Welcome to Gaia! ::

Band Nerd Guild

Back to Guilds

The coolest most awesome most BAND NERDIEST place EVER! 

Tags: band, nerd, music 

Reply Woodwinds/Brass
Brass VS. Woodwinds Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Which is better?
  Brass
  Woodwinds
  WTF!!! where percussion?
View Results

Merriara

5,650 Points
  • Consumer 100
  • Signature Look 250
  • Gaian 50
PostPosted: Sat Jun 14, 2008 7:56 pm


Woodwind, because I play oboe! ^__^
PostPosted: Thu Jun 26, 2008 3:02 pm


woodwinds!!!!
me and my friends are all woodwinds!!!
defentiltey clarinet and flute!!!!! ^^


sweetkittycupcake


Cluttered Witch


Wendy Wicked

PostPosted: Thu Jun 26, 2008 3:52 pm


I have yet to find a band with in tune woodwinds

therefore
I say brass
and it's not only because I play trumpet

But you can have a band without woodwinds

I mean look at corps. bands; they just have the different bells play the woodwind parts
PostPosted: Sun Jun 29, 2008 9:27 pm


Woodwinds all the way
heart

angelsfury666


SaoirseSephtis

Eternal Hunter

7,000 Points
  • Citizen 200
  • Guildmember 100
  • Tycoon 200
PostPosted: Fri Jul 04, 2008 9:41 am


elvnflame
This is such a dangerous thread. I say "Kick a** Brass!" The melody is always given to the trumpets or trombones because you can hear us, unlike woodwinds. You can have an army of flutes, and they'll still be drowned out by 5 trumpets
razz

thats not true my sister and I are the only flute player and we out play all five of our trumpets. so ww are the best.
PostPosted: Fri Jul 04, 2008 5:15 pm


They are equal, brass has the ability to play greater dynamics and has a large array of instuments while overall woodwinds have a more sultry lovely sound to them

I_am_poof


Giselle LeFlour

PostPosted: Sat Jul 05, 2008 8:41 pm


GuardianDragonsSpirit
1. You can actually HEAR us in marching band
2. We don't make people's eardrums explode because we are playing high screechy notes like the piccolos do!
3. We don't squeak
4. LOW BRASS KICKS a**!!!
5. We're stronger, since we have to actually hold our horns up in marching band (note: this comment is not aimed at flutes, since your shoulders look like they're about to be ripped off during flat circle drills)
6. Only bad players sound like crap. The good ones (including myself) sound really good.
7. There is nothing more awesome than a kikckin jazz trumpet solo
8. We actually have spines, unlike the clarinets that complain that they can't hold their instruments up while marching
9. We don't have wussy little neckstraps
10. Our instruments are shinier
11. We don't have to completely re-tune every time we take our instrument out
12. You can actually hear us when we speak, since brass people tend to speak louder than woodwinds
13. You cheat and try to steal the french horns/mellophones
14. You're thieves and try to steal the french horns/mellophones
15. Trumpet players are the best kissers (sorry had to add this XD)
16. *joke* Wait, scratch that; french horns are the best kissers (but they sure do hold you funny XD)
17. We have a sense of humor
18. We can keep time
19. No dippy "deed-dle-lad-dle"s for us
20. Though woodwinds were the first wind instruments, brass were the first to be truly "perfected".
21. We can play in the rain without destroying our instruments
22. Brass is just awesome


2. Mmm, I have to disagree. Trumpets may not play high very often, but when they do (and they're not good) it sounds like a small animal may be being tortured. And I think the pic sounds cool. (I play sax, so I'm not biased on the whole pic thing.)
3. Actually a good point, but sometimes squeeking can add to the music. Some jazz saxes do intentional squeeks.
4. Another good point. Nothing can beat lows. Which includes woodwinds.
5. I'd like to see you march with a tenor sax for a while. See how your right arm feels then.
6. Um, same for woodwinds.
7. Sax solos are just as good. And a good piano solo.
8. You can't base the entire woodwind section on clarinets. I'll admit, they're pretty lame at my school, too.
9. Again, tenor sax. And bari. Those things are HEAVY.
10. That is... I don't know how you came up with that.
11. At least we're in tune all the time, then.
17. Moot point. I know TONS of woodwind players that are way funnier than brass players.
20. Whatever. Our imperfection is what makes us better, because we can control our instruments to make them perfect.
21. So can we. I think the only section that has to worry about that is the percussion section.

I'm going for woodwinds. So much more potential.
PostPosted: Sun Jul 06, 2008 9:43 pm


OhEmGeeGhost
Which is better Brass or Woodwinds?

I think Brass is better because i play brass(the french horn) 3nodding

Neither the less BRASS IS BETTER mrgreen

(lol sorry Woodwinds) ninja

Post your reason

awsome my friend plays the french horn

magnum-pi G


magnum-pi G

PostPosted: Sun Jul 06, 2008 9:46 pm


MinorHeaven
Woodwinds are better (and I consider French horn a woodwind instrument because it sounds nice)...Brass is disgusting. Trumpets are too loud and everyone who plays them are stupid and can't play his instrument properly; trombones are arrogant freaks and their instruments are creepy; baritones...er...well...I can't say anything negative about them, but still, bass clarinet is better! And the tuba...is just laughable.

hey i play the trumpet and ur right unlike me everyone else in my section is to loud for the band and my teacher is always telling them to quiet down...as for me for some resone i never play very loud
PostPosted: Mon Jul 07, 2008 9:53 am


Bella_Angelo
elvnflame
This is such a dangerous thread. I say "Kick a** Brass!" The melody is always given to the trumpets or trombones because you can hear us, unlike woodwinds. You can have an army of flutes, and they'll still be drowned out by 5 trumpets
razz

thats not true my sister and I are the only flute player and we out play all five of our trumpets. so ww are the best.


yeah, well trumpets are arrogant instruments who think that they are better than everyone else. They think that they can play the loudest because they think they are the best. Plus, they don't know how to play piano. Woodwinds are just more humble and actually read the dynamics!!

tweety15cool


Immortal Intoxication

PostPosted: Wed Jul 09, 2008 6:34 am


lawlz, well as an oboe player i pretty much go with woodwinds by default :]

HOWEVER, i can agree that when it does come to like marching band, woodwinds aren't as valuable as the brass are.

but think about it, woodwinds are MUCH harder to play than brass instruments. i mean you have to fidle around for hours on end to get the right sound sometimes! <--and it never helps when your reed is acting up.
i have to have mad respect for anyone that can play the oboe or bassoon properly, double reeds for one thing, and its really really hard to play either.
ALSO, who doesn't love the gentle sounds of windwinds for concert bands?


mhmmm, so woodwinds > brass.

sorry kids :]
Reply
Woodwinds/Brass

Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum