostPosted: Thu Aug 31, 2006 12:34 am


Sophie C. Bell
Official Critique Request
Gaia Username: fallen_kitsune_thief
Character Name: Sophie C. Bell
Serum Animal(s): Red Kangaroo
Quest Thread: ]http://www.gaiaonline.com/guilds/viewtopic.php?t=2740195


Sophie sounds to be overall a sound character. The 'ephermial' looking eyes sounds a little bit questionable - it's a large cliche to use 'strange' eyes on an otherwise rather normal character. But that's more a suggestion that anything.

Other than that, she sounds fine other than the way to the island.

By this point, Sabin is on the island himself without contact to the outside world. Perhaps Sophie has gone to a Feral Labs owned clinic for studies with her narcolepsy? IT's common for disorders like that to have some experimental treatments that she might have tried at some point and gotten her on Moreau's radar. If she was easily disappearable, then she could be approached through that line.
PostPosted: Wed Sep 13, 2006 1:22 pm


harleykay
Official Critique Request
Gaia Username: harleykay
Character Name: Katherine Harley (yeah, i know....)
Serum Animal(s): possible lion/swan combo to make a sphinx, but also up for badger or otter
Quest Thread: http://www.gaiaonline.com/guilds/viewtopic.php?t=3530069


Thanks infinitely for doing this. Like a mother, I'm kind of blind towards the faults in my history/character/ideas in general, so the help is GREATLY appreciated.

Once more, thank you!!!!


I don't think that it's a bad idea to keep a couple of different animal choices for your character. I think that the sphinx concept is really neat, but, obviously not every opportunity is going to allow for a mythical combination serum. So it's good to have backups if you are able to get onto the island through a different opportunity, or if one of your ideas gets taken.

The character's personality sounds well-rounded and believable.

Her family's reaction is also very believable in regards to her father's disappearence (trying to find him, sending her to therapy).

*laughs at the irony of the sphinx reference pic you found* Sabin's flattered you liked it, and says that it was one of his earliest CG works, and he's sure he'd be able to do a much better job on a sphinx now ^_~

I'm usually one to advise against spontaneous developments of psychoses after the transformation (as usually it doesn't make sense without the potential being there) though admittedly with all of the physical changes going on, synthesia seems mor elikely of a side-effect. ALTHOUGH, if you do go with Sphinx, there would't be a lot of morphological changes in her head, and thus making it less likely?

Anywho, aside from that part, She looks good to go smile

User Image - Blocked by "Display Image" Settings. Click to show.

Island of Moreau
Captain


Island of Moreau
Captain

PostPosted: Wed Sep 13, 2006 1:31 pm


Rabid Jigglypuff
Official Critique Request
Gaia Username: Rabid Jigglypuff
Character Name: Calida Delgado
Serum Animal(s): Tauric Goliath Tarantula (Drider)
Quest Thread: ]http://www.gaiaonline.com/guilds/viewtopic.php?t=2945565


First off, yay for having a non-American character. We do have a lot of attractive, young characters, but that aspect definately ties into her concept, and there's nothing wrong with having a young, attractive character.

I really like the fact that despite being a very attractive woman, and yearning to go into modeling, that she has thus far failed in that attempt. The character's got depth and flaws, and sounds interesting.

User Image - Blocked by "Display Image" Settings. Click to show.
PostPosted: Wed Sep 13, 2006 4:21 pm


[-Darcy-]
Official Critique Request
Gaia Username: Darcy1992
Character Name: Artemis Jaeger
Serum Animal(s): Aardwolf
Quest Thread: Here


First off, the multi-colored hair: It is not natural to grow hair in multiple color patches for humans. You might see photos (like you posted) but those are dye jobs. It's been fairly popular of late, especially with the J-rock crowd, et al to dye the "outer" or "inner" parts of the hair. That or it's the sign of a dye job growing out.

Also, Artemis is not a modern name in the least, and even in its origin, is a woman's name. (more later).

I don't reccomend integrating the "discovered homosexual" at such a late age it doesn't make much sense that he wouldn't have some sort of inclination yet. Nothing against homosexuals (duh, given the owners), but we do already have a surprising proportion of gay characters on the island, and so I wouldn't reccomend putting it as a "tack on" to a character.

The character sounds like a toss together of a lot of concepts that don't necessarily mesh well. Particularly the gypsy grandmother with a Hitler-supproting grandfather. Gypsies were one of the groups that the nazi's expunged from Germany and/or killed on sight. And why would such a free-spirited woman elope with such a strict individual. And while Gypsies have integrated some aspects and symbology of Christianity, they aren't any single recognizable branch of Christianity. So why would they have lived in a "good Christian" home?

And as for the name, Both families had moved to America, and presumably integrated into the culture if the parents had been born there. Why go back to a Greek name? And beyond that, Artemis is not only an archaic Greek name (not in modern usage) but was the name of a Goddess (a woman's name). For the info on the character, you mention because of the "moony" eyes - being blind... but he wasn't born blind.
I have no problem if you want to go with an ethnic Greek name, but I'd reccomend going with a male name:
http://www.gaminggeeks.org/Resources/KateMonk/ is a good site for names. Particularly:
http://www.gaminggeeks.org/Resources/KateMonk/Europe-Eastern/Greece/index.htm For Greece.

And what were Sudanese slave traders doing in the middle of Chicago? IF it was that bad of a neighborhood, what would he have been doing wandering alone that young?

Honestly, you have a LOT going on in the character: from Gypsy immigrant history, unnatural colored hair, strange name, to Sudanese kidnapping, to slashes across the eyes, to almost being a professional sports player, to a big time lawyer with the time to study a lot of extra languages despite not liking listing to books on tape, to taking three simultaneous cases just out of law school.

He's still very young, and law school is VERY intensive. It is unlikely he would have the time to learn many extra languages for that sort of occupation.

It's probably a coincidence, though a blind lawyer in the practice for vengence reminds me a lot of the comic character Daredevil.

But regardless, I reccomend focusing the character, and keep in mind the modern real-world setting.

I like the idea of a blind islander - especially the point you raised about quite possibly never actually "seeing" a changed islander before his own change.

Island of Moreau
Captain


Island of Moreau
Captain

PostPosted: Wed Sep 13, 2006 4:29 pm


Trynt Loomis
Official Critique Request
Gaia Username: xMurdocx
Character Name: Trynt Loomis
Serum Animal(s): Spotted Salamander
Quest Thread: Zee thread

I recently changed my quest...since mine hasnt been critiqued yet, I hope that it is ok!


I think that the salamander's a great animal choice - especially like you said, there are already three bats on the island now (even though two of them are not exactly active).

His background/story sounds fine. He's a well developed and believable character. Obviously you haven't settled on a strict "how to get to the island" scenario. But yes, if he's applied to Feral Labs then he's certainly on their radar.

From there you've got a couple of options. One is that he IS hired as a labtech (although fresh out of his bacchelor's degree (right?)) it's unlikely that he would be hired onto the Island as a worker given his compassionate nature (being an environmentalist). Moreau looks for those with a ... "moral ambiguity."

But, in his system, it is plausible that since he doesn't have any big connections that he could be given a sham hiring, and instead be brought on as a subject. So that sounds like the most plausible approach :3

Keep in mind that you won't be able to dictate the transformation to the artist in most occasions, but I understand enjoying visualizing a hypotetical transformation sequence in your description.

User Image - Blocked by "Display Image" Settings. Click to show.
PostPosted: Wed Sep 13, 2006 4:36 pm


Raurhund
Official Critique Request
Raurhund:
Character Name: Jason Redman
Serum Animal(s): Maned Wolf-Wobbegong
Quest Thread: Raurhund's Quest


I'm assuming that you're getting Jason Redman critiqued since you've already gotten a crit for Roland. :3

Anywho, moving ahead:

The backstory sounds interesting, well-thought out, and plausible :3. The character is well-rounded and thought out.

I don't have any problem with the character, though I will need to note you privately about the animal choice. :3

User Image - Blocked by "Display Image" Settings. Click to show.

Island of Moreau
Captain


Island of Moreau
Captain

PostPosted: Wed Sep 13, 2006 4:39 pm


The Kat Aclysm
Official Critique Request
Gaia Username: The Kat Aclysm
Character Name: Seth Callaghan
Serum Animal(s): Thylacine
Quest Thread: http://www.gaiaonline.com/guilds/viewtopic.php?t=4664617


On July 19th, my Kat_Aclysm account was banned, so I ran into the dilemma of what to do - keep my old quest thread because of the active crit request? Or make another? With Sabin's permission, I have linked to my clone thread instead.

Sabin OKed it:
http://www.gaiaonline.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=9279157&page=14009#851569652

Please disregard my now-banned account's request and use this one in it's place. This is a 'clone' thread of the same quest which I can edit and access as needed.

Thank you. =3


Well, as we've been very slow getting through the critiques, by the time I sat down to critique Seth, we've already critiqued him due to Kat inquiring about a RL commission.

So, obviously, the character's now been discussed with Kat, and he's

User Image - Blocked by "Display Image" Settings. Click to show. 'd :3
PostPosted: Wed Sep 13, 2006 4:46 pm


PykeDarkewoulfe


After reading your valid points and taking them into consideration, I have compiled a response that will hopefully meet the seal of approval standards.

Jordan was not intended to be passed off as a Herculean Adonis, even if my choice of wording had given that impression. I admit I was being verbose in my vocabulary while it had been written.

As for the ice blue eyes, that was just an unconscious afterthought from my original husky concept, which had been changed to samoyed once I’d learned there was already a husky questor. His eyes can be changed to brown, if that works to create a more realistic character. Brown-eyed, brown-haired would be more appealing in my opinion and more realistic.

As for his maintenance of body and muscle tone, that was something that I admittedly did not detail in the quest thread. It was my thought that the psychological impact of being active in sports left him with a compulsion to continually upkeep his body, if not improve on it, finding it inferior if he were to let it slide into.

The bishie comment is amusing but no, there was no intent to create a bishie character. If that occurred, it was purely coincidental.

In regards to his backstory, his father was an abusive jerk, to him and to his mother. Angry, violent, ill-tempered, bitter that his fifteen minutes in the sun are over. His glory days had long ended and now he had the chance to relive those days through his only child. Considering his father is trying to relive his own high school football days through his son, it would make more sense for him to feel pride and treat him like one of the guys after that. I concede to that valid point most definitely.

His mother works two jobs, making her unavailable for the majority of his life, even though she would rather see her only child grow up. That’s just not a possibility for her since her husband can’t hold down a job long enough to contribute to the household. Yes, she resents what Jordan’s father represents and she does not know about the physical and psychological abuse her son has been put through. She stays with Jordan’s father till her son has graduated from high school, unaware of the deeper secrets kept from her. Jordan’s father does threaten him to keep the abuse quiet from his mother, threatening him with further physical beating. I do apologize if it made the overall concept less believable.

As for why he would want to work with Feral? That’s simple: new experience, further pursuit of academic knowledge in his field, and the hope for better pay, despite his convictions. The world doesn’t accept good intentions when it comes time to pay the rent and buy groceries. Now, as Jordan is naïve and does hold a world view differently than reality, he could very well be shocked or even mortified by the realizations of Feral’s practices, but he’d be too intimidated to turn down what he had believed a better opportunity.

Bruno Moretti –as briefly mentioned- is the alias that Tzell’s character, Adam Keller, had assumed when he entered America and worked in Feral. Jordan would have no clue that Bruno was a false identity and would not recognize the name Adam Keller. Being it was Adam Keller’s first expedition to America, he needed someone he believed was knowledgable enough to aid him and not knowing otherwise there were more qualified people to use, Adam Keller –under the guise of Bruno Moretti- conned Jordan into aiding him and it snowballs from there.

I do hope this has been informative and helpful. It was actually rather fun to write this response and fill in the gaps that I had overlooked. I thank you very much for pointing those errors out to me so they could (hopefully) be rectified.


The comments you've given make sense. And you don't need to change the eye color (it was just part of a flowery-described list.) But you're more than welcome to change it to brown if you wish.

But yes, as long as he does upkeep his muscle-tone, then it makes sense to have it, but not if he's inactive.

I'm glad that the crits helped you address and detail points about his background. So yes, as long as you do make the amendments that you mentioned regarding his father's attention and affections.

My only reccomendation from there is that if you do want him taking the Feral Labs job to be moving "onward and upwards" Than perhaps have him start off with a job not quite as prestigious as Busch Gardens, seeing as how that is a premier wildlife facility, and rather difficult to get into. Maybe working for a smaller or local zoo doing menial work? Regardless, he'd still likely be doing some rather routine things at a feral labs research facility.

But yup, other than that, the caracter sounds fine and seal-worthy.

Island of Moreau
Captain


Island of Moreau
Captain

PostPosted: Wed Sep 13, 2006 4:47 pm


Everyone who got their critique request in while the thread was open previously has now been Critiqued.

However, there were several crit requests submitted while the thread was closed:

ErikTheRed
Tristan Derskald/Kimari
Dark_Musashi
Shiaree
Justin Harp

These requests have been deleted. ONLY submit a critique request when the thread TITLE says OPEN.

So, now caught up, this thread is open until the thread title changes and I make a post closing this round of critiques in 3 hours from now or there are 5 new requests, whichever comes SECOND.
Reply
The Island of Dr. Moreau Questor Central

Goto Page: [] [<<] [<] 1 2 3 ... 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 [>] [»|]
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum