Forbidden List and What you would take off of it

[brotherofAnubus]

Okay, here's the deal. We all have one or more cards that we would love to see unbanned. So name one card from the Forbidden List that you would slip into the Limited List and name the reasons why. And no, children, "Because I want it to be" is not a reason.  

[Tsukinoki]

Move Pot of Greed to 1, just so that people who have the common Pot of Greeds can improve their decks, without spending so much for a pot of duality...though i think duality wouldd drop dramatically in price if greed were to come back...  

[iiShinichi_Kudo]

I wouldnt like anything taken off for the most part, I like the challenge of making a great deck with new cards. BUT! if I have to pick 1 card I would pick
DARK MAGICIAN OF CHAOS! FTW biggrin  

[DracoxisDiamond]

Goyo Guardian, it is a good card and my friend really likes it.  

[B1g_crunch]

Magician of faith.

Mask of darkness is at 3 right now, which doesn't make sense to me. You're saying we can re-use mirror force or magic cylinder, but bringing a spell back at the cost of a low level monster is no good. What gives?  

[Mr_dragon]

Because spells can be used immediately which opens the door for combos that abuse that(I believe 1 involved tsukiyomi and magician of faith)  

[Shahal Rainrix]

Pot of Greed, I hear that it isn't banned in a few countries and draw 2 for the cost of nothing is the most common TCG effect.

Goyo Guardian shouldn't be on there either. Its an okay card, but its nothing it a stall/burn deck.

Magician of faith should have been semi-limited three years ago. Reusing spell isn't much of a big deal. Mask of Darkness is just as broken and you can bluff your opponent with easily. All you do is take one trap that is a real bother, like mirror wall, and set another trap like cylinders.  

[Space Toad -B]

Tsukinoki

Move Pot of Greed to 1, just so that people who have the common Pot of Greeds can improve their decks, without spending so much for a pot of duality...though i think duality wouldd drop dramatically in price if greed were to come back...

Pot of Greed dictates the capability of not one deck, but all. The game is then based on who can draw what first, and no, Pot of Duality would actually increase in price if this limitation were made.

The_Wanderer_Samurai

I wouldnt like anything taken off for the most part, I like the challenge of making a great deck with new cards. BUT! if I have to pick 1 card I would pick
DARK MAGICIAN OF CHAOS! FTW biggrin

Dark Magician of Chaos is also a field dictator providing whatever Spell source you would want upon summon, in this format, that would be Dark Hole and Monster Reborn. Keep it banned.

DracoxisDiamond

Goyo Guardian, it is a good card and my friend really likes it.

Goyo Guardian is banned for a very simple reason, and people don't often recognize simple reasons for why these decisions are made.

Goyo Guardian, itself, is broken.

Every mechanical element to Goyo Guardian is like Paris Hilton was given the largest diamond in the world. A Level 6 Synchro, easily accessible in anything, with a 2800 attack - catastrophically high for its Level, complimented with a good 2000 defense, and an ability that does nothing but take advantage of its absurd attack and easy access to Level 6 in early-to-mid game.

A successful drop means everything is on your side of the field.

Labyrinthknight7

Magician of faith.

Mask of darkness is at 3 right now, which doesn't make sense to me. You're saying we can re-use mirror force or magic cylinder, but bringing a spell back at the cost of a low level monster is no good. What gives?

Read my reason on Dark Magician of Chaos, minus the attack, but faster.

Mask of Darkness is irrelevant, because in nature of how they're played, Trap cards are outdone by Spells. They activate at a faster rate, and the effects tend to be more devastating.

Shahal Rainrix

Pot of Greed, I hear that it isn't banned in a few countries and draw 2 for the cost of nothing is the most common TCG effect.

Goyo Guardian shouldn't be on there either. Its an okay card, but its nothing it a stall/burn deck.

Magician of faith should have been semi-limited three years ago. Reusing spell isn't much of a big deal. Mask of Darkness is just as broken and you can bluff your opponent with easily. All you do is take one trap that is a real bother, like mirror wall, and set another trap like cylinders.

1. Pot of Greed is not legal, anywhere. The list is GLOBAL, meaning it's followed everywhere in the world.

2. Read my previous comment on Goyo Guardian. What decks you could end up facing are irrelevant, because you won't summon Goyo Guardian against such decks anyway.

3. Read my commend on Magician of Faith/Dark Magician of Chaos. Mask of Darkness is nowhere near as good.  

[DracoxisDiamond]

Mustard Like Soup

Tsukinoki

Move Pot of Greed to 1, just so that people who have the common Pot of Greeds can improve their decks, without spending so much for a pot of duality...though i think duality wouldd drop dramatically in price if greed were to come back...

Pot of Greed dictates the capability of not one deck, but all. The game is then based on who can draw what first, and no, Pot of Duality would actually increase in price if this limitation were made.

The_Wanderer_Samurai

I wouldnt like anything taken off for the most part, I like the challenge of making a great deck with new cards. BUT! if I have to pick 1 card I would pick
DARK MAGICIAN OF CHAOS! FTW biggrin

Dark Magician of Chaos is also a field dictator providing whatever Spell source you would want upon summon, in this format, that would be Dark Hole and Monster Reborn. Keep it banned.

DracoxisDiamond

Goyo Guardian, it is a good card and my friend really likes it.

Goyo Guardian is banned for a very simple reason, and people don't often recognize simple reasons for why these decisions are made.

Goyo Guardian, itself, is broken.

Every mechanical element to Goyo Guardian is like Paris Hilton was given the largest diamond in the world. A Level 6 Synchro, easily accessible in anything, with a 2800 attack - catastrophically high for its Level, complimented with a good 2000 defense, and an ability that does nothing but take advantage of its absurd attack and easy access to Level 6 in early-to-mid game.

A successful drop means everything is on your side of the field.

Labyrinthknight7

Magician of faith.

Mask of darkness is at 3 right now, which doesn't make sense to me. You're saying we can re-use mirror force or magic cylinder, but bringing a spell back at the cost of a low level monster is no good. What gives?

Read my reason on Dark Magician of Chaos, minus the attack, but faster.

Mask of Darkness is irrelevant, because in nature of how they're played, Trap cards are outdone by Spells. They activate at a faster rate, and the effects tend to be more devastating.

Shahal Rainrix

Pot of Greed, I hear that it isn't banned in a few countries and draw 2 for the cost of nothing is the most common TCG effect.

Goyo Guardian shouldn't be on there either. Its an okay card, but its nothing it a stall/burn deck.

Magician of faith should have been semi-limited three years ago. Reusing spell isn't much of a big deal. Mask of Darkness is just as broken and you can bluff your opponent with easily. All you do is take one trap that is a real bother, like mirror wall, and set another trap like cylinders.

1. Pot of Greed is not legal, anywhere. The list is GLOBAL, meaning it's followed everywhere in the world.

2. Read my previous comment on Goyo Guardian. What decks you could end up facing are irrelevant, because you won't summon Goyo Guardian against such decks anyway.

3. Read my commend on Magician of Faith/Dark Magician of Chaos. Mask of Darkness is nowhere near as good.

This isn't about why the cards were banned, it's about what we would like to be able to use again.  

[Space Toad -B]

DracoxisDiamond

This isn't about why the cards were banned, it's about what we would like to be able to use again.

You were also supposed to support your reason why, instead of just throwing it up in the air.

Your reason for Goyo Guardian was, "because it's a good card and my friend likes it". Tells us nothing, too bad.

TheMalefic player said nothing but "FTW" for Dark Magician of Chaos, again, nothing.

Tsukinoki suggested Pot of Greed for economic purposes, and that's good samaritan and all, but completely irrelevant. Ignoring Shahal Rainrix's part on Pot of Greed, but will note his reason is bad for Magician of Faith.

See, my job here, is to give you guys that reality check about how stupid and/or terrible you are. And what a job it is.

And if ANY CREW wants to delete my post, again, with or without my know-how, I am more than willing to play this game with you.  

[Claus Iver]

I'd like to see Makyura the Destructor come back at atleast 1. Why? Besides the interesting potential with the trap monsters, it'd just be fun to see how it would change the game. Not sure if it would actually change the game too much at this point but it'd be a nice learning experience.
To sum up why, I don't know why and that is why.  

[Space Toad -B]

Claus Iver

Makyura the Destructor

Absolutely not.