Round 13: Make It Work... | Page 1 | Epic Tektekers Old Judging and Discussion | Guild Forums

Navenna

Offline

Posted: Sun Nov 02, 2008 5:58 pm

Theme:
For this round the contestants just have to pick a hard to match item from three that we provided them with and base an avi around it.

Judging Rubric:

6 - Orginality
7 - General Appeal
7 - color Usage & layering
5 - How well it works with the round's Theme
25 - Total Score

People who still need to submit:

- - S a r a L a n g -

- -Le Chien Chat-

- Sexy_Top_Model

- DanJF

- [ Danger Woman ]

- Ms Sadie

Posted: Mon Nov 03, 2008 2:45 pm

63/75
893/1025

Sexy_Top_Model-

Dee - 6. 5. 5. 4 = 20
Mm. It doesn't amaze me. Not bad, but it's kind of confusing. A lot going on, and I'm not sure if you did the greatest with making the scarf work well with an avi.

gray
6.5.7.5=23
great job its creative and definatley something i would have expected from you, its cute the dark blue shades are kind of disteracting though since were they are its a very small amount so its almost as if they arent there, which makes the more obvious spots of dark blue distracting.

Navi-
6.5.5.4=20
This one is a little shy of the mark for me. The purple in the scarf is what I was looking forward to see matched (the scarf wasn't my item, btw) but you didn't really do that. Even so it fits pretty well into the overall avi, though the overall look is a bit too cluttered.

Here Comes the Muffin Man
Vice Captain

Offline

Navenna

Offline

Posted: Wed Nov 05, 2008 1:11 pm

66/75
923/1025

[ Danger Woman ]-

Dee - 6. 5. 6. 5 = 22
I love how this is so interesting. Very original. Overall appeal is pretty good. Great color usage and layering. The avi looks a bit disturbing, not because of the pants. But I like the originality of it. (:

gray
5.5.6.5=21
very clownish. its a bit plain, very eye popping. Not my favorite of your avatars

Navi-
6.6.6.5=23
This avi is very cute. It does seem a little plain, however. A few more accessories, especially in silver to match the hoofs would have been great.

Posted: Wed Nov 05, 2008 9:35 pm

57/75
894/1025

- S a r a L a n g -

Dee - 6. 6. 6. 5 = 23
Very simple, yet nice. (:

gray= 5.2.3.4=14
i dont think you got the point of the challange. You were suposed to turn the item into a good looking avatar, all i see here is... slop. this is way to plain and simple, you didint even play it safe, that roads over, if you do make it out of this round you really need to head these words and STEP UP you will not make it if this is what you are turning in on one of the last rounds, we're going towards the end of the competition, you'll never win if this is the sort of thing your turning in!

Navi-
6.5.4.5=20
I'm a little underwhelmed by this avi. The colors and matching are there... and you worked with the item... but... it's so plain. So barren. There's nothing to it. Layering is too simplistic. It just fails to impress. =(

Navenna

Offline

Navenna

Offline

Posted: Fri Nov 07, 2008 10:26 am

57/75
879/1025

Ms Sadie-

Dee - 6. 4. 4. 5 = 19
Too much going on.

gray:
6.4.4.5=19
im disapointed, you can do alot better than this sadie, i've been in competitions competing against you and it seams that you havent been doing as good as you could be in this contest, your an avatar celeb for petes sake! anyway, this avatar is fairly cluttered and doesnt really match. though there is layering it just comes off as clutter, the main focus of the avatar is the scarf but it has a negative image to it.

Navi-
6.4.4.5=19
Whoa clutter. At least, that's my first impression each time I look at this. But once I get past that you did a good job with the scarf. The layering seems a bit off to me and could have been toned down some.

Posted: Sat Nov 08, 2008 11:55 am

71/75
903/1025

DanJF-

Dee -
my judging score doesn't count but i wanted to say, i love this one, Dan!
Great job. (:

Xin -
6.7.5.5 = 23
Nice! I like this one. It reminds me of 1337 5P34K's avi ^_^ It kinda looks like you tried to hide the pants, but no one said you couldn't do that. Plus I'm biased because that's the item that I picked ;3

gray: 6.7.6.5=24
im happy to say after looking at this avatar for a while it is not what i expected from you, its no secret that im not a fan of your older work in this competition but im happy that your stepping out of your shell with bolder colors and a whole new style. the layering is great and the face is fantastic, you may just be the winner for this round again!

Navi-
6.7.6.5=24
This avi is the easy favorite this week, it seems. The colors are eye catching, the layering is interesting, it's well balanced... overall it's just a great avi. I'm happy to see you really hitting your stride with this contest.

Here Comes the Muffin Man
Vice Captain

Offline

Felicity Roze
Captain

Shirtless Conventioneer

6,900 Points

200
100
150

Offline

Posted: Sat Nov 08, 2008 3:18 pm

58/75
906/1025

Chien-

Dee - 6. 4. 5. 5 = 20
Ack. The wave tiara killed it, I'm sorry. I think it could have done without.

gray:
6.3.5.5=19
wtf? this could be a good avatar but the wave tiara is just unneeded, it apears that you knew it would be to plain and you needed something to fill space. quite like the last time with the smoke bomb. unlike dan who's coming out of a shell into something great, i'd say your doing the complete oposite, your designs were fanomanal and lately they've been sinking into something, the dog wouldent eat.

Navi-
6.3.5.5=19
It seems weird that I just mentioned this in the thread... but the wave tiara is that step-too-far item from you this week (the frog is a close second, though). It's the right color but too much of it and distracts from the rest of the outfit, which I think you did a stellar job with. Especially with matching the top.

Posted: Sun Nov 09, 2008 2:50 pm

Editing as we go...

Round 13:

71 - DanJF --- 903

66 - [ Danger Woman ] --- 923

63 - Sexy_Top_Model --- 893

58 - -Le Chien Chat- --- 906

57 - - S a r a L a n g - --- 894

57 - Ms Sadie --- 879

Overall:
[ Danger Woman ] --- 923

-Le Chien Chat- --- 906

DanJF --- 903

- S a r a L a n g - --- 894

Sexy_Top_Model --- 893

Ms Sadie --- 879

Navenna

Offline

Welcome to Gaia! ::

Gaia Guilds

All Things Epic

Quick Reply

More Information