Welcome to Gaia! ::

The Asylum and Friends

Back to Guilds

Welcome to the machine. 

Tags: Gilgamesh, Chaos, Insanity, Fire 

Reply Eta (Debates)
First Debate!!! (Better Anime Hero, Ichigo vs. Ed) [CLOSED] Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3 4 [>] [»|]

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Who is the Better Anime Hero?
  Edward Elrich
  Ichigo Kurosaki
View Results

YummyBiscuits
Crew

Powerhouse

11,375 Points
  • Marathon 300
  • Brandisher 100
  • Partygoer 500
PostPosted: Tue Jan 04, 2011 9:13 am


Shadowlord9k
YummyBiscuits
Dionysus or Bacchus
YummyBiscuits
But...THEY...BOTH...SUUUUCCCCCKKKKKK.

There is no debate between the two, as both characters are simply...Ugh. They make RP characters you guys, debate over those peeps. rofl


This comment is purely opinion, and unless this post is backed with facts it will be considered stricken from the record.

((Stick a muzzle on my character, will you??? blaugh ))


The two have horible parents and adult figures. In FMA, no one tells the two boys to wait like fiove years before going out and about, so those KIDS are going to get killed!
In Bleach, No one says that Ichigo needs to calm down, finish school, and let the Adults deal with the worlds problems.

Those kids are going to get killed! or grow up to become criminals/become depressed or suffer other mental issues.

Yeah, because trying to bring your mom back from the dead but creating a abomination while your brother I'd turned into a walking suit of armor isn't traumatizing


Exactly! Either they are gonna die, or grow up with serious mental malfunctions.
PostPosted: Tue Jan 04, 2011 9:18 am


YummyBiscuits
Shadowlord9k
YummyBiscuits
Dionysus or Bacchus
YummyBiscuits
But...THEY...BOTH...SUUUUCCCCCKKKKKK.

There is no debate between the two, as both characters are simply...Ugh. They make RP characters you guys, debate over those peeps. rofl


This comment is purely opinion, and unless this post is backed with facts it will be considered stricken from the record.

((Stick a muzzle on my character, will you??? blaugh ))

Actually they both seemed fine at the ending from what I heard
The two have horible parents and adult figures. In FMA, no one tells the two boys to wait like fiove years before going out and about, so those KIDS are going to get killed!
In Bleach, No one says that Ichigo needs to calm down, finish school, and let the Adults deal with the worlds problems.

Those kids are going to get killed! or grow up to become criminals/become depressed or suffer other mental issues.

Yeah, because trying to bring your mom back from the dead but creating a abomination while your brother I'd turned into a walking suit of armor isn't traumatizing


Exactly! Either they are gonna die, or grow up with serious mental malfunctions.

Lord Shadow IX
Captain


Dionysus or Bacchus
Crew

5,700 Points
  • Peoplewatcher 100
  • Team Jacob 100
  • Brandisher 100
PostPosted: Tue Jan 04, 2011 9:38 pm


Shadowlord9k
YummyBiscuits
Shadowlord9k
YummyBiscuits
Dionysus or Bacchus
YummyBiscuits
But...THEY...BOTH...SUUUUCCCCCKKKKKK.

There is no debate between the two, as both characters are simply...Ugh. They make RP characters you guys, debate over those peeps. rofl


This comment is purely opinion, and unless this post is backed with facts it will be considered stricken from the record.

((Stick a muzzle on my character, will you??? blaugh ))

Actually they both seemed fine at the ending from what I heard
The two have horible parents and adult figures. In FMA, no one tells the two boys to wait like fiove years before going out and about, so those KIDS are going to get killed!
In Bleach, No one says that Ichigo needs to calm down, finish school, and let the Adults deal with the worlds problems.

Those kids are going to get killed! or grow up to become criminals/become depressed or suffer other mental issues.

Yeah, because trying to bring your mom back from the dead but creating a abomination while your brother I'd turned into a walking suit of armor isn't traumatizing


Exactly! Either they are gonna die, or grow up with serious mental malfunctions.


So in your opinion (Yummy and Shadow), no young hero is any good, and they should just move over for the out-dated anti-hero with a dark past?

Also, if you guys want to nominate a character, (must be the main character of an anime, mind) please, by all means, bring them up.
PostPosted: Tue Jan 04, 2011 10:08 pm


Dionysus or Bacchus
Shadowlord9k
YummyBiscuits
Shadowlord9k
YummyBiscuits

Actually they both seemed fine at the ending from what I heard
The two have horible parents and adult figures. In FMA, no one tells the two boys to wait like fiove years before going out and about, so those KIDS are going to get killed!
In Bleach, No one says that Ichigo needs to calm down, finish school, and let the Adults deal with the worlds problems.

Those kids are going to get killed! or grow up to become criminals/become depressed or suffer other mental issues.

Yeah, because trying to bring your mom back from the dead but creating a abomination while your brother I'd turned into a walking suit of armor isn't traumatizing


Exactly! Either they are gonna die, or grow up with serious mental malfunctions.


So in your opinion (Yummy and Shadow), no young hero is any good, and they should just move over for the out-dated anti-hero with a dark past?

Also, if you guys want to nominate a character, (must be the main character of an anime, mind) please, by all means, bring them up.
actually, I don't really mind the origins.
And I nominate Momosuke Yamaoka* from Requiem from the Darkness

*I actually had to use Wikipedia to get the name

Lord Shadow IX
Captain


Dionysus or Bacchus
Crew

5,700 Points
  • Peoplewatcher 100
  • Team Jacob 100
  • Brandisher 100
PostPosted: Tue Jan 04, 2011 10:57 pm


Shadowlord9k
Dionysus or Bacchus
Shadowlord9k
YummyBiscuits
Shadowlord9k
YummyBiscuits

Actually they both seemed fine at the ending from what I heard
The two have horible parents and adult figures. In FMA, no one tells the two boys to wait like fiove years before going out and about, so those KIDS are going to get killed!
In Bleach, No one says that Ichigo needs to calm down, finish school, and let the Adults deal with the worlds problems.

Those kids are going to get killed! or grow up to become criminals/become depressed or suffer other mental issues.

Yeah, because trying to bring your mom back from the dead but creating a abomination while your brother I'd turned into a walking suit of armor isn't traumatizing


Exactly! Either they are gonna die, or grow up with serious mental malfunctions.


So in your opinion (Yummy and Shadow), no young hero is any good, and they should just move over for the out-dated anti-hero with a dark past?

Also, if you guys want to nominate a character, (must be the main character of an anime, mind) please, by all means, bring them up.
actually, I don't really mind the origins.
And I nominate Momosuke Yamaoka* from Requiem from the Darkness

*I actually had to use Wikipedia to get the name


Why, on what grounds? Be specific now! blaugh
PostPosted: Tue Jan 04, 2011 11:19 pm


Dionysus or Bacchus
Shadowlord9k
Dionysus or Bacchus
Shadowlord9k
YummyBiscuits


Exactly! Either they are gonna die, or grow up with serious mental malfunctions.


So in your opinion (Yummy and Shadow), no young hero is any good, and they should just move over for the out-dated anti-hero with a dark past?

Also, if you guys want to nominate a character, (must be the main character of an anime, mind) please, by all means, bring them up.
actually, I don't really mind the origins.
And I nominate Momosuke Yamaoka* from Requiem from the Darkness

*I actually had to use Wikipedia to get the name


Why, on what grounds? Be specific now! blaugh

...nevermind I realize that he would definatly lose

Lord Shadow IX
Captain


YummyBiscuits
Crew

Powerhouse

11,375 Points
  • Marathon 300
  • Brandisher 100
  • Partygoer 500
PostPosted: Wed Jan 05, 2011 2:06 pm


Bobobo-bo Bo-bobo from Bobobo-bo Bo-bobo. Best thing EVER.
And the reason being, That nose hair is oh so sexy. heart
PostPosted: Wed Jan 05, 2011 11:01 pm


YummyBiscuits
Bobobo-bo Bo-bobo from Bobobo-bo Bo-bobo. Best thing EVER.
And the reason being, That nose hair is oh so sexy. heart


I disagree on the grounds of the nose hair; nose hair is considered disagreeable in Western Cultures.

Dionysus or Bacchus
Crew

5,700 Points
  • Peoplewatcher 100
  • Team Jacob 100
  • Brandisher 100

Dionysus or Bacchus
Crew

5,700 Points
  • Peoplewatcher 100
  • Team Jacob 100
  • Brandisher 100
PostPosted: Wed Jan 05, 2011 11:09 pm


Okay guys, it seems the Edward Elrich is on top barely, with Ichigo being mildly argued for, and Bobobo . . . whatever, is lagging behind in third. Is this how you want it to end?!?!?!

If no more posting of worth happens between now and 1-12-11, then I'll have no choice but to declare Edward Elrich the WINNER!
PostPosted: Thu Jan 06, 2011 3:17 am


Better Hair: Ichigo
Better Outfit: Ichigo
More Likely to Give Fan Service: Ed
More Likely to Receive Fan Service: Ichigo

Better Hand to Hand Fighter: Ed
More Likely to Survive Zombie Apocalypse: Ichigo.
More Fun to Watch Being Beat Up: Ed
Better Powers: Tie
More Resourceful with Powers: Tie

Better Origin Story: Ed
Better Love Interest: . . . sweatdrop
Better Chemistry with Love Interest: . . . neutral

Better Target for Mockery: Ed
Better Names Called: Ed



Yeah. . . I'm going mostly for Ichigo.

XFire_of_DarknessX


Kavoru
Vice Captain

Moonlight Hunter

8,850 Points
  • Conventioneer 300
  • Signature Look 250
  • First step to fame 200
PostPosted: Thu Jan 06, 2011 1:53 pm


Better Hair: Ed
Better Outfit: Ed
More Likely to Give Fan Service: Ed
More Likely to Receive Fan Service: Ed

Better Hand to Hand Fighter: Ed
More Likely to Survive Zombie Apocalypse: Ichigo.
More Fun to Watch Being Beat Up: Ed
Better Powers: Ichigo
More Resourceful with Powers: Ed

Better Origin Story: Ed
Better Love Interest: ...
Better Chemistry with Love Interest: Ed

Better Target for Mockery: Ed
Better Names Called: Ed
PostPosted: Thu Jan 06, 2011 7:02 pm


hmm. you know, we could just say screw both edward an ichigo. an consider the possibility Dante from DMC is just better then both. or anyone from sengoku bassara. then there lelouch from code geas.oh, wait. then you have to put in the possibility of Goku from DBZ

Razeal Valentine


Noble Negative J3T

9,975 Points
  • Member 100
  • Gaian 50
PostPosted: Thu Jan 06, 2011 8:55 pm


I say Edward. He has a better story, past, and he seems more likely to be hte hero. He's not doing this because of faith he has a goal that he needs to achieve. Now I love bleach to death, but Ichigo kinda just walked into it. Yeah, a holllow attacked his house, but doens't mean you was suppose to go to the SS and save everyone. and kick Byakuyas a**. *cough*
PostPosted: Fri Jan 07, 2011 6:11 am


I dont know much about the other character but i have a lot of very good reasons why ichigo sucks.

1) Ichigo's zanpakuto has only 2 special abilities, it makes him fast and he can use Getsuga Tenshou.
And now my problems with these two techniques.

1.1) Ichigo's so called 'amazing' speed is constantly outmatched after he rescues Rukia from Soul Society by nearly every opponent he faces.

1.2) The Getsuga Tenshou unless used at very close range either misses or does no damage at all yet again after he rescues Rukia. And when it does hit, Ichigo is usualy exhausted and his opponent can always still fight back!

2) The power levels in bleach got messed up when ichigo gained an inner hollow. Ok i understand a shinigami turning into a full hollow with Ichigo's power it would be strong but! He fights Ulquiorra and gets killed TWICE! in the same way! and second time he dies he becomes the hollow and kills Ulquiorra The 4TH Espada.
My point is Byakuya and Kenpachi can kill Espada number 0 (the strongest Espada) with little effort and Ichigo has to die twice to beat the 4th? the essential make-up of him as a character is messed up.

3) No surprises at all, the most annoying thing about him. He is always the same, his sword was constantly released in shikai (yet it had no special power except Getsuga Tenshou) then he learned Bankai which he then used in every single fight from then on. Most annoyingly of all he never learns any new powers even in Bankai!
He has a Hollow mask but all that does is make him stronger, he is just the same person with a mask and different voice his fights are immensely boring because he has nothing new to show. I look forward to seeing his opponents powers then hope the fight ends quick before he has one of his huge poinltess conversations with them

Super-Sui

3,150 Points
  • Gaian 50
  • Member 100
  • Dressed Up 200

YummyBiscuits
Crew

Powerhouse

11,375 Points
  • Marathon 300
  • Brandisher 100
  • Partygoer 500
PostPosted: Fri Jan 07, 2011 3:08 pm


Negative J3T
I say Edward. He has a better story, past, and he seems more likely to be hte hero. He's not doing this because of faith he has a goal that he needs to achieve. Now I love bleach to death, but Ichigo kinda just walked into it. Yeah, a holllow attacked his house, but doens't mean you was suppose to go to the SS and save everyone. and kick Byakuyas a**. *cough*


You kinda contradicted yourself there mate.
What you say makes Ichigo a better hero. 1) He fights for others, not his self. 2) He did just walk into it. He tried to save his family, and in the proccess was thrust into this world. From there, he sacrificed himself almost to go and save complete strangers. That makes him more of a hero then Ed could ever try to become in my opinion. Ed only does what he does for himself and his brother. When he saves his brother and his self, he will probaably quit state alchemy, and go off with winry.
Reply
Eta (Debates)

Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3 4 [>] [»|]
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum