David2074
azulmagia
David2074
I fail to see how acting like assholes is going to win people over to their cause.
There seem to be lot of things you "fail to see."
Quote:
Also, not every shooting of
a black person any person is unjust just because some of them are.
I'm facepalming over this.
Quote:
Some of the statistics from the FBI and other sources indicate black youth are six times more likely to commit violent crimes like robbery and murder and even leaders in the black community acknowledge this isn't all explained away with "cuz racist law / legal system".
Inherently, citing this general statistic cannot be used to assert that any
specific killing was "justifed". And a rightly-consituted legal system will hold that any known-to-be-intentional homicide is
at least second degree murder without great cause to otherwise consider it a justifiable use of force. The problem is that the actually-existing system gives police a virtual license to kill. And that's nothing compared to the "stand your ground law" in Florida!
Quote:
Unjust killings are unjust - of course. My point is that trying to imply every killing of a
black any person is unjust is not realistic.
And what's realistic about expecting a community that is policed as though they were militarily occupied to be able to adopt the same dispassionate "openness" to the possibility that the person shot "had it coming to them" as a white middle-class suburb? When, for example, the prosecutor
intentionally rigged the grand jury process in such a manner as to lead to the exoneration of Officer Wilson - including accepting the testimony of a pro-Wilson witness whose testimony the same prosecutor admitted was completely fraudulent!
Quote:
Focus on the wrongful killings should also focus on the problems that exacerbate the problem / increase the likelyness that someone is going to get killed. The vast majority of blacks being killed are being killed by other black people. Racist brutal cops should definitely be held accountable for their actions but it would also help if black people stopped killing each other.
According to the U.S. Bureau of Justice Statistics, 93 percent of black homicides were indeed committed by other blacks between 1980 and 2008. In 2012, the most recent data posted on the Web, the figure was 91 percent.
Most people tend to be killed by people personally known to them, period. Which generally means people of the same race or ethnicity. So, it's not exactly an earth-shattering revelation to point out these statistics. So why point it out in the first place?
If you're attempting to use this to somehow demonstrate that black-on-black killings are somehow swept under the rug by black activists, you're not merely factually incorrect (see below), you're sounding like a Fox News commentator, and that is hardly metaphorical.
Quote:
"Out with guns, in with jobs," the Rev. Jesse Jackson said to me in his trademark gravelly voice. "We're going to march in 20 cities" hard hit by the gun violence that has made the streets of America a bigger killing field for young black men in the United States than the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan have been for U.S. troops.
...
"Each year … about 7,000 African Americans are murdered,
more than nine times out of 10 by other African Americans," Jackson said in a painful acknowledgment of a crisis that for too long has received "drive-by" attention from most black leaders.
(link)
You seem to flip back and forth between serious conversation and intentional trolling.
I am unsure which you think your last post was but you definitely chose to twist some of my words - or at least what was intended by them.
Not sure why you are "facepalming" over the comment above.
Because it's a specious comment that's masquerading as common sense that at least some of them "had it coming".
Quote:
My point was that some police shootings of suspects are justified because some people are violent criminals who attack police and so on - regardless of race.
There are violent criminals in Germany too, and they (presumably) also attack police, but police shootings there are NOWHERE NEAR the rate you find in the United States. Ditto up here in Canada.
You have to cop to (no pun intended) that there
is a problem with police violence in the United States in general and against minorities in particular.
Quote:
But due to the recent news stories I seem some people immediately assuming "racist" when the read about the shooting of a black even when they do not know the details of the situation. My point was that is not automatically the case.
They also have no reason to trust that the police, let alone the justice system, will treat them equitably. They are therefore not disposed to give the police a "fair shake"...whatever
that is.
Moreover, I fail to see the RELEVANCE of your point. OK, so there are an strangely unspecified number of black people who automatically come to the conclusion that the black guy "dindu nuffin". Put aside, for a moment, that this is nothing more than the mirror image of the attitude that the police virtually never get it wrong.* What I want to know is, SO WHAT? What does this have bearing on?
* which is not exactly an attitude of some random people, but the more or less OFFICIAL attitude of the police/justice system itself, given the miniscule number of officers who actually get charged with anything.
Quote:
Yes, some "black leaders" acknowledge the violence among their people.
But if you read the comments made by various folks about these stories there are a lot of black folks who come across as being rather racist and just assume the black guy is innocent and the white guy is a racist hater - even if they do not know the details of the situation. Whatever the situation.
Again, this is GERMANE to what precisely?
Quote:
I never "asserted that any specific killing was "justifed"" That's just you twisting my words.
In fact just the opposite. I was pointing out that no specific killing is automatically "not justified" and deserves a thorough investigation instead of just folks automatically crying "racist cop".
If you want to argue that there are justified police shootings of black people, then you indeed have to produce specific examples of justified police shootings of black people. That should be obvious. Citing that "black youth are six times more likely to commit violent crimes like robbery and murder" establishes
absolutely nothing. Logically speaking, that statistic has NOTHING to say on what percentage of police shootings of blacks are "justified". It is even compatible with a hypothetical situation where literally ALL the police shootings were unjustified. I must additionally point out that solid numbers on how many people are shot at by American cops are outright
unobtainable.
Quote:
But... whatever. If you are in your troll mode you'll just make grand sweeping arguments that pretty much ignore what I'm saying anyway.
Well, that
is a problem, because I have hard time trying to figure out exactly what are you trying to argue. Pointing out that maybe
some police shootings are justified and that maybe
some black people simply leap to conclusions about how racist might both be true as facts, but I'll be damned if I can figure out how they relate to the problem at hand. Because, if you are asserting that these protestors regard
all the police shootings as unjust, then you are making a red herring argument, also I do not see how the protestors' position logically entails them believing that. If you're arguing that these protestors are knee-jerk cop-blamers, that's an argumentum ad hominem.
I mean what is even your point, that if even ONE of the shootings that the protesters are decrying were justified, these protestors should just pack up and go home? Or that they only have grounds to protest if x% of shootings are unjustified? What position are you even arguing against by pointing out these things? I am pretty sure it is not that of the protestors.They bear no relevance to the problem that these protestors are protesting. Which - strictly speaking - I do not see you even addressing.
I hate to be one to break it to you but polls consistently indicate that Black Americans and White Americans have WILDLY divergent evaluations on how equitably the police deal with minorities.