Welcome to Gaia! ::

UnderGaia~

Back to Guilds

The original UnderGaia guild, encompassing the entire world beneath Gaia. 

Tags: Drow, Underdark, Dark Elves 

Reply DARK ELVEN LORE --- History, culture, lore, myths and magic of the UnderGaia races
UnderGaia Canon Discussion Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3 4 [>] [»|]

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Reader Count
  +1
View Results

Catlander
Captain

Ruthless Capitalist

9,800 Points
  • Money Never Sleeps 200
  • Tycoon 200
  • Wall Street 200
PostPosted: Mon Dec 20, 2010 11:11 pm


Veldrin the Shadow
I believe he stated explicitly that the guild name should be the only remaining reference to Gaia. I think it's safe to say that none of us have any intention of changing the name of the guild.

As far as race relations go...I don't think we've gotten around to that part yet.


Nope, as Veldrin accurately states, I'm not suggesting a guild name change, and yes, I agree with keeping the world/setting nameless for now.

Other species of critters in the underdark and their relations? Good question.

I think we should just start immediately with those which are immediately useful to the drow... especially slave species. Also maybe livestock and/or predators in the near underdark as well as mounts. Less explored/civilized areas don't need to be examined yet methinks.

As to non-intelligent beasties, I think it's safe to say, at least in Lolthite areas, Spiders are going to be the most common critter eh? Different types of bats might be next on the list, with lizards of various types being third most common.

Also to address previous input from people about humans being created last by the gods... I think that it doesn't mean that the the gods couldn't have used the same genetic building kit to develop halflings, dwarves, elves and humans. I don't think it matters who came first, and I think that the whole "dropping the mold" thing was intentionally ambiguous as it was supposed to represent D&D's attempt at mythmaking. It's not meant to be taken literally.

My opinion: all demi-humans should be considered breedable with each other, and other humanoids such as goblinoids and giants should not be considered in this class so as not to allow half-goblin half-dwarves. This makes the most sense even if the creation of the races happened by gods and not genetic evolution I think. I do agree though, with previous input that breeding between demi-human races should be less likely to produce offspring than normal.
PostPosted: Mon Dec 20, 2010 11:26 pm


Ah, racial relations... almost an oxymoron in UnderGaia unless you consider constant open/subvert warfare, enslavement, and in some cases eating others to be considered relations xd

I jest though, I agree with Drae on the point for discussing those beneath the drow before going on to races equal in power, or greater, just yet. I perfectly agree with the order set forth for Lolthite cities, which brings into question the order in cities not so... Lolth-crazy, Au-Shinduago for example. These places would no doubt still have their fair share of spiders, but I think that bats or lizards might take up the spot for most numerous (This of course doesn't take into account other vermin races). As for slaves species, well that one is a bit harder to think about isn't it. I'd assume that slaves that are of more use to their masters would subsequently stand higher in relation to other slaves, though that is just a personal opinion on the matter. Predator and livestock wise though, yikes... there are so many different predators and so few livestock that it is somewhat... unbalanced. For each single livestock race you easily have a dozen predators that would gladly devour it.

Captain Chemosh

Romantic Prophet

8,550 Points
  • Elocutionist 200
  • Money Never Sleeps 200
  • Tycoon 200

Catlander
Captain

Ruthless Capitalist

9,800 Points
  • Money Never Sleeps 200
  • Tycoon 200
  • Wall Street 200
PostPosted: Tue Dec 21, 2010 12:51 am


Well Chem, there are the shaggy underdark bovine-like beasts known as rothen (incidentally the drow word 'rothe' is also used to describe a slave; singular 'rothe' plural 'rothen'). Drow use these as their livestock. A total stretch of reality but, this is fantasy so, we can suspend our disbelief in honor of Salvatore, who first introduced these critters. An entire ecosystem supposedly thrives on underdark mammals and mushrooms... yeah, completely unlikely... but that's ok, we will make it work, haha.

Since everyone likes the idea of only humans being able to produce half-anything, I will go ahead and concede the point. 3nodding You guys win... AGAIN! hehe.

So Aglo, I think we've actually decided on at least one thing so far, yippie!

About non-lolthite cities of drow... they could have spiders for sure, just not as venerated. In some sources, drow are said to have an affinity for spiders regardless of Lolth worship. I don't really have an opinion on this, so I remain neutral on this point.
PostPosted: Tue Dec 21, 2010 10:21 am


Actually I have found an older reference to Rothe in the novel Cormyr by Ed Greenwood and Jeff Grubb (1996), though this is an assumption that Salvatore used the term after this book was produced. Anyways, in the book Rothe are described as forest buffalo, which are smaller than a plains buffalo. But I detract from the reason why I posted in the first place, I concede on the point that drow might be considered to have an affinity towards spiders and thus have them in a good amount in every city. So... what have we set in stone, or close to it, so far?

Captain Chemosh

Romantic Prophet

8,550 Points
  • Elocutionist 200
  • Money Never Sleeps 200
  • Tycoon 200

Catlander
Captain

Ruthless Capitalist

9,800 Points
  • Money Never Sleeps 200
  • Tycoon 200
  • Wall Street 200
PostPosted: Tue Dec 21, 2010 3:18 pm


Captain Chemosh
Actually I have found an older reference to Rothe in the novel Cormyr by Ed Greenwood and Jeff Grubb (1996), though this is an assumption that Salvatore used the term after this book was produced. Anyways, in the book Rothe are described as forest buffalo, which are smaller than a plains buffalo. But I detract from the reason why I posted in the first place, I concede on the point that drow might be considered to have an affinity towards spiders and thus have them in a good amount in every city. So... what have we set in stone, or close to it, so far?


Ah, good hunting Chem... Greenwood invented Rothe (this means even the TOL in coining "rothe" as a drow word have booboo'd which I never thought possible).

Okay, anyone challenge the notion that drow have an affinity with spiders despite or regardless of Lolth?

On elven physiology, let's ignore the question for now as it's a small issue that would take longer to hash out.

I think we have decided (unless someone challenges it):

1) drow have black skin (if another color, then another name besides drow)

2) elves of any type can only breed with each other, or humans outside of their race if they expect any surviving offspring

Let's talk about hair and eye color next...

Here is a list of elven traits that I recommend as most common for each sub-race:

Grey Elves: white, silver or platinum blonde hair and amber or violet eyes; pale skin; average height = 5'6"

High Elves: brown or black hair and green eyes; pale skin; average height = 5'4"

Wood Elves: coppery red to blonde hair and green or hazel eyes; fair skin; average height = 5'4"

Drow Elves: white hair (with females occasionally showing blonde) and red, amber, yellow, or violet eyes; jet-black skin; average height = 5'2"

Grugach Elves: <---I find this race redundant and think that if someone really wants to play a grugach, just combine the bloodlines of really short statured high and wood elves and isolate them as a population... voila! Grugach! I say don't bother with this race unless someone insists.

Valley Elves: <----No, just no. This is a greyhawk specific race and though I love greyhawk, valley elves are "Like oh m'god" stupid when used anywhere but GH.

Other Elven Races: <---please add them if you think you want to use them. Purple and blue skinned and haired races were mentioned as desirable. If so, do the work to detail them. If not, let's leave it until someone actually wants to invent them.

So, anyone want to challenge this stuff? Please do so now. If you support the info as is, please also state this fact.
PostPosted: Tue Dec 21, 2010 3:29 pm


Jeffrey Boyd Garrison
Captain Chemosh
Actually I have found an older reference to Rothe in the novel Cormyr by Ed Greenwood and Jeff Grubb (1996), though this is an assumption that Salvatore used the term after this book was produced. Anyways, in the book Rothe are described as forest buffalo, which are smaller than a plains buffalo. But I detract from the reason why I posted in the first place, I concede on the point that drow might be considered to have an affinity towards spiders and thus have them in a good amount in every city. So... what have we set in stone, or close to it, so far?


Ah, good hunting Chem... Greenwood invented Rothe (this means even the TOL in coining "rothe" as a drow word have booboo'd which I never thought possible).

Okay, anyone challenge the notion that drow have an affinity with spiders despite or regardless of Lolth?

On elven physiology, let's ignore the question for now as it's a small issue that would take longer to hash out.

I think we have decided (unless someone challenges it):

1) drow have black skin (if another color, then another name besides drow)

2) elves of any type can only breed with each other, or humans outside of their race if they expect any surviving offspring

Let's talk about hair and eye color next...

Here is a list of elven traits that I recommend as most common for each sub-race:

Grey Elves: white, silver or platinum blonde hair and amber or violet eyes; pale skin; average height = 5'6"

High Elves: brown or black hair and green eyes; pale skin; average height = 5'4"

Wood Elves: coppery red to blonde hair and green or hazel eyes; fair skin; average height = 5'4"

Drow Elves: white hair (with females occasionally showing blonde) and red, amber, yellow, or violet eyes; jet-black skin; average height = 5'2"

Grugach Elves: <---I find this race redundant and think that if someone really wants to play a grugach, just combine the bloodlines of really short statured high and wood elves and isolate them as a population... voila! Grugach! I say don't bother with this race unless someone insists.

Valley Elves: <----No, just no. This is a greyhawk specific race and though I love greyhawk, valley elves are "Like oh m'god" stupid when used anywhere but GH.

Other Elven Races: <---please add them if you think you want to use them. Purple and blue skinned and haired races were mentioned as desirable. If so, do the work to detail them. If not, let's leave it until someone actually wants to invent them.

So, anyone want to challenge this stuff? Please do so now. If you support the info as is, please also state this fact.



works for me...

Veldrin the Shadow
Crew

Shadowy Rogue

17,075 Points
  • Battle: Rogue 100
  • Battle: KO 200
  • Battle: Counterstrike 150

Catwagon
Crew

Business Businesswoman

7,350 Points
  • Ultimate Player 200
  • Elocutionist 200
  • Tycoon 200
PostPosted: Tue Dec 21, 2010 4:55 pm


I haven't read through all the posting here yet, as I'm on a tiny netbook an s**t's hard to read, but here's my take and what direction I would like to see the guild go.

I've always taken the name "Undergaia" to be sort of metaphorical. We are the "underdogs" of Gaia, our world is a darker one-- and although I do like the idear of being Gaia's "evil twin" I think that the vote of the majority is inclined towards being a separate world. Perhaps we can still include the Gaia universe, but being directly under the cities and towns seems rather impractical with the way most people are going.

I'd more or less prefer we have our own world, and I would like to include a stronger dynamic between the surface world and the dark below-- maybe even have a plot centralized around the conflict of the two. That way we could attract more folks who prefer standard fantasy fare, and satisfy the people down below itching for developed conflict instead of just petty spats between cities.

That way, there would basically be two factions, a surface faction and an underark faction, with sub-factions between the two (cities, etc). I'd still like to leave it up to the faction leaders to nitpick what they want in their ranks, because that's part of what makes Undergaia fun.

I just think it's time we made some changes that would allow us to expand our ranks and give everyone fresh ideas.
PostPosted: Tue Dec 21, 2010 9:42 pm


Thank you very much Draevir. For the elven races Drae mentioned, I am all in favor as he listed them. I would like to add the following race.

Star Elves: Gold, red, or silver-white hair and amber or violet eyes; pale skin with occasional pearly gray or faint violet tinge; average height = Between 5 1/2 and 6 ft.
The Star Elves are FR canon from the Unapproachable East supplement.

I also agree with Serethiel's idea about having a distinct surface realm which opposes those of the world below. To add to her idea of a plot central to the two I suggest perhaps the classic opposition of deities, racial betrayal, or perhaps the need to flee from the surface due to the actions of other races; I will expound upon the last idea as the two are familiar. Perhaps two other races, such as humans and orcs as a rough example, have been going to war for so long that they are slowly destroying areas inhabited by dark elves. The dark elves are noticed by the budding demoness Lolth, who lures them down to the world below with promises of new life. Once down there they find it much harder but Lolth, being the chaotically evil genius she is, has prepared for this and gives power to the female priestesses that have been loyal to her. The dark elves, over centuries, evolve into drow both from natural influences as well as Lolth slowly changing them to make them more useful to her. Anyway, an extended length of time passes and the drow (and much smaller amount of surviving dark elves) find they must return to the surface (at least in part) to gather resources and find out if the war had ended. The war actually did end and High elves (who disliked the dark elves and now hate the drow for their worship of a demon) try to kill/maim/stop the drow from returning to the surface (Lolth meanwhile plays her pieces to see if she can't get all of the surface elves killed). Drow retaliate against this aggression/suppression and wage covert/total war against the High elves. The other races (including the other elven subraces) are torn between helping the drow to return or denying them their return.

I'd like to say that entire idea was completely spontaneous...

Captain Chemosh

Romantic Prophet

8,550 Points
  • Elocutionist 200
  • Money Never Sleeps 200
  • Tycoon 200

Catlander
Captain

Ruthless Capitalist

9,800 Points
  • Money Never Sleeps 200
  • Tycoon 200
  • Wall Street 200
PostPosted: Wed Dec 22, 2010 2:49 am


Check this out...
PostPosted: Wed Dec 22, 2010 11:18 am


Can I ask a question...beside this one, that is.
(if you don't want to answer don't read further)

I've fallen behind slight in the post here, so I'm not sure if this has been discussed. Are we adding on to pre-existing worlds (combined ideas from D&D and Forgetten, or adding modified concepts of the Gaian world...like medieval Gaia or some such) or are we building a new world from collected ideas?

I ask because I want to know whether the world we have at this moment will be changed. From what I'm read, we're build a new world from concepts. However, there seems to be hesitation, maybe on straying the already taken path. I'm not 100% sure on my thoughts here. It just from what I've read so far in this discussion.

Antique Ink

5,650 Points
  • Treasure Hunter 100
  • Member 100
  • Forum Regular 100

Catlander
Captain

Ruthless Capitalist

9,800 Points
  • Money Never Sleeps 200
  • Tycoon 200
  • Wall Street 200
PostPosted: Wed Dec 22, 2010 3:53 pm


Antique, the concensus so far is, we're not gonna use the Gaia world. We're making a new one and it's not been named yet. The guild will still be called UnderGaia but the world will not be associated in any way with Gaia (so no Barton, Durem, Gambino, Von Helsons, etc.).

Whether we use more original ideas, D&D Forgotten Realms and World of Greyhawk, or L. Ron Hubbard's Scientology as sources for this, is all dependant on this discussion.
PostPosted: Thu Dec 23, 2010 7:44 am


I haven't gone through and read back any either, but from what I glanced over you guys are getting waaaaaay technical. Like with Aglo wanting elves to be multi colored, and having it where you can only mate with a human and no other species.........

I don't want to peel back the flesh all the way to the bone, if you get what I'm saying. Some things should stay the same. Like creatures....what I'm more interested in settling is Pantheon issue. Where does Lolth stand? Are we placing it before or after her transformation? Things like the Farezz...or however the ******** you spell that magic ******** ******** stuff...

Quenthal
Crew

Greedy Genius


dot_hack_ver2

2,050 Points
  • Hygienic 200
  • Signature Look 250
  • Dressed Up 200
PostPosted: Thu Dec 23, 2010 11:10 am


My suggestion lets have an alternate pantheon we can keep some of the d&d stuff but lets add our own flavor to it make it something more our own
PostPosted: Thu Dec 23, 2010 3:10 pm


Okay Quen. The reason I created "one" canon discussion is because we've had topics before on various issues, but because they were spread out in different threads perhaps, few of us read them or paticipated.

How long is a drow preggers? or, how old is a baby drow when he goes to kidnergarten? How does infravision work? Things like that were looked at. Because those were simply discussions and people didn't actually decide anything, they couldn't really be referred to as "rules."

Anyhow Quen, I see your point about trying to hash every little thing out right here in one thread. Still, I mean, it feels like we did accomplish a little bit here at least? sweatdrop What I was gonna do is see about putting this info in our own little UG wiki type thread. Maybe we could just link to multiple threads which "discuss" the issues w/o actually making hard fast rules? How best would you like to approach it Quen?

Catlander
Captain

Ruthless Capitalist

9,800 Points
  • Money Never Sleeps 200
  • Tycoon 200
  • Wall Street 200

Captain Chemosh

Romantic Prophet

8,550 Points
  • Elocutionist 200
  • Money Never Sleeps 200
  • Tycoon 200
PostPosted: Thu Dec 23, 2010 5:17 pm


Faerzress, yeah I know it is a pain of a word to remember and spell correctly. I'm siding with dot hack on the panteon idea, an alternative one with Lolth and the rest of the drow deities in it, pulling in some other deities for flavor into an UnderGaia pantheon, or whatever the new name for the world below might become.

I do believe there is already a UG wiki, I don't think it has gotten much attention though. We could possibly hold these discussions here and when a decision has been fairly made with multiple people in agreement we could put them in the wiki proper.
Reply
DARK ELVEN LORE --- History, culture, lore, myths and magic of the UnderGaia races

Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3 4 [>] [»|]
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum