Welcome to Gaia! ::

The Any Topic Guild

Back to Guilds

I will find you... on Gaia! :D 

Tags: friendship, events, hangout, literate, chatting 

Reply Community Lounge
Vegetarians: why? Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3 ... 8 9 10 11 12 13 [>] [»|]

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Jafthasleftthebuilding
Vice Captain

PostPosted: Mon Dec 11, 2006 6:51 pm


You know, responses provoke responses.

So if you don't respond, you can avoid things like this, but people by nature always like to be right. (Or want the last say.)

I'm not placing any blame on anyone, just don't respond.

Violence begets violence.

Now, I'm a meat lover. I love meat. I love meat and taters. Absolutely delicious.

I don't worry about the diseases meat contains for if cooked well enough, I find myself to feel safe. I love me brocolli. That stuff tastes good. Especially with the ketchup and meat and taters.

I choose not to be a vegetarian because I love the taste of meat too much. biggrin
PostPosted: Mon Dec 11, 2006 6:51 pm


night ascot. 3nodding

~lizzerde~


Celestial Burden

PostPosted: Mon Dec 11, 2006 6:53 pm


Ascott
Celestial Burden
Ascott
Celestial Burden
~lizzerde~
why is it that religon is always sucked into heated discussions? confused
i mean i know it's a legitimate discussion point here... but the way it's been discussed has had almost no relation to the topic of foods people choose not to eat. confused

maybe i'm blind to it. but i don't see any relevance of the heated arguments on religious aspects to food.
No, Lizz, you're right. They way the discussion was carried on was completely irrelevent to the topic. I made a point about my religion stating why some witches were vegtarians, that's it. however, when he started telling sanzo what religion she could and could not follow he took things too far I think. I really don't think there is much left to discuss here.


If you'll notice, I took great care not to debate your religion with you. My religion, on the other hand...
That isn't the point. What I was saying was that you do not have the right to tell someone what religion they follow. If sanzo believes in the Catholic principles and calls herself Catholic, she's catholic. end of story.

Now, I'm going to try for the third time to get you to answermy question.

Acoording to you we are above animals and therefore have the right to do whatever we want. Does this give us the right to be cruel to animals?

All the principles. Picking and choosing the ones she likes is a bastardisation of the religion. If she follows all of them, she's Catholic. There's nothing more to it.

Yes, technically, humans have the right to be cruel to animals, if they're so inclined. Luckily, I also have the right to stop anyone I see being cruel to an animals. Which I would utilise to the fullest extent. In that situation, whichever one of us "won" the ensuing conflict would continue to enjoy his rights uninterrupted.

Right, I really am going to bed.
Well then, you do understand that these animals that are killed for food are treated very cruely, correct? Some people really do try to stop this by not eating meat. That makes perfect sense to me. The animals are killed in a painfukl way, and some people feel guilty that they are eating the product of animal cruelty.
PostPosted: Mon Dec 11, 2006 6:56 pm


Jaft

Now, I'm a meat lover. I love meat. I love meat and taters. Absolutely delicious.

*drool* ...mmmm.... yummeh.
Jaft

I don't worry about the diseases meat contains for if cooked well enough, I find myself to feel safe. I love me brocolli. That stuff tastes good. Especially with the ketchup and meat and taters.

I choose not to be a vegetarian because I love the taste of meat too much. biggrin

O___________o ketchup? with meat and taters yeah i understand.... but BROCOLLI WITH KETCHUP?!?!?!? sweatdrop i'll have to give 'er a try...

and also, while i'm COMPLETELY addicted to meat ( pirate ), i still respectother people's reasons for not eating meat. whatever the reasons. (not saying you don't jaft sweatdrop just trying not to make myself look insensative to the feelings of others sweatdrop )

~lizzerde~


jene-chan

PostPosted: Mon Dec 11, 2006 6:56 pm


Ascott
Out of sheer, baffled curiousity.

personal reasons....
PostPosted: Mon Dec 11, 2006 7:02 pm


Ascott
The-Mut-Cat
Ascott
The-Mut-Cat
Ascott
The-Mut-Cat


Wasn't it you who said "humans are at the top of the food chain"?


Yep, we're at the top. If an animal lower down on it thinks it can eat me, it's welcome to try. It might succeed. If so, it doesn't mean that humans as a species are any less low on the food chain; just that the bear/wolf/pig got lucky.


ok... is that based on your religious beleifs, or what? What religion are you?


Partially on the idea that we're inherently superior; partially on the idea that it took 50,000 or so years of evolution to get to this point, and that we owe it to our ancestors to be the ones eating the other animals.


so we inherited superiority? even though, today, I doubt many humans could hunt and kill "prey" even with the aid of hunting tools, while wild animals do it without any technological help...


We invented those weapons. We have a right to use them.

Yes. We inherited superiority through X-many thousand years of our species struggling to survive. Now, we're on top.


confused I dunno... that just sounds like our ancestors, or the inventors in particular, were superior to us... cuz, y'know, I don't think you can make a gun yourself... :/

Oh well, I'm just attempting to figure out why you even bothered to ask "why" when you already seem to have the "right" idea all figured out...

My answer to that would simply be that not everybody thinks the same as you do... and thus follow different logic.

The-Mut-Cat


Nami Tsuki

PostPosted: Mon Dec 11, 2006 7:03 pm


i'm not a vegetarian because i love animals!

i'm a vegetarion because i hate plants!

just kidding... i'm not a vegetarian at all.

BEEF IS GOOD.
PostPosted: Mon Dec 11, 2006 7:03 pm


So Elizzy... What's your favourite kind of flesh or meat to eat?

Jafthasleftthebuilding
Vice Captain


Jafthasleftthebuilding
Vice Captain

PostPosted: Mon Dec 11, 2006 7:06 pm


Actually here's a question I can pose to all meat eaters...

Why are you not a vegetarian?

biggrin
PostPosted: Mon Dec 11, 2006 7:08 pm


I'm not a vegetarian because I do not find it wrong to eat meat. While I do wish there was a way I could stop them from being killed in such brutal fashions, I'm a minor and therefore my opinion doesn't really matter to most people.

Celestial Burden


Jafthasleftthebuilding
Vice Captain

PostPosted: Mon Dec 11, 2006 7:10 pm


Yes Burden, you may have not walked on this Earth for as many moons as others, but you're still capable of advanced thought and logic unlike many other adults.

biggrin

I just can't resist meat. I can go without it for awhile, but I love eating it.
PostPosted: Mon Dec 11, 2006 7:11 pm


Jaft
So Elizzy... What's your favourite kind of flesh or meat to eat?


hmmmm... it's between corned beef and turkey/chicken 3nodding heart

gah...almost all meat is droolworthy... and i mean ALL xd
except goat neutral i hate that stuff. one time my granny got what we thought was pork... but turns out the label was wrong and it was goat meat. when that stuff isn't cooked outdoors.... the smell is intolerable gonk

~lizzerde~


~lizzerde~

PostPosted: Mon Dec 11, 2006 7:13 pm


BEEF FRIGGAN JERKY!!!!!!!!

that stuff is AWESOME!!!! *drools*

ninja mmk... i shall stop being a jerk... emo sweatdrop
PostPosted: Mon Dec 11, 2006 7:13 pm


~lizzerde~
Jaft
So Elizzy... What's your favourite kind of flesh or meat to eat?


hmmmm... it's between corned beef and turkey/chicken 3nodding heart

gah...almost all meat is droolworthy... and i mean ALL xd
except goat neutral i hate that stuff. one time my granny got what we thought was pork... but turns out the label was wrong and it was goat meat. when that stuff isn't cooked outdoors.... the smell is intolerable gonk

I don't like corned beef so much...

I do like Sloppy Joes. I mean, REALLY sloppy.

biggrin twisted

Jafthasleftthebuilding
Vice Captain


Red Glacier

PostPosted: Mon Dec 11, 2006 7:14 pm


well plants are living things too so either way your killing something. might as well put its dead body to use and eat it for your own well being.
Reply
Community Lounge

Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3 ... 8 9 10 11 12 13 [>] [»|]
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum