Welcome to Gaia! ::

Debate/Discuss Religion

Back to Guilds

A guild devoted to discussing and debating different aspects of various world religions 

Tags: religion, faith, tolerance, discuss, debate 

Reply Debate/Discuss Atheism
Atheists: We don’t bite! :3 Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3 ... 4 5 ... 12 13 14 15 [>] [>>] [»|]

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

People Counter
+1
100%
 100%  [ 71 ]
Total Votes : 71


Soulgazer the Gnostic

PostPosted: Wed Sep 02, 2009 7:21 am


alteregoivy
RubyLight
I have a question. Do you believe in the existence of the soul or some kind of afterlife?
Don't worry I'm not a hater. Some of my friends are athiests. wink


While I agree it is very tempting to look at human accomplishments, range of emotions, and intelligence, and conclude that there must be some kind of ghost in the machine that makes us who we are... I can't do it. The truth is that everything that we think of as making humans unique and arguments for a soul can be seen in more rudimentary forms in animals. Generally, they're just a step away or two from exhibiting the same behavior we do, the main difference being that different facets of us are found in different species, and our intelligence is all rolled into one species.

As for an afterlife, again, it is very tempting to believe that there's something after this to right all wrongs and some way in which we continue... but there just isn't any evidence for it, and especially if you don't believe in a soul, it's hard to believe in an afterlife.

That's what, to me, makes it so important that we are good people now! We have to change the world to be a better place and make life better for the people around us, because there (probably) won't be a second chance to do it.

I know that's a long answer to a short question. sweatdrop


I respect your belief. I see it as belief, as I see my belief as belief. There are 6.6 billion beliefs on this planet.

Belief is not reality; belief is how we shape our own reality, and we are each our own gods in this respect.

We each carry our own, and when somebody dies, a whole world, made up of that persons perceptions, dies. I can tell you that I have been in the presence of God, but that statement, that incident, is for me alone. Whatever proofs I carry, are meant for me alone, and not meant for you.


Do I believe you are "going to hell?" I don't know. The message of Jesus boils down to "be nice". Are you nice? What if you were not? The adulteress in the square was not "nice". Jesus refused to condemn her, so neither would I.

I have had to preside over funerals, and families want assurance that their loved ones are in a good place, even though the deceased was not a believer. I remind them that Jesus said that turning the other cheek was preferable to an eye for an eye, and to love those that hate us.

Surely God will not ask us to be more merciful and moral than He himself. Not one of us is born with a set of goggles that let's us see into the other realms, and a mans stories are that mans stories, and for some, carry no weight on this side of the veil.

Whose fault is that? Is being born blind the fault of some future wrong, or the fault of the parents? Jesus said, neither.
PostPosted: Thu Sep 17, 2009 7:30 pm


✩ Happy endings never really matter. ✩

▽▽▽ ▽▽▽ ▽▽▽ ▽▽▽ ▽▽▽ ▽▽▽ ▽▽▽ ▽▽▽ ▽▽▽ ▽▽▽ ▽▽▽ ▽▽▽ ▽▽▽ ▽▽▽ ▽▽▽ ▽▽▽



Personally, I often start debates with Christians to try and get them to see how ignorant they can be sometimes. No, I'm not saying all of them are naive or ignorant, but a lot of them follow a God blindly or without reason. To me, it seems a bit like a fairytale, if you don't believe in Cinderella, why would you believe in God? Honestly, how many of you think every word of the bible is absolutely true? It is a man-made book, meaning it could be full of opinions and exaggerations that no one even know about. Really it matters little to me what everyone else believes, but when they try to shove it in my face- with their door-to-door old lady shunning program- I get a little pissed off.

My main view on religion is that what I think works for me and what others think works for them. I'm not asking you to try and “save” me, so don't make the worthless effort. You know what I mean?



△△△ △△△ △△△ △△△ △△△ △△△ △△△ △△△ △△△ △△△ △△△ △△△ △△△ △△△ △△△ △△△

✩ The endings that stick with you aren't always happy. ✩

Autotrack


Cute Evil Taco

PostPosted: Thu Sep 24, 2009 1:51 pm


Aaxi
✩ Happy endings never really matter. ✩

▽▽▽ ▽▽▽ ▽▽▽ ▽▽▽ ▽▽▽ ▽▽▽ ▽▽▽ ▽▽▽ ▽▽▽ ▽▽▽ ▽▽▽ ▽▽▽ ▽▽▽ ▽▽▽ ▽▽▽ ▽▽▽



Personally, I often start debates with Christians to try and get them to see how ignorant they can be sometimes. No, I'm not saying all of them are naive or ignorant, but a lot of them follow a God blindly or without reason. To me, it seems a bit like a fairytale, if you don't believe in Cinderella, why would you believe in God? Honestly, how many of you think every word of the bible is absolutely true? It is a man-made book, meaning it could be full of opinions and exaggerations that no one even know about. Really it matters little to me what everyone else believes, but when they try to shove it in my face- with their door-to-door old lady shunning program- I get a little pissed off.

My main view on religion is that what I think works for me and what others think works for them. I'm not asking you to try and “save” me, so don't make the worthless effort. You know what I mean?



△△△ △△△ △△△ △△△ △△△ △△△ △△△ △△△ △△△ △△△ △△△ △△△ △△△ △△△ △△△ △△△

✩ The endings that stick with you aren't always happy. ✩


That's exactly how I feel. I have my beliefs and others around me try to push me into "being right with God". It pisses me off greatly and when push comes to shove, I end up completely ignoring the person all together. Honestly, You bible beaters aren't going to do much good here saying we're going to hell. I believe in neither heaven nor hell. I don't believe in a higher power/being. I believe that when you die, you die.

Also, she didn't start this thread for you to push your beliefs upon it. She started it just to simply discuss how we feel about our beliefs. The bible quotes aren't needed. I'm sure quite a few of us have screwed around with a bible even a little. Some may have tried to be Christian then, later on, have discovered the little holes within the story/stories told within the bible.

For me it's just another book. stare
PostPosted: Thu Sep 24, 2009 2:13 pm


Accido_Beauty
RubyLight
I have a question. Do you believe in the existence of the soul or some kind of afterlife?
Don't worry I'm not a hater. Some of my friends are athiests. wink


I believe in karma though? If that counts. XD


I'm not trying to be a jerk-just wanted to clear this up before people jump on it.

Do you mean Hindu karma, or the idea of we are accountable for our actions?

I'm very glad there's a thread like this. I haven't heard the "lazy" remarks, but I'm also glad there are atheists who want to convey they have rationally thought this out.

A1Saucy

Devoted Codger


Senonas Demon

PostPosted: Thu Sep 24, 2009 4:20 pm


So . . .
Maybe it's because I've been raised Catholic...but I don't get it.
Like, I'm sitting, staring at my computer screen, going ".......say what?"

I don't understand why you can't embrace the idea of God (or even a higher power). Wouldn't it be better to believe and have that love in your life, even if, in the end, you could be wrong and therefore not have an afterlife? Or if there really is a God (which I believe there is) isn't it better to be safe than sorry?



[@_@; Please be nice to me....Dx I'm not trying to pick a fight, I just don't get it...]
PostPosted: Thu Sep 24, 2009 5:08 pm


Emerald Dragoness
So . . .
Maybe it's because I've been raised Catholic...but I don't get it.
Like, I'm sitting, staring at my computer screen, going ".......say what?"

I don't understand why you can't embrace the idea of God (or even a higher power). Wouldn't it be better to believe and have that love in your life, even if, in the end, you could be wrong and therefore not have an afterlife? Or if there really is a God (which I believe there is) isn't it better to be safe than sorry?



[@_@; Please be nice to me....Dx I'm not trying to pick a fight, I just don't get it...]


There is no "safe" answer, because every religion claims that they are the "right" answer. Gods are jealous, so there's no "safe."

Also, say I believe just to be on the safe side. God is omniscient; He would know that that was the only reason, and I'd imagine He'd be pretty mad about that.

Maybe religion brings love into your life, but for me and for some other Atheists, religion brought pain, and that's part of why we can't believe anymore. I was totally miserable as a Christian.

alteregoivy


Shiori Miko

PostPosted: Thu Sep 24, 2009 5:09 pm


Emerald Dragoness
So . . .
Maybe it's because I've been raised Catholic...but I don't get it.
Like, I'm sitting, staring at my computer screen, going ".......say what?"

I don't understand why you can't embrace the idea of God (or even a higher power). Wouldn't it be better to believe and have that love in your life, even if, in the end, you could be wrong and therefore not have an afterlife? Or if there really is a God (which I believe there is) isn't it better to be safe than sorry?



[@_@; Please be nice to me....Dx I'm not trying to pick a fight, I just don't get it...]

Forcing ourselves to believe something so we can "have love in our life" is just lying to ourselves.

Plus a religion isn't the only place to get love. Family, friends, spouses.
PostPosted: Thu Sep 24, 2009 6:50 pm


RubyLight
I have a question. Do you believe in the existence of the soul or some kind of afterlife?
Don't worry I'm not a hater. Some of my friends are athiests. wink


First off, I do not believe in any kind of afterlife. I wouldn't even want one, so I guess it's good that I'm an athiest. Because supposedly heretics are sent to the sixth circle of hell and do not live forever in pain and torture, we are supposed to be eternally dead. We don't get an afterlife. Which is fabulous. Of course, this is only relating to Judaism and Christianity. I'm not very knowledgable about other religions. (Although I'm very interested in Buddhism, but that's a story for another time)

And as for souls? Uhm... I'm not sure. I like the idea, but I don't really believe in it. I sort of feel like we have souls, but it completely contradicts what science tells me. So I'm sort of on the fence, leaning towards souls not existing.

MissDemeter


Eccentric Detective

PostPosted: Thu Sep 24, 2009 7:39 pm


Emerald Dragoness
So . . .
Maybe it's because I've been raised Catholic...but I don't get it.
Like, I'm sitting, staring at my computer screen, going ".......say what?"

I don't understand why you can't embrace the idea of God (or even a higher power). Wouldn't it be better to believe and have that love in your life, even if, in the end, you could be wrong and therefore not have an afterlife? Or if there really is a God (which I believe there is) isn't it better to be safe than sorry?



[@_@; Please be nice to me....Dx I'm not trying to pick a fight, I just don't get it...]


Why we can't... Well, we've come to the conclusion that the concept of God is illogical. For many of us, it wasn't precisely a choice or decision. I know it wasn't for me. It was more like something falling away.

For us, there isn't a fear of hell, because we don't believe in it. The love you feel for your God is unnecessary to us because we focus more on our other relationships, such as those with friends and family.

Also, I don't like the idea of religion as insurance. It seems forced and not something that a loving God (or person) would require. If it's that easy for us to continue every day without believing in a higher power, why would God have made it so? He had other prophets that convinced many, so why not us? Surely he wants us to go to heaven. Why not do everything in his power to bring us to him?
PostPosted: Thu Sep 24, 2009 10:17 pm


See, I don't quite understand aetheism. On an itellectual level, I can understand what you believe and why but for me, it just doesn't feel right. That's fine though. Maybe, you're all right and there's nothing but that doesn't really bother me. If that's so, this life is all we have and all the more precious for that. Though, I believe we should do the most we can with what we have right now no matter what we believe happens, or doesn't happen, when we die.

And in response to the inevitable Christian telling me I'm going to Hell (I'm a Pagan by the way), I always thought a bumper sticker I once saw said it best. "It's your Hell. You burn in it." Besides, Hel in my mythology is a completely different ball of wax.

CalledTheRaven

Dapper Lunatic


Cute Evil Taco

PostPosted: Fri Sep 25, 2009 12:47 am


alteregoivy
There is no "safe" answer, because every religion claims that they are the "right" answer. Gods are jealous, so there's no "safe."

Also, say I believe just to be on the safe side. God is omniscient; He would know that that was the only reason, and I'd imagine He'd be pretty mad about that.

Maybe religion brings love into your life, but for me and for some other Atheists, religion brought pain, and that's part of why we can't believe anymore. I was totally miserable as a Christian.




Shiori Miko
Forcing ourselves to believe something so we can "have love in our life" is just lying to ourselves.

Plus a religion isn't the only place to get love. Family, friends, spouses.


MissDemeter
First off, I do not believe in any kind of afterlife. I wouldn't even want one, so I guess it's good that I'm an athiest. Because supposedly heretics are sent to the sixth circle of hell and do not live forever in pain and torture, we are supposed to be eternally dead. We don't get an afterlife. Which is fabulous. Of course, this is only relating to Judaism and Christianity. I'm not very knowledgable about other religions. (Although I'm very interested in Buddhism, but that's a story for another time)

And as for souls? Uhm... I'm not sure. I like the idea, but I don't really believe in it. I sort of feel like we have souls, but it completely contradicts what science tells me. So I'm sort of on the fence, leaning towards souls not existing.



tearingXheavenXdown
Why we can't... Well, we've come to the conclusion that the concept of God is illogical. For many of us, it wasn't precisely a choice or decision. I know it wasn't for me. It was more like something falling away.

For us, there isn't a fear of hell, because we don't believe in it. The love you feel for your God is unnecessary to us because we focus more on our other relationships, such as those with friends and family.

Also, I don't like the idea of religion as insurance. It seems forced and not something that a loving God (or person) would require. If it's that easy for us to continue every day without believing in a higher power, why would God have made it so? He had other prophets that convinced many, so why not us? Surely he wants us to go to heaven. Why not do everything in his power to bring us to him?


I just wanted to say..you guys are awesome. I love you, lol. razz

Also, I stopped believing in "GOD" a long time ago. My grandmother FORCED me to go to church. I was always uncomfortable..never felt like it was a place I fit into. Actually, most "christians"(if that's what you want to call them) always judged me. Even before I became an Atheist. I CONSTANTLY have people telling me to "get in touch with the lord" or "you've lost your faith in God" Yes. I have. I don't believe in him..nor a higher power. I see holes within the story man has written about "GOD" My grandmother has actually gone to the extreme: ALL of these things are evil.
Harry Potter, Black(yes the color), Sitting on the toilet for too long, Myspace, Not going to church, Not paying tide within church, Not singing in church, Not praying, Video games. Yes, theres more..I must be the "Devil" I read books about vampires, Love black, Love Harry Potter, I use Myspace, I hate anything involving church and i'll be damned if I give that pastor with his nice italian leather boots and expensive suits my freakin' money. Nuff said.
PostPosted: Fri Sep 25, 2009 8:25 pm


Emerald Dragoness
So . . .
Maybe it's because I've been raised Catholic...but I don't get it.
Like, I'm sitting, staring at my computer screen, going ".......say what?"

I don't understand why you can't embrace the idea of God (or even a higher power). Wouldn't it be better to believe and have that love in your life, even if, in the end, you could be wrong and therefore not have an afterlife? Or if there really is a God (which I believe there is) isn't it better to be safe than sorry?



[@_@; Please be nice to me....Dx I'm not trying to pick a fight, I just don't get it...]
I know that many people have already explained this, but I'd like to add a few things.
I've heard that idea a lot and the best way I can think to explain it to someone who believes in God is this:
Remember how happy you were when you believed in Santa Claus? Wouldn't it be great to have that same unquestioning belief again? You would be so much happier.

You couldn't believe in Santa again even if you wanted to.
And why would you? What's the point of having happiness and security if, as far as you're concerned, none of it is real?
With all due respect, I don't mean to belittle your beliefs in the slightest, but this is how I feel.
As far as I'm concerned, forcing myself to believe in a higher power so that I can justify the reason that the world is the way it is, or so that I can believe that I don't have to face it alone is living a lie.


And I think at the end you're describing Pascal's Wager which is basically the idea that if there is no god then we have no afterlife and suffer no consequences either way, but if there is a god and we live believing in that god, we go to heaven. But if we live as if He does not, we go to hell.
So logically the smartest choice would be to follow religion because then we have a 1 in 2 chance of going to heaven instead of hell.

But we, well I can't speak for anyone else so I'll use myself as an example, I am very confident in my belief that not only does God (or at least the one described in the bible) not exist, but there is no afterlife, including heaven and hell.
So why fear something that I am 100% sure does not exist?


Again, I don't mean to insult your beliefs so I'm sorry if I offended you at all.
I hope this helps you understand the atheist point of view though. (:

brainnsoup
Crew

Dapper Shapeshifter


Sanguina Cruenta
Crew

Eloquent Bloodsucker

PostPosted: Fri Sep 25, 2009 8:52 pm


brainnsoup
And I think at the end you're describing Pascal's Wager which is basically the idea that if there is no god then we have no afterlife and suffer no consequences either way, but if there is a god and we live believing in that god, we go to heaven. But if we live as if He does not, we go to hell.
So logically the smartest choice would be to follow religion because then we have a 1 in 2 chance of going to heaven instead of hell.

But we, well I can't speak for anyone else so I'll use myself as an example, I am very confident in my belief that not only does God (or at least the one described in the bible) not exist, but there is no afterlife, including heaven and hell.
So why fear something that I am 100% sure does not exist?


Pascal's Wager doesn't work anyway, because it only works for one deity. If it's another deity entirely that's real, and you're worshipping a false one and that pisses off Real Deity, you'd get punished anyway.

You'd be better off not believing in any of them because it's the same outcome either way and the not-believing way involves the least amount of effort.
PostPosted: Fri Sep 25, 2009 9:32 pm


Sanguina Cruenta
brainnsoup
And I think at the end you're describing Pascal's Wager which is basically the idea that if there is no god then we have no afterlife and suffer no consequences either way, but if there is a god and we live believing in that god, we go to heaven. But if we live as if He does not, we go to hell.
So logically the smartest choice would be to follow religion because then we have a 1 in 2 chance of going to heaven instead of hell.

But we, well I can't speak for anyone else so I'll use myself as an example, I am very confident in my belief that not only does God (or at least the one described in the bible) not exist, but there is no afterlife, including heaven and hell.
So why fear something that I am 100% sure does not exist?


Pascal's Wager doesn't work anyway, because it only works for one deity. If it's another deity entirely that's real, and you're worshipping a false one and that pisses off Real Deity, you'd get punished anyway.

You'd be better off not believing in any of them because it's the same outcome either way and the not-believing way involves the least amount of effort.
Oh, my bad. That's how I've always understood it.

brainnsoup
Crew

Dapper Shapeshifter


Sanguina Cruenta
Crew

Eloquent Bloodsucker

PostPosted: Fri Sep 25, 2009 9:38 pm


brainnsoup
Sanguina Cruenta
brainnsoup
And I think at the end you're describing Pascal's Wager which is basically the idea that if there is no god then we have no afterlife and suffer no consequences either way, but if there is a god and we live believing in that god, we go to heaven. But if we live as if He does not, we go to hell.
So logically the smartest choice would be to follow religion because then we have a 1 in 2 chance of going to heaven instead of hell.

But we, well I can't speak for anyone else so I'll use myself as an example, I am very confident in my belief that not only does God (or at least the one described in the bible) not exist, but there is no afterlife, including heaven and hell.
So why fear something that I am 100% sure does not exist?


Pascal's Wager doesn't work anyway, because it only works for one deity. If it's another deity entirely that's real, and you're worshipping a false one and that pisses off Real Deity, you'd get punished anyway.

You'd be better off not believing in any of them because it's the same outcome either way and the not-believing way involves the least amount of effort.
Oh, my bad. That's how I've always understood it.


Oh, no no no no, I'm agreeing with you! blaugh I was just adding a little "yeah, and also it's crap for other reasons" addendum.
Reply
Debate/Discuss Atheism

Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3 ... 4 5 ... 12 13 14 15 [>] [>>] [»|]
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum