Welcome to Gaia! ::

Reply Staffies At Work
Rushifa's Reviews Goto Page: 1 2 [>] [»|]

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Rushifa
Crew

PostPosted: Tue Apr 03, 2007 10:02 pm


Introduction

Welcome. This is just a little place for me to keep my reviews as I write them. That way I can keep editing them if I see faults, etc. When it comes time to start putting the current issue together, I'll pick an appropriate review from here and add it to the La Revue thread.

Map:
1 -Introduction
2 -Code of the Ninja / Grading / Tag / Poster Size
3 -Reviews in Progress / Completed Reviews
4 -Future Projects
5 -Author's Notes
6+ -Reviews and Comments
PostPosted: Tue Apr 03, 2007 10:04 pm


Code of the Ninja

5 - ninja ninja ninja ninja ninja - The ninja approves of this; failure to cohere with the ninja's decision is a grave mistake.
4 - ninja ninja ninja ninja - The ninja enjoys this, but he finds flaws.
3 - ninja ninja ninja - The ninja would rather date your sister, but since you may not have one he will take this instead.
2 - ninja ninja - The ninja warns you that he was only marginally impressed.
1 - ninja - If proper confession is made, the ninja will forgive you for taking part in this.
0 - xp - If you are looking for an invigorating experience I would suggest poking your eye out before this; the ninja does not approve.



Grading

-characters
-storyline
-style
-substance
-overall

Tag

Got a bone to pick with the reviewer? Want to suggest a work for review? Dying to hear about a new media or genre? Contact Rushifa with your questions and comments.

[i]Got a bone to pick with the reviewer? Want to suggest a work for review? Dying to hear about a new media or genre? Contact [url=http://www.gaiaonline.com/profile/index.php?view=profile.ShowProfile&item=39736]Rushifa[/url] with your questions and comments.[/i]


Poster Size

112 x 170

Rushifa
Crew


Rushifa
Crew

PostPosted: Tue Apr 03, 2007 10:06 pm


Reviews in Progress

Movies
Dream Girls

Games
Kingdom Hearts


List of Completed Reviews

Movies
Narnia: The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe Published Dec. 05, Issue 11
Brokeback Mountain Published Jan. 06, Issue 12
Memiors of a Geisha Published Feb. 06, Issue 13
Date Movie Published Mar. 06, Issue 14
Silent Hill Publsihed May 06, Issue 15
X-Men: The Last Stand Published June 06, Issue 16
Cars Published July 06, Issue 17
Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man's Chest Published Aug. 06, Issue 18
Lessons From a Lifetime of Writing Published Nov. 06, Issue 21
Eragon Published Dec. 06, Issue 22
TMNT
Pride and Prejudice

Books
Wicked: The Life and Times of the Wicked Witch of the West Published Sept. 06, Issue 19
The Kite Runner

Games
Okami Published Oct. 06, Issue 20

TV Shows
-none yet-

Comics
-none yet-
PostPosted: Tue Apr 03, 2007 10:07 pm


Future Projects

Movies
Serenity
Better Than Chocolate
Howl's Moving Castle
Ghost World
Heather
Interview With a Vampire
May
TransAmerica
Date Movie
But I'm a Cheerleader
If These Walls Could Talk, 2
Yours, Mine, and Ours


Books
Idoru
Geisha, A Life
Slayers
The Kite Runner
Howl's Moving Castle
Wicked
The Case of Einstein's Violin
Cabin Fever

Games
Suikoden III
ICO
Shadow of the Colossus
Silent Hill 4

TV Shows
Firefly
Lost

Anime
Slayers
Ranma 1/2
Maze

Comics
Sandman

Manga
Clover
X (X/1999)
Hana-kimi
Wish

Author Spotlight
Neil Gaimen
CLAMP
Robin McKinley
Diana Wynne Jones
Cornilia Funke
J.K. Rowling
Rumika Takehashi

Rushifa
Crew


Rushifa
Crew

PostPosted: Tue Apr 03, 2007 10:09 pm


Author's Notes, Rants, and Updates

04.03.07

Moving everything over to the new guild, finally. Not much has changed, although this gives me an opportunity to update everything. As I move the reviews over, I'm posting them by the date the were published, not the date they were actually written. Once I start using this as my 'factory,' though, all bets are off.

04.06.06

Finally, I have something besides a movie review up! I have a review for Wicked up, although it needs revising. The review is pretty upbeat, which doesn't feel critical enough to me, but then again, I did really enjoy the book. Oh well, there will be other, less favorable reviews of books in the near future, with any luck. I could rant about the Kite Runner all day, if I had to.

On another note, it sounds as if we may actually be getting more reviewers soon, which would be nice. This month I just want to work on building up a number of reviews so I have a few to choose from when the end of the month comes along, and more to draw on during my next slow month/s.

02.10.06

I'm begining to amass a collection of Movie Reviews, although I haven't branched out to the other medias yet. I do have a number of prospective works lined up. The catch is I want to actually have a chance to reread, watch, play, or what have you, the works before I write a review of them. This is mostly so I will be in the right mind frame, but to give me the chance to relook at them with a review in mind. It helps, believe me. Of course, some of the pieces are so beloved to me that I can write about them straight from memory. Which brings me to another problem.

I hate writing exclusively stunning reviews. Giving Brokeback Mountain all fives was difficult for me to stomach, but I really believe it deserved them. The main problem I'm facing is that I only tend to go to movies which look interesting to me, and so I am naturally leaning more towards liking them, since they're my type of movie. I suppose this is good and bad. On one hand, it allows me to cater directly to my own specific tastes. But on the other hand, it offers a very one-demensional opinion for the readers, especually since I'm currently the only reveiwer. I'll try to branch out and move outside my comfort zone, but I make no garantees!
PostPosted: Tue Apr 03, 2007 10:15 pm


Narnia: The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe

Published Dec. 05, Issue 11

C.S. Lewis's books have been beloved of children and adults alike for many years, but the new version of his original book can stand on its own. In this era where fantasy movies are the current rage, The Lion the Witch and the Wardrobe does not disappoint.

For viewers unfamiliar with the Narnia books, and those who have not stumbled upon earlier versions of the movie, this adaptation serves as a great introduction. It is the story of another world, populated mostly by non-human beings. In The Lion the Witch and the Wardrobe (which appeared as the second book of the series and the first written) four children from our world find their way into Narnia through a mysterious wardrobe. Awaiting them they find a world of endless winter, ruled over by the mysterious Snow Queen. A rebellion is brewing amongst the animal-inhabitants of Narnia, surrounding the true ruler of their land, the lion Arslan, and fueled by a prophecy describing the coming of the two Daughters of Eve and Sons of Adam, the future rulers of Narnia.

I enjoyed this movie immensely. I read the first few Narnia books when I was a child, and reread a number of them more recently. This movie adaptation was well done to say the least. All the characters and scenery look exactly as I had imagined them, and, unlike most movie adaptations, the plot is left almost completely intact. The only main differences are a few added scenes, which add much to the movie that the lack of narration took away. The CG in the movie was generally done well, although I found the cg of the beaver's slightly distracting. The voice talent of Arslan (Liam Niasen) absolutely blew me away, and the four children were all well done. The Snow Queen was perfectly sinister, with the right mix of cunning and evil.

One thing I would like to address is the obvious religious symbolism in this movie, and the original books. That was intentional on the part of C.S. Lewis, being a very religious man, and served as a kind lead-in to Christian beliefs for children. This transfers to the movie beautifully, but it neither adds to nor distracts from the story. The movie stands on its own with or without the hidden meanings. For Christians, this movie will show a kind, comforting connection to God, but for the non-Christians it will not impede enjoyment, or come of as an attempt at conversion. It is a well done movie, based off of a well done book, and can be enjoyed by all ages and backgrounds.


5- ninja ninja ninja ninja ninja -characters
5- ninja ninja ninja ninja ninja -storyline
4- ninja ninja ninja ninja -style
4- ninja ninja ninja ninja -substance
5- ninja ninja ninja ninja ninja -overall

Got a bone to pick with the reviewer? Want to suggest a work for review? Dying to hear about a new media or genre? Contact Rushifa with your questions and comments.

Rushifa
Crew


Rushifa
Crew

PostPosted: Tue Apr 03, 2007 10:16 pm


Brokeback Mountain

Published Jan. 2006, Issue 12

This movie was, in a word, excellent. All the characters were engaging and amazingly real. It is the story of two cowboys who fall in love, but it is definitely more than a gay-culture cult movie. It is a beautiful love story, and an excellent movie, regardless of the subject matter.

The story takes place primarily in Wyoming, and follows the two men, Jack Twist (Jake Gyllenhaal) and Ennis Del Mar (Heath Ledger), as they continue their lives without each other. Periodic "fishing trips" renew the love they share, but their society and families keep them from actually being together. They share the wonderful memories of a summer alone together on Brokeback Mountain, and the painful knowledge that their love could get them killed if they succumbed to it in the wrong place, at the wrong time.

Thematically, Brokeback Mountain is a small story. It is simply about two ordinary people, living their ordinary lives; but it is this simplicity which makes it such a powerful movie. The characters are not simply stereotypes, they are real. By the end, you are completely drawn in to the characters ups and downs, and the tragedy of their denied romance speaks directly to your heart.

Visually, the movie required very little special effects. The scenery was gorgeous and natural, and all the characters were real, working class people. The simple love scenes were as natural and normal as were the sad scenes, and the two main characters reacted beautifully together. They had a chemistry all their own, which was very powerful and very real. The R rating was for a reason, but it was not simply slapped on because of the homosexual relationship.

Brokeback Mountain is based on a short story by E. Annie Proulx. I have not yet read the original story, so I can not speak to its authenticity, but it was a good enough movie that I think its value as an adaptation is largely irrelevant. I also believe that this is a very timely movie, and I hope to see more directors taking gay/lesbian themes to the big screen. The fact that Brokeback Mountain was made, and made in the way it was, reassures me that the world is in fact moving in the right direction.


5- ninja ninja ninja ninja ninja -characters
5- ninja ninja ninja ninja ninja -storyline
5- ninja ninja ninja ninja ninja -style
5- ninja ninja ninja ninja ninja -substance
5- ninja ninja ninja ninja ninja -overall

(author's note: I hate to give completely complimentary reviews, but it looks like I'll have to make an exception here)


Got a bone to pick with the reviewer? Want to suggest a work for review? Dying to hear about a new media or genre? Contact Rushifa with your questions and comments.
PostPosted: Tue Apr 03, 2007 10:18 pm


Memoirs of a Geisha

Published Feb. 06, Issue 13

This movie was, in a word, gorgeous. The pacing feels a bit forced at times, which is a problem with many movie adaptations from books, but it doesn't detract from the overall flow of the film.

Memoirs of a Geisha is the story of a young Japanese girl sent to live and work in Kyoto. When their parents fall on hard times, she and her sister are sold, Chiyo to a Geisha Okiya, and her sister into prostitution. Alone and unhappy, Chiyo at first protests her change of lifestyle, but eventually comes to except it, and give it all she has. Her rivalry with the older Geisha in her Okiya, Hatsumomo, and her friendship and sisterhood with her mentor, Mameha, shape her growth and development as a successful young geisha.

Running along side Chiyo's success is the love-story between her and an older businessman. One day, when Chiyo is still unable to except her new life as a Geisha, the Chairman comes along and cheers her up by buying her a snack. As a result of his unlikely kindness, Chiyo develops a crush on him which inspires her to succeed as a Geisha, and eventually be near him. With this new determination, Chiyo is able to rise higher and higher, breaking records and charming men with her talented dancing and skilled manners.

I enjoyed this movie. The cinematography was well done and the sets and character design were beautiful. There were some lovely dance scenes, as well as a few more "artsy" scenes which didn't really add anything, but were pretty to look at. As a movie, it was a success, but as an adaptation of a good book, it missed the mark. Many scenes were omitted, as was to be expected considering the book was very long, but there were a few unnecessary added scenes, and subtle changes in the plot which seemed to serve no purpose.

Personally, I have never liked the romance in this story. Although I am a romantic, and a lover of Japanese culture, I would have preferred the story be about Chiyo's personal growth, instead of her unlikely and unhealthy relationship with a much older man. The ending, which I will not give away, did not satisfy me because it did not prove anything, did not define anything. I suppose the excuse for this can be that it was written as if it were someone's real story, and thus would not perfectly fit any definition of literature; but it was fiction, and written by an outsider to the culture and gender which the story surrounds, and it simply missed the mark. If anything, the movie made it even worse by cutting out key after-the-fact scenes.


3- ninja ninja ninja -characters
2- ninja ninja -storyline
5- ninja ninja ninja ninja ninja -style
2- ninja ninja -substance
3- ninja ninja ninja -overall


Got a bone to pick with the reviewer? Want to suggest a work for review? Dying to hear about a new media or genre? Contact Rushifa with your questions and comments.

Rushifa
Crew


Rushifa
Crew

PostPosted: Tue Apr 03, 2007 10:20 pm


Date Movie
Directed by Aaron Seltzer, 2006

Published Mar. 2006, Issue 14

If you see one movie this month, please, for the love of god, don't let it be this one.

For what it is, Date Movie isn't so bad. It's funny. Which of course, is its point. In a nutshell, Date Movie is to chick flicks what Scary Movie was to horror films. It's a parody, and not much else. Its novelty depends on the viewer having seen most if not all of the movies being parodied.

But it's bad. Painfully, graitingly, intentionally bad. So bad that even the characters know not to take themselves serious. It also pulls the whole 'I can be offensive as long as I'm offensive to everything' trick that is so popular these days. If you're uptight or thin skinned, avoid this movie; you simply wont be able to enjoy it. Date Movie proves that, above all, we have to be capable of laughing at ourselves.

Personally, I don't enjoy these types of movies. Sure, they're funny, but they're really nothing beyond that. I enjoy a good laugh, but I like it to be mixed in with a good plot or at least some entertaining dialogue.

2- ninja ninja -characters
1- ninja -storyline
2- ninja ninja -style
1- ninja -substance
2- ninja ninja -overall

Got a bone to pick with the reviewer? Want to suggest a work for review? Dying to hear about a new media or genre? Contact Rushifa with your questions and comments.
PostPosted: Tue Apr 03, 2007 10:20 pm


Silent Hill
Directed By Christophe Gans

Published Issue #15

User Image

This movie has been long anticipated by fans of the games. Although I've only played some of the 4th game (which, I'm told, while a good game, is not very "typical" of the series), I went in with a few specific expectations. For the most part, I left satisfied.

Plot wise, Silent Hill follows Rose, whose daughter Sharon is haunted by nightmares and sleep walking. A search for the cause of her repressed memories leads Rose toe Silent Hill, the town which may be Sharon's birth place. With Dad left behind and uninformed, Rose takes Sharon on a car trip to try to get to the bottom of her past. After a car crash and the disappearance of Sharon, Rose teams up with a sexy police woman named Cybil as they try to survive the abandoned city and find her daughter.

I'm not a big fan of horror, and I always prefer psychological thrillers to blood and gut horror. Most of the movie was the former, but a few scenes delved needlessly into the latter. There were some obvious fan-pleasers, and some cg which will definitely not stand up to the test of time.

The end was horribly disappointing, or at least the climax was. The actual note the movie leaves off on, however, gains it back some of the points it lost for cheesy special effects and unnecessary gore in the latter half of the movie.


4- ninja ninja ninja ninja -characters
3- ninja ninja ninja -storyline
2- ninja ninja -style
2- ninja ninja -substance
3- ninja ninja ninja -overall

Got a bone to pick with the reviewer? Want to suggest a work for review? Dying to hear about a new media or genre? Contact Rushifa with your questions and comments.

Rushifa
Crew


Rushifa
Crew

PostPosted: Tue Apr 03, 2007 10:21 pm


X-Men: The Last Stand
Directed by Brett Ratner

Published Issue #16

User Image

I'm kind of glad I'm not a long-time participant in this fandom, 'cause if I were I think this movie would have driven me crazy. As it was, I was only mildly offended at the shoddy job.

There were a few new faces to please fans, but entirely too many familiar faces were left out. I went in expecting to see way more hold-overs from the last movie, and left disappointed. They could have done so much more with it.

Plot-wise, we return to "the not so distant future" to find our hero's in a politically friendlier environment than the last 2 movies, at least to begin with. Their hold on equality, however, quickly begins to go down the drain when a "cure" for mutations is announced. What follows is a political and civil war of sorts, as mutants are divided between support and offense, anti-mutant leaders begin using the cure as a weapon, and a gripping secret is revealed about one of our hero's lost comrades.

All and all, this movie just didn't stand up. It's difficult with this type of movie to be appropriately incredible without turning ridiculous, and they seemed to do an even poorer job of it this go around. Far too many cheap puns for a mildly serious movie, and way too few characters, new and old.

A few heads up: make sure to stay through the credits, since there is a little extra bit at the end. Also, watch the horizon, there may be a 4th movie in the works, if the hints towards the end are any indication.


3- ninja ninja ninja -characters
2- ninja ninja -storyline
2- ninja ninja -style
2- ninja ninja -substance
2- ninja ninja -overall
PostPosted: Tue Apr 03, 2007 10:23 pm


Cars
Directed By John Lasseter and Joe Ranft

Published Issue #17

User Image
Well, Pixar has done it again.

As Disney seems to lose its footing, I applaud their choice to team up with Pixar, a studio which certainly seems to understand and love what they do. Although Cars does not quite live up to Pixar's other masterpieces, it certainly makes the grade.

Plot-wise, Cars is not terribly original. Hot-shot city slicker meets "country bumpkins," learns the true meaning of life, and comes away the better for it. However, the unique use of cars instead of people adds a novel twist. The movie also deals with consumerism, enviromentalism, and a traditional old generation v. new generation. There is romance, action, suspense...everything you want out of a movie.

As with many cg movies, the effects are half the appeal. I was fortunate enough to see this movie with a game-design student, so I had all the little animation details pointed out to me. I think it helped my enjoyment of the movie. Even though I'm certainly not an expert, I found the graphics amazing, smooth, and stylistic but consistant.

My favorite part of the movie was the soundtrack. I thought all the songs were well chosen and well placed, and really helped the flow of the movie. Due I think greatly to the music, the movie had the gripping, encompassing feeling which I haven't felt in a kids movie in awhile.

Now, for those of you who've seen the previews and have been unimpressed, I would like to introduce a simple formula which my friend and I have come to depend on. Don't worry, this doesn't involve math. Quite simple, the best movies tend to have the worse ads, and via se versa. From the previews, I though Cars looked kind of stupid, but I realy enjoyed it and am glad I didn' trust my first impression.

3- ninja ninja ninja -characters
4- ninja ninja ninja ninja -storyline
5- ninja ninja ninja ninja ninja -style
4- ninja ninja ninja ninja -substance
4- ninja ninja ninja ninja -overall

Got a bone to pick with the reviewer? Want to suggest a work for review? Dying to hear about a new media or genre? Contact Rushifa with your questions and comments.

Rushifa
Crew


Rushifa
Crew

PostPosted: Tue Apr 03, 2007 10:25 pm


Movie Review: Pirates of the Caribbean, Dead Man's Chest
Directed By Gore Verbinski
Review By Rushifa

Published Issue #18

User Image
Now really, who doesn't love a pirate movie?

If you liked the first Pirates of the Caribbean movie, you definitely shouldn't miss the second. Although it has a few problems common to sequels, it's overall a hilarious and well done movie.

Unfortunately, Dead Man's Chest starts out overdramatic and, frankly, boring. In fact, the first 20 minutes of the movie were dull, discouraging, and useless. It was obviously trying to pick up where the first one left off, but it simply didn't work. Although, perhaps that's because I've never been fond of William (Orlando Bloom) or Elizabeth (Keira Knightlyy). However, once they get to the island, it's all up from there. Keep your eyes open for Jack (Johnny Depp)'s awesome face paint, although it's pretty hard to miss.

Beware of old lines. The were wonderful and memorable the first time, but if we wanted to hear them again, we'd have watched them in their original context. Reusing old hit lines is a very common trait of sequels, but in most cases it comes of feeling forced. There are only about 3 instances where an old line is reused in a new and entertaining way. The upside is that all the new, original material lives up to the first movie's standards.

Length-wise, well, be sure to pace yourself with your drink. And look forward to a third movie. We'd heard rumors, but it's pretty much been confirmed by now; there will indeed be at least one more movie. Oh, and make sure to wait until the end of the credits, for a special look into a side character's fate.

4- ninja ninja ninja ninja -characters
4- ninja ninja ninja ninja -storyline
3- ninja ninja ninja -style
3- ninja ninja ninja -substance
4- ninja ninja ninja ninja -overall

Got a bone to pick with the reviewer? Want to suggest a work for review? Dying to hear about a new media or genre? Contact Rushifa with your questions and comments.
PostPosted: Tue Apr 03, 2007 10:26 pm


Book Review: Wicked, The Life and Times of the Wicked Witch of the West
By Gregory Maguire, 1995
Review by Rushifa

Publsihed Issue #19

User Image

When this book was first recommended to me, I didn't actually expect it to be good. I expected it to be funny, certainly; a lively parody and an entertaining read. But I certainly never expected to be captivated by it.

I've never been a big fan of the Wizard of Oz. Sure, I liked the movie well enough, and recently read the book, and have always enjoyed it, but I was never terribly attatched. Well, now I can never look at it the same way again.

Wicked doesn't change the events of the original book, at least not very much; it merely adds context to the events which simply wasn't there before. I'll admit, I've never read beyond the first book, so I can't say how much of the mythos was already established, but Maquire throws in demensions of politics, romance, betrayal, religion, racism, and maturity which I'm sure were not a part of the original childrens book.

As its title suggested, Wicked follows the life of the woman known to us as the Wicked Witch of the West. It sets up her birth, her family, her school days, her friends, her lovers, and her history, all while making her a character we identify with and love. He doesn't simply change her personality, he simply weaves everything together so her eventual meeting with Dorothy is understandable and sad.

The book itself is very well written. The author, although male, proves able to write both genders superbly, and allows each character to shine in their own vividly real ways. Despite being set in a fantastical land, the book feels very real. The writing is discriptive and entertaining, and the structure and connections are all very subte and well done.

5- ninja ninja ninja ninja ninja -characters
5- ninja ninja ninja ninja ninja -storyline
4- ninja ninja ninja ninja -style
4- ninja ninja ninja ninja -substance
5- ninja ninja ninja ninja ninja -overall

Wicked at Amazon.com
Wicked, the musical

Rushifa
Crew


Rushifa
Crew

PostPosted: Tue Apr 03, 2007 10:27 pm


Game Review: Okami
Directed By Hideki Kamiya
Review By Rushifa

Published Issue #20


User Image


Now, I'll be the first to admit that I'm by no means an expert when it comes to video games, but Okami is quickly becoming one of my favorites.

Style-wise, Okami takes tradition Japanese ink-paintings, and makes a game out of their aesthetic. You play as a lupine incarnation of the Sun Goddess Amaterasu, and it is you duty to save the land of Nippon for disaster. You're accompanied by bug-like little man who leads you through the game.

Fans of Zelda will feel especially nostalgic as they play this game, because it uses a lot of the real-time conditions which made the N64 game so enticing. Perhaps the most unique part of the game is the ink-brush: by pushing a button, you are able to actually paint on the screen using the analog stick. This comes in handy when you're being attacked, and is also an important part of the plot as you learn new brush strokes and can reach new levels.

Okami is overflowing with Japanese cultural references, themes, and familiar faces, so if you have interest or knowledge in such things this game is definitely for you. However, the game draws you in whether you have prior knowledge of the mythos or not. If you have not yet played Okami, I greatly recommend getting your hands on a copy of it. You won’t be sorry.

4- ninja ninja ninja ninja -characters
5- ninja ninja ninja ninja ninja -storyline
5- ninja ninja ninja ninja ninja -style
4- ninja ninja ninja ninja -substance
5- ninja ninja ninja ninja ninja -overall


Got a bone to pick with the reviewer? Want to suggest a work for review? Dying to hear about a new media or genre? Contact Rushifa with your questions and comments.
Reply
Staffies At Work

Goto Page: 1 2 [>] [»|]
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum