Welcome to Gaia! ::

~The Chronicles of Narnia~

Back to Guilds

A guild for Chronicles of Narnia, all fans welcomed! 

Tags: Narnia, Roleplaying, Lewis, Aslan, Chronicles 

Reply Other Discussions
My Rant...VERY CONTROVERSIAL! ^^

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

OMG pls no

PostPosted: Sun Jan 18, 2009 10:23 pm


this is my view on the movies on narnia (especially the Prince Caspian movie)...
prepare yourself...and if you are a serious fan girl/boy of the movies and the actors...GO NO FURTHER....JUS GO ABOUT YOUR BUSINESS AND DO NOT
i repeat:
DO
NOT
READ PAST THE THREE DOTS BELOW THIS TEXT!!!

...

*achem*

after seeing the lion the witch and the wardrobe...my passion for narnia became to become clear...i realized how awesome the series was and i couldn't wait for the prince caspian movie...
right after seeing the prince caspian movie...i became an instant fangirl for skandar keynes...i loved the movies...
however...after i became obsessed with edmund pevensie i started reading the books more deeply and more often.
i discovered the obvious. the prince caspian movie was a cheat.
if you have read the prince caspian book at all you will agree that the movie really left out a lot....and worse...THEY PUT IN THEIR OWN STORY!
im not gonna point out the fact that they even started the movie wrong because there is so many mistakes it would take too long.
i just want to say that they left out the best part. when aslan makes himself invisible to everyone but lucy and she has to lead them out of the mess they all lead themselves into. that scene was the most beautiful and it was (in my opinionated opinion) the best and most important scene in the entire book.
they left it out. they scratched it out and had peter get into a fight with caspian instead. then peter acts all stupid in the movie. when of course, in the book they became friends.
"We're not here to take your place you know. But to put you in it." -Peter to Caspian upon their first meeting.
the worst of it is that they added all this other stuff. like a castle raid and a love scene!
Dx
now here is where things get REALLY ugly.
How much worse will The Voyage of the Dawn Treader be?
if you don't feel sick to your stomach by now, you probably think im an idiot.
i might be, but im an idiot that doesnt like the way people are dealing with this. some people could care less about the books and think that the movies are way better!
crazy right?
PostPosted: Wed Jan 21, 2009 3:25 am


I've read all the books and I disagree with you. Just because they put their own spin on Caspian doesn't mean it was a bad movie or not worthy of fandom. Not only that but a lot of it was canon. And what are you talking about, Aslan was invisible to everyone else in the movie, just like in the book. Get your facts straight before you post.

sykothasadistik


cupfly
Vice Captain

PostPosted: Sat Jan 24, 2009 11:51 am


I liked the way the movie was turned and twisted. It made their journey seem more adventurous than in the book.
PostPosted: Thu Apr 16, 2009 3:46 pm


no, no,. i agree with "OMG its just you", shes totally right, i think i posted that too as my response to one of the forums, i totally agree, though it was an alright movie, as i watched i had to get the feel to read the actual book to my little brother who thought that was the only way possible the story was ever told.



scurd
Hellos im Scurd, or Ernesto. I live in Flordia. Ive read all of the books for a reading assighnment for english class, and loved them. Ive seen the movies afterwards and think there okay, but should of stayed along the lines of the books, because everything that happens in there affects what was shown in the movies, and if you dont show the cause, then its just confusing. Yes, yes, even if it would of made each movie three hours long.
xp <(But hey, that would of made them better in my point of view)

Scurd_Tito

Familiar Seeker

Reply
Other Discussions

 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum