|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
 Posted: Tue Aug 23, 2005 6:25 pm
Kevin Black KitsuneTsuki Kim, I simply adore your cheery outlook 4laugh But really, I have to disagree with you Kevin. Sirius wasnt as important as you make him sound. I mean, he played a big role for a short time in Harrys life, with the whole godfatherlyness and such, but he never came off as the type that would be able to do as much for Harry ans Dumbledore. Actually I cant see how he would fit into the book anymore. And Dumbledore too had to die. Harry DOES need to face this all on his own. It was his prophecy to defeat or be defeated, not Dumbledores, nor anyone elses. Dumbledore helped when and where he could, passed on what Harry needed to know, and went. It was his time, as sad as it is.
Though ever since the 4 book I knew Dumbledore would die... he was way to close to Harry...
Harry shouldn't have to face everything on his own... such as finding the Horcrux... he should just kill Voldemort on his own, which is what the prophecy says...I am now simply marveling at the fact that I have found someone who I disagree with on so far everything. I dont see how Dumbledore was anymore foolish than any other human. Everyone makes mistakes, he said so himself. He may be portrayed as the best wizard through Harrys eyes, and all such glorius nonsense, but he was ONLY human. How much is one person allowed to be perfect? He had to do SOMEthing wrong. And I think, if Harry were to be alone in ANY way [I dont see it happening] it would only be to protect his friends. I mean, we've seen how Voldemort hid the horcruxs, thats dangerous. Although they will all find a way to help him, anyways.
|
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Aug 24, 2005 11:30 am
KitsuneTsuki Kevin Black KitsuneTsuki Kim, I simply adore your cheery outlook 4laugh But really, I have to disagree with you Kevin. Sirius wasnt as important as you make him sound. I mean, he played a big role for a short time in Harrys life, with the whole godfatherlyness and such, but he never came off as the type that would be able to do as much for Harry ans Dumbledore. Actually I cant see how he would fit into the book anymore. And Dumbledore too had to die. Harry DOES need to face this all on his own. It was his prophecy to defeat or be defeated, not Dumbledores, nor anyone elses. Dumbledore helped when and where he could, passed on what Harry needed to know, and went. It was his time, as sad as it is.
Though ever since the 4 book I knew Dumbledore would die... he was way to close to Harry...
Harry shouldn't have to face everything on his own... such as finding the Horcrux... he should just kill Voldemort on his own, which is what the prophecy says...I am now simply marveling at the fact that I have found someone who I disagree with on so far everything. I dont see how Dumbledore was anymore foolish than any other human. Everyone makes mistakes, he said so himself. He may be portrayed as the best wizard through Harrys eyes, and all such glorius nonsense, but he was ONLY human. How much is one person allowed to be perfect? He had to do SOMEthing wrong. And I think, if Harry were to be alone in ANY way [I dont see it happening] it would only be to protect his friends. I mean, we've seen how Voldemort hid the horcruxs, thats dangerous. Although they will all find a way to help him, anyways.
Though I one last thing to say...
For someone that was so powerful, so long...
How can Snape possibly betray him for 16 years..
I think Snape was taking Dumbledore's orders...
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Aug 24, 2005 2:22 pm
Kevin Black KitsuneTsuki Kevin Black KitsuneTsuki Kim, I simply adore your cheery outlook 4laugh But really, I have to disagree with you Kevin. Sirius wasnt as important as you make him sound. I mean, he played a big role for a short time in Harrys life, with the whole godfatherlyness and such, but he never came off as the type that would be able to do as much for Harry ans Dumbledore. Actually I cant see how he would fit into the book anymore. And Dumbledore too had to die. Harry DOES need to face this all on his own. It was his prophecy to defeat or be defeated, not Dumbledores, nor anyone elses. Dumbledore helped when and where he could, passed on what Harry needed to know, and went. It was his time, as sad as it is.
Though ever since the 4 book I knew Dumbledore would die... he was way to close to Harry...
Harry shouldn't have to face everything on his own... such as finding the Horcrux... he should just kill Voldemort on his own, which is what the prophecy says...I am now simply marveling at the fact that I have found someone who I disagree with on so far everything. I dont see how Dumbledore was anymore foolish than any other human. Everyone makes mistakes, he said so himself. He may be portrayed as the best wizard through Harrys eyes, and all such glorius nonsense, but he was ONLY human. How much is one person allowed to be perfect? He had to do SOMEthing wrong. And I think, if Harry were to be alone in ANY way [I dont see it happening] it would only be to protect his friends. I mean, we've seen how Voldemort hid the horcruxs, thats dangerous. Although they will all find a way to help him, anyways.
Though I one last thing to say...
For someone that was so powerful, so long...
How can Snape possibly betray him for 16 years..
I think Snape was taking Dumbledore's orders...
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Aug 24, 2005 5:47 pm
KimCL Kevin Black KitsuneTsuki Kevin Black KitsuneTsuki Kim, I simply adore your cheery outlook 4laugh But really, I have to disagree with you Kevin. Sirius wasnt as important as you make him sound. I mean, he played a big role for a short time in Harrys life, with the whole godfatherlyness and such, but he never came off as the type that would be able to do as much for Harry ans Dumbledore. Actually I cant see how he would fit into the book anymore. And Dumbledore too had to die. Harry DOES need to face this all on his own. It was his prophecy to defeat or be defeated, not Dumbledores, nor anyone elses. Dumbledore helped when and where he could, passed on what Harry needed to know, and went. It was his time, as sad as it is.
Though ever since the 4 book I knew Dumbledore would die... he was way to close to Harry...
Harry shouldn't have to face everything on his own... such as finding the Horcrux... he should just kill Voldemort on his own, which is what the prophecy says...I am now simply marveling at the fact that I have found someone who I disagree with on so far everything. I dont see how Dumbledore was anymore foolish than any other human. Everyone makes mistakes, he said so himself. He may be portrayed as the best wizard through Harrys eyes, and all such glorius nonsense, but he was ONLY human. How much is one person allowed to be perfect? He had to do SOMEthing wrong. And I think, if Harry were to be alone in ANY way [I dont see it happening] it would only be to protect his friends. I mean, we've seen how Voldemort hid the horcruxs, thats dangerous. Although they will all find a way to help him, anyways.
Though I one last thing to say...
For someone that was so powerful, so long...
How can Snape possibly betray him for 16 years..
I think Snape was taking Dumbledore's orders...
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sun Aug 28, 2005 7:51 pm
I love(d?) Sirius. And maybe he's not even dead...maybe he's just floating through oblivion and one day he'll be found again? One can hope.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sun Aug 28, 2005 9:47 pm
Kevin Black KimCL Kevin Black KitsuneTsuki Kevin Black KitsuneTsuki Kim, I simply adore your cheery outlook 4laugh But really, I have to disagree with you Kevin. Sirius wasnt as important as you make him sound. I mean, he played a big role for a short time in Harrys life, with the whole godfatherlyness and such, but he never came off as the type that would be able to do as much for Harry ans Dumbledore. Actually I cant see how he would fit into the book anymore. And Dumbledore too had to die. Harry DOES need to face this all on his own. It was his prophecy to defeat or be defeated, not Dumbledores, nor anyone elses. Dumbledore helped when and where he could, passed on what Harry needed to know, and went. It was his time, as sad as it is.
Though ever since the 4 book I knew Dumbledore would die... he was way to close to Harry...
Harry shouldn't have to face everything on his own... such as finding the Horcrux... he should just kill Voldemort on his own, which is what the prophecy says...I am now simply marveling at the fact that I have found someone who I disagree with on so far everything. I dont see how Dumbledore was anymore foolish than any other human. Everyone makes mistakes, he said so himself. He may be portrayed as the best wizard through Harrys eyes, and all such glorius nonsense, but he was ONLY human. How much is one person allowed to be perfect? He had to do SOMEthing wrong. And I think, if Harry were to be alone in ANY way [I dont see it happening] it would only be to protect his friends. I mean, we've seen how Voldemort hid the horcruxs, thats dangerous. Although they will all find a way to help him, anyways.
Though I one last thing to say...
For someone that was so powerful, so long...
How can Snape possibly betray him for 16 years..
I think Snape was taking Dumbledore's orders...Dont hop on the bandwagon, individuality is neat. Ill lay down and take up all the room so you cant anyways xp hehe But yeah, I think Snape was acting on Dumbledores orders. Totally.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Thu Sep 01, 2005 12:53 am
I don't think Sirius should have died. In his letters to Harry, he gave a sense of home and stability, even though Harry was stuck in the muggle's house. He was Harry's link to his parents, whom he never got to know. He stood up to Snape for Harry because he loved Harry. And that is just it. Sirius loved Harry! Not in a slash pairing type of way, but in a paternal way. Harry didn't have a lot of that in his life. Sirius, from the beginning, loved Harry no matter what. He tried to be there for him whenever he could. He also faced uncertain, and untimely, death to go rescue Harry from the Department of Mysteries. Sirius loved Harry with all his heart. He was the son Sirius never got the chance to have. Sirius Black will be missed in the hearts of all Harry Potter fans. 
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sun Sep 04, 2005 6:17 pm
why did sirius have to die it is like Voldamort is out to get every one that gets close to him
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sun Sep 04, 2005 6:22 pm
jazzgirl101 why did sirius have to die it is like Voldamort is out to get every one that gets close to him That's exactly what Voldemort is doing! But one of these days he is going to push too hard and Harry is going to BRING HIM DOWN!
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sun Sep 04, 2005 7:31 pm
Departed Memories I think Sirius might not be dead. He could burst out of the veil in the last book and go save Harry''s life, then tell him something like "I couldn''t stay in there. Not when I knew how much you all needed me!" He did escape Azkaban, after all. But if not, Harry will probably make another trip to the veil and hear Sirius'' voice whispering along with all the others. Something like that. I could be competely wrong, though. but that would mean they would end up back in the department of msyterys ( i CANNOT spell) why would JK do that??
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Mon Sep 26, 2005 5:29 pm
Ahh, Sirius. How I love thee.
I actually kind of liked the way he died. It was interesting and different which is what I think he would have wanted [not that he wanted to die but you know]. How many wizards have fallen through a veil of mystery? Well I guess we don't know that but nobody besides him has throughout the series. It also left hope that he could possibly come back, however doubtful that is. If he had to go I think that was the best way.
I really want to write all about why I love him but so...tired... ~
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
