Welcome to Gaia! ::

Wow! That sucks...

I went to a Christian School growing up, and they were more strict about instilling certain disciplines in the students that went, but I was one of the blessed few that went to a place that didn't feel they held sway over the very thoughts of the students. They did try to teach us to control our mischievous ideas, but they encouraged us to ask hard questions about God and try to see that God and Science have their places. I didn't agree with everything that the curriculum taught, but I was required to pass the tests...

It depends on the place though. Some institutions feel it is their god-given duty to shape the very thoughts of the students. They fail to realize that it just weakens their influence, and causes conflict within those who can see common sense and the contradiction that many religious stances hold with said common sense.

Each school is responsible for the subject matter and curriculum they teach, and if they feel that actions are a part of the curriculum, then when students act contradictory to the rules, then they are rebelling. If the school has expelled you and your brother for the way you think, then it leads me to believe that you have made some good points that they don't know how to refute, and they don't want you "contaminating" their other students. I feel the school has failed you because they didn't take time to understand where you are coming from, but that is just my opinion.

I do hope I am not out of line here though....

So, what does your parents think about the whole mess?

I would agree with Lumany on the more challenging curriculum. My scores were in the top 10% of the state when testing time came, and I was doing college courses in my junior year, and all my senior year stuff (other than English, go figure) were advanced courses that could be accepted for college credit. Anymore, public schools hold students back and dumb down their courses to make their end-year reviews better (in the States anyway). I am glad for the opportunity. I think it would be great if you can get into a private school that encourages your free thought yet stimulates and challenges your intellect.

Lumany, your school sounds awesome! My Christian school was small, I was the only person in my grade. LOL We all got along great, the older students looking out for the younger like a huge family. But if Zakku's private school was Christian, I could see how things went down. Our school had people coming in who had been expelled from other Christian private schools BECAUSE they thought freely, or didn't agree with the pastor/principal/supervisor of their previous school. Just one of the bad consequences of having people more devoted to religious indoctrination than real education trying to run schools.

I love when parents try to force a religion on their children...

But I would imagine they can because it is a Christian/Catholic school after all. They do not want Atheist and Agnostic, even Pagans, in their schools. It would be contradicting to their beliefs. And if the child will not change their belief than the easiest solution would be to kick them out. You would not want a Catholic going to a Jewish school, now would you? That could spell disaster. But the weird thing, and I just remembered this, my mom was raised Christian {I think Lutheran, but I'm not sure. And that would be Catholic, right?} and went to Jewish high school. I do not believe it was private though, just the area she grew up in was mostly Jewish.

If you haven't been to both Private and Public you can't have an educated opinion. When I went to Public school I was bored literally to tears. Mental Health Proffessionals told me to seek private school. Private school has been so much better.

And did you forget that Judaism is a religion AND an ethnicity? So you can be Jewish ethnically but not even believe in G-d. We have quite a bit of that at my school. Minyans and minyans of them. All Jews at my school but some more religious than others in both extremes. They practice Judaism more as a culture.

By the way, in case I forgot to mention, my school does actually teach evolution. I mean, they touch on 7 days' Creation in Bible Study but in Science class and History class it is all Evolution. Homo Habilis to Homo Erectus to Neanderthals and Cro Magnons to us now in the Cenozoic Era. Fascinating stuff, really. Amazing.
But, LOL, my Orthodox friend doesn't believe in it. Neither does this one Orthodox Rabbi at school... but he's quite the character, actually. Notorious for his 'Zhe voman, she belongs in zhe kitchen' old country attitude. Very Orthodox. But he chants torah really well at the gender-separated minyan. And like I said, we just have all kinds of Jews at my school.

^ That's the reason the main reason they kicked me and my step bro out, "A personal and active faith in God" is their most important goal, they want their graduates to go off to Bible colleges and become missionaries. I heard at one point they hacked into half the high schools face book accounts and kicked out most of them until people found out about it.

I disagree. Free thought is more important than adherence to dogma.

My school doesn't require me to believe in God, they merely hope to instill long-lasting faith in their students. I know plenty of atheists at my Catholic school.

Anyway, it's not even in the rulebook that "If you call yourself an atheist, you will be expelled." Nothing like that. Sure, they want me to be Catholic or theist at the least, but they can't expel me.

We almost sued them for it, but we were actually happy that we were taken out of it, it had a horrible education system, they just kicked out two students a week ago because their parents were talking bad about the school.