When in Rome, do as the Romans do
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
Sounds like some Judges got their panties in a bunch with jealousy over the fact that GaGa comes up with awesome lyrical concoctions. No clue about Randy, as I know little abut him, but Jello ain't no spring chicken, and I don't think she comes up with her own stuff. Plus, she's been pretty trashy over the years, she use to change hubbies more than her underwear. Funny thing, though, how a musical GOD like Steven Tyler pretty much negated their shallow boo's.
I personally thought Haley tore that song apart(in a good way). Then again, I have found her singing to be of an amazing quality, her sound kinda reminds me of Adele or Amy Winehouse.
And this is sadly, why GaGa doesn't put her "rock ballads" like Speechless or You and I, out as singles; because they aren't "the right stuff" for a hit according to mainstream America(AKA the critics and people like Randy and Jello)