Such wonderful submissions! It was really hard to choose between them all.
Our first place winner: angelgirl2345! Holy crap. Between the dissonant tones and the childlike laughter inbetween the creepy-a** "La-la-la-la" chorus, this song is unsettling and unnerving and I do believe I'm going to have to add it to my Halloween playlist!
Second place: Ruriska! That song is perfectly haunting and moody, giving the feeling that there's something lurking, just behind you. And then when you add in the lyrics, it's so creepy and melancholy, and maybe a little bit apathetic to your plight ("It was always you that I despised/I don't feel enough for you to cry") which is still chilling.
And everybody who entered gets one free certing on the Moonlit tag, because I'm sneaky like that. (This can be a recerting, btw)

Angelgirl, please post your preference in this thread, so Ruri knows which one she gets. <3
Thank you all for participating!