I have no interest in spending all day reading this thread. I will say that I have been on Gaia since mid-2005, and I am both disappointed and disgusted by the "progress" of this site.
I don't give a damn about the battle system or the fish tanks. I already play one MMO, I don't need another. The fish tanks are a silly idea. If I wanted a tank I would buy a real one. I'm 25 years old, I can afford my own real fish. I am sure as hell not paying for virtual ones with a soaring mortality rate. I don't mind if other people want a virtual tank, more power to them if they wish to spend money on it.
What pisses me off is the assumption that the users are too stupid to see what's going on. By all means, believe that everyone is too young or naive to read between the lines. Those of us who have experienced this sort of tactic in the real world know better.
The quality of your Monthly Collectibles has been steadily declining with the release of more and more Evolving Items. Blame whatever you want, but it's a clear marketing maneuver to make the cheaper items less desirable, and the more expensive (what 13 year old can shell out $9.99 for a damn star?) items flow into the economy faster. That's clearly what you're doing, so have enough respect for your patrons to come right out and say it. Recent Collectibles have been
pathetic. Setting aside the issue of a bajillion poses for a moment, let's consider the shoddy graphics and lack of creativity. We know you well, Gaia. We know what you're capable of, and we know your usual standards. That release did not live up to them.
I believe that this site costs more to run than it brings in. However that, to me, is a clear sign of a poorly run business. If you cannot make enough to justify new expenditures,
why the hell are you creating new expenditures? Every feature costs money to develop and maintain. The ones that fail or do not produce a sufficient profit are a drain on your currently available resources and therefore a poor investment of both time and money. If money has been the issue for some time it shouldn't have taken you so long to introduce systems that bring in a profit. Stop wasting your time on pointless crap and develop a clear plan to make Gaia worthwhile to both yourselves and the users. I don't mean to be crass but quit dicking around and grow some focus. Gaia has been an ADHD six year old for a while now. You're announcing new features and systems and sponsorship and events and whatever faster than your patrons can blink, and you're lucky if most of them launch without having to be taken offline three hours later. Have you not yet noticed how many people are on this site? Foresight, get some. Now half of those aren't money-making ventures. Clearly the biggest problem facing Gaia is a lack of profit--don't claim it's anything else if the site costs money to run. That should be your first and foremost focus. The users, the patrons, are obviously loyal. Get your act together.