|
|
Why then? |
Exsample? |
|
20% |
[ 4 ] |
I have a different idea... |
|
50% |
[ 10 ] |
I dont know but it is a good question |
|
30% |
[ 6 ] |
|
Total Votes : 20 |
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Fri Aug 24, 2007 7:29 pm
Goldenlici Jesus fullfills all of the prophecies set forth in the old testament and there is proof that the old testament existed before Jesus. Remember when I quoted the verse about how you will know people by the fruits they produce. I look at the lives of the people I know as true Christians and see the "fruit" they produce. That is how I know, because of the actions producedd by them. I have experienced the things the Lord has done in my own life: the little miracles, the little lessons. I can't tell you exactly why I believe because it is something I just know. There is a lot of stuff about the person Jesus that proves He existed and proves He at least fullfills some of the prophecies in the old testament, if not all. I'm not saying Jesus didn't exist. I'm not even saying he wasn't the messiah. I'm asking you whether if another prophet or messenger of God came to change the rules again, how would you know that they were a real prophet? Would you honestly take them seriously if they told you that God had changed the rules again and that they were here to spread the word? Quote: Do you have any proof that shows that Jesus wasn't a messiah? Argumentum ad ignorantiam, again. You really need to stop doing that. Quote: The unforgivable sin is believing the Holy Spirit doesn't exist, who is to say that you will not believe in God some day. If you die still not believing, yes, you never believed and that would be the ultimate sin. But, it is yet to be proven that you will never believe. I believed in God until I was 13. Am I good on that one, then? Quote: Quote: Tell me, if you were in charge of the judicial system, would you put mass murderers in charge of the jail and then send everyone there, rather than separate petty criminals and the real criminals? Oh, and lock them up in there forever? That's essentially what God's doing. If there was no way out of the prison, no way for anyone to escape at all, maybe I would. Why send good people to hell to watch the sinners? A lot of guards are harmed by prisoners all the time. You may say there is a difference in the level of sinners, but there isn't. Little sins lead to bigger sins. I disagree. I don't think a guy who didn't pay his taxes because he would rather feed his children should be locked up in a prison run by a serial killer.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Fri Aug 24, 2007 9:17 pm
Quote: I'm not saying Jesus didn't exist. I'm not even saying he wasn't the messiah. I'm asking you whether if another prophet or messenger of God came to change the rules again, how would you know that they were a real prophet? Would you honestly take them seriously if they told you that God had changed the rules again and that they were here to spread the word? I would know Jesus when He comes again because the Bible tells us exactly what is going to happen and what He will look like and what He will do. Revelations is pretty specific. Also, throughout the new testament, Jesus says that there will be many people who will claim to be Him and tells us ways to recognize imposters. Quote: Argumentum ad ignorantiam, again. You really need to stop doing that. Why? Not being able to prove something is a logical argument in this instance only because I gave the counter argument. I gave some proof for my argument, I am merely asking you to give some proof for the opposite argument. You use argumentum ad ignorantiam frequently. In your other topic "why doesn't Jesus appear," you say that you don't believe God because He doesn't prove himself. Thus by argumentum ad ignorantiam, God must not exist because there is no proof. Quote: I believed in God until I was 13. Am I good on that one, then? Why did you believe? Because your parents told you to? Because you had a friend who showed you it? Because it made sense as a child? Why did you stop believing? It would be better to know more about you, so I could better understand where you are coming from. I don't want a life story and I won't ask you for anything that would compromise your safety, i.e. name, location, address, etc. Me: I have been a Christian all my life. My parents are Christian and I was raised in the church. I even attended a small (16 people total, who were in anywhere from kindergarden to 12th grade) private Christian elementary school. I did eventually come to a point in my life where I could no longer remain a christian simply because that was how I was raised. At that point in my life, I went really indepth into the study of Christianity, so I could decide whether or not I really believed it because I thought it was right or because my parents thought it was righ. In the end, I decided for myself to believe, but that is just me. Quote: I disagree. I don't think a guy who didn't pay his taxes because he would rather feed his children should be locked up in a prison run by a serial killer. See, there is a difference between hell and prison, no matter the similarities and the convenience of the analogy. The serial killers aren't going to be any more powerful than the people who simply did not believe in God. They are all going to experience the same thing. In God's eyes, all sin is equal because all sin creates damage. Even the little things cause a lot of problems that we can't see. Also, as I said, the only sins we are going to be accountable for are the actions we know are wrong, but do anyway. That is a big sin in itself, the sin of pride and defiance.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Fri Aug 24, 2007 10:45 pm
Goldenlici Quote: I'm not saying Jesus didn't exist. I'm not even saying he wasn't the messiah. I'm asking you whether if another prophet or messenger of God came to change the rules again, how would you know that they were a real prophet? Would you honestly take them seriously if they told you that God had changed the rules again and that they were here to spread the word? I would know Jesus when He comes again because the Bible tells us exactly what is going to happen and what He will look like and what He will do. Revelations is pretty specific. Also, throughout the new testament, Jesus says that there will be many people who will claim to be Him and tells us ways to recognize imposters. A lot of other things in the Bible are rather specific, but when asked about them many Christians call them metaphors. How do you know the really weird-looking creature descibed in Revelations isn't a metaphor? Quote: Quote: Argumentum ad ignorantiam, again. You really need to stop doing that. Why? It's a logical fallacy. Quote: Not being able to prove something is a logical argument in this instance only because I gave the counter argument. I gave some proof for my argument, I am merely asking you to give some proof for the opposite argument. I saw absolutely no evidence but your own word that Jesus fit the Old Testament's prophecies. Quote: You use argumentum ad ignorantiam frequently. In your other topic "why doesn't Jesus appear," you say that you don't believe God because He doesn't prove himself. Thus by argumentum ad ignorantiam, God must not exist because there is no proof. First of all: That's not the only reason I don't believe in God. My point there is that if God proved himself to me, all of my other reasons would go out the window. Second of all, and for somewhere around the 200th time: I do not consider the fact that God does not exist an absolute truth. Quote: Quote: I believed in God until I was 13. Am I good on that one, then? Why did you believe? No idea, really. I just sort of took it for granted. I didn't think about it much, I just sort of assumed that He existed. Quote: Because your parents told you to? Hardly. lol I think we went to Church as a family a total of once in my entire childhood. Any other time I went to Church was to either go with a friend or to go with my grandma for Christmas Mass. I recently began to go with a friend of mine who's agnostic. Quote: Because you had a friend who showed you it? I suppose my (other Christian) friend might have had a part in it, but we never really talked about it much. I went to his Church twice. Quote: Because it made sense as a child? I'm guessing that was it. Quote: Why did you stop believing? It would be better to know more about you, so I could better understand where you are coming from. I don't want a life story and I won't ask you for anything that would compromise your safety, i.e. name, location, address, etc. It started in the beginning of my 8th grade year at an old nun convent in Guatemala, in which I realised that locking up a bunch of women in a dirty compound was a rather silly way to show your devotion to God. During my 8th grade year I travelled Central and South America, New Zealand, Australia, Malaysia, and Rome. Rome was where I officially became atheist. Come to think of it I was 14. It's sort of ironic, really, since I realised I was atheist in Vatican City right after visiting the Vatican Museum to see all of the gold that had been stolen from the Inca temples I had visited earlier that year. On the way back to our hotel we passed an atheist rally. I didn't talk to any of them. I didn't even understand any of them (I don't speak Italian very well), but it made me consider my own beliefs and realise that I really didn't take the idea of God very seriously. When I got home I set out to learn as much as I could about any religion I heard about. I'm still going at it today, and I vary on my level of belief in each philosophy. For instance: I'm agnostic to Hinduism. Quote: Me: I have been a Christian all my life. My parents are Christian and I was raised in the church. I even attended a small (16 people total, who were in anywhere from kindergarden to 12th grade) private Christian elementary school. I did eventually come to a point in my life where I could no longer remain a christian simply because that was how I was raised. At that point in my life, I went really indepth into the study of Christianity, so I could decide whether or not I really believed it because I thought it was right or because my parents thought it was righ. In the end, I decided for myself to believe, but that is just me. Did you look into any other religions, out of curiosity? Quote: Quote: I disagree. I don't think a guy who didn't pay his taxes because he would rather feed his children should be locked up in a prison run by a serial killer. See, there is a difference between hell and prison, no matter the similarities and the convenience of the analogy. The serial killers aren't going to be any more powerful than the people who simply did not believe in God. They are all going to experience the same thing. In God's eyes, all sin is equal because all sin creates damage. Even the little things cause a lot of problems that we can't see. Also, as I said, the only sins we are going to be accountable for are the actions we know are wrong, but do anyway. That is a big sin in itself, the sin of pride and defiance. By "serial killers" I was sort of referring to Satan and his angels. They sinned, too, and they even knew that God existed. Why do they get the power?
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sat Aug 25, 2007 10:23 am
Quote: How do you know the really weird-looking creature descibed in Revelations isn't a metaphor? I don't believe Revelations is a metaphor. Christians who do say that are probably the same people who say you don't have to follow the Bible word for word. I believe the Bible is clear enough that you can understand everything you need to from the words. They don't need to be interpretid for you by someone else, though I am not saying it is not helpful to get outside opinions from someone you trust. I just think you always have to test anything anyone else says to you against the Bible for yourself. Quote: I saw absolutely no evidence but your own word that Jesus fit the Old Testament's prophecies. Fine, I suppose I got lazy and didn't quote everything for you, but I am sure you already know a lot of the prophecies. However, if you really want me to go look them up for you, I will. Quote: That's not the only reason I don't believe in God. I never said it was the only reason, I just said it was a reason. By your own argument, that is not enough proof. *I know I am going to be treading on very dangerous waters for a few paragraphs, but please hear me out, especially anyone who is Catholic.* I'm sorry you had some bad experiences with the Catholic church. I am not Catholic and don't particularly believe in a lot of the things they practice (don't get me wrong anybody, I know a lot of Catholic people who are great and who are Christian). To use your example of the nuns, I don't believe in that because there is nothing in the Bible to support any such institution, and as I said, I am a person who believes that only the Bible and God Himself should be sources for your beliefs. I understand that Catholocism has some beneficial things. It really tries to help people uphold the things in the Bible, but I believe that the responsibility for following the Bible should remain on the individual otherwise the faith is not strong. (Again, I do not believe that individual Catholics do not have strong faith, just that the individual Catholic must make the decision for himself. Just being a part of the Catholic church or going to mass is not enough.) Quote: Did you look into any other religions, out of curiosity? Yea, a lot of them. Around this same time, we were actually studying world religions in my classes, which got me even more curious. Hinduism, Buddhism, Atheism, Agnostics, Judaism, Catholicism, Church of England, Baptists, Mormonism, and other Christian denominations. I even looked into Greek and Roman mythology and Satanism, just out of curiosity (I had no intention of believing in those particular religions.). Quote: They sinned, too, and they even knew that God existed. Why do they get the power? True, but they did not believe in everything God was, namely the ultimate authority in the universe. Lucifer believed he could challenge God. I have no doubt Lucifer believes now, but he is now trying to get as many people to follow him as he can and spend eternity with him in hell.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sat Aug 25, 2007 10:53 pm
Goldenlici Quote: How do you know the really weird-looking creature descibed in Revelations isn't a metaphor? I don't believe Revelations is a metaphor. Christians who do say that are probably the same people who say you don't have to follow the Bible word for word. I believe the Bible is clear enough that you can understand everything you need to from the words. They don't need to be interpretid for you by someone else, though I am not saying it is not helpful to get outside opinions from someone you trust. I just think you always have to test anything anyone else says to you against the Bible for yourself. I think you say that but don't really mean it. Have you ever eaten seafood besides fish or seen a family member naked? Quote: Quote: I saw absolutely no evidence but your own word that Jesus fit the Old Testament's prophecies. Fine, I suppose I got lazy and didn't quote everything for you, but I am sure you already know a lot of the prophecies. However, if you really want me to go look them up for you, I will. I'm merely saying that you can't claim to have given evidence when you haven't. Quote: Quote: That's not the only reason I don't believe in God. I never said it was the only reason, I just said it was a reason. By your own argument, that is not enough proof. I know, but it is a bit of evidence. Quote: *I know I am going to be treading on very dangerous waters for a few paragraphs, but please hear me out, especially anyone who is Catholic.* I'm sorry you had some bad experiences with the Catholic church. I am not Catholic and don't particularly believe in a lot of the things they practice (don't get me wrong anybody, I know a lot of Catholic people who are great and who are Christian). To use your example of the nuns, I don't believe in that because there is nothing in the Bible to support any such institution, and as I said, I am a person who believes that only the Bible and God Himself should be sources for your beliefs. Why is that, by the way? I mean, how do you know the Bible's right? Quote: I understand that Catholocism has some beneficial things. It really tries to help people uphold the things in the Bible, but I believe that the responsibility for following the Bible should remain on the individual otherwise the faith is not strong. (Again, I do not believe that individual Catholics do not have strong faith, just that the individual Catholic must make the decision for himself. Just being a part of the Catholic church or going to mass is not enough.) That's strange coming from someone who claimed that humanity is only strong in groups. neutral Quote: Quote: Did you look into any other religions, out of curiosity? Yea, a lot of them. Around this same time, we were actually studying world religions in my classes, which got me even more curious. Hinduism, Buddhism, Atheism, Agnostics, Judaism, Catholicism, Church of England, Baptists, Mormonism, and other Christian denominations. I even looked into Greek and Roman mythology and Satanism, just out of curiosity (I had no intention of believing in those particular religions.). All in one year? eek That's a lot of ground to cover. Which sect of Christianity did you end up following, anyway? Quote: Quote: They sinned, too, and they even knew that God existed. Why do they get the power? True, but they did not believe in everything God was, namely the ultimate authority in the universe. Lucifer believed he could challenge God. I have no doubt Lucifer believes now, but he is now trying to get as many people to follow him as he can and spend eternity with him in hell. But why does he have dominion over everyone else in Hell when he is probably one of the worst of the lot?
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sat Aug 25, 2007 11:02 pm
Lethkhar By "serial killers" I was sort of referring to Satan and his angels. They sinned, too, and they even knew that God existed. Why do they get the power? I think angelic lore would interest you. Not as a base of truth, but the stories are good. All the angels were given a power. I can't list them now because a friend of mine borrowed my book, but during the great war, God stayed out and let the angels hack each other to pieces. It wasn't just with swords and such, but with fire and brimstone, and all the other things that they could use as heavenly beings. After the fallen angels were locked out of heaven, they got to keep their powers. What Satan's trying to do us keep as many human souls from God as possible, because that would hurt God. I'm pretty sure you've read my little history lesson on how Hell was created because the fallen had nowhere else to go. I mean, if you were trying to kick an enemy in the gut, wouldn't it be to hurt the thing he loves the most? As to why God LET them keep their powers... *shrug* I'm sure there's a grand cosmic reason. I just can't be the one to tell you.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sun Aug 26, 2007 6:41 pm
Lethkar I think you say that but don't really mean it. I completely believe that. Letkar Have you ever eaten seafood besides fish or seen a family member naked? I have read through the entire Bible, including the passages in which God specifically says the old rules written about in Leviticus don't need to be followed. I will agree that I follow the new testament more than the old testament because it is the new "testament" or new covanent God created with man. You think you have had some bad experiences with the church. Believe me I have had a really, really bad experience with a church institution that took me years to recover from. That is why I know better than to follow any church institution. Letkar I'm merely saying that you can't claim to have given evidence when you haven't. I know, I just said "Fine, I suppose I got lazy and didn't quote everything for you." I suppose I alluded to the evidence instead of actually giving the evidence. Truthfully, do you want me to go look up the prophecies? Lethkar I mean, how do you know the Bible's right? sweatdrop That is the same as asking me why I believe in God. I believe wholly in God, so I believe the Bible. Letkar That's strange coming from someone who claimed that humanity is only strong in groups. eek eek eek When in the world did I ever say anything even remotely like that? Letkar All in one year? That's a lot of ground to cover. I said the class was studying some world religions. The class only covered Hinduism, Buddhism, Judaism, Islam, and "Christianity" in general, but this led me to want to study other religions. Letkar Which sect of Christianity did you end up following, anyway? Like I said, I don't really follow my church as much as I follow what is in the Bible. The church I do attend is a church that also believes that: Calvary Chapel. The church teaches through the Bible chapter by chapter, meaning one sunday they do, say, Matthew 8 then the next sunday they do Matthew 9 then Matthew 10, etc. That way, the pastor only teaches specifically what the Bible teaches, instead of the pastor choosing a topic and finding a bunch of verses to support his topic. My pastor only explains what is already in the text, like the meaning of words in the original Greek and the traditions behind the parables and allusions Jesus uses, and, on the rare occasion that he does give his own opinion, he always specifically says that it is only his opinion. My church is more for the people who want to really deeply study the Bible. For example, my aunt really doesn't like our church because it's not all touchy feely, preachy, and gospel like. It's not that we don't praise the Lord and sing songs and stuff. It's just more like a college class or something. *shrug* It's not for everybody. Letkar But why does he have dominion over everyone else in Hell when he is probably one of the worst of the lot? Because God gave him power, which he abused. I don't think it should matter what Hell is like if you know how not to go there and that you will go there if you do certain things. Why do some people go to jail for ... oh, blowing up a mailbox (or some other simple crime that didn't technically hurt any noticible person) the same as people go to jail for asault?
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sun Aug 26, 2007 8:00 pm
Quote: Goldenlici Lethkar I think you say that but don't really mean it. I completely believe that. Letkar Have you ever eaten seafood besides fish or seen a family member naked? I have read through the entire Bible, including the passages in which God specifically says the old rules written about in Leviticus don't need to be followed. I will agree that I follow the new testament more than the old testament because it is the new "testament" or new covanent God created with man. You think you have had some bad experiences with the church. Believe me I have had a really, really bad experience with a church institution that took me years to recover from. That is why I know better than to follow any church institution. Then let's discuss the New Testament literally: Luke 18:18-22 18 An official asked him this question, "Good teacher, what must I do to inherit eternal life?" 19 Jesus answered him, "Why do you call me good? No one is good but God alone. 20 You know the commandments, 'You shall not commit adultery; you shall not kill; you shall not steal; you shall not bear false witness; honor your father and your mother.'" 21 And he replied, "All of these I have observed from my youth." 22 When Jesus heard this he said to him, "There is still one thing left for you: sell all that you have and distribute it to the poor, and you will have a treasure in heaven. Then come, follow me. You have to sell everything and give it to the poor to go to heaven. Luke 14:26-33 26 " If any one comes to me without hating his father 7 and mother, wife and children, brothers and sisters, and even his own life, he cannot be my disciple. 27 Whoever does not carry his own cross and come after me cannot be my disciple. 28 Which of you wishing to construct a tower does not first sit down and calculate the cost to see if there is enough for its completion? 29 Otherwise, after laying the foundation and finding himself unable to finish the work the onlookers should laugh at him 30 and say, 'This one began to build but did not have the resources to finish.' 31 Or what king marching into battle would not first sit down and decide whether with ten thousand troops he can successfully oppose another king advancing upon him with twenty thousand troops? 32 But if not, while he is still far away, he will send a delegation to ask for peace terms. 33 In the same way, everyone of you who does not renounce all his possessions cannot be my disciple. You must hate everyone you love. You must also renounce all your possessions. Jesus was rather adamant about this. John 6:53-56 53 Jesus said to them, "Amen, amen, I say to you, unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink his blood, you do not have life within you. 54 Whoever eats my flesh and drinks my blood has eternal life, and I will raise him on the last day. 55 For my flesh is true food, and my blood is true drink. 56 Whoever eats my flesh and drinks my blood remains in me and I in him. You have to eat Jesus's flesh and drink his blood to get into Heaven. Literally, according to you. Quote: Letkar I'm merely saying that you can't claim to have given evidence when you haven't. I know, I just said "Fine, I suppose I got lazy and didn't quote everything for you." I suppose I alluded to the evidence instead of actually giving the evidence. Truthfully, do you want me to go look up the prophecies? Well, I don't really want to debate about whether Jesus was the Messiah or not, since it's really irrelevant and doesn't mean much to me as an atheist. Quote: Lethkar I mean, how do you know the Bible's right? sweatdrop That is the same as asking me why I believe in God. I believe wholly in God, so I believe the Bible. Why? And why the God from the Bible? Quote: Letkar That's strange coming from someone who claimed that humanity is only strong in groups. eek eek eek When in the world did I ever say anything even remotely like that? In the Evolution thread: Goldenlici If the neo-Darwinian synthesis were correct, humans would have become extinct before they had a chance to develop because they would have been weak in comparison with the other animals. The only reason humans are so strong is because they work together. One human-like thing would die because its human emotions would have caused it problems Quote: Letkar All in one year? That's a lot of ground to cover. I said the class was studying some world religions. The class only covered Hinduism, Buddhism, Judaism, Islam, and "Christianity" in general, but this led me to want to study other religions. Such as... Quote: Letkar But why does he have dominion over everyone else in Hell when he is probably one of the worst of the lot? Because God gave him power, which he abused. So why doesn't God take that power from him? Quote: I don't think it should matter what Hell is like if you know how not to go there and that you will go there if you do certain things. Why do some people go to jail for ... oh, blowing up a mailbox (or some other simple crime that didn't technically hurt any noticible person) the same as people go to jail for asault? A person who blows up a mail box and a person who assaults someone will not go to the same prison. I think it matters what Hell's like. I care what prisons are like, too. I don't want mingling between different types of criminals.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sun Aug 26, 2007 8:58 pm
Very clever use of verses out of context. You've had practice. Believe me, I have faced plenty of people who try and prove a point by quoting a specific verse in the bible. Lethkar I openly admit to sinning, Lethkar Things in the Bible are rather specific. Lethkar God is completely in charge. You seem to be a very devote Christian, Lethkar. Do you get my point? Luke 18 talks about one very specific man asking Jesus what he alone had to do to get into heaven. This man was described as a very rich man, and Jesus obviously saw that he put his wealth above God. Jesus says "There is still one thing left for *you:" *He was talking to that man. I agree that if you come to a point where your possessions are more important than God, you should sell them. If God specifically tells you that is your sin, I agree you should do that; however, Jesus did not teach this lesson to a crowd of people, only to one man. Luke 14 does talk about hating your family, but there are numerous other verses that talk about loving your family and everyone else. I believe (now this is only my interpretation) that Jesus was speaking about the fact that you can not serve two masters. I know that sounds weird, so just let me explain. Luke 16:13 "No servant can serve two masters; for either he will hate the one and love the other, or else he will be loyal to one and despise the other. You cannot serve God and mammon." *Note*As always, feel free to read the verses surrounding my quotes to ensure the passage was interpretid correctly. Any verse I use, I would actually feel better if you went to check it out in context for yourself, so we don't misunderstand each other. I believe that Jesus was saying in Luke 14 that you cannot place anyone, even your most beloved family members above God. If there comes a time when I have to choose between my family and God, I will follow the words of Luke 14 and choose God. At the same time Jesus was saying the words in John 6, He was passing out bread and wine, clearly showing that it was a metaphor, otherwise He would have peeled some of his flesh off and poured some of His blood into cups to give to the disciples. Like I said, I don't believe there aren't metaphors in the Bible, just that there are clear ways to know when a metaphor is being used. Believing the lesson behind a metaphor is still believing in the words of the metaphor. Goldenlici The only reason humans are so strong is because they work together. Yes, those are my words, taken out of context. I think I already pointed out that you can get someone to say anything they want out of context. We were talking about the physical fitness and overall strength of a species in that thread. Physically, humans are stronger in groups. True, humans can create good mental ideas when together. And, yes, spiritually, there can be wisdom gained from groups. But, ultimately I believe the true strength of a person comes from what they decide as individuals. That is why I don't believe I should try to "convert" you to Christianity. I can only offer some wisdom I believe in, but the choice is ultimately yours alone. sweatdrop I think I already said which ones. Goldenlici Hinduism, Buddhism, Atheism, Agnostics, Judaism, Catholicism, Church of England, Baptists, Mormonism, and other Christian denominations. I even looked into Greek and Roman mythology and Satanism, just out of curiosity (I had no intention of believing in those particular religions.). Quote: A person who blows up a mail box and a person who assaults someone will not go to the same prison. But, they both go to jail. Jails are essentially the same thing, confinement with less than ideal living conditions. Quote: I think it matters what Hell's like. Why does it matter what Hell is like? God made the choice to design Hell as He saw fit. Honestly, no one really knows what Hell is going to be like other than really bad. I believe God created Hell to have conditions that fit the crime of the men there. Quote: I care what prisons are like, too. I don't want mingling between different types of criminals. I agree that prisons should be safe and humane because jails are run by humans who are imperfect beings. God says in the Bible that men should not judge other men because men are quite capable of making mistakes. That is not to say I don't believe people should go to jail. I believe it is within man's responsibilities to protect others from criminals, but I don't believe that man has the right to decide ultimately and eternally what will happen to these people. And, Jesus calls us to love our enemies, so we should treat prisoners with respect.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Mon Aug 27, 2007 1:47 am
Goldenlici Very clever use of verses out of context. You've had practice. Believe me, I have faced plenty of people who try and prove a point by quoting a specific verse in the bible. Lethkar I openly admit to sinning, Lethkar Things in the Bible are rather specific. Lethkar God is completely in charge. You seem to be a very devote Christian, Lethkar. Do you get my point? Not at all. I stand by each and every one of those statements. I can explain why, if you like. Quote: Luke 18 talks about one very specific man asking Jesus what he alone had to do to get into heaven. This man was described as a very rich man, and Jesus obviously saw that he put his wealth above God. Jesus says "There is still one thing left for *you:" *He was talking to that man. I agree that if you come to a point where your possessions are more important than God, you should sell them. If God specifically tells you that is your sin, I agree you should do that; however, Jesus did not teach this lesson to a crowd of people, only to one man. That seems rather unfair. That one man had to give up a lot more than most people. cry Quote: Luke 14 does talk about hating your family, but there are numerous other verses that talk about loving your family and everyone else. It sounds to me like Jesus contradicted himself. Quote: I believe (now this is only my interpretation) that Jesus was speaking about the fact that you can not serve two masters. I know that sounds weird, so just let me explain. Luke 16:13 "No servant can serve two masters; for either he will hate the one and love the other, or else he will be loyal to one and despise the other. You cannot serve God and mammon." *Note*As always, feel free to read the verses surrounding my quotes to ensure the passage was interpretid correctly. Any verse I use, I would actually feel better if you went to check it out in context for yourself, so we don't misunderstand each other. I believe that Jesus was saying in Luke 14 that you cannot place anyone, even your most beloved family members above God. If there comes a time when I have to choose between my family and God, I will follow the words of Luke 14 and choose God. In this case I don't believe I took it out of context. It specifically says "hate", not "hate compared to God". Believe me, I've heard this argument before. Quote: At the same time Jesus was saying the words in John 6, He was passing out bread and wine, clearly showing that it was a metaphor, otherwise He would have peeled some of his flesh off and poured some of His blood into cups to give to the disciples. Like I said, I don't believe there aren't metaphors in the Bible, just that there are clear ways to know when a metaphor is being used. Believing the lesson behind a metaphor is still believing in the words of the metaphor. I could make the same argument for Revelations. This is exactly my point. Quote: Goldenlici The only reason humans are so strong is because they work together. Yes, those are my words, taken out of context. I think I already pointed out that you can get someone to say anything they want out of context. We were talking about the physical fitness and overall strength of a species in that thread. Physically, humans are stronger in groups. True, humans can create good mental ideas when together. And, yes, spiritually, there can be wisdom gained from groups. But, ultimately I believe the true strength of a person comes from what they decide as individuals. That is why I don't believe I should try to "convert" you to Christianity. I can only offer some wisdom I believe in, but the choice is ultimately yours alone. You changed your mind, then. A single human would be strong alone. Quote: sweatdrop I think I already said which ones. Goldenlici Hinduism, Buddhism, Atheism, Agnostics, Judaism, Catholicism, Church of England, Baptists, Mormonism, and other Christian denominations. I even looked into Greek and Roman mythology and Satanism, just out of curiosity (I had no intention of believing in those particular religions.). You didn't look into Baha'i? You should check it out. It's by far my favorite monotheistic religion. Quote: Quote: A person who blows up a mail box and a person who assaults someone will not go to the same prison. But, they both go to jail. Jails are essentially the same thing, confinement with less than ideal living conditions. But they will not be in the prison together. The guy who blew up a mailbox will not go to a prison run by psychopaths. They will be separated. Plus, federal prisons are a helluvalot nicer than state prisons. Well, I guess it depend on which state you're in... Quote: Quote: I think it matters what Hell's like. Why does it matter what Hell is like? God made the choice to design Hell as He saw fit. Honestly, no one really knows what Hell is going to be like other than really bad. I believe God created Hell to have conditions that fit the crime of the men there. I think it matters because the majority of people are going there. I would like to know what's going to happen to most of my friends and family, thank you very much. Quote: Quote: I care what prisons are like, too. I don't want mingling between different types of criminals. I agree that prisons should be safe and humane because jails are run by humans who are imperfect beings. God says in the Bible that men should not judge other men because men are quite capable of making mistakes. That is not to say I don't believe people should go to jail. I believe it is within man's responsibilities to protect others from criminals, but I don't believe that man has the right to decide ultimately and eternally what will happen to these people. And, Jesus calls us to love our enemies, so we should treat prisoners with respect. Which apparently translates to burning them for eternity...What am I not getting here? sweatdrop
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Mon Aug 27, 2007 10:37 am
Quote: Not at all. I stand by each and every one of those statements. I can explain why, if you like. I am sure you could explain your quotes and why you used them and what you meant by them, that's not my point. On their own, out of context, they sure make you sound like you are a Christian. Quote: That seems rather unfair. That one man had to give up a lot more than most people. You really think it is unfair to base what each person should do on what that individual person is like? God knows what sins are hardest for a particular person to overcome, and tries to help them accordingly. This man's greatest sin was putting wealth above God, and in the end, he choose not to give up his wealth for God. There are some very rich people in the Bible who God blesses. It isn't so much about the wealth, but the mind of the individual. Quote: It sounds to me like Jesus contradicted himself. To truly argue this point, I would have to know what the word "hate" is in the original greek. I will look it up. If it really means hate as we see it in English, I'll read it in context. If it means something a little different, I'll show you what I found. I know for a fact there are like three different words for three different kinds of love in Greek. I really don't think it would be fair for me to argue this verse any further until I know specifically what God meant. Please don't think I am trying to avoid the subject, I will gladly argue it, but I want to know what it means first. Quote: I could make the same argument for Revelations. What indications do you have that imply a metaphor in Revelations? John very clearly says this is what he saw in his dream. A revelation means "something revealed or disclosed, esp. a striking disclosure, as of something not before realized" (dictionary.com). The very definition of the word John uses says it is not a metaphor, but something discovered. The passage in John was clearly a metaphor because Jesus showed it as such with the use of the bread and the wine. Quote: You changed your mind, then. A single human would be strong alone. I didn't change my mind. Biologically, which is the context we were using when I said this, the human species is strong as a group. And, yes, an individual can have physical strength. Strength of the mind and spirit relies on the individual that is all I am saying. Though I do acknowledge that an individual can gain strength from a group, it is still the individual who grows stronger. Baha'i? I'll check it out. Quote: I think it matters because the majority of people are going there. I would like to know what's going to happen to most of my friends and family, thank you very much. Instead of trying to figure out how horrible their lives are going to be in hell, why not try to help them to heaven? I believe a lot of people don't want hell to exist because they don't want to have the burden of trying to minister their loved ones. Again, don't be so quick to jump down my throat for calling you a bad person. I don't think this is you. I personally think you are still trying to figure out what you believe, and the Bible says you should figure out your own spirituality before trying to help others with their spirituality. Quote: Which apparently translates to burning them for eternity...What am I not getting here? Everything. I don't get everything either. That has been point through this entire argument: that we can not completely understand Hell because we don't know everything that happens. God is omnipotent, so He understands all the sins a person has committed and all the stuff that happened because of those sins. There is no one who has never sinned, and, in fact, I don't believe there is anyone who has only sinned once. A person who has blown up one mailbox may not go to the same prison as a murderer, but a person who has blown up lots of mailboxes and injured some people in the process might.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Mon Aug 27, 2007 2:07 pm
Goldenlici Quote: Not at all. I stand by each and every one of those statements. I can explain why, if you like. I am sure you could explain your quotes and why you used them and what you meant by them, that's not my point. On their own, out of context, they sure make you sound like you are a Christian. No they don't. They make it look like I have an understanding of Christianity. Quote: Quote: That seems rather unfair. That one man had to give up a lot more than most people. You really think it is unfair to base what each person should do on what that individual person is like? God knows what sins are hardest for a particular person to overcome, and tries to help them accordingly. This man's greatest sin was putting wealth above God, and in the end, he choose not to give up his wealth for God. There are some very rich people in the Bible who God blesses. It isn't so much about the wealth, but the mind of the individual. So how do you know what you need to do? Obviously, it's different for everyone, and there's no Jesus to tell you what to do. Quote: Quote: I could make the same argument for Revelations. What indications do you have that imply a metaphor in Revelations? John very clearly says this is what he saw in his dream. A revelation means "something revealed or disclosed, esp. a striking disclosure, as of something not before realized" (dictionary.com). The very definition of the word John uses says it is not a metaphor, but something discovered. The passage in John was clearly a metaphor because Jesus showed it as such with the use of the bread and the wine. I dunno, maybe the whole part about "holding seven stars" and "seven golden lampstands" sort of threw me off... All those fantastic creatures and numbers are very easy to take as a metaphor. Quote: Quote: You changed your mind, then. A single human would be strong alone. I didn't change my mind. Biologically, which is the context we were using when I said this, the human species is strong as a group. And, yes, an individual can have physical strength. Strength of the mind and spirit relies on the individual that is all I am saying. Though I do acknowledge that an individual can gain strength from a group, it is still the individual who grows stronger. Which should apply to biology as well. Quote: Quote: I think it matters because the majority of people are going there. I would like to know what's going to happen to most of my friends and family, thank you very much. Instead of trying to figure out how horrible their lives are going to be in hell, why not try to help them to heaven? I believe a lot of people don't want hell to exist because they don't want to have the burden of trying to minister their loved ones. Again, don't be so quick to jump down my throat for calling you a bad person. I don't think this is you. I personally think you are still trying to figure out what you believe, and the Bible says you should figure out your own spirituality before trying to help others with their spirituality. Some people are quite beyond "help". Some people are so convicted that their religion is right that it would be impossible to convince them that Christianity is the correct path. I want to know what happens to those people. Quote: Quote: Which apparently translates to burning them for eternity...What am I not getting here? Everything. I don't get everything either. That has been point through this entire argument: that we can not completely understand Hell because we don't know everything that happens. God is omnipotent, so He understands all the sins a person has committed and all the stuff that happened because of those sins. Actually, I think you meant "omniscient". I mean, I'm sure He's omnipotent, too...Sorry for being nitpicky. Quote: There is no one who has never sinned, and, in fact, I don't believe there is anyone who has only sinned once. A person who has blown up one mailbox may not go to the same prison as a murderer, but a person who has blown up lots of mailboxes and injured some people in the process might. There is still a difference between a serial killer and a guy who blows up mailboxes. As far as I know, I haven't killed anyone by sinning. And even then it wouldn't have been intentional, which of course is different from a serial killer.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Mon Aug 27, 2007 6:50 pm
Quote: They make it look like I have an understanding of Christianity. Christians believe they are sinners, Jesus is the Messiah, and God is in control. Do you doubt that if someone was shown those quotes without knowing you that they would probably believe you were a Christian? Quote: So how do you know what you need to do? Obviously, it's different for everyone, and there's no Jesus to tell you what to do. There are very obvious rules that you must follow, and then there are areas where God will speak to you specifically. In this case, the issue is whether or not you have to sell all your possessions to become a christian. The Bible says that you should have nothing above the Lord, so if you, as an individual, place possessions above God, you should take away those possesions because they disobey the rule about not having anything above God. The Bible has guidlines for the individual, you just have to figure out for yourself what the Bible says to your personality, which is why I believe you have to read through the whole Bible not just bits and pieces. Quote: All those fantastic creatures and numbers are very easy to take as a metaphor. Agreed. But, there is no indication that it is a metaphor, so I guess in the end of the world we are going to see some pretty amazing creatures. 4laugh Quote: Which should apply to biology as well. Are you intent on making me a hypocrit or do you just like to have the last word? I believe my last quote was pretty specific. Quote: Some people are quite beyond "help". Some people are so convicted that their religion is right that it would be impossible to convince them that Christianity is the correct path. I don't like to give up on people, but I don't doubt that there are people who will not believe no matter what you say. These people then commit the sin of pride. Quote: Actually, I think you meant "omniscient". I mean, I'm sure He's omnipotent, too...Sorry for being nitpicky. Yeah, probably both. I wonder if you can be one and not the other? Quote: There is still a difference between a serial killer and a guy who blows up mailboxes. As far as I know, I haven't killed anyone by sinning. And even then it wouldn't have been intentional, which of course is different from a serial killer. How do you know, for either of these situations? A person who blew up a mailbox may have the same evil mind, but the serial killer just had a situation in which to escalate. Quote: As far as I know, I haven't killed anyone by sinning. And even then it wouldn't have been intentional, which of course is different from a serial killer. That is kind of my point. You really don't know if your sin has harmed anyone. God knows that sins will harm others, so He specifically tells us what things are sins. I believe He is warning us that our little sins have big consequences, which are the topics of several Bible stories and parables of Jesus.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Mon Aug 27, 2007 7:13 pm
Goldenlici Quote: They make it look like I have an understanding of Christianity. Christians believe they are sinners, Jesus is the Messiah, and God is in control. Do you doubt that if someone was shown those quotes without knowing you that they would probably believe you were a Christian? I'd be willing to bet that if a person was shown those quotes and asked "Is this person a Christian" that they would say "no" because it's too obvious to be "yes". Of course, a well-read person would say,"I don't know, I'd have to ask them." Quote: Quote: So how do you know what you need to do? Obviously, it's different for everyone, and there's no Jesus to tell you what to do. There are very obvious rules that you must follow, and then there are areas where God will speak to you specifically. In this case, the issue is whether or not you have to sell all your possessions to become a christian. The Bible says that you should have nothing above the Lord, so if you, as an individual, place possessions above God, you should take away those possesions because they disobey the rule about not having anything above God. The Bible has guidlines for the individual, you just have to figure out for yourself what the Bible says to your personality, which is why I believe you have to read through the whole Bible not just bits and pieces. That's funny, because a lot of people tell me not to read it straight through because it doesn't seem as meaningful that way. Quote: Quote: All those fantastic creatures and numbers are very easy to take as a metaphor. Agreed. But, there is no indication that it is a metaphor, so I guess in the end of the world we are going to see some pretty amazing creatures. 4laugh And random household items... Quote: Quote: Which should apply to biology as well. Are you intent on making me a hypocrit or do you just like to have the last word? I believe my last quote was pretty specific. I am asking which one you believe. You're not a hypocrite if you just changed your mind. Quote: Quote: Some people are quite beyond "help". Some people are so convicted that their religion is right that it would be impossible to convince them that Christianity is the correct path. I don't like to give up on people, but I don't doubt that there are people who will not believe no matter what you say. These people then commit the sin of pride. It's not pride it you show so much humility before your own God that you do not look into other religions. Quote: Quote: Actually, I think you meant "omniscient". I mean, I'm sure He's omnipotent, too...Sorry for being nitpicky. Yeah, probably both. I wonder if you can be one and not the other? An omniscient being without being omnipotent may be possible. And as long as an omnipotent being chose not to be omniscient... Yeah... sweatdrop Quote: Quote: There is still a difference between a serial killer and a guy who blows up mailboxes. As far as I know, I haven't killed anyone by sinning. And even then it wouldn't have been intentional, which of course is different from a serial killer. How do you know, for either of these situations? A person who blew up a mailbox may have the same evil mind, but the serial killer just had a situation in which to escalate. There are certain nearly-universal traits that serial killers have. Torturing and/or killing animals, liking soft velvety objects, etc. Blowing up mailboxes isn't one of them unless the intent is to harm or kill someone, as far as I know. I'm not exactly an expert on serial killers, though. Quote: Quote: As far as I know, I haven't killed anyone by sinning. And even then it wouldn't have been intentional, which of course is different from a serial killer. That is kind of my point. You really don't know if your sin has harmed anyone. God knows that sins will harm others, so He specifically tells us what things are sins. I believe He is warning us that our little sins have big consequences, which are the topics of several Bible stories and parables of Jesus. Please read the second part of what you quoted, which specifies the consequences if I had, indeed, harmed someone. I bolded it for you.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Mon Aug 27, 2007 7:29 pm
Quote: That's funny, because a lot of people tell me not to read it straight through because it doesn't seem as meaningful that way. And, were these same people the ones who weren't able to convince you to believe in Christianity? I find people who believe that often have a very warped idea of what it means to be a christian because they pick and choose the verses that let them live the "christian" life they want to live. That is why there are so many sects of christianity. Quote: I am asking which one you believe. You're not a hypocrite if you just changed your mind. I believe that humans are biologically more fit for their environment in a group, but their mental and spiritual strength comes from the individual. Quote: It's not pride it you show so much humility before your own God that you do not look into other religions. Even Christians are called, by God, to question their religion, so they do not fall into the sin of blind obedience. Quote: An omniscient being without being omnipotent may be possible. And as long as an omnipotent being chose not to be omniscient... Yeah... sweatdrop 3nodding That's an interesting idea ... Quote: As far as I know, I haven't killed anyone by sinning. And even then it wouldn't have been intentional, which of course is different from a serial killer. I think what I said for the first part applies to the second part. Even if you don't know that a simple sin would harm someone, God does, and warns you not to do the little sins because he knows that.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
 |
|
|
|
|
|