who was the better 3rd charmed 1, pru, or paige

[13lackMagic]

icedancer16

I honestly liked them both, the more I wastch the earlier season, it's harder to choose. Before I saw the first couple seasons, I totally picked paige, now it's just both.

I feel the same way.. When I first saw Prue die, I was a little upset, but then I watch the DVD sets and it's just omg, she's dead.. also hard to compare the youngest sister with the oldest. Prue had more of the "You mess with my family you die now!" Paige has more of that "you mess with my sisters you die, but without the torture."  

[XxsweetbabygirlxX]

ITS PRU FOR SHUR DUH  

[Mizu Sayuri]

I'd vote for Prue.  

[13lackMagic]

sweetbabygirl93

ITS PRU FOR SHUR DUH

you make it seem so easy!  

[FluffysBabyGirl]

paige is better.
pre just got on my nerve alittle.
...opkay most of the time...  

[Charming_Nienna]

I would have to say Paige

Don't get me wrong, I liked Prue, she had great powers and was always there to help her sisters and I really felt bad when she died. But I just don't liked her storylines in the auction house or museum and sometimes she was just too bussy like 'Look at me, look at me, I'm Mrs. Superwitch'.
In that way, I like Paige more, she had better storylines and is more freeminded.  

[ForgottenPieces]

Mine was PRUE (it's spells with a e not pru PRUE )
She was my favorite but i kinda like Paige now too  

[StrawBerryApple]

ForgottenPieces

Mine was PRUE (it's spells with a e not pru PRUE )
She was my favorite but i kinda like Paige now too

ya. Its hard to say you hate Paige because she has been on the show longer thatn Shannen's three years.  

[elf_star]

Prue, obviously. The episodes after she died just weren't as good for me. The only reason I actually kept on watching was because I also really liked piper. Paige is okay, she grew on me a little. But she's no Prue.  

[tiko0]

heart PRUE heart PRUE heart PRUE heart PRUE heart PRUE heart

RIP emo  

[Ross Mohan]

Paige. Prue was too "OMG I'm the best witch ever". It was annoying. Paige had much better powers, even just the ability to Orb was amazing. She added new dimensions to the show.  

[LadyUsako]

I liked them both. Prue was more demanding true, but she did work with her sisters in an aspect. Yes, she saw herself as leader and did the whole give orderd thing, but I still liked her. Paige was more laid back and decided to go find her own path without her sisters a few times. But I like her too. Each of the two had their own faults, but who doesn't. They were, after all, human even if they were witches.  

[super tonia]

i prefer prue and as a character ans as power  

[me_is_kelly]

I definitely think Prue was the better charmed one, without a doubt.
- Great leadership
- Great relationship with both of her sisters
- Very powerful, and if she had lived, her powers would have advanced even more so.
- Great character
- My favourite character

While Paige was okay, she will never be as good as Prue was, in my opinion.  

[Febbo]

Prue was a better leader, but Paige since she is half whitelighter is more versatile ^^ I go with Paige.