Welcome to Gaia! ::

The Politically Incorrect Guild

Back to Guilds

For anyone who is sick of politically correct effluvium. 

Tags: Conservative, Right, Libertarian, Moderate, Unrestricted 

Reply Entertainment (Music, Games, Movies, Art)
Book: Cultural Amnesia

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Intuet
Captain

Conservative Survivor

PostPosted: Sun Mar 14, 2010 4:15 am


Reading it now. Haven't gotten too far into it, but it is a nice reminder of when liberal and humanism were good words.

Also, as the author addresses the "young, hungry culture-vultures" he assumes will be perusing his scrawl, it makes me wonder: am I one? Are all young(ish: I am not a kid) conservatives culture-vultures, or at least all young intellectuals? Is culture, the enduring kind, something we crave after having mass pop culture shoved down our eyeballs daily?

EDIT: This one's by Clive James. Not Stephen Bertman. xD
PostPosted: Fri Mar 19, 2010 1:06 am


What the heck is a culture vulture?

I had to look this book up... whoever wrote the description on amazon wasn't too complimentary about it.

What do you mean by culture? I usually think of it as customs and traditions, food, clothes, morality, stuff that you usually don't think about unless confronted by something different. This definition doesn't seem to fit too well here though.

Kira84


Intuet
Captain

Conservative Survivor

PostPosted: Sat Mar 20, 2010 11:10 pm


I'm not sure either what a culture vulture is. My first assumption would be those middle- to upper-class people who have plebian taste but convince themselves they like abstract art because it makes them sound cool.

But the dictionary suggests they might be less doltish than that.

Dictionary.com

culture vulture

–noun Slang.
a person with an excessive or pretentious interest in the arts.

Origin:
1945–50

Slang Dictionary
culture-vulture

1. n. an avid supporter of the arts. : Many culture-vultures seem to be long on enthusiasm and short on taste.
2. n. someone who exploits the arts for monetary gain. : Some culture-vultures are throwing a wine and cheese party on behalf of some of the young dolts they have grubstaked.



Hmm...maybe the author was using the term playfully. Or just differently.

I went to Amazon and looked at the editorial reviews - they seemed to praise it, but I guess he's too straight for them to actually like. He's a liberal with a lower-case l.

By culture in this context, I mean in the sense of what is produced by those striving to achieve more than what our everyday life gives us. In that sense, a Chris Claremont comic book (he's a hack writer, known mostly for his stint(s) on X-men) is not culture, and a book by Dickens or a symphony by pretty much anybody is.
PostPosted: Sun Mar 21, 2010 12:35 am


I just clicked on the first one I saw, which, after going back and checking, turned out to be the Clive James one.

I got the idea that the people who did the editorial reviews were made uncomfortable by the book - one said his theme can grow intrusive, the other thought there were too few women covered. Although the second review did start out pretty glowing.

Going based on the Slang Dictionary definition 1, I have to say that sounds like a liberal thing.

Not going based on that, I'd like to think that all young-ish people are interested in enduring culture. stare Barring that, I'll go with young intellectuals

Kira84

Reply
Entertainment (Music, Games, Movies, Art)

 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum