A few days ago, I was going through the business cards people gave me at cons in the past year, and I came across an unusual one.
I think I got this one when I saw a woman with an interesting hat (or something), so I told her I liked it and asked where she got it, and she said she made it. She told me I could order a piece from her website and gave me her business card.
The problem with the business card (at least I see it as a problem), was the title under the name. It isn't "crafter" or "accessory designer" or something close to what she does. It says "Steampunk Pirate Captain".
I was wondering what you guys thought of this. Keep in mind that she wasn't in the Artist Alley (at least not at this con), and since I never went to her website, I don't know if it was mostly crafts for sale or something else (if it was mostly, say, an RP website in which she played a steampunk pirate captain, it would be fairly appropriate).
But say there was an artist making new business cards to hand out in Artist Alleys, and considering putting something like "Mad Scientist" or "Knight in Shining Armor" or some other phrase like that as their job title? Would you say they should or advise against it?
On one hand, in the world of artist alley artists there are no formal job titles the way there are in more structured jobs. If a banker or lawyer called themselves a "pirate captain" on their business cards, they'd probably be fired, but we more or less don't have bosses, at least not in this sector of our lives. Some people could really want to use that freedom to whatever extent they can imagine and call themselves the role they would have in a fantasy/SF world, and the fact that it's an option is honestly part of the beauty of the job. Plus there would be a demographic of people at any convention who would see this as an awesome, creative thing to do, and be tons more likely to buy from the artist for it.
On the other hand, is it really the most professional thing to do? Sure we have that freedom, but one of the reasons lawyers and bankers and such have job titles given to them by their firm, company, etc. is because those titles let the clients know what they do. A title like that has nothing to do with drawing, or making comics, or handmade crafts, etc. so it probably won't help the customer's mind associate the product with the artist, unless it has a picture drawn by the artist (or a photo of an example of the type of crafts they do), which it should, but even then...
Maybe this is just me, but I find it kind of silly. It makes me feel like the person thinks on some level that they are in that world. Even though there are conventions and such that emulate those types of worlds, a business card should be able to stand outside of that and still be an accurate representation of what you do. I feel like putting something you're clearly not, on your business card doesn't show you to be the type of professional most people want to deal with.
*did not intend for that be to so long* Sorry.
tl:dr; Fantasy business card titles, good idea/bad idea?
PS: No offense to the Steampunk Pirate Capitan who I got the business card from, if you read this, I'm sorry I used you as a jumping-off point to a more hypothetical situation. Please forgive me. sweatdrop