|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Thu May 25, 2006 10:52 am
Cassidy Smith Official Critique RequestGaia Username: Sundragyn (I am on the WRONG ACCOUNT HA) Character Name: Elijah Clay Serum Animal(s): Undecided + transgender. Leaning towards either a bison, three-toed sloth, or orangutan. Quest Thread: http://www.gaiaonline.com/guilds/viewtopic.php?t=2949725 Things are still a little rough right now, I admit, especially as far as timeline goes. But I wanted to know how I was getting along. I really like the character, Sunny/Cass :3 Its believable, you obviously have done your research into transgendered characters, and interesting even beyond that character point, so that being transgendered doesn't completely define the character. And of course, the being disowned by the parents also makes it that much easier to disappear, and I like the angle on the psychological tests of the transgender serum on someone who already associates themselves with the final gender. (And would make for an interesting control with a character the other way around). And there's no problem with a big list of animals to consider - it leaves you options!
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Thu May 25, 2006 11:08 am
First off, Neato! Another character over the age of 25 smile He sounds realistic, a three-dimensional character from an interesting region and occupation to pull from that most people wouldn't think about. I also like the realistic maritial issues, the impotence explaining why he wouldn't have made any steadfast ties he couldn't be pulled from (wife or kids). Which also makes him feel out of place among his friends. And the connection with Jake being with Feral Labs is an interesting twist.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Thu May 25, 2006 11:36 am
Omikuji Official Critique Request Gaia Username: Omikuji Character Name: Derek_Robenson Serum Animal(s): Meerkat Quest Thread:http://www.gaiaonline.com/guilds/viewtopic.php?t=2889684 Round two! After reading the critique for the frist time, I have taken away the pinky ordeal, and also added a deeper insomia problem to him.
Also added some information on his eye color to show that it is possible, along with three examples. (the last one I can get the person to vouch for me if you really want me to.)
Derek isn't really, well 'crazy' anymore after taking away the chopping. It's only when he's alone for a long period of time is when he does alot of damage to himself, and the nightmares messing up his sleeping habits. But all in all, he might be alot more 'sane' then alot of the people on the island.
-Ker Edit- I came up with a possibly better idea how he would get to the island. It's placed under the same one, I think this one is a little more crafty then the last one I had. My bad on the eyecolor thing - I was mistaken and should have looked into it before saying otherwise. The problem with the second island sceme would be that especially if the psychiatrist doesn't work for feral labs anymore, she wouldn't know anything about a special island being used for test subjects - or what they looked for in canidates. Most feral labs employees don't even know about it. I do think with toning down the severity of his disorder that he wouldn't have as hard a time getting 'selected' to be taken to the island. As far as psychiatrists go, it's not a simple thing as a "cure". Most work with clients for years, getting to know them, not just trying to mould them to casebook examples. It wouldn't be viewed badly if it wasn't an open and shut case because it didn't fit a mold. Given his wealthy family, however, it would be very difficult to disappear him. If they were given the "answer" that he killed himself, then Feral Labs would be sued for a LOT of money. he's underage, in their care, and supposedly at a center to be treated. It would likely draw a lot of REALLY bad press for them. And the disorder that he is under isn't one that might have fatal consequences usually barring a suicide - so a pass off of "he didn't make it" wouldn't fly. To me it seems like you're trying to make him special in a number of unrelated aspects (the eyes, the WEALTHY family, and the cutting psychosis). I would ask why the wealthy family? If you could have him being from a low income family, then the fact that they are seeking help for him but don't know really what to do - they might turn to a low cost clinic out of desperation not knowing what else to do. They could come up with a special opportuity to travel to a clinic that would watch him long-term, ensure his health and safety... etc.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Thu May 25, 2006 11:45 am
Remove Island of Moreau THere would be no technical problem in doing a black jaguar (panther) as the only panther is a black leopard, a taur, and technically not yet introduced. But we dont' have a jaguar yet either if that's what you want :3 As far as the family background, almost all American teens go through a rebellious "no one understands me/I hate my parents" Stage, or at least a period of friction where they don't feel that they fit in and that their parents don't understand them. I find it very difficult to swallow that her parents would have turned her out at the age of 13 because of this. Not only is it highly illegal (and would get them into SERIOUS legal issues when she suddenly goes missing) but the drastic change of heart from her being their "princess". AND she's their only child. It is much more likely they would have tried counselling or other forms to work with her than sending her out on her own. I would suggest having a VERY good reason of her being turned out if you don't just want her to have run away (which would be rather similar to Lauren). Maybe she's from a very religious family and she got pregnant (to miscarry/abort/etc the child) and lost too much respect for her parents to go home. Other than that, she sounds fine, if a little on the similar side to Lauren. But that might just be becaus of the middleclass girl to runaway thing :3 ok thanks, I think I will stick with a Jaguar for now, just so there wont ever be a problem with it ^_^ erm, she has a brother, I thought I put that in and is the youngest out of the two. If I didnt put that in then I must have forgotten. I will edit it to make it better but I dont know much about american kids and stuff but i know someone got kicked out at 13 over here and her parents told authorities she ran away but I shall change the history a bit. I haven't read Laurens history but I will and change mine so it not so similar and I like the religious idea, could work, not sure what would happen with the baby unless she can come pregnant to the island or something? I edited it and I hope it sounds better but I was curious to whether or not she can be pregnant when she comes to the island or if it wouldn't be possible? I just think it would be interesting plot wise. thread: ]http://www.gaiaonline.com/guilds/viewtopic.php?page=1&t=2654286#55909734Thanks for making the edits :3 As far as the pregnancy thing, I think it works out pretty well as well giving them an excuse for doing something as drastic as kicking her out, with the basis of being a religious family. As far as pregnancy after that you have options. She could have miscarried the child and lost it after being kicked out (malnutrition on the streets, etc, could justify that) Or she could have adopted it out, OR you CAN have her come to the island pregnant (but be prepared for an RP challenge). This might be an interesting from the scientists' side to compare to Natsumi - who is coming pregnant, but becoming a reptile and will thus likely lose the child. Since your character would be becoming mammalian it might be an interesting comparison to see if she keeps the child, and if so, what happens to it. Of course, if that's the case, she wouldn't have been on the streets very long at all if she was pregnant with the same child she was kicked out because of. Unless it's a separate pregnancy. Not sure if your question pertains to what you've gotten written - but of course the abortion is fine for her backstory if you don't want to worry about being pregnant on the island.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed May 31, 2006 7:00 pm
Sounds like a good start, and the character is definately interesting. I like the ethnic background a lot.
I'm not entirely sure if how he got the island really jives, however. They usually try to avoid people in the public eye since they have more connections. One idea I could just toss out - what if Jin used the temporary enhancer serum? Perhaps he was using it, and he was beginning to feel ill and went to a hospital. Feral Labs would be very interested in getting to him and figuring out the effects. ANd of course.. once he was there, they could let him leave.
Just an idea. But I think the "getting there" part is only part that really needs a workover. Otherwise the character sounds fine.
While its not required to change or anything, I just want to let you know that there is another questor is questing for an ahnorexic girl getting turned into a whale. Just FYI incase thats a problem for you. (some people dont' want a concept that overlaps at all, some people don't care. Niether or you would be 'required' to change the cocnept either way). BUT - since the guy is already huge because of muscle mass, have you ever considered a sloth (lazy animals) or a like.. something notably skinny and scrawny. Like a walking stick bug, or a flamingo/stork or some kind. Or a whippet dog XD
Just something food for thought. Whale's are actually quite muscular - the later of blubber is there mostly for insultation and bouincy.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed May 31, 2006 7:06 pm
Ieeko Takeru Official Critique Request Gaia Username: Ieeko Takeru Character Name: Sebastion Gordon Serum Animal(s): Black-Tailed Prairie Dog. Quest Thread: Here we go! Well rounded, believable character. I can't see anything that really needs changing.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed May 31, 2006 7:15 pm
Sounds awesome. The how he got the island seems little shakey, however. Feral Labs would be very picky who they took to work on, say, construction jobs. BUt its willwork if nothing comes up differently. God knows Aubrey is on the lookout for men like Gaius for Colche!
However, one of Feral Labs more "sneakier" ways to get people to the island are to steal them at hospitals and say they died during surgery. It doesn't beg a lot of questions from people, and its an easy way to "dissapear" people with family and friends.
The idea that's come to my mind is what if he and some co-workers were involved in a construction accident? He might not have been hurt very much, at least nothing more serious than a concussion, but again, being the hosputal would give Feral Labs a reason to 'flag' him and get him away easier.
But thats just a suggestion of course.
Over all, love it. We need more general 'nice guys' on the island.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
 |
|
|
|
|
|