Welcome to Gaia! ::

Reply The RENT Guild
Something I realized that doesn't make sense.... Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Juria-San

PostPosted: Sun Mar 11, 2007 10:01 am


discoshorty2005
Aerine Lillet
I wonder when Benny and Mimi were together. Didn't she say it was two years ago? Wouldnt that have made mimi 17? Wow.

eek I never thought of that. Ew! Benny is wierd.
Yeah, that always got at me, too... But in La Vie Boheme in the theatre version, didn't it go... Um, how did it go, I think it was...
Benny: Your new boyfriend doesn't know about us!
Mimi: There's nothing to know...
Benny: Don't you think that we should discuss...?
Mimi: It was three months ago...

That makes it a bit less disgusting, methinks... But the movie played with it, I guess.

And um... Doesn't that mean Mimi would've given Mr. Landlord AIDS? Benny's supposed to be one of the half that doesn't have it... And sure it's never stated one way or the other, but I'm just sayin'. I think maybe Jonathon Larson wanted to puzzle us, even before the movie came out, to wonder if they were really together or not; I mean, Angel could've just lied to Muffy about Benny sleeping with Mimi to get him out of the picture. x3

It kind'a seems like Benny disappeared after the funeral scene in the movie... I mean, he's MENTIONED in the end in the theatre, but in the movie it's just like poof! Bye Benny. Unless you watch deleted scenes.

And to make this post even longer, I find it kind of funny how they even Benny out in the theatre and movie. In the theatre, he obviously states that he'll pay for Angel's funeral, and that gets him points in anyone's book, no? And that he'll pay for Mimi's rehab. It's not that obvious in the movie, it's not clearly stated unless you watch the deleted scenes. But in the movie, I always loved how in Without You, there was that part where Mimi was it looked like at the Cat Scratch, and Benny's visiting her, and she's just holding onto his arm looking like she's gonna cry. I dunno, that just looked like a... Best friend moment, if you will, how he was there for her.
But in the play, he pays for the funeral and Mimi, but it doesn't have that sentimental crap where he's comforting Mimi, and at the end it makes him out to be a cheating lapdog, the whole "Alison found out about Mimi" thing. See, it evens it out.

Nice.
PostPosted: Sun Apr 08, 2007 6:55 pm


laFred
Yeah, the difference from the movie and the play is that in the movie, Mimi and Benny were once together, but now their relationship is simply platonic.

And my guess as well would be that no matter how the group feels about that relationship, they probably wouldn't go out of there way to let Alison know what her husband is doing.

I think i figured it out. it's funny that this forum is here, because i was thinking about it a lot earlier. In finale A, Mark and Roger talk about how the film is in honor of Alison, pulling benny out of the westside village location. "i wonder how alison found out about mimi" "maybe a little bird told her" Collins: "or an angel". So she finds out somehow or other, at the end of the play, and i listened to the soundtrack every day for a year and a half and never thought about it. anyway i think that's it. Benny didn't really care if the main characters knew as long as he could use the info to make roger's life hell. In my opinion, he secretly wants to be in the group, but he got himself hooked on money, and now he can't go back because maureen makes such a formitable enemy...

Thundersmurf


Thundersmurf

PostPosted: Sun Apr 08, 2007 7:01 pm


Juria-San
discoshorty2005
Aerine Lillet
I wonder when Benny and Mimi were together. Didn't she say it was two years ago? Wouldnt that have made mimi 17? Wow.

eek I never thought of that. Ew! Benny is wierd.
Yeah, that always got at me, too... But in La Vie Boheme in the theatre version, didn't it go... Um, how did it go, I think it was...
Benny: Your new boyfriend doesn't know about us!
Mimi: There's nothing to know...
Benny: Don't you think that we should discuss...?
Mimi: It was three months ago...

That makes it a bit less disgusting, methinks... But the movie played with it, I guess.

And um... Doesn't that mean Mimi would've given Mr. Landlord AIDS? Benny's supposed to be one of the half that doesn't have it... And sure it's never stated one way or the other, but I'm just sayin'. I think maybe Jonathon Larson wanted to puzzle us, even before the movie came out, to wonder if they were really together or not; I mean, Angel could've just lied to Muffy about Benny sleeping with Mimi to get him out of the picture. x3

It kind'a seems like Benny disappeared after the funeral scene in the movie... I mean, he's MENTIONED in the end in the theatre, but in the movie it's just like poof! Bye Benny. Unless you watch deleted scenes.

And to make this post even longer, I find it kind of funny how they even Benny out in the theatre and movie. In the theatre, he obviously states that he'll pay for Angel's funeral, and that gets him points in anyone's book, no? And that he'll pay for Mimi's rehab. It's not that obvious in the movie, it's not clearly stated unless you watch the deleted scenes. But in the movie, I always loved how in Without You, there was that part where Mimi was it looked like at the Cat Scratch, and Benny's visiting her, and she's just holding onto his arm looking like she's gonna cry. I dunno, that just looked like a... Best friend moment, if you will, how he was there for her.
But in the play, he pays for the funeral and Mimi, but it doesn't have that sentimental crap where he's comforting Mimi, and at the end it makes him out to be a cheating lapdog, the whole "Alison found out about Mimi" thing. See, it evens it out.

Nice.

Yeah, i'd say mimi and benny were definately sleeping together. They probably used protection. You'd think mimi would have learned to be safe in more aspects of her life by now.
(you're seeing wicked???YAY!!!have fun)
Reply
The RENT Guild

Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum