Welcome to Gaia! ::

Reply ::Gamer Chicks::
Video Games in Politics Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3 [>] [»|]

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Does Video Game Violence lead to Violence in real life?
  I agree
  I don't agree
  I agree but I stand halfway to what the politicians are plaing to do about it.
  I have no coment
View Results

Epidemic of Insanity

PostPosted: Mon May 07, 2007 7:32 pm


Of course children are heavily influenced by the media around them.
And of course, there will always be kids determined on obtaining what their parents have forbidden them to have. Such as GTA.
If parents ban their kids from playing games such as GTA, they need to make sure that their children understand why they're banning it. All you can hope is that the importance of not copying violent video games verbatim gets through to them.

Of course kids are going to get their hands on GTA.
But drugs and alcohol have obvious negative effects. And it doesn't matter if we ban them, or try to talk to kids about them. Kids still get their hands on them.

In the end, it really just comes down to the kid. Parents would like to protect their children from everything, and we wish they could. But they can't.
PostPosted: Wed May 09, 2007 8:34 pm


ji-an
I will agree with most of you above that parents should regulate what thier children are watching/ playing, but I have to say that there are instances that children sneak around, out of curiousity to find out what is so taboo. There is reasearch that shows children are extremelly influenced by what they see. There was an anaysis a few years back that put preschool kids in a room one day and showed them watching Barnie. The next day they were watching Power Rangers. The differences in play time after watching the two shows was phenominal! Kids that watched Barnie were more into sharing and sensitivity, and kids that watched power rangers seemed to be acting on a more agressive scale.

In such times when a child is away from a parent for one reason or another, how will it be certain they won't be influenced is they got thier hands on a game like halo or grand theft auto?

Thus posting another problem. Children, this is something you cannot deny, will always try to find out why the game cannot be played. If the parents dont bother to tell them why its considered taboo, the children will want to find out why.

Okay, so there are those that do still want to find out even if their parents stated why they shouldnt very properly. And sometimes its the media to blame when they advertise all these things. But at times, it really depends on how well kids control themselves.

Arekusa

7,050 Points
  • Peoplewatcher 100
  • Consumer 100
  • Window Shopper 100

plethorakin

PostPosted: Thu May 10, 2007 12:41 pm


I'm seventeen years old and I have been playing ever since I can remember. I can get a lousy temper but I'd never attribute it to video games. Its ussually because of someone else's stupidity or obstinance. I'm pretty much in a huge community of gamers and as I look around at all of my friends, I have never seen one of them show unusual aggression or acting violent towards other kids.
Sure little kids would copy somethings from a game. Didn't you copy things you see on tv when you were little. Who doesn't. But the is a huge difference between using a thumbstick and the A button to beat down a giant monster, and picking up a gun, aiming at another human being and firing. But I have never seen the things that the media portrays happen in the vast sea of gamers that I know. I find it very hard to believe that a video game can compell someone to kill. I think video games are just our generations scape goat. Our parent's was rock and roll. Years ago some books were thought to cause people to be violent.
But I can't ever really find solid scientific evidence when I look around. I'm pretty sure that most of it is biased on both sides.
PostPosted: Sat May 12, 2007 9:36 pm


It say Mature, ages 17 and up on there for a reason! If the parents are stupid enough to let their kids play it early that's their screw up! mind, The maturity level of the kids plays a factor too. I started playing M rated games when I was 15, cause I was mature enough to understand its a GAME. And that shotting the person in the game was kewl but its BAAAAAADDDD to do so in real life! >_< plus my mom refused to let me till then...
Canada & Japan are the 2 countries with the most sex and violence on tv, however they're countries have a significantly SMALLER crime rate and stuff than ze U.S. Why? BECAUSE PARENTS THERE TEACH THEIR KIDS ABOUT MORALS AND ETHICS! If a parent sits down with their kid and explains about game v. real life, and actually is around or has a competant adult babysit their child, then the kid is less likely to pick up a gun and start shooting people in the middle of the streets.
Mind, some people are mentally/emotioncally disturbed. If that's the case, don't give them the damn game!
*takes a deep breath as she finishes rant. looks at clock and crawls into bed to sleep.*

Sakyh


SilverBellsAbove

PostPosted: Sun May 13, 2007 5:04 pm


I wrote a speech on videogame violence for English class. Maybe I'll post it later; it's saved on my school computer account and I need to retrieve it. It's quite a piece of work, if I do say so myself.
PostPosted: Sun May 13, 2007 6:03 pm


A speech? I wanna see! Please post it soon!

I think it's truely the parents fault. They seem to be so stupid when buying video games. My mother knows what we buy, they are mostly E+10 or T we only have one M rated game, & that's 99 Knights. I don't even let my little cousin who's 3 years old play my games. I make sure I'm playing a game he can watch when he's over. I know I'm being protective, what can I say? He's only 3!


Fibonacci To Infinity

Forum Assistant

Spicy Librarian

44,025 Points
  • Potion Master 50
  • Knife Club Lifetime Membership 0
  • Master Librarian 500

SilverBellsAbove

PostPosted: Mon May 14, 2007 1:12 pm


Here is my speech. I made it for english class, just to tic my teacher off. He hates technology.


http://docs.google.com/Doc?id=dkhw3hx_028n6hw

Read it. It's pretty okay. I got an A on it, in any case. sweatdrop Even if he hated the subject matter.

Serves him right for going on a spiel on how games will be the end of us. domokun I canned every single point he made, and he came out red as a beet by the end of it. Mwehehe... I may act totally nutso, but I assure you all that happened because of my PARENTS, not because of videogames.

Kids and games can be sort of awkward. I came into preschool one day and the teacher asked us all what we had done over the weekend. My parents were and still are avid DnD fans, and I even had my own character when I was that little. And of course, to make it more interesting, I said to the teacher 'My mommy and daddy and friends all slew demons in the basement!'

gonk We got a call a while later from a priest. The teacher had reported us to her church as satanists. gonk
PostPosted: Thu May 17, 2007 6:09 am


MsDevin92
Well, I'm not exactly sure about proposed bans. For the people who can play games like GTA (which, pardon my opinion, I just don't see the enjoyment in) and not become violent, kudos to you- you are truly something else. However, my experiences with kids who have played such games are not pleasant at all- in fact, I think 80% of the boys in my grade played GTA, excluding a few sweet individuals. Do you KNOW how many fights we get a day? eek
Still, I'd feel bad about proposing a ban and punishing innocent game-players...So I'm sort of at a loss confused


I really want to comment on this. I'm twenty eight years old and when I was in high school GTA was yet to be invented and there were fights all the time as well. It had nothing to do with videogames because back then, games were considered something exclusively nerdy, hardly anyone did it.
I really don't see the connection between games and aggressive behaviour anyway, most people who have committed violent crimes will have eaten bread, that doesn't mean eating bread makes you violent.
The problem with videogames and violence are the media and people like Jack Thompson. As soon as there's someone admitting he played violent games and committed a violent crime the media are all over it. However, you'll never read in the papers about the millions of people who play violent games and have never harmed a fly in their lives. The reason for that is that violence sells, and not just in videogames.
As for Jack Thompson, anyone remember the Virginia Tech shootings? The first thing Jack Thompson said about that was that we would probably find out that the perpetrator had a history of playing violent games, quite possibly Counter-Strike. It turns out that the guy only had a laptop and his room mates had never see him play any games at all, he was just a nut who believed he was serving some deluded religious purpose.
That being said, I don't believe everyone should be allowed to play every game, small children are easily influenced as has been said before but that's what the age ratings are for in which case it becomes a matter of parent responsibility, not the government. Parents are always eager to blame anything but their own shortcomings when their kids go bad. In the fifties it was rock 'n roll, in the seventies punk, then metal, movies, and now they've found videogames to be a nice new scapegoat.

Alaisha


DarkAeonPenance

PostPosted: Fri May 18, 2007 5:15 am


Not sure if anyone said this before but, the army took advantage of the games so they can make their "Perfect Killing Machine". stressed It would also seem that they forgotten that violence is in Human nature no matter how you see it, they say games cause violent tendencies, so do people who say the dumbest crap that comes outta their mouths
PostPosted: Sun May 20, 2007 8:45 am


Considering that I'm only 14, & I like blood & gore. Come one,it's fact that you know it's not real & there's no way you can chop a guy's head with a Katana when he has a machine gun in his hand & come out unscathed. Now fantasy is my scapegoat when I've had a bad day or there's a fight going in between my sister & my mom. Now if someone could answer me this: Why can't the politians leave us gamers alone? If a kid is violent, don't look at video games. Look at the parents.


Fibonacci To Infinity

Forum Assistant

Spicy Librarian

44,025 Points
  • Potion Master 50
  • Knife Club Lifetime Membership 0
  • Master Librarian 500

Eternal Euphoria

PostPosted: Sun May 20, 2007 4:24 pm


I've heard alot about video games and violence. I play a lot of very gory video games, and I think that their a big stress relief. It stops me from hurting the stupid people in real life. I believe that the government thinks that it needs to point fingers at different things that they don't like or agree with. On the other hand their are people out there that really get into games I mean REALLY into games. I heard once that a young man started to play World of Warcraft and fell in love with someone else over it asked her to marry him, she said no and he killed himself. So I believe both sides have their stories. Maybe, parents need to keep a close eye on their children, and adults that play games should know that it's just a game.
PostPosted: Sat May 26, 2007 1:57 pm


Like I said in my essay, if kids are MORE LIKELY to play videogames than adults. If a kid is violent, they have a BIGGER CHANCE of playing games than a violent adult does.

People make connections all the time when they don't want to get involved. It's much easier to blame a gaming company than someone's parents. Because a corporation has no human face to point a finger at.

People don't want to take responsibility for their actions. It's been that way since the beginning of time. They want something to blame that can't bite back.

So they overlook things in order to make themselves feel right. Even if they're wrong.

If a person can't distinguish fantasy (videogames) from reality, there's something wrong there. Something that a game can't screw up. There is absolutely no game that can turn a person insane.

Unless they are having trouble beating a level, of course. wink

SilverBellsAbove


Maker Of Tomorrow

Distinct Consumer

PostPosted: Mon May 28, 2007 2:38 pm


This topic is a really hard debate to call. The rating system as it stands, ESRB or something like that, is actually a really effective system. It allows parents to monitor what their kids play based on what's in the game, and they can also set limitations for their children based upon ratings, content, and other things that they think should be considered. If there's a person in the game store to help as well, that's even better. From experience, that person can give opinions of the game based on the age of the child the game is for, what they've experienced in life, etc.

Anyway, rant aside, I think the debate has to be decided on by the parents and the kids together. I know my parents didn't let me play particularly violent games when I was young because they weren't sure if I could handle what the game was like. They had to be sure that I was mentally able to tell the difference between reality and the game. Make sense? So personally, I think that you can't decide this debate on a broad, overall basis. It needs to be handled on a case by case.

~Maker Of Tomorrow
PostPosted: Mon Jun 11, 2007 12:38 am


Back in elementary and middle school, I used to sometimes play Mortal Kombat, Doom 64, Starcraft, Goldeneye 007, and all sorts of violent games. Oh, and I also used to watch something as "mature" as Ranma 1/2 at that age.

Yet, every time my mom freaked out about the massive violence and how it could affect us, I finished the discussion with a simple rebuttal: "It's just a TV series/videogame! It ain't real! I can't kill anyone!".

So far, the only thing a videogame or movie could do to me or a relative was making my brother speak like a character from that film. And that's because he has this habit of speaking like one of the characters of the last film or videogame he liked. When he was playing GTA San Andreas, he used to scream "Oh, a*****e, my s**t!", just like CJ. But then he watched Scarface and began talking like Tony Montana: "You ******** with me? Fine, say hello to my little friend". Before that, he watched LOTR:ROTK and began speaking like Gandalf. Now that he watched 300, he keeps speaking like Leonidas.

Conclusion: playing violent videogames doesn't makes you a violent dude.

Da_Nuke

Reply
::Gamer Chicks::

Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3 [>] [»|]
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum