Welcome to Gaia! ::

Reply Jewish Gaians Guild
Meeting with an Orthodox rabbi Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3 [>] [»|]

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

LordNeuf
Crew

PostPosted: Mon Jul 28, 2008 12:21 pm


In Medias Res II
I was reeeeejected, and rejected hard by Chabad.


In what respect were you rejected?
PostPosted: Mon Jul 28, 2008 12:25 pm


LordNeuf
In Medias Res II
I was reeeeejected, and rejected hard by Chabad.


In what respect were you rejected?


He said that most people never call him back, to call him in a month, observe shabbat as best I can, and I will probably not want to be Jewish.

I asked him if I could at least go to shul, or something else to integrate me with Jewish community?

"no".

AND he was playign with his blackberry while talking with me...
how disinterested and disrespectful.. very discouraging.

In Medias Res II


LordNeuf
Crew

PostPosted: Mon Jul 28, 2008 12:30 pm


In Medias Res II

He said that most people never call him back, to call him in a month, observe shabbat as best I can, and I will probably not want to be Jewish.

I asked him if I could at least go to shul, or something else to integrate me with Jewish community?

"no".


That's not a rejection, that's a challenge. There's a difference.

He wants you to be the best damn Jew you can in the next month. Observing custom and traditions while immersing yourself in the lifestyle. It's not an easy task, which is why most don't get back to him in a month.

If a month passes and you do your best and show him your true intentions, he will be more open towards you.

The reason he didn't want you to integrate into the community aspects is because he didn't want you to get a sense of... for lack of a better term... arrogance. He wants to remind you that you're still on the outside looking in, and didn't want you to get ahead of your self.

I think that it went well.
PostPosted: Mon Jul 28, 2008 12:36 pm


LordNeuf
In Medias Res II

He said that most people never call him back, to call him in a month, observe shabbat as best I can, and I will probably not want to be Jewish.

I asked him if I could at least go to shul, or something else to integrate me with Jewish community?

"no".


That's not a rejection, that's a challenge. There's a difference.

He wants you to be the best damn Jew you can in the next month. Observing custom and traditions while immersing yourself in the lifestyle. It's not an easy task, which is why most don't get back to him in a month.

If a month passes and you do your best and show him your true intentions, he will be more open towards you.

The reason he didn't want you to integrate into the community aspects is because he didn't want you to get a sense of... for lack of a better term... arrogance. He wants to remind you that you're still on the outside looking in, and didn't want you to get ahead of your self.

I think that it went well.


My mother is now against me being orthodox though, after I explained to her JUST what shabbat entails, and being kosher means.

I am not going to close my options, I'm going to try to meet with a conservative rabbi.

In Medias Res II


darkphoenix1247
Vice Captain

PostPosted: Mon Jul 28, 2008 12:51 pm


I agree with Neuf- conversion to Judaism, especially Orthodoxy, is incredibly difficult. He didn't flat-out tell you no, and if he said, "Most people..." that's all the more reason for you to prove him wrong! Don't be discouraged- it's exceptionally common for rabbis to try to discourage converts so people will show their true determination.

If this is what you want to do, don't let anybody or anything stop you.
PostPosted: Mon Jul 28, 2008 12:59 pm


darkphoenix1247
I agree with Neuf- conversion to Judaism, especially Orthodoxy, is incredibly difficult. He didn't flat-out tell you no, and if he said, "Most people..." that's all the more reason for you to prove him wrong! Don't be discouraged- it's exceptionally common for rabbis to try to discourage converts so people will show their true determination.

If this is what you want to do, don't let anybody or anything stop you.


I don't think I can handle Chassidic Judaism at this point in my life.
I'm a student, I NEED to be able to work or do homework on Saturdays in order to survive.

I can't drive an hour to get kosher meats and ALL kosher food. I can follow the milk/meat and pork laws but I cannot have a kosher kitchen.

I want to be conservative, for now, but I also don't want to be frowned upon for it.

Not to mention the fact that I am gay...

In Medias Res II


LordNeuf
Crew

PostPosted: Mon Jul 28, 2008 1:16 pm


In Medias Res II

I want to be conservative, for now, but I also don't want to be frowned upon for it.

Not to mention the fact that I am gay...


>snaps fingers< oh well, there goes the wedding plans.

I'm sensing a great deal of confusion in your goals. You want to find acceptance and be part of the Jewish Community, but you don't want to be condemned for 'not being Jewish enough to be a Chassid.'

Would you believe that there are conservative temples that cater to the homosexual community?

Would you believe there are several of them, including a shul in Toronto?

Would you believe that you're just as Jewish being in a homosexual Jewish community shul then at being in a Chabad House?

and would you believe I changed my sig line?
PostPosted: Mon Jul 28, 2008 1:18 pm


LordNeuf
In Medias Res II

I want to be conservative, for now, but I also don't want to be frowned upon for it.

Not to mention the fact that I am gay...


>snaps fingers< oh well, there goes the wedding plans.

I'm sensing a great deal of confusion in your goals. You want to find acceptance and be part of the Jewish Community, but you don't want to be condemned for 'not being Jewish enough to be a Chassid.'

Would you believe that there are conservative temples that cater to the homosexual community?

Would you believe there are several of them, including a shul in Toronto?

Would you believe that you're just as Jewish being in a homosexual Jewish community shul then at being in a Chabad House?

and would you believe I changed my sig line?


Ooooh! I love that sig with the menorah!

Unfortunately, I don't live in Toronto.

Do you think it's plausible to start with Conservative?

The rabbi today insinuated that I have to get married ASAP!

In anycase, I know in Canada they require a Beit Din AND a Mikveh for Conservative conversions as well.

In Medias Res II


LordNeuf
Crew

PostPosted: Mon Jul 28, 2008 1:22 pm


Beis Din is 3 Jews who say "yeah you're jewish enough to be one of us."

a Mikveh is a purifying bath.

also

http://www.glbtjews.org/ <--- for resouces.
PostPosted: Mon Jul 28, 2008 1:24 pm


LordNeuf
Beis Din is 3 Jews who say "yeah you're jewish enough to be one of us."

a Mikveh is a purifying bath.

also

http://www.glbtjews.org/ <--- for resouces.


oooh, thanks for the link. And yup, it's that BUT because of that law in Canada... apparently some modern Orthodox shuls actually see Conservative converts as real Jews.

In Medias Res II


LordNeuf
Crew

PostPosted: Mon Jul 28, 2008 1:44 pm


All Jews are Jews. Regardless of what sectarianism says.

Labels just get in the way of everything.
PostPosted: Mon Jul 28, 2008 1:45 pm


LordNeuf
All Jews are Jews. Regardless of what sectarianism says.

Labels just get in the way of everything.


True =]

I feel so much like a Jew, I can't even explain it...

I can't wait till the Conservative rabbi gets back from vacation.

I may contact a reform rabbi as well. Apparently converts can actually request a beit din and a mikveh with the reform movement.

In Medias Res II


dancing-in-the-streets

PostPosted: Mon Jul 28, 2008 1:52 pm


It did sound more like a challenge...
The lifestyle isn't an easy one to live, from what I've gathered. If you can do it, though, or at least do your best, maybe the next meeting he'll put away his Blackberry smile

Or try the Conservative/Reform route.

Sort of off sides question- How will being homosexual effect the process of conversion? Isn't it a pretty frowned upon situation in the Jewish faith?
PostPosted: Mon Jul 28, 2008 2:52 pm


In Medias Res II
LordNeuf
All Jews are Jews. Regardless of what sectarianism says.

Labels just get in the way of everything.


True =]

I feel so much like a Jew, I can't even explain it...

I can't wait till the Conservative rabbi gets back from vacation.

I may contact a reform rabbi as well. Apparently converts can actually request a beit din and a mikveh with the reform movement.

You know, it is okay to go the reform/conservative route- I'm a mix of both myself, so I guess I'm a bit biased, though. Not sure how the conversion is, but I'd imagine they'd be a bit more socially open than traditional Orthodox.

darkphoenix1247
Vice Captain


YvetteEmilieDupont

PostPosted: Mon Jul 28, 2008 3:59 pm


I don't think Chassidim was the way to go on your first try.

The fact you are gay perhaps the conservative is a better option, but I refuse to believe that it'd really matter. (If you go chabad though I probably will)

anyways.
If you don't want to keep kosher, if you don't want to keep shabbos that's fine. We can't force you to do it.


I know this doesn't help at all, but he was rude because we can't just go around welcoming prospective converts with open arms. In the middle ages communities were erased because they accepted converts, and the christian society didn't like that. Also once you're jewish you are jewish, it doesn't matter if you become buddhist five months, years, or decades later, you will ALWAYS be jewish. And by becoming Jewish you will ALWAYS be commanded to observe the 613 mitzvot (which really is only like 83 ish and then like really 50 or so)


Anyways. If you want to be conservative you can. I can't say finding a shomer shabbos job is easy, because it's not. You get a lot of rejection, but if you do go into a modern othodox community you may run into people whom own businesses that , once they trust you, they will give you a helping hand.

Your mom won't like it, I went through this EXACT thing, too, she's against change. She doesn't want to loose her baby. All you can do is reaffirming how happy and fullfilled you are from being jewish. She will warm up to the idea, but it will take time.

::hugs::

The best part. The anti semitism, you will get it. All you can do is keep an upper lip and know you aren't alone. You have a 6 million+ plus family going through the exact same thing. Some less and some more, but the point is you will never be alone. You have this guild and you have your community and you will have a little jewish family. We all will be there to support you and to help you mend the wounds.


I know it's so hard right now because you just took that leap of faith and you jumped from being completely accepted to wanting to be unaccepted, and when you took that jump the jews on the otherside didn't exactly welcome you with open arms as you wanted and may have expected. Trust me, give it a month or two, maybe three and they will warm up to you. Don't get angry when they ask you why, and don't feel stupid when you don't exactly know why yourself. Just tell them every reason that has brought you to this point. The list of 'why' will grow and certain things will become less important, but none the less your list will be morphing for a while.

You may want to talk to a conservative shul, but if you want to have a frum (observant: kosher keeping, shabbos sitting) experience then I would suggest a modern synagogue. (but that isn't saying much)

Based on where you life the modern othodox shul may be even less open, I have been blessed with a very open and loving shul and they would, perhaps, be a good starting point.

I don't know exactly what to suggest to you, but I've said all I want to say.

Finally, I know that you are hurt, sad, and angry right now, I was the exact same way when I was rejected. All I can say in short is don't give up because I know it'll hurt more to give up than to not push at all.

As shakespear said (with my luck it won't be shakespear at all)

It is have better to have loved and lost to have never loved at all.

With converting it is the same, it is better to have looked been rejected, hurt, cried, and been heart broken and then to realize you don't want it. Than to simply not do anything. :hugs:

((That was long.. I'll add some smilies to make it more friendly!!!)) 4laugh 4laugh 4laugh 4laugh 4laugh 4laugh 4laugh 4laugh 4laugh emo emo emo emo emo ninja ninja ninja ninja wahmbulance wahmbulance wahmbulance wahmbulance dramallama dramallama dramallama dramallama dramallama dramallama



cheese_whine cheese_whine cheese_whine cheese_whine cheese_whine <-- Kiddush, Let's get wasted!!!!!
Reply
Jewish Gaians Guild

Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3 [>] [»|]
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum