Casrial
Pavilo
Hated having to choose between Hulk and Captain America, but I had to go with Cap. I'm surprised at how high Iron Man got, while I like him well enough I just never felt drawn in by his character. Sure, the tech is cool, but I like those with physical talents (even if it's brought about by science stuff) over tech guys.
By the way, if I could become a Revenger that would be nice. Not sure how to do all that though.
Iron Man gets a good redemption story... everyone likes a good redemption story. He's a bad boy but with a heart of gold. Plus, he's funny.
Personally, I like tech over powers. It's using brains to make brawn (but in a non-zombie way).
I get what's nice about tech, especially centered on Stark finding new meaning and purpose through his tech, but I think the main thing I dislike is the whole issue of running out of power that showed up in the first Iron Man film, or a malfunction, or just something about the tech going wrong. It's just, "Really? We need to work through that?" and it generally just decreases my viewing pleasure.
On top of that, when you have those epic moments where the battle is against them, I enjoy the idea that willpower allowed them to keep working towards what was right, rather than, "Seems the suit could do more" or any of the solutions that generally come with tech based. Either they tried something risky with questionable science/rationale, they reroute power from one thing into that and manage to pull off one big shot, or they think of a clever way to make a weak spot in the enemy.
That's good and all, but I like to see when a hero is literally being beat down and they get up and push back. Their body aches, they burn from the strain of it all, but they can't stop, they do something their body hadn't done before. Pushed to new limits by their will alone. While I see how it can be quite similar, there is just some flavor differences there that keep me choosing physical powers over tech.
Specifically for Captain America, I like the feeling that even when he hadn't the power to be a hero, he had the heart. He wished to do good, and when he was given the power he tried his best to do more than he even imagined before.
Then there's the Hulk, a genius of a man who has that terrifying beast inside him. His hope is to find a cure, or at least keep it locked away, but the world around him just won't allow it. No matter what he does or where he goes, there is always something there that draws out the Hulk, and it's him against the world, where all he tries to do is stop himself from hurting too many. That's an interesting struggle to me, making it the big drawing point of the Hulk.
Spider-man, while not a talking point already, is one hero I would say surpasses Captain America. I think his 'redemption' is more interesting than Stark's, and it really reaches out to the common man more. He comes from having nothing, he's that nerdy kid in school who didn't amount to much, he's just about as powerless as you can imagine but then he gets power, it goes to his head and he thinks of how he can use it for himself.
Lost in that fantasy of having strength over average people, he loses his good nature, he gets full of himself, but then something reminds him of what's really important. We all know the phrase, "With great power comes great responsibility" which is as tied to the character of spider-man as are his webs. It's really the pain that defines him, and it's not in a "my life is nothing but torture and ruin" type of melodramatic bullshit, but rather that his pain snapped him back into what the world is.
From there he took that phase and set out to do good, not for himself, but for everyone else. He was going to fight his hardest to make sure no one else had to feel that pain, he was willing to do this even though he had no real security of his own. Life stayed hard on Peter Parker, he had to struggle to get work and the pay wasn't good enough to live comfortably with, but he was going to keep fighting for the people, because he knew how hard things were for them and he had the power to prevent them from having to fight harder.
Sorry about the ramble, I'll shut up for now, I'm sure you've got more important things to read.