Welcome to Gaia! ::

The NFL Guild

Back to Guilds

A guild for fans of the game. 

Tags: National Football League, Football, Pigskin, American, Sports 

Reply The NFL Guild
Best QB in the League Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3 ... 4 5 6 7 [>] [»|]

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Best QB?
  Tom Brady
  Drew Brees
  Peyton Manning
  Jake Delhomme
  Eli Manning
  Ben Rothlisberger
  Donovan McNabb
  Phillip Rivers
  Kurt Warner
  Other- Write-in Vote
View Results

Austin Shipp

PostPosted: Sat Jan 31, 2009 9:57 pm


Dude-LAP
gayus fagus
Austin Shipp
collins is only 2 years older than delhomme
Where the hell are you getting your info? Just look at a picture of each and tell me if Delhomme looks as old as Collins.


Why do you never think inside the box? A simple 20 second Google search would justify that he is right.

Jake Delhomme was born 1/10/1975

Kerry Collins was born 12/30/1972

...Collins is older by only two years and eleven days. stare
PostPosted: Sun Feb 01, 2009 9:09 am


Austin Shipp
Dude-LAP
gayus ******** class="quoted">
Austin Shipp
collins is only 2 years older than delhomme
Where the hell are you getting your info? Just look at a picture of each and tell me if Delhomme looks as old as Collins.


Why do you never think inside the box? A simple 20 second Google search would justify that he is right.

Jake Delhomme was born 1/10/1975

Kerry Collins was born 12/30/1972

...Collins is older by only two years and eleven days. stare
Look at the two guys side by side. Who would you rather have?

Argus Plexus


Dude-LAP

PostPosted: Sun Feb 01, 2009 11:22 am


Argus Plexus
Austin Shipp
Dude-LAP
gayus ******** class="quoted">
Austin Shipp
collins is only 2 years older than delhomme
Where the hell are you getting your info? Just look at a picture of each and tell me if Delhomme looks as old as Collins.


Why do you never think inside the box? A simple 20 second Google search would justify that he is right.

Jake Delhomme was born 1/10/1975

Kerry Collins was born 12/30/1972

...Collins is older by only two years and eleven days. stare
Look at the two guys side by side. Who would you rather have?


Well first of all, appearance has nothing to do with their ages and performance.

...Anyways, I think it's a draw. Kerry Collins had the better career. Jake Delhomme had the better season. Collins had a better playoff performance, although both lost.

Delhomme may have more upside, since his is a bit younger, but Collins is a veteran leader than can get it done.

...It really depends on the team around them. As of now, Collins fits the Titans well and Delhomme fits the Panthers well.
PostPosted: Sun Feb 01, 2009 1:18 pm


Dude-LAP
Argus Plexus
Austin Shipp
Dude-LAP
gayus ******** class="quoted">
Austin Shipp
collins is only 2 years older than delhomme
Where the hell are you getting your info? Just look at a picture of each and tell me if Delhomme looks as old as Collins.


Why do you never think inside the box? A simple 20 second Google search would justify that he is right.

Jake Delhomme was born 1/10/1975

Kerry Collins was born 12/30/1972

...Collins is older by only two years and eleven days. stare
Look at the two guys side by side. Who would you rather have?


Well first of all, appearance has nothing to do with their ages and performance.

...Anyways, I think it's a draw. Kerry Collins had the better career. Jake Delhomme had the better season. Collins had a better playoff performance, although both lost.

Delhomme may have more upside, since his is a bit younger, but Collins is a veteran leader than can get it done.

...It really depends on the team around them. As of now, Collins fits the Titans well and Delhomme fits the Panthers well.
You're forgetting the Tommy Johns surgery that Delhomme got. That made his passing so much better. I think that gives him an advantage over Collins. Delhomme, I think, would be the better choice in the long run. Although, Collins does a lot better under pressure. I have to give him that.

Argus Plexus


Dude-LAP

PostPosted: Tue Feb 03, 2009 9:12 pm


Argus Plexus
Dude-LAP
Argus Plexus
Austin Shipp
Dude-LAP


Why do you never think inside the box? A simple 20 second Google search would justify that he is right.

Jake Delhomme was born 1/10/1975

Kerry Collins was born 12/30/1972

...Collins is older by only two years and eleven days. stare
Look at the two guys side by side. Who would you rather have?


Well first of all, appearance has nothing to do with their ages and performance.

...Anyways, I think it's a draw. Kerry Collins had the better career. Jake Delhomme had the better season. Collins had a better playoff performance, although both lost.

Delhomme may have more upside, since his is a bit younger, but Collins is a veteran leader than can get it done.

...It really depends on the team around them. As of now, Collins fits the Titans well and Delhomme fits the Panthers well.
You're forgetting the Tommy Johns surgery that Delhomme got. That made his passing so much better. I think that gives him an advantage over Collins. Delhomme, I think, would be the better choice in the long run. Although, Collins does a lot better under pressure. I have to give him that.


Players get surgeries to repair themselves, not to improve themselves. The Tommy John surgery that Delhomme got was to heal his arm from ligament damage. Sure, it made him look better than he did when he was injured, but it didn't improve his game. I have to say, though, that he made a pretty good recovery, considering how long it usually takes.
PostPosted: Wed Feb 04, 2009 1:27 pm


Dude-LAP
Argus Plexus
Dude-LAP
Argus Plexus
Austin Shipp
Dude-LAP


Why do you never think inside the box? A simple 20 second Google search would justify that he is right.

Jake Delhomme was born 1/10/1975

Kerry Collins was born 12/30/1972

...Collins is older by only two years and eleven days. stare
Look at the two guys side by side. Who would you rather have?


Well first of all, appearance has nothing to do with their ages and performance.

...Anyways, I think it's a draw. Kerry Collins had the better career. Jake Delhomme had the better season. Collins had a better playoff performance, although both lost.

Delhomme may have more upside, since his is a bit younger, but Collins is a veteran leader than can get it done.

...It really depends on the team around them. As of now, Collins fits the Titans well and Delhomme fits the Panthers well.
You're forgetting the Tommy Johns surgery that Delhomme got. That made his passing so much better. I think that gives him an advantage over Collins. Delhomme, I think, would be the better choice in the long run. Although, Collins does a lot better under pressure. I have to give him that.


Players get surgeries to repair themselves, not to improve themselves. The Tommy John surgery that Delhomme got was to heal his arm from ligament damage. Sure, it made him look better than he did when he was injured, but it didn't improve his game. I have to say, though, that he made a pretty good recovery, considering how long it usually takes.
What do you mean no improvement? This year was his best year since his 04 and 05 seasons, where he actually set a few records. his 06' year was garbage, and 07' was cut short for reasons stated earlier. His throwing arm is much stronger than it was before, and I believe he will continue to improve.

Argus Plexus


Dude-LAP

PostPosted: Sat Feb 07, 2009 3:44 pm


Argus Plexus
Dude-LAP
Argus Plexus
Dude-LAP
Argus Plexus
Look at the two guys side by side. Who would you rather have?


Well first of all, appearance has nothing to do with their ages and performance.

...Anyways, I think it's a draw. Kerry Collins had the better career. Jake Delhomme had the better season. Collins had a better playoff performance, although both lost.

Delhomme may have more upside, since his is a bit younger, but Collins is a veteran leader than can get it done.

...It really depends on the team around them. As of now, Collins fits the Titans well and Delhomme fits the Panthers well.
You're forgetting the Tommy Johns surgery that Delhomme got. That made his passing so much better. I think that gives him an advantage over Collins. Delhomme, I think, would be the better choice in the long run. Although, Collins does a lot better under pressure. I have to give him that.


Players get surgeries to repair themselves, not to improve themselves. The Tommy John surgery that Delhomme got was to heal his arm from ligament damage. Sure, it made him look better than he did when he was injured, but it didn't improve his game. I have to say, though, that he made a pretty good recovery, considering how long it usually takes.
What do you mean no improvement? This year was his best year since his 04 and 05 seasons, where he actually set a few records. his 06' year was garbage, and 07' was cut short for reasons stated earlier. His throwing arm is much stronger than it was before, and I believe he will continue to improve.


Delhomme got better from his injury, which repaired a physical setback. He physically didnt improve his arm strength or health. He just had a very good season, because he had a good team around him. Believe it or not, a good defense and good runningbacks actually help a QB too. Then there's Steve Smith and the addition of Mushin Muhammad, and a good offensive line.
PostPosted: Sat Feb 07, 2009 6:20 pm


Dude-LAP
Argus Plexus
Dude-LAP
Argus Plexus
Dude-LAP
Argus Plexus
Look at the two guys side by side. Who would you rather have?


Well first of all, appearance has nothing to do with their ages and performance.

...Anyways, I think it's a draw. Kerry Collins had the better career. Jake Delhomme had the better season. Collins had a better playoff performance, although both lost.

Delhomme may have more upside, since his is a bit younger, but Collins is a veteran leader than can get it done.

...It really depends on the team around them. As of now, Collins fits the Titans well and Delhomme fits the Panthers well.
You're forgetting the Tommy Johns surgery that Delhomme got. That made his passing so much better. I think that gives him an advantage over Collins. Delhomme, I think, would be the better choice in the long run. Although, Collins does a lot better under pressure. I have to give him that.


Players get surgeries to repair themselves, not to improve themselves. The Tommy John surgery that Delhomme got was to heal his arm from ligament damage. Sure, it made him look better than he did when he was injured, but it didn't improve his game. I have to say, though, that he made a pretty good recovery, considering how long it usually takes.
What do you mean no improvement? This year was his best year since his 04 and 05 seasons, where he actually set a few records. his 06' year was garbage, and 07' was cut short for reasons stated earlier. His throwing arm is much stronger than it was before, and I believe he will continue to improve.


Delhomme got better from his injury, which repaired a physical setback. He physically didnt improve his arm strength or health. He just had a very good season, because he had a good team around him. Believe it or not, a good defense and good runningbacks actually help a QB too. Then there's Steve Smith and the addition of Mushin Muhammad, and a good offensive line.
Yeah, definitely.

Argus Plexus


Dude-LAP

PostPosted: Mon Feb 09, 2009 6:48 pm


Argus Plexus
Dude-LAP
Argus Plexus
Dude-LAP
Argus Plexus
You're forgetting the Tommy Johns surgery that Delhomme got. That made his passing so much better. I think that gives him an advantage over Collins. Delhomme, I think, would be the better choice in the long run. Although, Collins does a lot better under pressure. I have to give him that.


Players get surgeries to repair themselves, not to improve themselves. The Tommy John surgery that Delhomme got was to heal his arm from ligament damage. Sure, it made him look better than he did when he was injured, but it didn't improve his game. I have to say, though, that he made a pretty good recovery, considering how long it usually takes.
What do you mean no improvement? This year was his best year since his 04 and 05 seasons, where he actually set a few records. his 06' year was garbage, and 07' was cut short for reasons stated earlier. His throwing arm is much stronger than it was before, and I believe he will continue to improve.


Delhomme got better from his injury, which repaired a physical setback. He physically didnt improve his arm strength or health. He just had a very good season, because he had a good team around him. Believe it or not, a good defense and good runningbacks actually help a QB too. Then there's Steve Smith and the addition of Mushin Muhammad, and a good offensive line.
Yeah, definitely.


So you're admitting you're wrong? blaugh lol
PostPosted: Mon Feb 09, 2009 7:29 pm


LP, stop messing with this guy, i know its fun but it gets annoying after a while rofl

Austin Shipp


Nyuupyon
Captain

PostPosted: Tue Feb 10, 2009 12:12 am


By the way... How the hell is Ryan, Pennington, and Delhomme in that poll and not Drew motha effin' Brees? Tony Romo even? Favre maybe? Warner?

Come on. I mean really. Come on.
I go with Carson Palmer by the way. xD
Shaun Hill.
I must fix this travesty!

And Jake Delhomme? Come on. A good quarterback? Nah. When you have Smith, you gotta throw for 4000+ yards and 30+ TDs. Lol. He's not a good quarterback.

He's a winner, I give you that. Played well in that Super Bowl. Lol. Lost though. Adam Vinatieri.
PostPosted: Tue Feb 10, 2009 11:32 am


Nyu-kun
By the way... How the hell is Ryan, Pennington, and Delhomme in that poll and not Drew motha effin' Brees? Tony Romo even? Favre maybe? Warner?

Come on. I mean really. Come on.
I go with Carson Palmer by the way. xD
Shaun Hill.
I must fix this travesty!

And Jake Delhomme? Come on. A good quarterback? Nah. When you have Smith, you gotta throw for 4000+ yards and 30+ TDs. Lol. He's not a good quarterback.

He's a winner, I give you that. Played well in that Super Bowl. Lol. Lost though. Adam Vinatieri.


lol, it's ironic and funny how you questioned the QBs in his poll, when you make a mistake while changing it. blaugh Why isn't Tom Brady up there? rofl I say take off Cassel and Rodgers, and add Brady and Eli Manning.

Dude-LAP


Nyuupyon
Captain

PostPosted: Tue Feb 10, 2009 6:58 pm


I didn't mess up. I did that purposely. For one, Brady is out injured and stuff. Granted, he's still good, but I didn't really feel like putting him in there. Also, Eli, statistically didn't do as well as Cutler, Rivers, or Rodgers.
That's why.

And Delhomme... He shouldn't even be in there... You people and your biasedness. Lol.
PostPosted: Tue Feb 10, 2009 7:32 pm


Oh, okay.

...I'm just wondering why so many people were down on Brady. Everyone gets injured, and just because his replacement did fairly well doesn't mean that he isn't as good as when he was healthy.

Dude-LAP


Nyuupyon
Captain

PostPosted: Tue Feb 10, 2009 7:53 pm


I have nothing on Brady. He's very good. Even with Moss and Welker, to throw 50 TDs is something. Not even Montana or Young got that high with Rice and JT. Even Rice and Owens...
Reply
The NFL Guild

Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3 ... 4 5 6 7 [>] [»|]
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum