faolan
Once upon a time, I bought a couple tshirts...

The Kiki shirt was for my little sister, and the Coco shirt was for me. And since then, we've both moved at least five or six times; it's anyone's guess where they are now. crying
But in googling to find those images, I did run across this old thread, in case anyone's curious about what all they offered, back in the day.
I had those shirts too! I actually only got rid of them a few months ago. I haven't fit into a medium in, like, a decade, and I was hanging on to them for so long "just in case," but..
emotion_facepalm I finally faced reality.
Somewhere I still have the mini angel wing and nitemare wing hair clips, a Kiki Kitty plush with the headband hole, mini Gwee keychain, and those pink PJ pants. I think I actually threw away the PJ pants, they got super ratty and faded over the years. Still have the Gaia item in my inventory though, I wear it when I want to dress up in Gaia anniversary items.
My biggest embarrassment is that I bought this limited edition shirt that had a ton of signatures from the Gaia staff on it in sharpie.. and then I washed it and all the signatures came off.
sweatdrop So then I just had a really expensive, but ultimately pretty plain, shirt. I think I left it behind when I moved out on my own.
Sorry that I can't contribute to your quest, OP.
gonk I was never a big fan of Zurg so I don't even remember that shirt. I know how it feels when one of your favorite shirts goes missing though, so I hope you can find it soon!