Welcome to Gaia! ::

Reply Pro-Choice Gaians
Hong Kong Limits pregnant chinese women Goto Page: 1 2 [>] [»|]

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Trite~Elegy

PostPosted: Tue Jan 16, 2007 7:42 pm


Story

Quote:
HONG KONG - Pregnant women from mainland China who are near their due date will be turned away at Hong Kong borders if they cannot prove they have appointments in the city's hospitals, officials said Tuesday. The number of births by mainland Chinese women in Hong Kong nearly doubled in 2005 — from 10,128 in 2003 to 19,538 — according to the city's Hospital Authority. Many come to evade China's one-child policy, take advantage of higher quality health care or earn Hong Kong residency rights for their babies.
The former British colony of Hong Kong is now under Chinese rule, but it remains separately governed and maintains immigration controls. Hong Kong residency, which is required to live in the city, is coveted by mainland Chinese because of the higher standard of living here and prospect of a better education for their children.

Starting in February, mainland Chinese women who are more than seven months pregnant cannot enter Hong Kong if they cannot prove that a Hong Kong hospital has confirmed arrangements for their admission, said Patrick n**, deputy secretary for the Health, Welfare and Food department.

Many mainland women currently do not make bookings or provide prenatal records to Hong Kong hospitals, choosing instead to rush to emergency wards at the last minute to give birth. Some leave behind large hospital debts when they return to China.

As part of the new rules, mainland Chinese mothers will have to pay double the normal fee to give birth in Hong Kong hospitals. Medical staff stationed at border control points will help officials step up checks on women who appear far along in their pregnancies, an immigration official said.

"If there's a need to ascertain whether a woman is pregnant or not, medical staff would be at hand to provide assistance," said David Chiu, an assistant director of Immigration.

But some say the new measures are discriminatory because they single out mainland Chinese women. According to officials, pregnant women of other nationalities will not be subject to the measures because their numbers are relatively small.

"It's important to see if this is really justified," said Law Yuk-kai with the Hong Kong Human Rights Monitor.

"Why is it just Chinese women, not women from other places? Pregnant women may also have legitimate reasons for coming to Hong Kong," he said.



And all they wanted to do was to do their best for their babies.
pro lifers should be estatic that women are willing to leave their homes and lives just to make sure the baby gets the best care as possible.
but sadly, s**t like this happens all over the world, especially in developed countries like the U.S. because they can get away with it, and it's usually caused by pro lifers (not saying this case is).
If pro lifers want to change the way abortion is veiwed to them as a nesscary form of gender equality, well then they need to start giving some equality to pregnant women. neutral
PostPosted: Tue Jan 16, 2007 11:10 pm


Hong Kong keeps getting worse and worse. -__-
And I wanted to go and study in Hong Kong next year...

As a Chinese-Canadian, this hits closer to home. I'm quite insulted that they would do this.

And they already have laws limiting abortion too.

Talk about discrimination.

Rosamaine

Tipsy Elder

9,550 Points
  • Forum Sophomore 300
  • Signature Look 250
  • Wall Street 200

Grip of Death

PostPosted: Wed Jan 17, 2007 4:30 pm


Sorry, the truth hurts. sweatdrop

But it's just like all of the illegal Mexicans and Latinos giving birth in hospitals for free in the U.S., on the taxpayers expense. Then declaring the child an American citizen for nothing more than being a crotch dumpling on U.S. soil. Clogging up all of the social safety net resources in America and they aren't even ********' legal.

The Chinese going to Hong Kong were just taking advantage of a loop hole, and for a time they brilliantly exercised it. There's too many Chinese people on the planet and as large and old a country as China is, they have the laws on giving birth to children for a good reason. If they don't like having restrictions on the amount of kids they want to have, they should legally apply to live somewhere else where the law allows for more children.

The law isn't even that bad. If a couple has a girl before a boy, the couple can still end up having two children if the first born is a girl. Most people can't even raise one child, let alone two, let alone five.
PostPosted: Wed Jan 17, 2007 4:37 pm


Grip of Death
Sorry, the truth hurts. sweatdrop

But it's just like all of the illegal Mexicans and Latinos giving birth in hospitals for free in the U.S., on the taxpayers expense. Then declaring the child an American citizen for nothing more than being a crotch dumpling on U.S. soil. Clogging up all of the social safety net resources in America and they aren't even ********' legal.
If they are born in America then they are legal citizens and deserve all he rights everyone else has. It doesn't matter if their parent's broke the law, they can be dealt with, but that shouldn't stop the kid from getting what's rightfully theirs.

MipsyKitten
Crew


Trite~Elegy

PostPosted: Wed Jan 17, 2007 4:56 pm


BUT Hong Kong is part of china.
it's a city of china - not even a state.
that would be like saying that women in vermont couldn't go have their children in a new york city hospital confused
PostPosted: Wed Jan 17, 2007 6:47 pm


No, it's not like a Vermont couple going to a New York hospital BECAUSE there are different laws involved in the Chinese system. The Chinese are attracted by the legal ramifications of giving birth in Hong Kong versus mainland China.

Your position would be stronger if there was just the issue of quality of care.

Also, in response to Mipsy Kitten,

the newborn can't raise itself in America while the parents are back in Mexico. The Mexicans are using a loophole in U.S. laws to get their foot in the U.S. door. The kid is still going to be raised strongly Mexican.

The huge flood of illegal immigrants is putting a serious strain on the social systems here. It's not fair to all of the people who work hard and pay taxes and do so LEGALLY.

While employing illegal labor sounds so thrifty on paper, it costs society big, big money.

Grip of Death


MipsyKitten
Crew

PostPosted: Wed Jan 17, 2007 8:09 pm


Grip of Death
No, it's not like a Vermont couple going to a New York hospital BECAUSE there are different laws involved in the Chinese system. The Chinese are attracted by the legal ramifications of giving birth in Hong Kong versus mainland China.

Your position would be stronger if there was just the issue of quality of care.

Also, in response to Mipsy Kitten,

the newborn can't raise itself in America while the parents are back in Mexico. The Mexicans are using a loophole in U.S. laws to get their foot in the U.S. door. The kid is still going to be raised strongly Mexican.

The huge flood of illegal immigrants is putting a serious strain on the social systems here. It's not fair to all of the people who work hard and pay taxes and do so LEGALLY.

While employing illegal labor sounds so thrifty on paper, it costs society big, big money.

I know that, but if you're born on American soil you have every right to use American resources. You can't tell them "too bad, you're not American so you have to leave with your kid".
PostPosted: Wed Jan 17, 2007 8:14 pm


I'm going to have to agree with Grip of death on this one.

I live down here in Arizona right next to the Mexican border. There are so many Mexicans that come over here illegally every year and have their babies so they can stay. It's frustrating for everyone because of all the problems it causes.

And I can't stand our Governor. I can't believe that she got voted back in. The only thing she did during her last term was make all-day kindergarten...umm? Whoop dee doo? I'm still wondering why she's taken so long to react to the illegal immigration problem here, that's the real issue, not fussing over all-day kindergarten...

I don't care if there are immigrants here so long as they are here legally. It's just not fair for them to be coming over here and taking free stuff from us because it comes right back to everyone else here who works hard and pays their taxes.

SterileNeedles


SterileNeedles

PostPosted: Wed Jan 17, 2007 8:20 pm


MipsyKitten

I know that, but if you're born on American soil you have every right to use American resources. You can't tell them "too bad, you're not American so you have to leave with your kid".

So what do you want them to do? Chuck the kid into an orphanage and send the parents back to Mexico?
PostPosted: Wed Jan 17, 2007 9:56 pm


No, she probably wants the parents to stay and raise the "American citizen" child in America.

I hate to get really off topic from the Chinese conversation....

But

1) illegal immigrants cost the whole society big money. It's not fair to people who immigrated here legally, and it's definitely not fair to the citizens who work and pay taxes to give the illegal immigrants a "free ride". Schools and Hospitals are cramped. Roads are cramped.

2) many of them do not want to assimilate to the melting pot, they want to build a culture of their own and be separated from the whole. I'm all for pluralist tendencies and diversity can be really fun and enjoyable, but SOME assimilation is NECESSARY in order to have a more harmonious society. It's not fair to expect America to speak Spanish when all of the previous groups of immigrants had to learn how to speak English to live here.

Grip of Death


MipsyKitten
Crew

PostPosted: Thu Jan 18, 2007 2:45 pm


SterileNeedles
MipsyKitten

I know that, but if you're born on American soil you have every right to use American resources. You can't tell them "too bad, you're not American so you have to leave with your kid".

So what do you want them to do? Chuck the kid into an orphanage and send the parents back to Mexico?

First of all, don't assume I want to do anything to them, and don't try to put words in my mouth. I know illegal immigration is a problem, but the fact is there is an AMERICAN child now, and they deserve all the benefits every other American has. I'd say let them stay, and when Americans clean up America and stop blaming everything on illegals, then maybe they can deal with that problem. Illegals are a scapegoat for a much larger problem.

And Grip, I'm seeing a pattern with your posts on other races that I'm not happy with. Quite frankly all I see is racist remarks about people you don't want to deal with.
PostPosted: Thu Jan 18, 2007 2:53 pm


MipsyKitten
SterileNeedles
MipsyKitten

I know that, but if you're born on American soil you have every right to use American resources. You can't tell them "too bad, you're not American so you have to leave with your kid".

So what do you want them to do? Chuck the kid into an orphanage and send the parents back to Mexico?

First of all, don't assume I want to do anything to them, and don't try to put words in my mouth. I know illegal immigration is a problem, but the fact is there is an AMERICAN child now, and they deserve all the benefits every other American has. I'd say let them stay, and when Americans clean up America and stop blaming everything on illegals, then maybe they can deal with that problem. Illegals are a scapegoat for a much larger problem.

And Grip, I'm seeing a pattern with your posts on other races that I'm not happy with. Quite frankly all I see is racist remarks about people you don't want to deal with.


Have fun generalizing me and labeling me as a racist rather than confronting sensitive and controversial issues. It shows how much you know about me after all.


* little known fact: my best friend happens to be a legally immigrated Chinese woman who is 10 years older than me. How's that for diversity?

Grip of Death


PhaedraMcSpiffy

PostPosted: Thu Jan 18, 2007 6:17 pm


Grip of Death
Sorry, the truth hurts. sweatdrop

But it's just like all of the illegal Mexicans and Latinos giving birth in hospitals for free in the U.S., on the taxpayers expense. Then declaring the child an American citizen for nothing more than being a crotch dumpling on U.S. soil. Clogging up all of the social safety net resources in America and they aren't even ********' legal.

The Chinese going to Hong Kong were just taking advantage of a loop hole, and for a time they brilliantly exercised it. There's too many Chinese people on the planet and as large and old a country as China is, they have the laws on giving birth to children for a good reason. If they don't like having restrictions on the amount of kids they want to have, they should legally apply to live somewhere else where the law allows for more children.

The law isn't even that bad. If a couple has a girl before a boy, the couple can still end up having two children if the first born is a girl. Most people can't even raise one child, let alone two, let alone five.


So you deserve more rights than these people just because you were lucky enough to be born here from parents who were born or naturalized here? They're human beings. They're coming here because they have to, and they're doing or shitty jobs and getting almost nothing in return. They're desperate enough to risk their lives coming here, how can you just dismiss them so easily? It's not their fault they were born someplace shitty.

We're an entire country of immigrants, except the Native Americans who we stole the land from from. We started out as illegal immigrants.

And you have to understand that being pro-choice means allowing reproductive freedom, even if you personally disagree with that choice. The government has no place telling people how and when and if in the case of reproduction. That's their choice.

Quote:
The kid is still going to be raised strongly Mexican.


How is that a problem?

Quote:
The huge flood of illegal immigrants is putting a serious strain on the social systems here. It's not fair to all of the people who work hard and pay taxes and do so LEGALLY.


I'm going to have to agree that this is a serious problem, but I doubt that the illegal immigrants are entirely to blame. We'd have more money for these systems if we weren't wasting it in Iraq, but that's a different story...

Quote:
illegal immigrants cost the whole society big money. It's not fair to people who immigrated here legally, and it's definitely not fair to the citizens who work and pay taxes to give the illegal immigrants a "free ride". Schools and Hospitals are cramped. Roads are cramped.


In my area (San Diego) we have a lot of illegal immigration, but I'm seeing the crowding come from rich Anglos. Maybe I just don't see it because of the area I'm in, but I'm not seeing this supposed massive flood of human vermin everyone's freaking out about.

Quote:
many of them do not want to assimilate to the melting pot, they want to build a culture of their own and be separated from the whole. I'm all for pluralist tendencies and diversity can be really fun and enjoyable, but SOME assimilation is NECESSARY in order to have a more harmonious society. It's not fair to expect America to speak Spanish when all of the previous groups of immigrants had to learn how to speak English to live here.


Pardon the pun, but it seems you're bordering on ethnocentrism here.

America does not have a national language. True, you really can't survive without English, but it's not the official language. And they're not trying to. Nobody's expecting you to learn Spanish except school. Because you
should study a foreign language. In most parts of the world, people speak or understand more than one language.

Quote:
Illegals are a scapegoat for a much larger problem.


More like a series of larger problems, but yes. I'm just not seeing why everyone thinks the sky is falling. People are people. Yes, they should come here legally and pay taxes. But don't make the mistake we see so often in the pro-lifers. The world is not perfect. People are going to do things they shouldn't. The solution is not to punish, but to make the best of a bad situation. These people aren't freeloading and they sure as hell aren't depriving American citizens of anything. They're living on almost nothing.

Quote:
little known fact: my best friend happens to be a legally immigrated Chinese woman who is 10 years older than me. How's that for diversity?


The "But my best friend is ___!" Argument doesn't really work. We've all seen female misogynists and self-hating members of various races. We've seen people who are freinds with people who they should logically be enemies with.

And you're talking about a legal Chinese immigrant, not an illegal Mexican or Latin American immigrant. You don't know any of the people you're talking about, do you?
PostPosted: Thu Jan 18, 2007 9:17 pm


MipsyKitten
SterileNeedles
MipsyKitten

I know that, but if you're born on American soil you have every right to use American resources. You can't tell them "too bad, you're not American so you have to leave with your kid".

So what do you want them to do? Chuck the kid into an orphanage and send the parents back to Mexico?

First of all, don't assume I want to do anything to them, and don't try to put words in my mouth. I know illegal immigration is a problem, but the fact is there is an AMERICAN child now, and they deserve all the benefits every other American has. I'd say let them stay, and when Americans clean up America and stop blaming everything on illegals, then maybe they can deal with that problem. Illegals are a scapegoat for a much larger problem.

Well I know my state isn't trying to clean up America, it's mostly focused on just cleaning up itself at the moment. And since the recent voting for all the different propositions, hopefully everything that passed will come into play and help fix the problem. The first problem though is getting the illegal immigrants legalized so they can start paying taxes like the rest of us. The second I believe is stopping more Mexicans from coming over illegally.

If you don't mind my asking, what do you mean when you say the illegals are a scapegoat for a much larger problem? What is this larger problem you are talking about?

SterileNeedles


nobhdy

PostPosted: Thu Jan 18, 2007 9:25 pm


Quote:
We're an entire country of immigrants, except the Native Americans who we stole the land from from. We started out as illegal immigrants.


Excuse me? WE? I never did that, and I certainly hope that you didn't. My "people," didn't even do that, so I don't see how this bears any relevancy to the argument. It fails to address any of the problems or issues we are talking about.

Quote:
I'm going to have to agree that this is a serious problem, but I doubt that the illegal immigrants are entirely to blame. We'd have more money for these systems if we weren't wasting it in Iraq, but that's a different story...


So... you are saying that instead of dealing with the problem we should totally ignore it and just fund their illegal behavior with public funds?

Quote:
Nobody's expecting you to learn Spanish except school. Because you should study a foreign language. In most parts of the world, people speak or understand more than one language.


Down here in Arizona, almost everything is printed in Spanish and English. Some things are just printed in Spanish. I'm talking about road signs, too. Plus, this is just the least of the problems.

Quote:
We've seen people who are freinds with people who they should logically be enemies with.


nobody has any logical reason to be enemies with anybody... i don't get it.

Quote:
You don't know any of the people you're talking about, do you?


Excuse me? Does that have any relevancy at all? I don't need to know them to know that they've raised my Public University's tuition by 300% over the last 5 years because we have to pay for their "in-state tuition." I don't need to know them to know that Hospitals are closing in my area because they just can't afford to stay in business with all the illegals getting free healthcare and the government not being able to afford to fix it. Is it fair that kids don't learn anything in school because 40% of the class doesn't speak English?

I'd continue but I'm tired.
Reply
Pro-Choice Gaians

Goto Page: 1 2 [>] [»|]
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum