|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
 Posted: Fri Aug 31, 2007 3:35 pm
Quote: Muskratio PostPosted: Fri Aug 24, 2007 9:26 pm There's just so much love for Tennant that it's getting a bit ridiculous. D: I mean, he's a great actor, but to be completely honest he's NOT great as the Doctor. He's just good-looking. So even though I do love him, let's all b***h about him for a bit. Even if you love him to death, there must have been at least one moment somewhere during his run (so far) that has really irked you, pissed you off, or confused you! Name it. : D I have several, unfortunately. >.> The end of the Family of Blood two-parter where he was obscenely out of character. The end of New Earth with the WTF-inducing antibiotic cocktail, because that is SO not even remotely how it works. Him yelling at the drug-selling people in Gridlock because, really, what the hell did they do? He had no reason to yell at them. They didn't kidnap Martha and he's not usually the insanely illogical type. And speaking of, did anyone else notice the massive RAIN plot hole? XD The painfully stupid Scooby Doo/Ghostbuster imitation. Picking up the torch and running in Fear Her. What the f**k was with that??? Every single time he ever mentioned Rose from the end of series 2 onward, barring the reference in Utopia because it was, of course, expected. Every single second of Evolution of the Daleks/Whatever the f**k it was called. D: That's all I can think of now. XD And it looks like a lot but it's not, really. Most of those are pretty short scenes. XD Most of your problem (as well as some other people) seems to be with the actual plot, not the Doctor himself. I love Tennant as the Doctor, and I think he has his ups and downs, but a lot of his stuff isn't really his fault. For example, the rain plot-hole (which was silly), or the antibiotic cocktail (which was doubly silly), or... Actually, ALL of this stuff was the writing. If you have a problem with his acting skills, that's fine, but seriously, stupid scenes or trends or episodes OR plots aren't TENNANT'S fault. That's all. smile
|
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Fri Aug 31, 2007 7:57 pm
Dalek13 Quote: Muskratio PostPosted: Fri Aug 24, 2007 9:26 pm There's just so much love for Tennant that it's getting a bit ridiculous. D: I mean, he's a great actor, but to be completely honest he's NOT great as the Doctor. He's just good-looking. So even though I do love him, let's all b***h about him for a bit. Even if you love him to death, there must have been at least one moment somewhere during his run (so far) that has really irked you, pissed you off, or confused you! Name it. : D I have several, unfortunately. >.> The end of the Family of Blood two-parter where he was obscenely out of character. The end of New Earth with the WTF-inducing antibiotic cocktail, because that is SO not even remotely how it works. Him yelling at the drug-selling people in Gridlock because, really, what the hell did they do? He had no reason to yell at them. They didn't kidnap Martha and he's not usually the insanely illogical type. And speaking of, did anyone else notice the massive RAIN plot hole? XD The painfully stupid Scooby Doo/Ghostbuster imitation. Picking up the torch and running in Fear Her. What the f**k was with that??? Every single time he ever mentioned Rose from the end of series 2 onward, barring the reference in Utopia because it was, of course, expected. Every single second of Evolution of the Daleks/Whatever the f**k it was called. D: That's all I can think of now. XD And it looks like a lot but it's not, really. Most of those are pretty short scenes. XD Most of your problem (as well as some other people) seems to be with the actual plot, not the Doctor himself. I love Tennant as the Doctor, and I think he has his ups and downs, but a lot of his stuff isn't really his fault. For example, the rain plot-hole (which was silly), or the antibiotic cocktail (which was doubly silly), or... Actually, ALL of this stuff was the writing. If you have a problem with his acting skills, that's fine, but seriously, stupid scenes or trends or episodes OR plots aren't TENNANT'S fault. That's all. smile Well, I really meant problems with how his character is being handled by ANYONE, not just him. :B My problems with Tennant's acting are a little less consequintial. I don't like that he has about three expressions and I don't like that he reacts to every situation the same. I don't like a couple other things about him, but the point is, he's not the only Doctor made annoying by bad stories. 6-8 had the same curse. @_@
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Fri Aug 31, 2007 8:17 pm
Muskratio Dalek13 Quote: Muskratio PostPosted: Fri Aug 24, 2007 9:26 pm There's just so much love for Tennant that it's getting a bit ridiculous. D: I mean, he's a great actor, but to be completely honest he's NOT great as the Doctor. He's just good-looking. So even though I do love him, let's all b***h about him for a bit. Even if you love him to death, there must have been at least one moment somewhere during his run (so far) that has really irked you, pissed you off, or confused you! Name it. : D I have several, unfortunately. >.> The end of the Family of Blood two-parter where he was obscenely out of character. The end of New Earth with the WTF-inducing antibiotic cocktail, because that is SO not even remotely how it works. Him yelling at the drug-selling people in Gridlock because, really, what the hell did they do? He had no reason to yell at them. They didn't kidnap Martha and he's not usually the insanely illogical type. And speaking of, did anyone else notice the massive RAIN plot hole? XD The painfully stupid Scooby Doo/Ghostbuster imitation. Picking up the torch and running in Fear Her. What the f**k was with that??? Every single time he ever mentioned Rose from the end of series 2 onward, barring the reference in Utopia because it was, of course, expected. Every single second of Evolution of the Daleks/Whatever the f**k it was called. D: That's all I can think of now. XD And it looks like a lot but it's not, really. Most of those are pretty short scenes. XD Most of your problem (as well as some other people) seems to be with the actual plot, not the Doctor himself. I love Tennant as the Doctor, and I think he has his ups and downs, but a lot of his stuff isn't really his fault. For example, the rain plot-hole (which was silly), or the antibiotic cocktail (which was doubly silly), or... Actually, ALL of this stuff was the writing. If you have a problem with his acting skills, that's fine, but seriously, stupid scenes or trends or episodes OR plots aren't TENNANT'S fault. That's all. smile Well, I really meant problems with how his character is being handled by ANYONE, not just him. :B My problems with Tennant's acting are a little less consequintial. I don't like that he has about three expressions and I don't like that he reacts to every situation the same. I don't like a couple other things about him, but the point is, he's not the only Doctor made annoying by bad stories. 6-8 had the same curse. @_@ jon culshaw actually parodies him brilliantly in the doctors at christmastime thing XDD im trying to get over him cos i dunno i dont think the storyline is the problem cos im pretty much dazzled by anything XDD im not sure wot it is dont worry ill try and get myself more into it over the weekend or something. i dunno. comp takes too long to deal with; i cant be bothered with tennant on youtube i get bored and amble off to older doctors ill try and get better wif tennant tho i dunno why i cant...i dunno i just cant put my finger on it but something bugs me : (
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sat Sep 01, 2007 3:06 pm
One of my least favorite moments was with Sarah Jane Smith and how they made it seem like there was a romance going on there, which is so not how I see Sarah Jane's and the Doctor's friendship!
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sat Sep 01, 2007 6:39 pm
I hated Daleks in Manhattan/ Evolution of the Daleks- it sucked! So naturally he sucked! But I don't really blame that on him- Helen Raynor screwed it up without any help from anyone else. So most of his problems are writing, not acting.
And he is my favorite Doctor, but Eccleston is a REALLY close second. Honestly, Eccleston is a better actor (or he just had better stories). So I have no rational explanation for why David Tennant is my favorite Doctor, even if only by a little.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sat Sep 01, 2007 6:43 pm
silverarrow92 Galaxy_defender To be honest, half of those things you said weren't that bad, in my opinion.
The running with the flame in Fear Her was hilarious.
He was acting out of character in Human Nature/Family of Blood because he was out of character. He was John Smith, not the Doctor.
Selling drugs to get rid of things is stupid. Forget?? Why would you do that? It's morally wrong.
Scooby Doo/Ghostbusters impersination was funny.
Things I disliked about Tennant's Doctor;
*Daleks in Manhatten/The Evolution of the Daleks [That was just apalling]
*He was too.....vunerable. He cried to much. As cute as it was, I felt the Doctor shouldn't be that emotional.
*Mentions of Rose were okay, but she was mentioned a bit too much....
Are we talking about Tennant in Doctor Who, or Tennant in general? 'Cause i didn't really like him when he appeared in "Friday Night Project" ages ago... I know thats a late night channel 4 programme, and being an a**hole is expected, but my respect for the guy dropped so much after i watched that.What did he do on "Friday Night Project"? Actually, what is "Friday Night Project"? Honestly, actors get WAY too much fame and fans for just being able to act. Don't get me wrong, I love acting. But how can people have a crush on someone they've never even met? Just because they play an awesome character doesn't mean they're awesome in real life. And what about people who save lives every day? Do they get fans and credit? Mostly, no. I find that obscene. Okay,t hat's my off topic rant for the day.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sun Sep 02, 2007 8:09 pm
Spidrei One of my least favorite moments was with Sarah Jane Smith and how they made it seem like there was a romance going on there, which is so not how I see Sarah Jane's and the Doctor's friendship! yeah i dunno cos i mean hm. she was wif the fourth and like the doctors have their own different liddle quirks and im sure ten and four have similarities but i think theyre a bit different to say the least XD sure its the same man in the end and i mean if you were with him and loved him or wotever i guess you still could. the problem is, the writers want EVERY. SINGLE. THING. to fall in love. or thats the way it seems to me. part of the reason why martha annoys me but thats for another day XD tennant. XD must try and stay on topic. its hard for me to do i know XD Edit: im watching the clip where the master dies. i cried. stfu ino im stupid i cant help it
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Mon Sep 03, 2007 4:01 am
darkhorsegeorge Spidrei One of my least favorite moments was with Sarah Jane Smith and how they made it seem like there was a romance going on there, which is so not how I see Sarah Jane's and the Doctor's friendship! yeah i dunno cos i mean hm. she was wif the fourth and like the doctors have their own different liddle quirks and im sure ten and four have similarities but i think theyre a bit different to say the least XD sure its the same man in the end and i mean if you were with him and loved him or wotever i guess you still could. the problem is, the writers want EVERY. SINGLE. THING. to fall in love. or thats the way it seems to me. part of the reason why martha annoys me but thats for another day XD tennant. XD must try and stay on topic. its hard for me to do i know XD Edit: im watching the clip where the master dies. i cried. stfu ino im stupid i cant help it I creid too, your not stupid biggrin , anyway, I think the main problem is RTD and his lonely god obsession, so maybe The Doctor could tune himself in to the phsychic net or whatever, and revive himself, but why, was he freakin' glowing and floating?! Why?! in no way is that even possible, its just stupid! And they had to have the Master shot, I had it all worked out, the Master would escape with Jacks wrist device and return to take over the world at a later date, I mean whaaat? we know they'll just think up some impossible way for him to have survived being shot, not regenerating and then being cremated and bring him back.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Sep 05, 2007 5:10 pm
I didn't like when he was 'human' either.
but it WAS adorable when he fell down the stairs so...
that kinda made up for the EXTREME boringness.
one thing I didn't like was how he trusted the Daleks in the Manhattan one.
he was just so blind to what was OBVIOUSLY going on.
seriously.
but thats about it. I luff him too much. xD
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Thu Sep 06, 2007 11:31 am
Every time he wears that wretched blue suit of his.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Fri Sep 07, 2007 6:56 pm
When he killed me. BLAST YOU!!! BUT IM BACK NOW!!! SOOO HA!!!
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sun Sep 09, 2007 7:37 am
Its not exactly David Tennants fault ...at all... but I hate how ever since he came the writers feel the need to make him fall in love with every damn woman he meets?
I mean seriously.....
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sun Sep 09, 2007 7:44 pm
whispering muffin Its not exactly David Tennants fault ...at all... but I hate how ever since he came the writers feel the need to make him fall in love with every damn woman he meets? I mean seriously..... or to the reverse of that every girl falling in love with him. srsly. martha saw him and you bet in her mind she was prolly like i wanna jump his bones RTD just needs to get his sexual frustrations out. maybe he should be given the opportunity to do an adult show. maybe with aliens and lots of sex with the chance to include lots of gay moments if need be. hmm...
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Mon Sep 10, 2007 5:17 pm
darkhorsegeorge whispering muffin Its not exactly David Tennants fault ...at all... but I hate how ever since he came the writers feel the need to make him fall in love with every damn woman he meets? I mean seriously..... or to the reverse of that every girl falling in love with him. srsly. martha saw him and you bet in her mind she was prolly like i wanna jump his bones RTD just needs to get his sexual frustrations out. maybe he should be given the opportunity to do an adult show. maybe with aliens and lots of sex with the chance to include lots of gay moments if need be. hmm... and the girl in the fireplace. she saw him like once when she was little and the next time she saw him she was like *ATTACK!* aaaaaahahaha xD thats the most amazing thing i've heard all day. =)
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Mon Sep 10, 2007 7:44 pm
whispering muffin darkhorsegeorge whispering muffin Its not exactly David Tennants fault ...at all... but I hate how ever since he came the writers feel the need to make him fall in love with every damn woman he meets? I mean seriously..... or to the reverse of that every girl falling in love with him. srsly. martha saw him and you bet in her mind she was prolly like i wanna jump his bones RTD just needs to get his sexual frustrations out. maybe he should be given the opportunity to do an adult show. maybe with aliens and lots of sex with the chance to include lots of gay moments if need be. hmm... and the girl in the fireplace. she saw him like once when she was little and the next time she saw him she was like *ATTACK!* aaaaaahahaha xD thats the most amazing thing i've heard all day. =) its true tho. relationships mean more when the doctor isnt played almost to the extent of manwhore or resident meat. let him form a bond but not too strong a bond or for chrissakes let the women know him for a lengthy amount of time before planning the perfect time to catch him unawares...
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
