Welcome to Gaia! ::

If Sonic and Shadow were destined to fight eachother to the death, and one HAD to kill the other, who would win the battle?

Don't just choose your favorite character, consider it carefully. Create some Senerios if you want.

Things to consider:
- Sonic is cool, but Shadow is "the ultimate life form"
- Sonic's speed is all natural. Shadow uses thoes silly floaty shoes to run fast.
- Sonic will protect his friends to his own death. Shadow is all angsty over his already dead girlfriend.
- Sonic has all his friends to defend him, Shadow has NO FRIENDS sad (except maybe Rouge and robots)
- Shadow already knew how to use Chaos Control, but Sonic learned it in a few seconds using a fake Chaos Emerald.
- Sonic is bright blue, Shadow is Black & Red (much easier to hide in the dark)
- Sonic isn't stupid, Shadow obeys anyone powerful and lets himself get used like a b***h.


I can't think of anything else. Have conversation already.

i'd say shadow because he is just a badass how can he not win, i mean now he has guns and i can almost guarentee that shadow is going to kill off sonic in that game where shadow has guns i think it's ccalled like shadow the hedgehog or something like that, sorry for the spelling errors

You know... That's a somewhat good question... Hmm... I'd have to say, though, that it would probably all come down to the question of motivation. Whichever is more motivated at that particular moment, for whatever reason, would probably be the overall winner.
This could generally come down to vengeance, a plot, or protection.

On the same note, losing inhibitions would assist in the outcome. If one party thought they had nothing left to live for, they'd go all out, not caring for their own safety in the process. This usually takes an opponent by surprise, upsetting the balance of a fight.



...Yay for cliches!

I dont know...it's hard to say really....
shadow and sonic are evenly matched i would say no one would in because the fight would end because they would be to tired out to fight becuase they have the same strength,speed,and whatever
but Shadow is more ruthless and WOULD kill sonic
i dont think sonic would, even if he had to, kill shadow


P.s: i am not a idiot :gonk ((ur siggy lol)):

Its too much of a close fight. But I ahve to go with Sonic. I mean, without him, Shadow would never exist in the series!

But getting to the point on their atrebues (Sp?)

Sonic relys on friendship, but on the outside it makes him look uselessy weak. Shadow on the otherhand is power hungry, but is so blinded by that power, he'd utterly less wind up killing himself sooner or later.

Sonic, has 3 FORMS. His normal happy go lucky form, and the more seious Super AND Hyper forms. WHich gives him a slight advantage, consedering Shadow only has a Super, inspite the fact people claim that its "HYPER" Shadow. But its "SUPER" Giving Sonic a lead.

Shadow constaltly dwells on the past which also gives him the part of avengence, but Sonic is always thinking ahead, which makes him a lot more confident.

And as said before, Shadow only listens to people who are better than him, which is bad, because he'll beliveve almost anything that person says, like Emerl/Gizoid, which will end up killing himself as well, due to the fact hes a weapon, and part alein.

Sonic has a free will and right to do whatever he pleases, so he can really choose not to fight, kill someone, which I hardly doubt, or sacrifice his own life for others. Shadow only did that for his girlfriend.

In conclusion, Sonic wins in the end.

Serious people! be serious!



I wish that their rivalry would just end. Now that Shadow knows his past....Somewhat, (ShTH PEOPLE!) he shouldn't be too emo and violent. I mean, not happy go lucky like Sonic. But a bit more...uhhh....normal.

I heart Shadow!

Shadow would win.

He has Chaos Spear and Chaos Control, while Sonic has spindash and his ability of speed.

Shadow is immortal, never ages. Sonic can age, he's 15.
There's a big differene between them, and how they could die.