Welcome to Gaia! ::

neonascence

Back to Guilds

Musings on organic gardening, frugal living, the environment, self-sufficiency and whatever else strikes our fancy. 

Tags: gardening, environment, organic, permaculture, green 

Reply General Discussion
Two days ago, I met my meat. Goto Page: 1 2 [>] [»|]

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Yanueh
Crew

Shameless Shapeshifter

PostPosted: Sun Jan 31, 2010 11:51 am


Well, not mine. It belongs to a local rancher. I just took the picture. razz

This is how we do things where I come from.

User Image - Blocked by "Display Image" Settings. Click to show.

I'd say it looks pretty content there, wouldn't you?
PostPosted: Sun Jan 31, 2010 12:03 pm


Yanueh

I'd say it looks pretty content there, wouldn't you?

So far. But he probably doesn't know he's going to be murdered yet. Follow that cow for a while more, and I bet you'll get some pictures that are far from content.

LorienLlewellyn

Quotable Informer


Yanueh
Crew

Shameless Shapeshifter

PostPosted: Sun Jan 31, 2010 12:04 pm


The point is that the cow isn't living a "life in agony" as some ARA groups claim all livestock do.

Incidentally, if I followed a wild animal until the end of its lifespan, I'd probably end up seeing it ripped to shreds by predators.
PostPosted: Sun Jan 31, 2010 12:11 pm


Does your farmer slaughter his animals on his farm? If they don't they send your lovely cow to a slaughter house where they are put down with all the other horrified animals from every other farm that doesn't have a slaughter house built in. Your cow will be dragged in and hopefully knocked out, but possibly not. Your cow will die and it will die in agony and fear. Good work. You can look your meat in the eye and have someone else murder it for you and feel great about it.

Quote:

Incidentally, if I followed a wild animal until the end of its lifespan, I'd probably end up seeing it ripped to shreds by predators.


So... if the cow would have died anyway... oh wait. This cow wouldn't have been alive if it weren't bred to be killed anyway. This is a whole new animal placed on this earth specifically to die.

Most animals don't die by predators, there aren't enough animals out there for that, you might see it hurt itself and starve to death because it can't feed, or you might see it die of old age, death happens. Just because something might die anyway doesn't mean its ok to kill it now.

What rationalization are you using to keep yourself from killing people on the street? "They're just going to die anyway."

What rationalization are you using to keep your evident blood lust in check when you see a dolphin. "Its just going to end up as by catch anyway."

Tandahda


Yanueh
Crew

Shameless Shapeshifter

PostPosted: Sun Jan 31, 2010 12:14 pm


I don't know. What I do know is that most people graze their cattle out on open land in my state, which reduces fire hazard during the dry months.
PostPosted: Sun Jan 31, 2010 12:22 pm


I apologize for editing to add more to my original post.

Also, that's not even relevant to the argument. You stated that you had met your meat and was thus ok with eating it, implying that you're ok with slaughter and that since animals die in the wild it is then ok to kill them, that's what you're being called on.

Depending on which state you live in you should have herds of wild buffalo or mustangs grazing in that open land but those breeds have been corralled and moved to a different spot, or killed off for your ******** cattle.

Tandahda


Yanueh
Crew

Shameless Shapeshifter

PostPosted: Sun Jan 31, 2010 12:31 pm


Quote:
What rationalization are you using to keep yourself from killing people on the street? "They're just going to die anyway."

A natural, instinctual aversion to killing off my own species? Most species have natural aversions to killing their own kind simply because it isn't conducive to the survival of the species.

Quote:
Depending on which state you live in you should have herds of wild buffalo or mustangs grazing in that open land but those breeds have been corralled and moved to a different spot, or killed off for your ******** cattle.

Having the buffalo roaming around would be cool, but why mustangs? They were introduced by Europeans. If cattle have no right to be on this land, then neither do mustangs.
PostPosted: Sun Jan 31, 2010 12:33 pm


But why kill it at all. Why keep breeding more for lives destined to be cut short, to be bred bigger larger and be more of a burden on the land. It's not a natural life. It's kinda greedy of us, don't you think? I dream of symbiosis.

If you can't stand to do something to an animal yourself, deep down, it's probably going against your own moral compass.

[Kegan]

Nimble Cultist


Yanueh
Crew

Shameless Shapeshifter

PostPosted: Sun Jan 31, 2010 12:40 pm


[Kegan]
But why kill it at all.

No matter what you eat, an animal has to die for it. If you eat meat, an mammal died. If you eat plants, insects died. As long as whatever you are eating was raised sustainably, what difference does it make?

Honestly, what I find disturbing is that along my walk I kept finding bits of trash left by people out target practicing or whatever. I don't mind that they were target practicing, but leaving your plastic pigeons and shotgun casings around isn't nice at all.
PostPosted: Sun Jan 31, 2010 12:48 pm


Quote:
Quote:
A natural, instinctual aversion to killing off my own species? Most species have natural aversions to killing their own kind simply because it isn't conducive to the survival of the species.


Quote:

Depending on which state you live in you should have herds of wild buffalo or mustangs grazing in that open land but those breeds have been corralled and moved to a different spot, or killed off for your ******** cattle.


Quote:
Having the buffalo roaming around would be cool, but why mustangs? They were introduced by Europeans. If cattle have no right to be on this land, then neither do mustangs.



Wait whut? Species have a natural aversion to killing their own? Clearly this explains why people kill other people, and why we let corporations murder and kill in third world countries... unless you're saying people of a different skin colour are a different species than you... polar bears kill each other, walrus kill each other, big horned sheep kill each other some times. Killing one's own species is an art perfected by humans but it happens among animals across -vore status and across animal kingdoms.

By your logic about the mustangs, Europeans also shouldn't be here. Get out. Also the other 7/8ths of me that aren't Native American can go too. Good work.

Tandahda


Tandahda

PostPosted: Sun Jan 31, 2010 12:54 pm


Yanueh
[Kegan]
But why kill it at all.

No matter what you eat, an animal has to die for it. If you eat meat, an mammal died. If you eat plants, insects died. As long as whatever you are eating was raised sustainably, what difference does it make?

Honestly, what I find disturbing is that along my walk I kept finding bits of trash left by people out target practicing or whatever. I don't mind that they were target practicing, but leaving your plastic pigeons and shotgun casings around isn't nice at all.


How is that even related to our discussion here?

The difference between the animals that die in the production of plants and the animals that are meant to die in the production of animals that you eat, are that a) we don't bring insects and small wild mammals into existence for the purpose of killing them with the thresher. and b) you get to add all those little animals onto your plate as well because the animals you eat, are eating plants as well.
PostPosted: Sun Jan 31, 2010 12:54 pm


Without getting too deep into the great debate, I'd have to say that pasture raised cows are preferable to the alternative if the alternative is grain-fed and enclosed while being pumped with growth hormone for your short existence.

Since everyone isn't going to become vegetation even if I wanted them to, this is the better way to go.

I hate the idea of meeting meat though, because cows are sweet and to think they will be a burger for someone is horrible. When I was a child we kept a few cows. I mean a small amount like 3-5. I was there and helped when two of them were born and I fed them every day. One day a truck came and loaded them up and a few days later we got the white freezer paper packages in return. That was awful at the time but it's more traumatic thinking back on it. Still I'm glad they had the chance to live the lives they did, because I know I loved them and I'd like to think they knew it too. I wish every factory-raised cow had that opportunity.

Ellavemia

Invisible Informer

9,000 Points
  • Team Bunny 250
  • Flatterer 200
  • Elocutionist 200

Yanueh
Crew

Shameless Shapeshifter

PostPosted: Sun Jan 31, 2010 12:54 pm


Quote:
Wait whut? Species have a natural aversion to killing their own? Clearly this explains why people kill other people, and why we let corporations murder and kill in third world countries... unless you're saying people of a different skin colour are a different species than you... polar bears kill each other, walrus kill each other, big horned sheep kill each other some times. Killing one's own species is an art perfected by humans but it happens among animals across -vore status and across animal kingdoms.

Of course there are exceptions, but most higher lifeforms do not have an instinct that actively tells them to seek out and destroy their own kind. Actual killings are usually over matters of defense of territory, self, or spreading their genes to the next generation.

Quote:
By your logic about the mustangs, Europeans also shouldn't be here. Get out. Also the other 7/8ths of me that aren't Native American can go too. Good work.

Actually, I believe that's your logic more than mine.
PostPosted: Sun Jan 31, 2010 12:57 pm


Yanueh
[Kegan]
But why kill it at all.

No matter what you eat, an animal has to die for it. If you eat meat, an mammal died. If you eat plants, insects died. As long as whatever you are eating was raised sustainably, what difference does it make?

Honestly, what I find disturbing is that along my walk I kept finding bits of trash left by people out target practicing or whatever. I don't mind that they were target practicing, but leaving your plastic pigeons and shotgun casings around isn't nice at all.
I don't judge... aloud, but by your own logic you are a double murderer. Those animals eat plants too.

--And mammals show a significant deal more brain power than bugs. That is for certain.

[Kegan]

Nimble Cultist


Yanueh
Crew

Shameless Shapeshifter

PostPosted: Sun Jan 31, 2010 1:00 pm


Seraphsody
The difference between the animals that die in the production of plants and the animals that are meant to die in the production of animals that you eat, are that a) we don't bring insects and small wild mammals into existence for the purpose of killing them with the thresher. and b) you get to add all those little animals onto your plate as well because the animals you eat, are eating plants as well.


[Kegan]
I don't judge... aloud, but by your own logic you are a double murderer. Those animals eat plants too.

Allowing an animal to graze doesn't require you to seek out and destroy insects and the eggs of insects that would destroy your tasty and delicious crops. Gardening does. Therein lies the difference.

And how can I be a murderer by my own logic when I do not equate either action to murder?

[Kegan]
--And mammals show a significant deal more brain power than bugs. That is for certain.

Just wondering, do you, in fact, have a 'brainpower line' that you draw defining what is and isn't acceptable to kill?

It seems to me that the whole matter is one of very fuzzy logic for either side.
Reply
General Discussion

Goto Page: 1 2 [>] [»|]
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum