Welcome to Gaia! ::

The Doctor Who Guild

Back to Guilds

 

Tags: Doctor Who, Cyber Man, Dalek, SciFi, Banana 

Reply The Doctor Who Guild
Series Three - Good and Bad - HUGE SPOILERS! Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Martha Jones
  Good
  Bad
View Results

atrixa

PostPosted: Tue Jul 31, 2007 3:25 pm


Oh, i'd forgotten about the dalek two-parter. The fist ep was brilliant, but the second part was lacking something.
PostPosted: Sat Sep 22, 2007 7:42 pm


GOOD

-The Master
-Captain Jack
-Human Nature/Family of Blood
-Martha
-Greame Harper's directing
-Tennant's acting (especially in 42).
-Blink
-Gallifrey
-"Reverse the polarity" in-joke (one of my favourite old series quotes).
-The final three-parter
-42
-Captain Jack/the Face of Boe
-John Smith


BAD

-The former half of the series.
-Mentions of Rose (it's taking people a while to get over her, isn't it?).
-Pig slaves (this is a serious show, dammit).
-The Doctor improbably saving Lazlo's life when he was no longer necessary to the plot of EotD (callous, aren't I?).
-Still too earth-based (although not as much as the last two series).
-The Master got killed off after just three episodes. (Yes, of course he'll return, but probably a different actor. Dammit! I liked Jacobi and Simm).
-Smeagol Doctor.
-Martha leaves (she was a good companion, in my opinion).

Travis III


pikalex88

PostPosted: Fri Sep 28, 2007 4:48 pm


I don't know what so many people have against the blue suit! I love it blaugh
PostPosted: Sat Sep 29, 2007 6:32 pm


Good
-Smith and Jones
-Barefoot on the Moon
-The Shakespeare Code + Harry Potter (Good timing for the US airdate)
-Gridlock & Car Jumping
-The Face of Boe/Jack
-Dalek Sec
-The Doctor in 42
-Vote Saxon
-Martha's Family
-The Chameleon Arch
-The Weeping Angels
-Chan Tho
-Jack & Martha & The Doctor together
-Seeing Galifrey
-The Soundtrack
-John Simm (In the Tardis)

Bad
-The Christmas special wasn't as good
-The Doctor is sad about Rose
-The Doctor is kind of mean to Martha
-Pig Slaves
-There's an episode in an identifiable part of the U.S. but it's set in the 1930s and is mostly about Daleks.
-Too much Earth
-Lack of cool, new aliens
-John Smith is a jerk (though I guess it made for a suspenseful plot, since I couldn't wait to get the Doctor back...)

Mecill


Lidaby
Crew

PostPosted: Sun Sep 30, 2007 5:32 am


Ehh overall I didn't think this series was as good as the previous one. There were some pretty good episodes like Blink and... whatever else, I can't remember, but there were also some truely shocking ones (coughSHAKESPEARE CODEcough) and some pretty averages ones...

I quite liked Martha though, she's pretty cluey and I liked how she was able to ... well, how she was strong enough if you like, to leave the Doctor in the end.
There was a bit too much earth and not enough cool aliens really, but the Master was awesome, and I liked the thing about the Titanic at the end!!
PostPosted: Thu Oct 18, 2007 9:17 pm


Okay...the monster in "smith and Jones" was an old lady with a straw. I LOVE IT!

Best:

Reverse Polarity
The Master
The Master singing & dancing
David Tennants acting
David Tennants acting in 42
Marthas Moms acting
Laser Screwdriver
The Judoons
Barefoot on the Moon
That guy in the Family of Blood
Sally Sparrow
The Angels
Martha when she wasn't flirting with the Doctor or Anyone else
young Shakespeare
Jack!


Worst:
Doctor Kissing Martha
Martha loving Doctor
"never waste time hugging"
Evolution of the Daleks
The witches in "Shakespeare Code"
bad plots.


I'll add more later...

fourtysecondscarf


Dr. Demented

PostPosted: Thu Oct 18, 2007 9:58 pm


Good:
Everything except the bad ones listed

Bad:
Evolution of the Daleks (Not the first part)
The death of Simm and Jacobi's Masters crying
Martha and Jack's departure
The sun creature
The Titanic scene being the favorite scene in the BBC polls
PostPosted: Fri Oct 19, 2007 3:54 am


Best Bits:
judoons shoes
judoon platoon upon the moon
blue suit (whats wrong with it!?)
converse (YAY)
harry potter mentions
face of boe in gridlock(dont die!)
martha gets kidnapped in gridlock YAY
"its bigger on the inside!" "is it I hadent noticed"
Hermits united
weeping angels
david tennants acting
david tennant in general *fantisizes*
journal of impossible things
Timey Wimey Dectector
happy primes
here comes the sun
hand in jar in your bag!
gallifrey
the master
track 3 I Cant Decide awesome song mmm poison birthday cake
"hes like fire, ice and rage"
Jack hitting on every one
Jack "was someone just kissing me?"
Kittens
"its like when you fancy someone and they dont even no you exist" that part cracked me up

cant think of anymore at the moment

BAD PARTS
Dalek episodes (daleks are way to over used in the new series)
Martha didnt change her clothes like rose did (thats no fun)
Martha get saved in gridlock *shakes fist*
the doctor constanly getting hurt(having his blood drained, getting his heart stopped by witches, struck by lighting, being burned from the inside from a living sun and being turned really old to name a few)
whiney martha
toclophane humans becoming gaint balls
laslo living as a pig?
jack leaving
the doctor crying NOOOOOOO MADE ME CRY

IMPENDING DOOM:
the inebetible retern of and certain red head last seen waering a weeding dress

lemonpiepie


3mmi

PostPosted: Sun Oct 28, 2007 4:39 am


GOOOD:
david tennant
JACKK!!
blink
scary statues
sally sparrow
timey wimey detector
the master
last 3 eps
rose mentions
HP mention
martha leaving (LOL)

BAD:
the matron (yuck)
jack leaving!
martha
daleks!
dalek human!
doctor crying
master dying (so mean!)

thats all i can think of now. :]
PostPosted: Sun Oct 28, 2007 5:12 am


Freaj
Ehh overall I didn't think this series was as good as the previous one. There were some pretty good episodes like Blink and... whatever else, I can't remember, but there were also some truely shocking ones (coughSHAKESPEARE CODEcough)


I thought the shakespeare code was crap as well, but I watched it again about two weeks ago and it was probably one of the best episodes of the series.

Takuha


lemurs366

PostPosted: Thu Nov 22, 2007 2:09 pm


i love the blue suit too!@ and i ADORE Martha!!! She's not gone for good though, you guys! (thank god) i loved john simm too
Reply
The Doctor Who Guild

Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum