Welcome to Gaia! :: View User's Journal | Gaia Journals

 
 

View User's Journal

Noir's Journal
Why Noir is better than Rorschach
Rorschach's philosophy is flaud.
He believes that there is good and evil and that evil must be punished no matter what, but he does this by murdering people which is against the law and evil. There for if he truly believed that he would kill himself.
Noir however takes that philosophy and uses it correctly, by working for the government, working within the law. True good.
He doesn't murder people.






User Comments: [4] [add]
bee pollen
Community Member
avatar
commentCommented on: Tue Apr 28, 2009 @ 06:21am
1. If he doesnt kill people...why does he carry a gun?
1.5. If you are going to say "just to shoot people in the knee" that's just as illegal as murder so whats the difference, its still breaking the law, and if he is doing it with government liscence-the government would just as easily liscence him to murder depending on the target. & if he had a liscence...it wouldnt be breaking the law, soooo....he could avenge atrocities without remorse.
2. If he works for the governemt as a last resort best of the best, then he would have to kill people-Noir doesnt share the same mercy as the judicial system I'm sure.
3. Rorshach killed fat men who raped little girls and fed them to dogs. I see no evil in that, I see unconventional justice. Just because it's outside of the law doesnt necessarily mean it's wrong. Noir must be blind to assume that this is so.

Sorry. Just had to get that off my chest.
Government=Corrupt.
Everything is corrupt, philosophies are flawd, but that doesnt mean good cant come of it. Rorschach is just fine in my book.


commentCommented on: Tue Apr 28, 2009 @ 06:25am
XD I didn't say he didn't kill people, I said he didn't murder people. Police Officers are allowed to kill people, they just have rules surrounding it. Yeah, he definitely kills people. I'm not saying Rorschach isn't good, I'm saying I'm better and he's flaud.



Classic Noir
Community Member
bee pollen
Community Member
avatar
commentCommented on: Tue Apr 28, 2009 @ 06:40am
I dont necessarily view Rorscach as a murderer though. More like...a garbage man, just taking out the trash. But I understand and Im glad you still view him as a good character. I can say one thing though...Noir is much sexier. Technically we are still married I guess. Lucky me. Hehe. (Just teasing) We should get sexy couple art again though. I liked the couple art you have. <33


commentCommented on: Wed May 06, 2009 @ 05:49pm
Murder is nothing but the early release of someone's life line.
Are you a religious man? Then believe that god planned it.
Perhaps fate put them in your way to test you, will you show your strength?
Or will you not step up to your place of higher standards and inequality.
I see now, through my rants what might be the hardest part for you.
You think that everyone deserves to live? Everyone is created equal?
They're not! Some people were meant solely as fodder slowing down the hero.
The boss pays them to be there, the boss pays them to go kill someone.
Either way, they must be stopped in the permenant sense or they'll..
just be back on the streets in no time because the evil, are always rich.
And even when you take down the boss, their are others to take his place..
and recruit his minions to their efforts. Kill them all, and you have less to worry about.



Eldroot
Community Member
User Comments: [4] [add]
 
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum