Welcome to Gaia! ::

Not to Us: A Christian Guild of Faith and Belief

Back to Guilds

 

 

Reply Debates
CONSERVATIVE VS LIBERAL OR PROGRESSIVE let it loose Goto Page: 1 2 3 [>] [»|]

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Luke_of_Chaos0911
Crew

PostPosted: Sun Nov 12, 2006 10:55 am


Don'ty worry mods, this post is being made because it is all on our minds. This is where the guild can post what they believe in about Gay Marriage, Abortion, the war in iraq, taxes, anything political.

Here are the strict rules!
1. NO FLAMING!
2. NO JUDGING, but you may put possibilities using words like "may"
3. Follow all guild, GGN, and Gaia ToS in this topic.
4. No mods delete this post or lock it until 3 moderators on Gaia can prove to me how this will turn someone away from christ. 1 moderator has to be a captain.
5. Any breaking of these rules will result in an automatic referal to a crew member or the captain. Violations can result in a demotion of power.
PostPosted: Sun Nov 12, 2006 3:09 pm


This sounds cool but if it does get too out of hand it will be locked, just saying.

OnceAgain89
Crew

3,050 Points
  • Forum Explorer 100
  • Forum Dabbler 200
  • Person of Interest 200

LearningtoBreath63
Vice Captain

PostPosted: Sun Nov 12, 2006 4:36 pm


Liberal. I think the right have it wrong and generally make a mockery of Christianity (Mark Foley is one example). I believe America is a free country and that we shouldn't come in and force our religion on others through a free government which is meant to have no religious rulings. I also believe it is wrong to take away people rights because of their sexual orientation and it is disrespectful to the homosexual community to give them "civil unions" but not give them the respect to call those unions marriage. I also am pro choice, but pro choice and anti life are two different things. I think women should have the right to two abortions each and they must do it before the second trimester begins (first three months), but of course it won't count if it is for something like rape. I also am very against the war. Their was no reason to go to war (well not in Iraq anyways) and all we've done is make it worse (their on the verge of civil way.) I don't think myself to be a liberal Christian I just think myself as a Christian who votes as a Christian, not conservative or liberal.
PostPosted: Sun Nov 12, 2006 9:30 pm


I'm canadian so I don't know if my two cents would count, but I do favour the conservatives more than the liberal. They seem to have a little more class. I obviously do not favour gay marriage or abortion.

Allythea


LearningtoBreath63
Vice Captain

PostPosted: Wed Nov 15, 2006 7:01 pm


Link, I have a problem with rule number 4 and am telling you now that if I feel that this post is causing problems I will lock it and possibly move it to the mods forum for a time to review the post. I know you don't like us taking your post away, but if we feel it's causing a problem, we reserve the right to review the post in private.
PostPosted: Wed Nov 15, 2006 10:26 pm


LearningtoBreath63
Link, I have a problem with rule number 4 and am telling you now that if I feel that this post is causing problems I will lock it and possibly move it to the mods forum for a time to review the post. I know you don't like us taking your post away, but if we feel it's causing a problem, we reserve the right to review the post in private.


I like the part in number 4 where it says 1 mod must be the captain.

Allythea


OnceAgain89
Crew

3,050 Points
  • Forum Explorer 100
  • Forum Dabbler 200
  • Person of Interest 200
PostPosted: Thu Nov 16, 2006 11:23 am


Allythea
LearningtoBreath63
Link, I have a problem with rule number 4 and am telling you now that if I feel that this post is causing problems I will lock it and possibly move it to the mods forum for a time to review the post. I know you don't like us taking your post away, but if we feel it's causing a problem, we reserve the right to review the post in private.


I like the part in number 4 where it says 1 mod must be the captain.


No it says one mod must be "a" captain. And me and John (Learning) are both Vice Captains so it protains to us and we both disagree with that rule. And it's stated now that if either of us see this causing a problem, we won't hesistate to lock and/or possibly move it to the crew forum. (Although right now I see no problem with this debate.)
PostPosted: Thu Nov 16, 2006 5:53 pm


SaraRenee
Allythea
LearningtoBreath63
Link, I have a problem with rule number 4 and am telling you now that if I feel that this post is causing problems I will lock it and possibly move it to the mods forum for a time to review the post. I know you don't like us taking your post away, but if we feel it's causing a problem, we reserve the right to review the post in private.


I like the part in number 4 where it says 1 mod must be the captain.


No it says one mod must be "a" captain. And me and John (Learning) are both Vice Captains so it protains to us and we both disagree with that rule. And it's stated now that if either of us see this causing a problem, we won't hesistate to lock and/or possibly move it to the crew forum. (Although right now I see no problem with this debate.)

If anything goes wrong, you hav the responcibility to ask Mike or someone about it. What is posted in a forums should be looked over by the crew, not tossed away and the forgotten. The system of one person judging puts people ahead of eachother. I see it, that both Sara and John have very close views. I think that if we didn't mandate ANOTHER moderator that it would always be close to the same views. As I see it, you both are Liberal and have the same view. Of course, Mike hides what he is very intellegiently and is a support of all; while I am conservative and am against most everything mandated in the guild without Mike or anothe moderators position. Therefore by the power given, I overide any argument that stands on the forth rule, even if it would cost me my position.

Luke_of_Chaos0911
Crew


OnceAgain89
Crew

3,050 Points
  • Forum Explorer 100
  • Forum Dabbler 200
  • Person of Interest 200
PostPosted: Thu Nov 16, 2006 7:20 pm


One don't call me a liberal becaquse I stay neutral when it comes to stuff like this. Mainly because I'm not too informed on all subjects. But when it comes to a lot of political issues and stuff I'm a conserative thank you very much. Secondly I have talk to Mike about stuff like this before and how I help out with the forum and he has not shown any objections to how I do so.
PostPosted: Thu Nov 16, 2006 7:33 pm


SaraRenee
One don't call me a liberal becaquse I stay neutral when it comes to stuff like this. Mainly because I'm not too informed on all subjects. But when it comes to a lot of political issues and stuff I'm a conserative thank you very much. Secondly I have talk to Mike about stuff like this before and how I help out with the forum and he has not shown any objections to how I do so.
Link, please be reasonable. Firstly, Sara is not as liberal as I am, one being when I take a Liberal stand point on views we argue a lot. This makes it more fair considering theres one person in charge thats liberal and one conservative. Also, we can't tell when crew members will be on, so if no crew members check the guild than how will we get a third person to agree if something is offensive. Fourthly, we don't just throw away posts. We put them in the crew forum or we just lock them until we have reviewed the posts and talked with the people making the problem. Another thing is that me and Sara have to keep control on this because this is one of the most controversial subjects put in here. It's taking all these controversial subjects (War in Iraq, Abortion, Gay Marriage, etc.) and putting them in one post and if things get ugly we will have to come in and stop them. If you have further complaints on our defying rule #4 if necessary, then pm them to me (or Sara) and we will deal with it there. Now lets just start the debate.

LearningtoBreath63
Vice Captain


Luke_of_Chaos0911
Crew

PostPosted: Sun Nov 19, 2006 6:03 pm


Allright! What is your beliefs on this topic.

Gay rights

I believe a Homosexual is a sinner. I believe they sin when they are Gay and it shows from the beginning of time that they are sinners. WE SHOULD ABOLISH rights for Gay people because "Sinners who refuse to repent, shouldn't be housed by the just people of America." No they should either be counseled and turn from Homosexuality or be rejected. Maybe if they are rejected, they will change their ways. I think that God will forgive them if they CHANGE but if they don't and their heart is hardened they should not be helped.

Example from Bible:
Sodom and Gimorah.
PostPosted: Sun Nov 19, 2006 7:02 pm


I believe homosexualtisy is sin. I don't believe in gay marriage either. But should we reject gay people? No we shouldn't. Jesus rejected no one. Even the Pharisees he ate dinner with. The more we reject them the less they'll turn to God. We are only showing them how judgemental Christians can be and that's not cool. We have to show them the love of Jesus for them to be able to accept him.

OnceAgain89
Crew

3,050 Points
  • Forum Explorer 100
  • Forum Dabbler 200
  • Person of Interest 200

LearningtoBreath63
Vice Captain

PostPosted: Sun Nov 19, 2006 7:27 pm


Luc_of_Chaos0911
Allright! What is your beliefs on this topic.

Gay rights

I believe a Homosexual is a sinner. I believe they sin when they are Gay and it shows from the beginning of time that they are sinners. WE SHOULD ABOLISH rights for Gay people because "Sinners who refuse to repent, shouldn't be housed by the just people of America." No they should either be counseled and turn from Homosexuality or be rejected. Maybe if they are rejected, they will change their ways. I think that God will forgive them if they CHANGE but if they don't and their heart is hardened they should not be helped.

Example from Bible:
Sodom and Gimorah.
This is very wrong. Firstly, America is not a Christian nation. We shouldn't be butt holes to everyone else because it's a sin to us. An atheist wouldn't have a problem with gay people and believe it or not we have to share America. Secondly if we make a law against homosexuality than we would have to make a law against all other sin. That's what your saying basically, homosexuality is a sin and therefore we must ban sin, and if we banned sin then everyone would be in jail and therefor we would have to fund prisons, there would be nobody to run America because the poloticians would all be in jail. All the doctors would be in jail along with the police and firemen, and all the gaurds would be in jail so there would be nobody in jail. Now you might say "but we don't have to ban all sin in America." But if no sin is held over another than we would or we're just being hypocrits as a religion. That is why we choose battles that affect the safety physically and mentally of other people and I don't see how homosexuality harms people. So don't take your anger out on the homosexuals for sinning without taking yourself to jail for sinning first.
PostPosted: Sun Nov 19, 2006 7:36 pm


LearningtoBreath63
Luc_of_Chaos0911
Allright! What is your beliefs on this topic.

Gay rights

I believe a Homosexual is a sinner. I believe they sin when they are Gay and it shows from the beginning of time that they are sinners. WE SHOULD ABOLISH rights for Gay people because "Sinners who refuse to repent, shouldn't be housed by the just people of America." No they should either be counseled and turn from Homosexuality or be rejected. Maybe if they are rejected, they will change their ways. I think that God will forgive them if they CHANGE but if they don't and their heart is hardened they should not be helped.

Example from Bible:
Sodom and Gimorah.
This is very wrong. Firstly, America is not a Christian nation. We shouldn't be butt holes to everyone else because it's a sin to us. An atheist wouldn't have a problem with gay people and believe it or not we have to share America. Secondly if we make a law against homosexuality than we would have to make a law against all other sin. That's what your saying basically, homosexuality is a sin and therefore we must ban sin, and if we banned sin then everyone would be in jail and therefor we would have to fund prisons, there would be nobody to run America because the poloticians would all be in jail. All the doctors would be in jail along with the police and firemen, and all the gaurds would be in jail so there would be nobody in jail. Now you might say "but we don't have to ban all sin in America." But if no sin is held over another than we would or we're just being hypocrits as a religion. That is why we choose battles that affect the safety physically and mentally of other people and I don't see how homosexuality harms people. So don't take your anger out on the homosexuals for sinning without taking yourself to jail for sinning first.

Agreed.

OnceAgain89
Crew

3,050 Points
  • Forum Explorer 100
  • Forum Dabbler 200
  • Person of Interest 200

LearningtoBreath63
Vice Captain

PostPosted: Sun Nov 19, 2006 8:08 pm


SaraRenee
LearningtoBreath63
Luc_of_Chaos0911
Allright! What is your beliefs on this topic.

Gay rights

I believe a Homosexual is a sinner. I believe they sin when they are Gay and it shows from the beginning of time that they are sinners. WE SHOULD ABOLISH rights for Gay people because "Sinners who refuse to repent, shouldn't be housed by the just people of America." No they should either be counseled and turn from Homosexuality or be rejected. Maybe if they are rejected, they will change their ways. I think that God will forgive them if they CHANGE but if they don't and their heart is hardened they should not be helped.

Example from Bible:
Sodom and Gimorah.
This is very wrong. Firstly, America is not a Christian nation. We shouldn't be butt holes to everyone else because it's a sin to us. An atheist wouldn't have a problem with gay people and believe it or not we have to share America. Secondly if we make a law against homosexuality than we would have to make a law against all other sin. That's what your saying basically, homosexuality is a sin and therefore we must ban sin, and if we banned sin then everyone would be in jail and therefor we would have to fund prisons, there would be nobody to run America because the poloticians would all be in jail. All the doctors would be in jail along with the police and firemen, and all the gaurds would be in jail so there would be nobody in jail. Now you might say "but we don't have to ban all sin in America." But if no sin is held over another than we would or we're just being hypocrits as a religion. That is why we choose battles that affect the safety physically and mentally of other people and I don't see how homosexuality harms people. So don't take your anger out on the homosexuals for sinning without taking yourself to jail for sinning first.

Agreed.

I'm going to also talk about quotes from two respected Christians. One is C.S. Lewis who talks about how he doesn't vote in Parliament people who want to make laws banning divorce because he doesn't want to impose his rights on people. Another is Dallas Taylor who said this about Christian music but this could be applied to in this type of situation:
"I feel like so much of music today, especially those who come from a Christian background, spend so much time hiding who they really are, or being ashamed of their beliefs, trying to be 'scene' or to sell records. I want every kid to know I am not going to change who I really am to sell records. I mean, I absolutely hate shoving things down people's throats, but hiding who you are is just as bad."
Yes, we should be proud of being Christian like he said, but he also talks about how he hates shoving things down peoples throats. Now this is a respected Christian musician who formed Underoath and is in Maylene and the Sons of Disaster talking about his beliefs in music. This can be applied to all aspects of Christianity though. A sense of not hiding our belief but not forcing our belief upon others or shoving our belief down peoples throats. That's why I don't believe in banning marriage. I think we should make laws against things that harm people mentally or physically or go against there unalienable rights, but being homosexual harms nobody, whether it is sin or not. So murder or rape does harm people mentally and physically, that is why those sins should be banned by law, but homosexuality shouldn't. If you don't agree with me then turn yourself into the nearest jail for being a sinner before the next time you vote against homosexuality.
Reply
Debates

Goto Page: 1 2 3 [>] [»|]
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum