Welcome to Gaia! ::

point one: Island in danger
point two : satalite phone is bringing MORE danger, Karl believes this
point three: if Karl belives he is saving Alex and the entire island by wrestling the phone away from Jack, why would he think Alex didn't want him to?

Point one: by the island, I mean everyone on it. Others, Losties, French Woman, everyone is in danger, that includes Karl, that includes Alex

Point Two: thats the assumption my entire theory is based on, we could argue whether or not he does once I've gotten my main thought through to you

Point Three: *calms myself down* It doesn't matter whose side she's on, everyone is in danger, I don't think Karl would take into consideration who he's wrestling the phone away from if he was doing it to save everyone, including Alex.... I've repeated this at least twice, what about it are you not grasping?

Point one: mrgreen

Point two: mrgreen

Point three: Yes, I think she would, but I don't think he'd pay much attention if he was doing it to save her. She wouldn't really be aware of why he was doing it, he'd have to explain later.

you think she would? jump between two wrestling guys fighting over a phone? I wouldn't.

... Alex... sweatdrop yeah she would but I'm not sure if she'd get very far!

He would shake her off and grab the phone, its for her own good after all.

Why? He's trying to save her life here, she says no let me die, he's going to listen to that?

1. Benry lying is not the issue, the issue is whether Karlito believes him or not

2. Oi! Benry doesn't lie, except when he lies! Its a simple principal. That being, when he is lying, the show gives more than enough foreshadowing! Thus is the statement 'Ben always lies' an incorrect one.