Welcome to Gaia! ::

Band Nerd Guild

Back to Guilds

The coolest most awesome most BAND NERDIEST place EVER! 

Tags: band, nerd, music 

Reply Marching Discussion
The Cavelier Drum and Bugle Core Goto Page: 1 2 [>] [»|]

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Should girls be allowed in the cavies?
  Yes
  No
View Results

Melphina Micaela

PostPosted: Thu Dec 20, 2007 11:36 pm


OMG...The Cavies... 4laugh They SO rock! I wish I was allowed to join... (I'm a girl and I play Clarinet). They should make a female version of the Caveliers... It's only fair. What do u think?  
PostPosted: Mon Dec 24, 2007 6:25 am


Cavies rock! That's all I can say. I have seen them 6 times(Top seats) and every time I have been dazzled! But, Santa Clara and Phantom rock too.

Serephim Eternia


Melphina Micaela

Liberal Informer

7,000 Points
  • Statustician 100
  • Consumer 100
  • Hygienic 200
PostPosted: Mon Dec 24, 2007 3:55 pm


Blue Devils as well but I must say that the cavies are the best! (in my opinion)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lT_S1estF5E

That is hilarious (^)
PostPosted: Sat Dec 29, 2007 12:09 pm


They should allow girls in. It's not fair. If you're good enough, you should be allowed in.
Omg, the guard instructor/drill coordinator from last year used to be in the caveliers. He was evil Nazi person. i hated him with a passion.

TLO666


Kakarie

PostPosted: Sun Dec 30, 2007 11:27 am


omg.
cavies = freaking amazing.

i loved their show "machine."
PostPosted: Sun Dec 30, 2007 7:02 pm


If they let girls in, it would make it that much less cool. D:

They're 1 of 2, and if they changed that, they just wouldn't be the Cavaliers anymore.

Besides that, they originated from a Boyscout troop, and as far as I know, people from Illinois are pretty adamant about their roots.

Prosthesy


Ralps

PostPosted: Sun Dec 30, 2007 7:03 pm


I think their should be a seperate female band that pwns.

The caviliers have a tradition of being all male and they want to keep that
PostPosted: Sun Dec 30, 2007 7:26 pm


Not to sound like a sexist, but have you ever heard of a female soloist in the I & E competitions making it to the finals on something besides melodics? An all-female Corps wouldn't really have too great of a chance at being somewhere near the top.

Prosthesy


Blckpanthr13

PostPosted: Sun Dec 30, 2007 11:38 pm


I marched corps last summer.
I loved it beyond words.
And I plan to do it until I age out.
But knowing that I will never have to opportunity to be a member of one of the world's top corps, means that I don't have an equal opportunity to be a world champion as a male.
I know of the tradition that they uphold to, but since it is a boyscout troop and the boyscouts are a nationanationally recognized as a christian organization, they are usually erected by a church.
In the case of the Cavaliers, the city of Park Ridge Illinois sponsored the establishment of this corps.

And according to records, Park Ridge was a Christian society run by the church in 1948 when the corps was established.


So, why do they not discriminate against sexual orientation as well as gender?
To me, this is completely appalling.
Does this mean, to be a member of the Cavaliers, I would have to be a get a sex change?
I happen to very much dislike the Cavaliers and their organization.
I think if they allow males who aren't boyscouts, religious, and don't discriminate against sexual orientation, then they should allow females into the corps as well.


They can't say that they uphold to their traditions if, in actuality, they only uphold to part of tradition. Otherwise, they are just being selective.
PostPosted: Wed Jan 02, 2008 2:11 pm


The Caveliers are freaking awesome!!!! I wish they would allow girls to join, though. We had a guy come in to help our marching band from the Caveliers! He was really cool, he played baritone and trombone!

flamingearthadept


TLO666

PostPosted: Sat Jan 05, 2008 3:52 pm


Blckpanthr13
I marched corps last summer.
I loved it beyond words.
And I plan to do it until I age out.
But knowing that I will never have to opportunity to be a member of one of the world's top corps, means that I don't have an equal opportunity to be a world champion as a male.
I know of the tradition that they uphold to, but since it is a boyscout troop and the boyscouts are a nationanationally recognized as a christian organization, they are usually erected by a church.
In the case of the Cavaliers, the city of Park Ridge Illinois sponsored the establishment of this corps.

And according to records, Park Ridge was a Christian society run by the church in 1948 when the corps was established.


So, why do they not discriminate against sexual orientation as well as gender?
To me, this is completely appalling.
Does this mean, to be a member of the Cavaliers, I would have to be a get a sex change?
I happen to very much dislike the Cavaliers and their organization.
I think if they allow males who aren't boyscouts, religious, and don't discriminate against sexual orientation, then they should allow females into the corps as well.


They can't say that they uphold to their traditions if, in actuality, they only uphold to part of tradition. Otherwise, they are just being selective.


I totally agree. Also, Prosthesy does sound sexist, especially with the line
"If they let girls in, it would make it that much less cool. D: " I mean, if they are only going to have males in, they need an equal female group. And that tradition thing is crap if they only stick to parts of it.
PostPosted: Sat Jan 05, 2008 5:53 pm


TLO666
Blckpanthr13
I marched corps last summer.
I loved it beyond words.
And I plan to do it until I age out.
But knowing that I will never have to opportunity to be a member of one of the world's top corps, means that I don't have an equal opportunity to be a world champion as a male.
I know of the tradition that they uphold to, but since it is a boyscout troop and the boyscouts are a nationanationally recognized as a christian organization, they are usually erected by a church.
In the case of the Cavaliers, the city of Park Ridge Illinois sponsored the establishment of this corps.

And according to records, Park Ridge was a Christian society run by the church in 1948 when the corps was established.


So, why do they not discriminate against sexual orientation as well as gender?
To me, this is completely appalling.
Does this mean, to be a member of the Cavaliers, I would have to be a get a sex change?
I happen to very much dislike the Cavaliers and their organization.
I think if they allow males who aren't boyscouts, religious, and don't discriminate against sexual orientation, then they should allow females into the corps as well.


They can't say that they uphold to their traditions if, in actuality, they only uphold to part of tradition. Otherwise, they are just being selective.


I totally agree. Also, Prosthesy does sound sexist, especially with the line
"If they let girls in, it would make it that much less cool. D: " I mean, if they are only going to have males in, they need an equal female group. And that tradition thing is crap if they only stick to parts of it.

The problem with the creation of a female group would be the same problem that is with all feeder corps like Blue Devils B and C for example. Do these corps prepare you, have similar standards, goals and staff as the Division 1 Blue Devils corps? Not usually.

The female group of Cavaliers might be looked upon at the same level as a feeder corps might be.

Blckpanthr13


Rogers77

PostPosted: Sun Jan 06, 2008 6:15 pm


Cavies march weird. Like their battery, the way they crab. When they crab, their feet are sideways and heels down. That puts all the strain in think on your hips I think. But, yeah, they're cool. Didn't understand their show in 2007, but 2004 rocked.
PostPosted: Fri Jan 11, 2008 7:33 pm


TLO666
Blckpanthr13
I marched corps last summer.
I loved it beyond words.
And I plan to do it until I age out.
But knowing that I will never have to opportunity to be a member of one of the world's top corps, means that I don't have an equal opportunity to be a world champion as a male.
I know of the tradition that they uphold to, but since it is a boyscout troop and the boyscouts are a nationanationally recognized as a christian organization, they are usually erected by a church.
In the case of the Cavaliers, the city of Park Ridge Illinois sponsored the establishment of this corps.

And according to records, Park Ridge was a Christian society run by the church in 1948 when the corps was established.


So, why do they not discriminate against sexual orientation as well as gender?
To me, this is completely appalling.
Does this mean, to be a member of the Cavaliers, I would have to be a get a sex change?
I happen to very much dislike the Cavaliers and their organization.
I think if they allow males who aren't boyscouts, religious, and don't discriminate against sexual orientation, then they should allow females into the corps as well.


They can't say that they uphold to their traditions if, in actuality, they only uphold to part of tradition. Otherwise, they are just being selective.


I totally agree. Also, Prosthesy does sound sexist, especially with the line
"If they let girls in, it would make it that much less cool. D: " I mean, if they are only going to have males in, they need an equal female group. And that tradition thing is crap if they only stick to parts of it.


I hate to say it, but life's not fair. It's a private organization that isn't forced to accept girls into their ranks. They can choose to be as selective (or not selective) as they want. Perhaps one day they'll start only accepting members of a certain height range.

I personally think it's all male simply for uniformity's sake. In case you haven't noticed, your body is different from that of a guy. Even in a uniform, hips and breasts stick out to some degree.

Bottom line: they don't care what you think.

Ryalla


Blue Night Rhapsody

PostPosted: Sat Jan 12, 2008 5:44 am


While the Cavaliers are a very good corps, not being in the Cavaliers doesn't mean that your chances of winning are lower. The Blue Devils have more championships (is it 11 or 12 now?). Since the Cavaliers are currently the only "top tier" all male corps (hopefully the Madison Scouts can make a comeback), there are at least 5 other corps in the top 6 (an extremely elite group, especially in the last several years) that allow females.

Bottom line: If they get enough talented males to audition (which won't be a problem anywhere in the near future), they don't need to allow females. They currently have no affiliation with a church or Boy Scout troop, and so have dropped some membership requirements which those affiliations would entail. However, they choose to keep the all-male requirement.

Here's their explanation: (from www.cavaliers.org)

"It's not that The Cavaliers think men can do it better, or that women couldn't hack it, it's that they want to rejoice in the brotherhood that can only be felt by working, sweating, and bleeding with other men. It's a special type of bond. There are a lot of excellent corps out there that accept women; The Cavaliers do not.

Is The Cavaliers being all-male what makes them great? No, it's part of what makes them The Cavaliers."

As for the question of why they don't discriminate on sexual orientation, the administration of the corps has a (as stated on their website) "don't ask, don't tell" policy.
Reply
Marching Discussion

Goto Page: 1 2 [>] [»|]
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum