|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sun Jan 06, 2008 11:25 pm
I just came across this interesting article on the LA Times that I'd like to share.
http://www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/nation/la-na-menabort7jan07,0,5749127.story?coll=la-home-center
The article talks about men who are pro-life because their lover's abortion affected them so much. Okay, I can understand women and men who wonder about the unborn child, but last I checked, it takes two to make a baby. One of the guys from the article actually impregnated his girlfriend twice, yet he didn't think anything was wrong with continuous unsafe sex? Another guy, who's now a lawyer, gave money to his pregnant girlfriend for the abortion and never spoke to her again, yet he feels like he's a victim and is pro-life now?! Geez! In my opinion, those girlfriends who had the abortion would have been vilified with or without the abortion. I can just imagine those guys bitching about being tied down with the wife and kid if she didn't have the abortion. Right, because it's always the woman's fault if she's pregnant and it's always her fault if she gets an abortion. Boo hoo hoo, when will the silly woman consider the man, even though it's her life!
Unfortunately, people seem to think a grown man crying equates a good man, and I definitely can pro-lifers clinging onto these loser men who didn't think twice about the ex-lovers back then and now feel guilty when things are sunshine and rainbows now as new poster child.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Mon Jan 07, 2008 12:17 am
I have a question for the males in this guild. Setar, M something I don't want to butcher your name Blade, Kata Samones ......and my mind just went blank. gonk
Do you actually care about every single sperm. Like mourn over it when you lose some?
~~~~~~
THEN WHY IN THE ******** WOULD YOU CARE IF A SINGLE ONE SUDDENLY JOINED WITH AN OVUM? [/Trite's pissed] You don't care it it joins with spermicide AND DIES. Or if you lost ten million last night to the evil Mr. Tissue. OR how about that lost city of Atlantis you have in your undergarments?!?
Don't give me no "but it's a pwecious baby" NO. IT'S A COUPLE OF CELLS THAT YOU DIDN'T CARE ABOUT IN THE FIRST PLACE.
The last time I checked it's the woman who gets pregnant. Not guys. And if you're a guy and pregnant, well thats a tad bit creepy imo, but it is the women who have abortions.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Mon Jan 07, 2008 3:45 am
I believe they only did it for the attention, or they want to be able to control what women do with their bodies. They don't care about what the woman thinks, just the fetus inside of her.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Mon Jan 07, 2008 7:19 am
I don't know. I can understand how a man might be upset over the loss of potential. Potential doesn't matter in a debate- but it can matter in emotions.
I just know that myself and my fiance have discussed abortion, and while he agrees it's my choice, and that it is a necessity at this point, he doesn't want it to happen, either. I know it would make him upset if I did, even though he'd be strong and support me, I'd have to support him later (or earlier... if something happens that upsets both of us, we tend to take turns being the strong one. Usually I'm the strong one first, cause I tend to have a very long "in shock" period where it doesn't hurt yet).
I guess I can understand why the men are hurt... but not why it suddenly makes them pro-life... and especially not with the guys in the article. All of them, how the ******** did they end up emotionally involved? They just gave the money and left. I can see how it might hurt with a long-term partner, but damn, if you're just giving the money and leaving, how about thinking about your EX, not the fetus with your genetic material? Take care of the living before the unborn! Priorities, gentlemen, priorities. Have you ever thought about that woman who had an abortion? Who may NOT have had one if you had said "I'll be a father"? If I got pregnant after my fiance graduates and has a good job (*crosses fingers*... he graduates in June... I hope he gets a good job), I'd probably want to keep it... but, I'd talk it over with him... and if he left (which he wouldn't), I'd have an abortion, because I'm not ready to do it alone... and that would hurt more than having one now, when I acknowledge the complete lack of readiness on both of our parts.
Gah! I don't even know what I said there anymore.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Mon Jan 07, 2008 10:55 am
Hello Soma Unfortunately, people seem to think a grown man crying equates a good man, and I definitely can pro-lifers clinging onto these loser men who didn't think twice about the ex-lovers back then and now feel guilty when things are sunshine and rainbows now as new poster child. Yes, yes, and again, yes! Especially the bolded part! A certain lifer on Gaia PMed me about a comment of mine in a "men's rights in an abortion" type of topic. Something like, "Well, I hope you're happy, you made a grown man cry!" I had said that you could have another child with another woman. I don't think I was wrong, but I did think it was callous and I apologized. Because, as RoseRose said, losing potential can hurt, emotionally. I don't remember if this was the next reply after that, or after a few more replies, but he startted to go batshit on me. He was scary. He told me that when he's in an abortion debate, he has two goals: Argue against abortion and make pro-choice women look heartless and cruel. He was proud to tell me that s**t!
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Mon Jan 07, 2008 3:18 pm
Well hell, I don't like it when my boyfriend smokes. So rather than just tell him I'm concerned about his health, I'll just join the movement to ban smoking.
Maybe we should get guys involved in the same way on our side now. Let's recuit men who have to pay child support because their girlfriends kept the pregnancy even though these guys didn't want her to.
Just because someone regrets doing something doesn't mean it should be abolished. Some people regret getting married, yet the conservatives generally tell these people to stay together and make it work, because "divorce is a sin." Some people regret having sex too early, and in fact some people even argue that as a reason for raising the age of consent, or banning premarital sex altogether.
That's basically like saying that if something is worth regretting, it should be worth punishing. Do these women who regret having abortions really believe that they should have gone to jail for their actions? They should go back to when they were considering abortion, and wonder how they would have felt if they were unable to get an abortion in the first place. Would they have been angry. Would they still be angry now, knowing they were legally compelled to have the baby whether or not they wanted to? Or would they be happy, knowing the state made the right decision for them?
Really, this whole "I regret it so it should be illegal" is basically blaming someone else for something you regret doing. They regret getting abortions, so they blame the government for letting them get abortions in the first place.
I do have sympathy for women who regret making that decision, but it seems to me like some of these women aren't even taking responsibility for their decisions. Rather than say "I made a bad decision," they say "The government made a bad decision for me"
Or, in the case of these men who want abortion illegal because they regret the decisions their girlfriends made, they're blaming the government for not making the right decision for their girlfriends. Did it ever occur to you that your girlfriend was the one who decided to get the abortion? Why aren't you upset with her for the decision she made? And if you supported, encouraged, or pressured her to get an abortion, why aren't you mad at yourself?
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Mon Jan 07, 2008 3:39 pm
I think Freedom summed up my thoughts on the matter. Quite nicely.
So I'll just add: I HATE STUPID ******** LIKE THOSE GUYS.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Mon Jan 07, 2008 3:57 pm
Trite~Elegy I have a question for the males in this guild. Setar, M something I don't want to butcher your name Blade, Kata Samones ......and my mind just went blank. gonk
Do you actually care about every single sperm. Like mourn over it when you lose some?
~~~~~~
THEN WHY IN THE ******** WOULD YOU CARE IF A SINGLE ONE SUDDENLY JOINED WITH AN OVUM? [/Trite's pissed] You don't care it it joins with spermicide AND DIES. Or if you lost ten million last night to the evil Mr. Tissue. OR how about that lost city of Atlantis you have in your undergarments?!?
Don't give me no "but it's a pwecious baby" NO. IT'S A COUPLE OF CELLS THAT YOU DIDN'T CARE ABOUT IN THE FIRST PLACE.
The last time I checked it's the woman who gets pregnant. Not guys. And if you're a guy and pregnant, well thats a tad bit creepy imo, but it is the women who have abortions. Every sperm is sacred, you know! But yeah, I'd be in constant mourning if I cared about every single sperm. Seriously, what the ******** is with these guys. If anyone remembers my rant about the "sex education" my Planning 10 class got, how the CPC b***h cited a book called "Forgotten Fathers"? That made me sick. It makes me sick whenever a guy thinks he has the right to forcibly prevent someone he had sex with from aborting. Hell, it makes me sick to see a guy even b***h about it. Men have no excuse to b***h about their partner aborting. Wah wah, I had no say because it's not residing in my body. Grow the ******** up or find a partner who wants a kid. This isn't the 1950s, you do not have the right to force your partner to have a child if they don't want one. Freedom Fire Maybe we should get guys involved in the same way on our side now. Let's recuit men who have to pay child support because their girlfriends kept the pregnancy even though these guys didn't want her to. I support men being able to sign their parental rights away, and I even have a hypothetical system to prevent abuse. It requires a bit of paperwork, though. However, a woman should not be able to force a man into parenthood or child support, much like a man cannot force a woman into parenthood. Rights do not only go one way, and supporting abortion while not supporting the man being able to sign off parenthood is not feminism, as that's not gender equality. Besides, the man signing off parental rights may be a reason for the woman to reconsider her decision, which is why the time limit for the man being able to sign off his rights (if he is duly notified) should be about 16 weeks, to give the woman time to reconsider and possibly abort. How does it work? Here's how it goes: The woman gets pregnant. She notifies her partner that she is pregnant. Her partner or her simply has to go down to the nearest human services office (or whatever it's called where you live) and pick up the correct form to fill out and sign. The form must be returned before the woman is 16 weeks pregnant. If the father is not notified until after 16 weeks for whatever reason, he has 60 days after notification to sign off his rights. If the woman gives birth and the father is located, he will be exempt from child support payments if he decides to sign off, however, once again, he has 60 days to sign off after he is notified. The reason for exemption is to prevent abuse - the woman can't hold off on paternity for a few years then notify the man for back payments if he wants to sign off. Any disputes should be settled in family court, where lying on the form would be punishable by a charge of perjury, such as if the woman lied about the gestational age in order to attempt to nullify the form or give the father insufficient time to read the form, make his decision, fill out the form and return it to the government office. However, signing off parental rights will not just be exemption of child support. It will carry the same restrictions that relinquishing custody would. If necessary, the woman may also seek a restraining order. Convicted rapists will not be allowed to sign their rights off as part of their sentence. If the woman aborts, the rapist should pay the full cost of the abortion as part of his sentence. If the woman decides to have the child, the rapist should have custody and visitation revoked under a restraining order against him (which should be mandatory on all rape cases after release), however, as part of his sentence, he should be responsible to pay child support payments in full if and when he is able to after his release.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Mon Jan 07, 2008 4:32 pm
We all regret a lot of things in our life. The lawyer got me the most.Quote: Every now and then, though, Aubert wonders: What if his first girlfriend had not aborted? How would his life look different? Okay, thats great. But why don't you wonder what it would have been like if he had put softball second. He put his own priorities first and walked away. He doesn't really have any right to be having these thoughts, especially about what if his girlfriend hadn't aborted. His thoughts should be "What if I hadn't put softball first? What if I hadn't just stuck a check in her door? What if I had actually taken responsibility for the results of my actions?" I'm sure the article is designed to somehow generate sympathy for the mens cause but it does a poor job. In a way it tries to paint the men as helpless victims while the women are these horrible monsters that didn't have the opportunity to just write a check and walk away.
I wish they would tell all the stories about the women that did not have abortions for their partners who are then left to handle raising their children on their own because the man ran. Always a problem with this debate. If the pro-lifers want to show the real results of not having an abortion they need to focus on all aspects, not just those tearful "What ifs" and more of the tearful "What did happen"
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Mon Jan 07, 2008 4:42 pm
I can see it from their point of view about not being part of the decision process, however I also see an equal amount of males who complain about their girlfriend/fiance/FWB that got pregnant, ran off because she was pregnant and then complained about her getting an abortion. I just see this article as a way to get attention, not to bring attention to the other involved parties' decisions.
OP- you're right, these men WOULD be complaining about tied down and probably physically and/or psychologically harming the child they did not plan to procreate and the mother also.
And our sex ed classes actually taught girls that it was their fault they got pregnant. If I ever dig out the booklet we got in 5th grade sex-ed, I will scan it (we're moving right now and going through alot of boxes that are in the old house so we might find it)
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Mon Jan 07, 2008 4:53 pm
Malee We all regret a lot of things in our life. The lawyer got me the most.Quote: Every now and then, though, Aubert wonders: What if his first girlfriend had not aborted? How would his life look different? Okay, thats great. But why don't you wonder what it would have been like if he had put softball second. He put his own priorities first and walked away. He doesn't really have any right to be having these thoughts, especially about what if his girlfriend hadn't aborted. His thoughts should be "What if I hadn't put softball first? What if I hadn't just stuck a check in her door? What if I had actually taken responsibility for the results of my actions?" I'm sure the article is designed to somehow generate sympathy for the mens cause but it does a poor job. In a way it tries to paint the men as helpless victims while the women are these horrible monsters that didn't have the opportunity to just write a check and walk away.
I wish they would tell all the stories about the women that did not have abortions for their partners who are then left to handle raising their children on their own because the man ran. Always a problem with this debate. If the pro-lifers want to show the real results of not having an abortion they need to focus on all aspects, not just those tearful "What ifs" and more of the tearful "What did happen" Sadly, militant pro-life and far-right tends to encompass the higher-income bracket, giving them more power to voice their side effectively due to their financial resources.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Mon Jan 07, 2008 10:55 pm
Lord Setar Sadly, militant pro-life and far-right tends to encompass the higher-income bracket, giving them more power to voice their side effectively due to their financial resources. Oh of that I have no doubt. I just hope that the readers won't take from this story that all men grow up to be religious figures (and lawyers) that all regret their girlfriends decisions. Some just don't give a ******** and while the militant pro-life and far-right wingers don't show that, I would hope the media would.
Although I'm not under the allusion that it will ever happen.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Tue Jan 08, 2008 12:13 pm
Freedom Fire That's basically like saying that if something is worth regretting, it should be worth punishing. "Punishing? Why, heavens no! We're not punishing women, we're protecting them. It's a wonderfully positive and feminist thing to do, protecting women from making bad decisions. And everyone knows that if abortion were illegal, no one would do it!" Quote: Do these women who regret having abortions really believe that they should have gone to jail for their actions? "Oh no no no no no! Putting women in jail? We'd never stand for that. We'd jail those nasty doctors, sweetie." (That aside, that is a ******** brilliant question to ask them, Freedom Fire!) Quote: Really, this whole "I regret it so it should be illegal" is basically blaming someone else for something you regret doing. They regret getting abortions, so they blame the government for letting them get abortions in the first place. Exactly! I want to tell these women that, but you really can't, unfortunately. It looks cruel to tell them that they're just blaming others for things they regret, but they really are. Quote: I do have sympathy for women who regret making that decision, but it seems to me like some of these women aren't even taking responsibility for their decisions. Rather than say "I made a bad decision," they say "The government made a bad decision for me" They'd say "No, I made a bad decision and the government just let me. I want to protect other women from making the same bad decision." But as cruel and callous as it sounds to say this...they really are trying to escape responsibility for an action they regret.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Tue Jan 08, 2008 1:30 pm
Things that people regret: Marriage Children Drinking Smoking An extra dessert Eating greasy foods Renting an expensive house Buying an expensive house Getting in a girlfriend/boyfriend Telling someone off Quitting their job Moving Watching bad movies Taking a specific course in school Sex Looks like all these things need to be made illegal. After all, people regret it.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Tue Jan 08, 2008 6:03 pm
At least Mr. Genius Catholic Lawyer admits that LOL NEVER THOT ABOUT THE WIMMINZ BEFORE. Look dude, just because you get all sniffly about your girlfriends getting abortions doesn't mean they regret it, or that they carry "scars." I think about my abortion all the time; I'm not SCARRED. It's something that happened in my past and I came to terms with it. I don't regret it, The End.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|