Welcome to Gaia! ::

Reply Mecha Awareness Guild
An Outsider's Questions

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Hino Recca

PostPosted: Thu Jun 16, 2005 1:45 am


Question #1: Is this guild for all mecha, or only human piloted mecha such as Gundams or Gravion?
Question #2: Would this guild mind being linked to from the Transformers GGN?
Question #3: If the answer to question #2 is yes would you mind putting a link to the Transformers GGN?
Question #4: Do the Armors used in Exo Squad count as Mecha?
Question #5: What is a Super Robot?
Question #6: THERE IS NO question #6
Question #7: Are you aware the Transformers G1 Unicron was a god before he became trapped on an asteroid and became a mecha planet? (Marvel Comic Continuity)
PostPosted: Thu Jun 16, 2005 9:38 am


Hino Recca
Question #1: Is this guild for all mecha, or only human piloted mecha such as Gundams or Gravion?
Question #2: Would this guild mind being linked to from the Transformers GGN?
Question #3: If the answer to question #2 is yes would you mind putting a link to the Transformers GGN?
Question #4: Do the Armors used in Exo Squad count as Mecha?
Question #5: What is a Super Robot?
Question #6: THERE IS NO question #6
Question #7: Are you aware the Transformers G1 Unicron was a god before he became trapped on an asteroid and became a mecha planet? (Marvel Comic Continuity)


1) Doesn't matter. If it's a big metal weapon of humanoid shape, we'll pretty much discuss it. Pilot doesn't really matter. Look at GaoGaiGar. Who can tell me that Volfogg isn't a kickass guy/mech/police car?

2) Ask GeeTee. He's the head honcho around here.

3) See 2.

4) Yep.

5) Super Robots are giant robots that don't adhere to usual science basis. They can be as fantastic as needed and have as little or as much detail as wanted (Example: The early Mazinger Z isn't terribly detailed if we hold it up to the more recent GaoGaiGar, but that may not be fair). Their attacks usually consist of things like Eye Beams, Pressure Punches, and giant swords/axes/hammers. Each one is usually created by a single person or organization with little outside asisstance (Fair examples are the Mazingers, Getters, Daimos, Goshogun, and I'll be here all day if I go on). Enemies usually consist of a giant empire that can use monsters or machines (Or machine monsters in the case of some series).

6) In that case, your Avatar kinda reminds me of Mai Kobayashi from Super Robot Wars OG2 (And the upcoming Alpha 3).

7) Nope. Are you aware that the Super Double Zeta was flown by Amuro Ray and Judo Ashita against Ideon (Or at least a suspiciously similar machine)?

Shake mo Tv mo


GeeTee
Captain

PostPosted: Thu Jun 16, 2005 10:47 am


Hino Recca
Question #1: Is this guild for all mecha, or only human piloted mecha such as Gundams or Gravion?
Question #2: Would this guild mind being linked to from the Transformers GGN?
Question #3: If the answer to question #2 is yes would you mind putting a link to the Transformers GGN?
Question #4: Do the Armors used in Exo Squad count as Mecha?
Question #5: What is a Super Robot?
Question #6: THERE IS NO question #6
Question #7: Are you aware the Transformers G1 Unicron was a god before he became trapped on an asteroid and became a mecha planet? (Marvel Comic Continuity)


1.) If someone feels like talking about tanks then they can feel free to do so but the intention is more for robots (SS-LL sizes), assault suits, and the like.
2.) Sounds cool to me.
3.) Hand me a link and I'll put it up.
4.) As Guilliam said, yup.
5.) *copy and paste from FAQ*

Quote:
Q. What is the difference between a Real Robot and a Super Robot?

A. Real Robots are mecha that can be considered realistic. There is an
established science to the units and their main weapons are likely to
consist of various guns (of course there are exceptions). All Gundam
series, with the exception of G Gundam that has Super Robots, are Real
Robots. Real Robots are most often involved in a military or special
operations organization and the mecha themselves are often produced in a
similar manner to most military vehicles.

Super Robots are those big fantastic robots that run on no realistic
scientific application whatsoever. They may fight with giant swords,
hammers, bend the elements to their will, and/or fire rocket punches. A
punch from a Super Robot can be stronger than a blast of mega particles
or other beam weaponry. Super Robots are often created by a single
brilliant scientist or a small team of them who are somehow able to
create these unique insanely powerful mecha with little outside influence
and resources. Basically, Super Robots are not what you would expect of
something that could be "real."

Some series don't cleanly fit in either category though such as units
from Evangelion, Dunbine, and Brain Powerd.

It is also possible for a series to have both SR and RR units. Rahxephon
is an SR show and Rahxephon is an SR itself. There are vehicles on that
show that are RR though (namely the variety of aircraft used by TERRA,
with the exception of the Vermillion which would almost be totally RR
other than what is under the hood... which puts it into a hybrid
category).


For the sake of more examples:

Transformers are sentient beings infused with life from their god Primus so I would favor putting them in the SR realm over the RR realm for that reason. Arguments for Transformers being RR are still logical of course, but at their basic level they are SR. Also after watching the Pretenders animation there is no way I can see them being labeled as RR. ^_^;

EXO-Squad's frames are totally RR. Sure things get fruity sometimes, but they are mass-produced (but end up being very individualized) military weapons and for the most part have weapons that operate on established science.

6.) Smarty Pants

7.) Yup.
PostPosted: Thu Jun 16, 2005 5:19 pm


Well with those answered questions I'll be subbmitting my membership aplications after this post.

Oh I wasn't being a Smarty Pants, aside from my full swing mecha fandom, I'm also a fan of Monty Python.

Recca Hino

Eternal Curse

43,050 Points
  • Perfect Attendance 400
  • Conventioneer 300
  • Gaian 50

Recca Hino

Eternal Curse

43,050 Points
  • Perfect Attendance 400
  • Conventioneer 300
  • Gaian 50
PostPosted: Thu Jun 16, 2005 5:50 pm


Since I can't edit my post here the Link to the Transformers Guild: http://www.gaiaonline.com/guilds/index.php?page_mode=4&guild_id=926
Reply
Mecha Awareness Guild

 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum