Why?! | Page 1 | The Full Metal Alchemist Official guild | Guild Forums

ScarXLust_Fan

Offline

Posted: Fri Sep 02, 2005 7:05 pm

Ok, I read the who killed Winry's parents and someone said (Spoiler.): Scar killed Winry's parents in the manga. Why?! crying That's what I want to know really badly.

Posted: Fri Sep 02, 2005 7:36 pm

BakuraFan

Ok, I read the who killed Winry's parents and someone said (Spoiler.): Scar killed Winry's parents in the manga. Why?! crying That's what I want to know really badly.

Actually I don't think it was (spoiler)Scar. I think it was Scar's bro. Because they only knew that he had that tattoo on the arm. And before (spoiler) Scar's bro used to have that tattoo also. How Scar has that tattoo is cuz Scar's bro gave him his arm so Scar could survive. So the arm that scar has...u no...the one with the tattoo.....that's scar's bro's arm.

kikyo98

Offline

ScarXLust_Fan

Offline

Posted: Fri Sep 02, 2005 7:39 pm

kikyo98

BakuraFan

Ok, I read the who killed Winry's parents and someone said (Spoiler.): Scar killed Winry's parents in the manga. Why?! crying That's what I want to know really badly.

Actually I don't think it was (spoiler)Scar. I think it was Scar's bro. Because they only knew that he had that tattoo on the arm. And before (spoiler) Scar's bro used to have that tattoo also. How Scar has that tattoo is cuz Scar's bro gave him his arm so Scar could survive. So the arm that scar has...u no...the one with the tattoo.....that's scar's bro's arm.

Really? That's interesting... was this a manga only thing?

Posted: Fri Sep 02, 2005 8:07 pm

BakuraFan

kikyo98

BakuraFan

Ok, I read the who killed Winry's parents and someone said (Spoiler.): Scar killed Winry's parents in the manga. Why?! crying That's what I want to know really badly.

Actually I don't think it was (spoiler)Scar. I think it was Scar's bro. Because they only knew that he had that tattoo on the arm. And before (spoiler) Scar's bro used to have that tattoo also. How Scar has that tattoo is cuz Scar's bro gave him his arm so Scar could survive. So the arm that scar has...u no...the one with the tattoo.....that's scar's bro's arm.

Really? That's interesting... was this a manga only thing?

Hightlight to read:It was Scar that killed them, I read the chapeter of the manga in which it happened.Because Winry found out and took a gun and was about to shoot Scar.And Scar said somthing like "You have a reason to shoot me,but once you shoot you will become my enemy" so it was Scar.I would give the link to the site where I found it but I forgot it,but they already reached chapter 50 on it

ninjamamamama

Offline

ScarXLust_Fan

Offline

Posted: Fri Sep 02, 2005 8:35 pm

Darn... crying

Posted: Tue Sep 06, 2005 2:55 pm

foxy1413

BakuraFan

kikyo98

BakuraFan

Ok, I read the who killed Winry's parents and someone said (Spoiler.): Scar killed Winry's parents in the manga. Why?! crying That's what I want to know really badly.

Actually I don't think it was (spoiler)Scar. I think it was Scar's bro. Because they only knew that he had that tattoo on the arm. And before (spoiler) Scar's bro used to have that tattoo also. How Scar has that tattoo is cuz Scar's bro gave him his arm so Scar could survive. So the arm that scar has...u no...the one with the tattoo.....that's scar's bro's arm.

Really? That's interesting... was this a manga only thing?

Hightlight to read:It was Scar that killed them, I read the chapeter of the manga in which it happened.Because Winry found out and took a gun and was about to shoot Scar.And Scar said somthing like "You have a reason to shoot me,but once you shoot you will become my enemy" so it was Scar.I would give the link to the site where I found it but I forgot it,but they already reached chapter 50 on it

Really? In the manga it said (highlight...if u dare, dun dun dun)(anime spoiler):

They showed a flash back to were the war. Roy was orderd to kill Winry's parents because they wouldn't stop healing the 'enemy's' wounds (Winry parents were doctors)

artistic_flare

Offline

kikyo98

Offline

Posted: Sat Sep 17, 2005 11:27 am

I'll say what i did in the other topic in this forum....

foxy1413

No people! Scar's brother did not kill Winry's parents! Scar did I got hold of what chapter of the manga is it in,its chapter 46 and 47.Here is the link http://groups.msn.com/FullMetalAlchemist/fullmetalalchemistmanga.msnw and that link is very good because it goes all the way to chapter 51 3nodding

And i got a hold of that chapter too, and i still think it's Scar's bro. You know why? It's becuz i'm combining the anime and the manga together. If you had read my super long explanation to why i think it's him....then u'd see that i had some ppl saying that i make a really good point.

Spoiler:
In the manga where Ed said, "Do you remember killing the two doctor's who helped you, Scar?!!?" You see that Scar thought in his head right away, "BROTHER!!!" Why the heck would he think brother if he thinks he did it? And i'm still telling you...the ppl who said that the person who killed winry's parents said that they could only make out a tattoo on his arm, and couldn't make out the face becuz it was wrapped in bandages. So i ask you this...if you were Ed...who would u NATURALLY assume?? Scar, right? U only assume him cuz u only know that he, and he alone has a tattoo on his right arm. But little did Ed know that Scar's bro had that tattoo on his arm before Scar. Here is where i'm involving the anime. Scar's bro had the tattoo on his arm....Scar was dying....Scar's bro gave Scar his arm in order for Scar to survive. And besides...in the anime....Scar's bro was goin all crazy and stuff. And in the manga...it kinda showed that the person who killed Winry's parents obviously was NOT thinking about what he was doing...basically....he was acting crazy.

So in conclusion, I think you're being like Ed and making the assumption u see if obvious due to the tattoo.

foxy1413

No people! Scar's brother did not kill Winry's parents! Scar did I got hold of what chapter of the manga is it in,its chapter 46 and 47.Here is the link http://groups.msn.com/FullMetalAlchemist/fullmetalalchemistmanga.msnw and that link is very good because it goes all the way to chapter 51 3nodding

YOU KNOW WHAT?!?!?! I FOUND PROOF THAT IT WASN'T SCAR!!!

http://groups.msn.com/FullMetalAlchemist/chapter47.msnw?action=ShowPhoto&PhotoID=7057

Look!!! Scar's bro has the tattoo....on BOTH ARMS!!!

http://groups.msn.com/FullMetalAlchemist/chapter47.msnw?action=ShowPhoto&PhotoID=7058

Second url shows that guy with his face shadowed. You know who that is? That's the guy who almost killed Scar, makin his bro give hiim his arm in order for Scar to survive! Boo ya! I kick butt! I think i made my point and what's better is that i have

PROOF!!!

Posted: Sat Sep 17, 2005 1:48 pm

I just re-read the manga and i must admit i'm wrong. I mis-inerpreted the manga and so i believe that it was no Scar's bro now, and that it is Scar himself. I apologize to....foxy1413 for bickering over something i miss-interpreted.

kikyo98

Offline

Welcome to Gaia! ::

Gaia Guilds

The Full Metal Alchemist Official guild

Quick Reply

More Information