i might have voted for legolas, but instead i bid on pip.
i love the legolas of the books, and i love the legolas portrayed by one of the loves in my life, orlando bloom. BUT, they're not the same character. they changed legolas so much for the movie, that i really can't call him legolas any more, i refer to movie legolas as 'leggy.'
leggy's more of the quiet battle-ready kinda guy.
legolas would rather sing a song. that's what he does in the majority of the book, he sings! yeah, he can kick but, but in the books he'd rather not.
i choose pippin because he is the character that changes the most throughout the story. he starts off as a total dimwit & grows (quite literally) into a nobalman. by the time of his death, he was the most cherrished thane of hobbiton.
well, i'll stop rambling now...