Welcome to Gaia! ::

Reply Gaia Gun Enthusiasts
SKS vs M1 Carbine vs AR-15 Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3 4 [>] [»|]

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

What gun has the best overall value?
  The SKS (≈300$)
  The M1 Carbine (≈900$)
  The AR-15 (≈700$)
  Other (Please specify. Must fire an intermediate cartridge and be semi-automatic.)
View Results

Shrantic

PostPosted: Wed Oct 28, 2009 5:08 pm


OberFeldwebel
I would add to my post but the quote edit and delete buttons are gone.


If you're thinking of putting a scope on the SKS and expecting a sniper, no.
Yeah, I don't expect that at all. I'm not an expert marksman, I just want a rifle/carbine with an intermediate cartridge that's passably accurate up to 200 yards. I don't need a 1,000+ dollar sniper rifle firing rounds that cost 2 bucks a piece or anything.
Quote:


Any mounts, other than D&T wont hold zero, also it's the design, they're not that accurate and it's the round too, not accurate.
I understand. By the way, I may load my own rounds eventually. (To pass time and to get a bit more accurate rounds for a bit more money.)
Quote:



Well, the SKSs are made for human sized targets at 100 yards.
It is possible to hit a pie plate at 200 yards with an SKS I don't doubt that, but I wouldn't stake my life on it.
Nor would I, but I don't really need to.
PostPosted: Wed Oct 28, 2009 5:10 pm


Shrantic
OberFeldwebel
I would add to my post but the quote edit and delete buttons are gone.


If you're thinking of putting a scope on the SKS and expecting a sniper, no.
Yeah, I don't expect that at all. I'm not an expert marksman, I just want a rifle/carbine with an intermediate cartridge that's passably accurate up to 200 yards. I don't need a 1,000+ dollar sniper rifle firing rounds that cost 2 bucks a piece or anything.
Quote:


Any mounts, other than D&T wont hold zero, also it's the design, they're not that accurate and it's the round too, not accurate.
I understand. By the way, I may load my own rounds eventually. (To pass time and to get a bit more accurate rounds for a bit more money.)
Quote:



Well, the SKSs are made for human sized targets at 100 yards.
It is possible to hit a pie plate at 200 yards with an SKS I don't doubt that, but I wouldn't stake my life on it.
Nor would I, but I don't really need to.
Reloading will usually end up cheaper by-round than factory.

uryu ishida


OberFeldwebel

PostPosted: Wed Oct 28, 2009 5:16 pm


uryu ishida
Shrantic
OberFeldwebel
I would add to my post but the quote edit and delete buttons are gone.


If you're thinking of putting a scope on the SKS and expecting a sniper, no.
Yeah, I don't expect that at all. I'm not an expert marksman, I just want a rifle/carbine with an intermediate cartridge that's passably accurate up to 200 yards. I don't need a 1,000+ dollar sniper rifle firing rounds that cost 2 bucks a piece or anything.
Quote:


Any mounts, other than D&T wont hold zero, also it's the design, they're not that accurate and it's the round too, not accurate.
I understand. By the way, I may load my own rounds eventually. (To pass time and to get a bit more accurate rounds for a bit more money.)
Quote:



Well, the SKSs are made for human sized targets at 100 yards.
It is possible to hit a pie plate at 200 yards with an SKS I don't doubt that, but I wouldn't stake my life on it.
Nor would I, but I don't really need to.
Reloading will usually end up cheaper by-round than factory.


The edit button is gone again!
FFS!!!


Anyway,

http://www.surplusrifleforum.com/viewtopic.php?f=78&t=85431&p=618720&hilit=7.62x39+accuracy#p618720
PostPosted: Wed Oct 28, 2009 5:31 pm


uryu ishida
Shrantic
OberFeldwebel
I would add to my post but the quote edit and delete buttons are gone.


If you're thinking of putting a scope on the SKS and expecting a sniper, no.
Yeah, I don't expect that at all. I'm not an expert marksman, I just want a rifle/carbine with an intermediate cartridge that's passably accurate up to 200 yards. I don't need a 1,000+ dollar sniper rifle firing rounds that cost 2 bucks a piece or anything.
Quote:


Any mounts, other than D&T wont hold zero, also it's the design, they're not that accurate and it's the round too, not accurate.
I understand. By the way, I may load my own rounds eventually. (To pass time and to get a bit more accurate rounds for a bit more money.)
Quote:



Well, the SKSs are made for human sized targets at 100 yards.
It is possible to hit a pie plate at 200 yards with an SKS I don't doubt that, but I wouldn't stake my life on it.
Nor would I, but I don't really need to.
Reloading will usually end up cheaper by-round than factory.
Cheaper than 10¢ a round wolf ammo? O_o;

Shrantic


OberFeldwebel

PostPosted: Wed Oct 28, 2009 5:46 pm


Shrantic
uryu ishida
Shrantic
OberFeldwebel
I would add to my post but the quote edit and delete buttons are gone.


If you're thinking of putting a scope on the SKS and expecting a sniper, no.
Yeah, I don't expect that at all. I'm not an expert marksman, I just want a rifle/carbine with an intermediate cartridge that's passably accurate up to 200 yards. I don't need a 1,000+ dollar sniper rifle firing rounds that cost 2 bucks a piece or anything.
Quote:


Any mounts, other than D&T wont hold zero, also it's the design, they're not that accurate and it's the round too, not accurate.
I understand. By the way, I may load my own rounds eventually. (To pass time and to get a bit more accurate rounds for a bit more money.)
Quote:



Well, the SKSs are made for human sized targets at 100 yards.
It is possible to hit a pie plate at 200 yards with an SKS I don't doubt that, but I wouldn't stake my life on it.
Nor would I, but I don't really need to.
Reloading will usually end up cheaper by-round than factory.
Cheaper than 10¢ a round wolf ammo? O_o;


Lol true
But Wolf is steel cased and non-reloadable.

With reloadable stuff you can squeeze the groups a little tighter if you know what you're doing.

Also the Wolf stuff with that little hole isn't really a hollow point, they don't expand worth a damn.


I found this.

http://www.surplusrifle.com/reviews2005/sksscoutscopemnt/index.asp
PostPosted: Wed Oct 28, 2009 5:57 pm


OberFeldwebel
Shrantic
uryu ishida
Shrantic
OberFeldwebel
I would add to my post but the quote edit and delete buttons are gone.


If you're thinking of putting a scope on the SKS and expecting a sniper, no.
Yeah, I don't expect that at all. I'm not an expert marksman, I just want a rifle/carbine with an intermediate cartridge that's passably accurate up to 200 yards. I don't need a 1,000+ dollar sniper rifle firing rounds that cost 2 bucks a piece or anything.
Quote:


Any mounts, other than D&T wont hold zero, also it's the design, they're not that accurate and it's the round too, not accurate.
I understand. By the way, I may load my own rounds eventually. (To pass time and to get a bit more accurate rounds for a bit more money.)
Quote:



Well, the SKSs are made for human sized targets at 100 yards.
It is possible to hit a pie plate at 200 yards with an SKS I don't doubt that, but I wouldn't stake my life on it.
Nor would I, but I don't really need to.
Reloading will usually end up cheaper by-round than factory.
Cheaper than 10¢ a round wolf ammo? O_o;


Lol true
But Wolf is steel cased and non-reloadable.

With reloadable stuff you can squeeze the groups a little tighter if you know what you're doing.

Also the Wolf stuff with that little hole isn't really a hollow point, they don't expand worth a damn.


I found this.

http://www.surplusrifle.com/reviews2005/sksscoutscopemnt/index.asp
Oh, I don't plan on reloading, but just plain old loading. Making my own cartridges. I hear that after you get good at it and find the right stuff, you can make your own cartridges that are sometimes far superior to even match-grade ammo.

Shrantic


uryu ishida

PostPosted: Wed Oct 28, 2009 6:00 pm


Shrantic
OberFeldwebel
Shrantic
uryu ishida
Shrantic
Yeah, I don't expect that at all. I'm not an expert marksman, I just want a rifle/carbine with an intermediate cartridge that's passably accurate up to 200 yards. I don't need a 1,000+ dollar sniper rifle firing rounds that cost 2 bucks a piece or anything. I understand. By the way, I may load my own rounds eventually. (To pass time and to get a bit more accurate rounds for a bit more money.)Nor would I, but I don't really need to.
Reloading will usually end up cheaper by-round than factory.
Cheaper than 10¢ a round wolf ammo? O_o;


Lol true
But Wolf is steel cased and non-reloadable.

With reloadable stuff you can squeeze the groups a little tighter if you know what you're doing.

Also the Wolf stuff with that little hole isn't really a hollow point, they don't expand worth a damn.


I found this.

http://www.surplusrifle.com/reviews2005/sksscoutscopemnt/index.asp
Oh, I don't plan on reloading, but just plain old loading. Making my own cartridges. I hear that after you get good at it and find the right stuff, you can make your own cartridges that are sometimes far superior to even match-grade ammo.
THat's still reloading.

You are re-loading components. Even using virgin brass it's considered reloading.
And it's even CHEAPER to reload, when you use brass-cased ammo, because you don't have to buy more brass. Just take the time to pick it up at the range.
PostPosted: Wed Oct 28, 2009 6:02 pm


Shrantic
OberFeldwebel
Shrantic
uryu ishida
Shrantic
Yeah, I don't expect that at all. I'm not an expert marksman, I just want a rifle/carbine with an intermediate cartridge that's passably accurate up to 200 yards. I don't need a 1,000+ dollar sniper rifle firing rounds that cost 2 bucks a piece or anything. I understand. By the way, I may load my own rounds eventually. (To pass time and to get a bit more accurate rounds for a bit more money.)Nor would I, but I don't really need to.
Reloading will usually end up cheaper by-round than factory.
Cheaper than 10¢ a round wolf ammo? O_o;


Lol true
But Wolf is steel cased and non-reloadable.

With reloadable stuff you can squeeze the groups a little tighter if you know what you're doing.

Also the Wolf stuff with that little hole isn't really a hollow point, they don't expand worth a damn.


I found this.

http://www.surplusrifle.com/reviews2005/sksscoutscopemnt/index.asp
Oh, I don't plan on reloading, but just plain old loading. Making my own cartridges. I hear that after you get good at it and find the right stuff, you can make your own cartridges that are sometimes far superior to even match-grade ammo.



Wait what?

... What are you thinking of just buying brass and precast/copper jacketed bullets and reloading that way?

You'd get experience with reloading but I don't think it'd be any cheaper or any more accurate (unless it is a good weighted bullet) than just getting Wolf stuff.

OberFeldwebel


Shrantic

PostPosted: Wed Oct 28, 2009 6:24 pm


OberFeldwebel
Shrantic
OberFeldwebel
Shrantic
uryu ishida
Shrantic
Yeah, I don't expect that at all. I'm not an expert marksman, I just want a rifle/carbine with an intermediate cartridge that's passably accurate up to 200 yards. I don't need a 1,000+ dollar sniper rifle firing rounds that cost 2 bucks a piece or anything. I understand. By the way, I may load my own rounds eventually. (To pass time and to get a bit more accurate rounds for a bit more money.)Nor would I, but I don't really need to.
Reloading will usually end up cheaper by-round than factory.
Cheaper than 10¢ a round wolf ammo? O_o;


Lol true
But Wolf is steel cased and non-reloadable.

With reloadable stuff you can squeeze the groups a little tighter if you know what you're doing.

Also the Wolf stuff with that little hole isn't really a hollow point, they don't expand worth a damn.


I found this.

http://www.surplusrifle.com/reviews2005/sksscoutscopemnt/index.asp
Oh, I don't plan on reloading, but just plain old loading. Making my own cartridges. I hear that after you get good at it and find the right stuff, you can make your own cartridges that are sometimes far superior to even match-grade ammo.



Wait what?

... What are you thinking of just buying brass and precast/copper jacketed bullets and reloading that way?

You'd get experience with reloading but I don't think it'd be any cheaper or any more accurate (unless it is a good weighted bullet) than just getting Wolf stuff.
Loading your own cartridges, if done correctly, will give you ammunition that is drastically more accurate than even match-grade ammo.

I don't plan on doing it to cut costs or really even for the extra accuracy, but as a hobby. I have a lot of free time, but not to do anything of any real enjoyment or importance. >.>
PostPosted: Wed Oct 28, 2009 6:27 pm


Shrantic
OberFeldwebel
Shrantic
OberFeldwebel
Shrantic
Cheaper than 10¢ a round wolf ammo? O_o;


Lol true
But Wolf is steel cased and non-reloadable.

With reloadable stuff you can squeeze the groups a little tighter if you know what you're doing.

Also the Wolf stuff with that little hole isn't really a hollow point, they don't expand worth a damn.


I found this.

http://www.surplusrifle.com/reviews2005/sksscoutscopemnt/index.asp
Oh, I don't plan on reloading, but just plain old loading. Making my own cartridges. I hear that after you get good at it and find the right stuff, you can make your own cartridges that are sometimes far superior to even match-grade ammo.



Wait what?

... What are you thinking of just buying brass and precast/copper jacketed bullets and reloading that way?

You'd get experience with reloading but I don't think it'd be any cheaper or any more accurate (unless it is a good weighted bullet) than just getting Wolf stuff.
Loading your own cartridges, if done correctly, will give you ammunition that is drastically more accurate than even match-grade ammo.

I don't plan on doing it to cut costs or really even for the extra accuracy, but as a hobby. I have a lot of free time, but not to do anything of any real enjoyment or importance. >.>
THAT IS RELOADING.
There is little significant difference between virgin and (properly) used brass. Used brass is cheaper to get, simply by picking it up when you're done. Load to SAAMI specs, and that brass can last a really long time.

uryu ishida


Shrantic

PostPosted: Wed Oct 28, 2009 6:48 pm


uryu ishida
Shrantic
OberFeldwebel
Shrantic
OberFeldwebel


Lol true
But Wolf is steel cased and non-reloadable.

With reloadable stuff you can squeeze the groups a little tighter if you know what you're doing.

Also the Wolf stuff with that little hole isn't really a hollow point, they don't expand worth a damn.


I found this.

http://www.surplusrifle.com/reviews2005/sksscoutscopemnt/index.asp
Oh, I don't plan on reloading, but just plain old loading. Making my own cartridges. I hear that after you get good at it and find the right stuff, you can make your own cartridges that are sometimes far superior to even match-grade ammo.



Wait what?

... What are you thinking of just buying brass and precast/copper jacketed bullets and reloading that way?

You'd get experience with reloading but I don't think it'd be any cheaper or any more accurate (unless it is a good weighted bullet) than just getting Wolf stuff.
Loading your own cartridges, if done correctly, will give you ammunition that is drastically more accurate than even match-grade ammo.

I don't plan on doing it to cut costs or really even for the extra accuracy, but as a hobby. I have a lot of free time, but not to do anything of any real enjoyment or importance. >.>
THAT IS RELOADING.
I KNOW BUT IT JUST SEEMS SO ******** WEIRD TO SAY "RELOADING" WHEN USING VIRGIN MATERIALS. gonk
Quote:

There is little significant difference between virgin and (properly) used brass. Used brass is cheaper to get, simply by picking it up when you're done. Load to SAAMI specs, and that brass can last a really long time.
Yeah, I guess I might as well use the spent casings, too, but I'm probably going to be reloading more rounds than I fire until I find a range that'll let me shoot more than single-load only. >.>

Seriously, it's barely worth it to go to that range unless you're firing high-powered rifles. And even then, the range only extends to 220 yards, so it's not like any truly experienced marksman is going to have any kind of fun or challenge. stare
PostPosted: Wed Oct 28, 2009 7:15 pm


uryu ishida
Requiem in Mortis
OberFeldwebel
I think the milsurp x39 is corrosive. I think.

I do know that the lake city .30 Carbine ammunition is non-corrosive.

Also,
$900 for an M1 Carbine?

Buying from a shop?

http://www.thecmp.org/m1carbine.htm

Get Service Grade, rack grade is near the death of the barrel or unshootable.


Is isn't very difficult to be able to get stuff from them the biggest thing is being 21.

http://www.thecmp.org/eligibility.htm


While it may take a couple months to get your order in and have it shipped you'll have about $300 to spend on ammo.

If and when you do an order, have a couple selections of makes, in case they sell out of the one.

Just looked, they sold out of mags. sad
Just looked at the Garand. Hot damn, $500 for my all-time favorite WWII battle rifle? Sign me up!

If I did, though, what grade should I go with? I want one of the grades that's under nine hundred, but I heard this talk about the rack-grade being s**t.
You'd want to spend the extra for at least a field-grade. They have an SA field-grade up for $500.
Yea, I saw it. It doesn't do me any good until I move out and get some money, but the person I'm moving in with doesn't give a damn if I own guns.

Now the apartment complex, on the other hand....

Requiem ex Inferni

Eloquent Streaker


uryu ishida

PostPosted: Wed Oct 28, 2009 7:55 pm


Requiem in Mortis
uryu ishida
Requiem in Mortis
OberFeldwebel
I think the milsurp x39 is corrosive. I think.

I do know that the lake city .30 Carbine ammunition is non-corrosive.

Also,
$900 for an M1 Carbine?

Buying from a shop?

http://www.thecmp.org/m1carbine.htm

Get Service Grade, rack grade is near the death of the barrel or unshootable.


Is isn't very difficult to be able to get stuff from them the biggest thing is being 21.

http://www.thecmp.org/eligibility.htm


While it may take a couple months to get your order in and have it shipped you'll have about $300 to spend on ammo.

If and when you do an order, have a couple selections of makes, in case they sell out of the one.

Just looked, they sold out of mags. sad
Just looked at the Garand. Hot damn, $500 for my all-time favorite WWII battle rifle? Sign me up!

If I did, though, what grade should I go with? I want one of the grades that's under nine hundred, but I heard this talk about the rack-grade being s**t.
You'd want to spend the extra for at least a field-grade. They have an SA field-grade up for $500.
Yea, I saw it. It doesn't do me any good until I move out and get some money, but the person I'm moving in with doesn't give a damn if I own guns.

Now the apartment complex, on the other hand....
Same with mine. But I don't give a s**t!
PostPosted: Thu Oct 29, 2009 2:19 am


My dad has a Chinese SKS, with a PLAA 'Red Star' scope. GOD is it a nice gun. It has absolutely NO recoil, it just shakes like mad. For the price, you could certainly do worse.

Curious though... why is it you want intermediate?

Fresnel
Crew

Citizen


Shrantic

PostPosted: Thu Oct 29, 2009 10:46 am


Fresnel
My dad has a Chinese SKS, with a PLAA 'Red Star' scope. GOD is it a nice gun. It has absolutely NO recoil, it just shakes like mad. For the price, you could certainly do worse.

Curious though... why is it you want intermediate?
Because the only guns we have either kick like mules (hunting rifles, shotguns) or can't reach out to 100 yards without dropping IMMENSELY. (.22)

Also, .30-06 is really, really expensive around here, and shotgun slugs just don't seem to agree with our shotgun. (2 foot groups at 50 yards, not human error.)
Reply
Gaia Gun Enthusiasts

Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3 4 [>] [»|]
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum