He was alarmed when her head smacked the rain-slick ground--so alarmed he just sort of gaped stupidly for a minute while the strangers did all the heavy lifting, not that that was unusual when Amity tried to tangle himself up in a fight--and then even more alarmed (and maybe, despite himself, impressed) when she miraculously recovered.
So apparently he wasn't the only one who could do something like that.
Fine.He darted ahead of her to root around in the spoils and grab up his prizes.
For some reason, he just kept staring at them, with a stirring in the back of his head that suggested something important.